Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

ADVICE NEEDED!!

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Fiona 1
cmi 3
RRay 1
planemom 3
Sandyr9111 1
fabulous 1
♥SATex♥ 1
Rachel 1
humbleteacher 1
haroldoftherocks 1
Raia's Mommy 1
mamamiaow 1
momof5 2
JET 6
allofus 1
bidingmytime 1
HappyMomma 1
Kristen 1
3babyzmom 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Kristen --- 18 years ago -

I am a married Mom with 3 children. My oldest daughter is from a previous relationship and my current husband has adopted her. My question is when do we tell her and how? I feel that the sooner the better before she is too emotionally developed. He feels that this is HIS responsiblity and wants to wait until she is older. The biologoical father is not in the picture at all. If anyone has been through this or has any sound advice, please leave it for me. Thanks! 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

How old is ur DD? 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

A friend was in the same situation. I believe her son grew up knowing his dad didn't father him. However, the parents made a big deal about it when dad was able to adopt him. My opinion is the sooner the better. If she grows up knowing it, it's not a big deal. If you wait until she is older then you run into "Why did you hide it from me?". 

♥SATex♥ --- 18 years ago -

I feel you do need to tell her and before she starts school. My 3 older sisters were adopted by my dad and I did not know until one was getting married and I was 12 at the time. I was with them at the church and the pastor ask what last name she was going to use, I was so confused! I ran out crying thinking that they really were not my sisters at all. So I think the sooner the better. My parents did not tell them either, it was their fiends and that is no way to find out. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

My dd has just turned 8 and I do feel that she needs to know now... its just getting my hubby to see that. He is afraid that she will use that against him if he ever has to discipline her by saying " you are not my dad"!! 

Fiona --- 18 years ago -

I think the sooner the better. As far as her using it against him well the sad truth is she will use something against him even if it is just "you are the meanest parent in the whole world or the ever so popular I hate you" 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Of course she'll use it against him. Just like kids use "If you loved me you would let me", or "I hate you, you are mean". 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

thats what I keep telling him that she will always have something to use against him, if not that, then something else. I just feel the sooner the better and do you think that I should be there, he wants to do it alone??? Also. her "other biological grandparents have made SOME small attempts to be in her life and hubby doesnt like that either.. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Here is my take on this with the limited information you supplied. Since the biological father is not involved at ALL, and your current husband has adopted her..... I see NO REASON to tell her AT ALL> She HAS a father........ HIM> Leave it at that. Simple if you think about it. Since the biodad is just a sperm doner, let him remain just that, with the remainder of him washed down the drain with your shower at the time. Let her enjoy her REAL father, and her life with HIM. Simpler IS better. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for putting it so gently.. But my concern is that some of the family knows that he isnt her real father.. so what happens if someone "slips" one day and spills the beans.. that happened to a family member of mine and she was 17 at the time and devastated!! 

JET --- 18 years ago -

Kristen/Maggie, Give you husbands Kudos for adopting them. I have 4 kids and the first 2 (15/Matt and 10/Cara) I wasn't able to adopt. I firmly believe when they are of age, you should tell them. To wait, well I just believe if you wait its more of you asking 'what if they won't love me if they find out?' They will love you. They will have questions that you'll have to answer but that's alright. Answer them and love them. I don't know the situations of the 2 biological fathers, but in my case, the father was abusive. I wasn't around and my wife really doesn't like to talk about the past, thats alright too. I know his parents, their grandparents still want to be involved with their life, and thats also alright. as far as his responsibility to tell them, its both of yours. They'll have just as much questions for you as for him. TO adopt was a family decision, to tell them should be the same. JHMO..... Whatever you do... just let them know you love them and will always be there for them...... 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Bio-dad saw her last when she was 2 months old. His parents have asked for pictures and call me to see how she is periodically. I guess my main concern is that she will feel "unloved" or "unwanted" by her bio-dad and that kills me. She will want to know ho he is and why he didnt want her. that will be hard for an 8 yr old to understand, but at the same time alot less painfull! Agree?? 

JET --- 18 years ago -

no one ever said telling them would be easy. Its so easy to shield our children from things that we feel that will hurt them..... if she asks why doesn't he love me or want me?', just tell he loves her and wants her to be happy. Is it a lie? I don't know but I think I would rather do that then have her lying awake at night... The lord gave us the ability to have children, he just never gave us an instruction manual....... 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Thanks Jet, but he should have included that manual.. would have been real nice. lol. I'm really hoping that it will roll off her back and she wont think twice about it. Its just getting Dad to agree that the time is right... 

JET --- 18 years ago -

yeh... agreed, it would have been nice. Good luck with you and dad... and listening to you, it sounds like everything will turn out alright!! God Bless..... 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I think so too. God has this all planned out.. everything... we just have to make the adjustments. My hubby is an awesome man in every way and I could not have found a better father for her and my other children. (not that that's why i married him- of course, but he is wonderful with her. We were married when she was almost 2. and he has never ever treated her like a "step-child" or not his responsiblity. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

My daughter went through the whole process with us, it was a great experience for all of us. She was 6 yrs old at the time. 

JET --- 18 years ago -

how old is she now???? 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

she is 8 

fabulous --- 18 years ago -

Kristen, I think it is up to you; I have to say, though, don't wait too long...I have a (former) step-mother and a 1/2 brother...she was always against telling my brother that my 2 sisters and I were not his full blood sisters, so she told him that we were her kids...it was VERY strange. They didn't end up telling him until he was like 12 years old and then it WAS SHOCKING for him. Us 3 girls kept saying, "this is a little strange...we should just say it" (because we were much older than him" but we were being respectful of my father. When he finally found out, as I'm sure you can imagine, it WAS strange for him because they waited WAY TOO LONG. Of course, your daughter will find out eventually. I think you should tell her when you feel comfortable and the timing is natural. It's a delicate subject for everyone, and it's important that you handle it properly whenever you decide. It's different for everyone. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I am ready now and want to get this behind us.. no doubt. I do not want someone else to tell her in an accidental way. It's our responsibility to tell her not anyone elses. Thanks for everyones advice, I will keep checking the advice that is posted and give an update when we do tell her. Thanks again! 

JET --- 18 years ago -

8 ... that really is an age where they begin to understand and learn about the world around them..... our son Ian/4, he sees/hears the older 2 and sees their last name is different than his. He'll say "I'm Ian Jones' instead of his own last name because He idolizes his big brother. thats alright...I guess in the end, as long as your children see you love them, thats what counts. The worst a parent can do is tell them about their biological father and act as if they want the children to make a choice between fathers. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

My friend went through this when her daughter was 13, it wasn't pretty. She had always wanted to tell her the truth, but her husband didn't. Finally, the daughter asked her mother why she looks so much different than her brother, and she doesn't look anything like her dad...etc etc. That's when my friend told her the truth. She was completely shocked and the first words out of her mouth were, "Why did you lie to me?" It was devestating to both of them. So, from being there for my friend during this time, I would have to say, the sooner you tell them the truth the better. If there was absolutely NO WAY she could find out, then maybe never knowing would be better, but kids notice little things, and that's how this girl figured it out. Good luck, it's not an easy position to be in. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

My advice is to wait until she is twelve. Eight is too young, but you don't want to wait until she starts the tween years, that is a tough time for everything. Also, I would make a very special deal about it. Just you and your husband take her out to dinner as a special occasion and tell her how very blessed she is to have her father (step-father). Your husband will not be told you're not my father from her, because by that time especially she will have completely bonded and accepted him as her authoritative father. What was hard for me was, that now that I am 47, I have had bio-relations look me up and I like them and I want to have a relationship with them (not my bio-dad, he is deseased) and it has become a painful issue for my mom. So, think about some of this too. Good luck! When you and your husband tell her how very very much you love her, she will thrive in that. But, honesty is absolutely important, don't keep it from her. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Thanks momof5. ya, she has already asked things like that.. why she has a better tan that the other two and why her hair is darker and asks who she looks like more me or him so she is starting to notice these things already. Jet, as far as the bio-dad.. he's not even an option to be chosen as father for her. One reason, he is scum and the other reason he has legally signed away his rights. I dont think that he wanted the financial responsibility of it and that is the saddest part. He could have been a father if he wanted to be.. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

My friend's daughter asked if she could contact the bio dad, after NO communication at all. He wasn't there for the birth, nothing. My friend was very hesitant, but her daughter really wanted to see for herself what this guy was about. Well, he proved himself to her without anyone having to say a word against him. Broken promises of phone calls and possible visits, emails left unanswered. It was heartbreaking, BUT, she got to see the true colors of this man for herself. It also made her realize what being a real father is about, and made her appreciate her Dad that much more, even if they weren't "blood". The biggest question her daughter had when she was questioning things was why her eyes were brown, when everyone else's were blue..both parents and her brother. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

I still have that issue to deal with too. Bio-dad's family. In the first year of her life they were involved and i would take her to see them and send pictures, etc. Once my husband and I were married and the adoption done, that didnt happen anymore. Out of resepct for my husbands wishes he felt it would be easier for her not knowing that side of the family. This has also caused grief in knowing that she does have other family that should know her. They have made some attempts in being in her life, but they understand my husbands point of view and respect that. I can honestly say.. if i had a niece or granddaughter that the mom was keeping from me.. she'd have hell doing that. but thats just ME! 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

Of course she'll use it against him. My kids are adopted and not one (of course one is only 4 months old) has ever said "you're not my real mom" to me. I think you should tell her sooner than later...I know lots of adoptees who weren't told until later and they didn't like that. When it is a part of your "normal every day life" then it isn't so shocking or odd. It is all in your delivery and day to day attitude. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

Well, I would only hope that she doesnt want to meet the real dad. I do have a few pics of him and that is all I want her to know.. is what he looks like. He does also have 3 other children.. all boys.. that he doesnt have much dealings with either so she's not the only one. I will gladly give her that information if she wants it.. name.. phone #, etc, but I really and truly hope that she sees that he isn't worth the time and effort in making that call. 

JET --- 18 years ago -

Jet, as far as the bio-dad.. he's not even an option to be chosen as father for her he signed away his rights.... thats actually a good thing because now she can be loved by her real father.... its not a bad thing since now she has been blessed by a whole loving family. Share the information with her, don't break down bio-dad, build up 'DAD'. She'll learn in time about her real dad and the circumstances. Again, She has a loving set of parents that adore her more than anything.......this is enough to take her through anything!!! 

HappyMomma --- 18 years ago -

I myself was in your daughters shoes before. My suggestion being the one who "found out" would be not to say anything to her at all about it. I found out because someone slipped and I questioned my parents, I was 13. They were truthful and were ready to answer any and all questions openly. They did, I found out i had a brother I actually looked him up about a year ago and talked to him once on the phone and a couple times online but I never have contacted my "sperm donor" and don't plan to. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

ya, Jet, I'm sure that you are right. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

i was adopted when i was 5 and it was made part of our every day life...we celebrated anniversaries... it was made a BIG deal that they wanted us so badly... never hidden.... i dont think it should be kept from her.... 

humbleteacher --- 18 years ago -

I am always on the side of telling the truth. I just can't imagine how she would feel finding out from another source. It could be a birth certificate, a slip from a family friend, or blood typing. 

Carla --- 18 years ago -

My brother and I were both adopted when we were babies and there was never a time that I didn't know. It was just a part of my birth story. My mom would tell me how long they waited, what they were doing when they got the call, about the trip to the hospital, etc. Your parents are the people who raise you, and sometimes it is different than who you are born to. It's not a big deal unless you make it one, and if you don't tell her until later . . . you are turning it into something she has to be ashamed of. 

Raia's Mommy --- 18 years ago -

i am adopted, and can tell you from experience that telling her as soon as possible is the best way to go. i sit on both sides on this, and here's why. my parents never kept from me the fact that i was adopted, ive known as long as i can remember. what they did keep from me was the fact that i have a brother 2 yrs older than me. i didnt find that out until i was 18, and i was very hurt that my parents kept that from me....i still am hurt. my birth mother kept my brother, i dont know her or the circumstances of my adoption, but ive always grown up knowing i was loved. if you have any questions or anything pm me anytime :) 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

My brother was not told until he was about 20. My dad has been there since his birth, and I really don't think it should matter wether or not it was his sperm that fertilized the egg that became my brother. My dad IS his dad and it really didn't matter that he wasn't told before that. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

They have made some attempts in being in her life, but they understand my husbands point of view and respect that. I'm sorry, but I totally would not understand my husband's wishes if he didn't want my child's extended family in their life. 

3babyzmom --- 18 years ago -

ami- to better explain this... if she doesnt know that she is adopted... How would I explain the extended family. That is the reason they are not involved at this point... 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

In my opinion, the sperm donor signed away his families wishes when he gave up his parental rights to her. You are under no obligation to his family. That includes other siblings she may have. Keep it simple. Tell her she's adopted and thats it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground