Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should obese/overweight people have to pay more for insurance???

who's talking here?

4x4mom 1
stampin' gal 1
txsweetpotato 1
Sandyr9111 1
gking 1
amb07 1
cowboyswife 1
Mabbers 1
iwaveatcows 1
Itty Bitty Prints 1
HsMommy 1
Brennan 1
Carole 1
Breath 1
~sassy~ 1
Perfection 1
mommato3 1
brian* 1
SandFace 1
Lillabeth 1
TWHRider 1
caring parent 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
keepinitreal09 2
Spawn_of_Santa 3
Katrina 1
ts_the1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

I spend alot of time workin out, eating right and trying to stay healthy..My insurance cost is off the walls I spend close to 700 a month for my family and I and rarely use it... Something is not right..Should at risk folks have to pay a bigger portion since they have choosen to live unhealthy lifestyle??? Just tryin to stir debate??? 

Lillabeth --- 18 years ago -

Just like smokers do yes!! 

txsweetpotato --- 18 years ago -

possibly... but do you really think that making meeeeeeeee pay more for insurance will save uuuu money?? I think NOT... it will go in some fat cat's pocket, and NEITHER of us will see an advantage. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Actually, companies ARE starting to initiate programs concerning health-related issues...smoking, weight, gym programs, incentives, higher medical premiums for certain individuals, etc. I've read a variety of different approaches to this controversial issue. All's fair in love and war. 

Brennan --- 18 years ago -

Ok i am over weight, and i can tell you that the only thing that i seeks help for is heart burn. only cause i thought i had strep throat. i never knew it was heart burn but at this time i pay cash for my meds. I do not think that i should be penalized and charged a higher cost for medical when other then being fat i have no medical problems. i deal with my back and knee pain cause i know it is my own fault. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

rates are different based on health. I know when we got our new insurance they had a lady come here and do medical tests (blood work, blood pressure etc). The first thing she did? Weigh me and write down that I was within the normal range. I asked her if I was overweight or obese would the premiums be higher and she said 'absolutely'. 

cowboyswife --- 18 years ago -

I think NOT... it will go in some fat cat's pocket, and NEITHER of us will see an advantage. I agree! 

Katrina --- 18 years ago -

If it's a medical condition making them that way then no.. ie hypothyroidism 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

I spend alot of time workin out, eating right and trying to stay healthy..My insurance cost is off the walls I spend close to 700 a month for my family and I and rarely use it... Something is not right..Should at risk folks have to pay a bigger portion since they have choosen to live unhealthy lifestyle??? It is already happening....I'm just waiting for rates to be raised for folks whose parents have diabetes, heart problems, cancer.... 

caring parent --- 18 years ago -

If it's a medical condition making them that way then no.. ie hypothyroidism that's how i feel. I have hypothyroidism and was told when i was younger that it was just my genes. While my family is very thin and my grandmother had thyroid cancer....why should I pay more because the doctors didn't figure out what was wrong with me until I was way older. 

TWHRider --- 18 years ago -

I think so as long as the belimic/anerexic people have to pay more. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Yes. 

HsMommy --- 18 years ago -

I do not have any health problems and I am overweight. I do realize that I may oneday have issues because of my weight. Do I believe I should have to pay more? Maybe. I also believe that health care for everyone, including those on medicaide, should be revamped.undefined 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Yes, but it should be based on percentage body fat, not a height/weight chart. A lot of people who are considered healthy on a height/weight chart are carrying way too much body fat. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

I believe so. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

This is a really good question. I don't know just yet how I feel because....I have family members that are healthy, workout, eat right, etc. and they have high blood pressure, asthma and have had heart attacks, yet I am heavy and don't have any of these issues, so I am not sure that it would work, or at least how it would work. And then there is the question of overweight children, would they cost more also? My fear with this would be that they would then go without insurance, or adequate coverage due to the increased cost. Hmm, thoughts to ponder. 

Itty Bitty Prints --- 18 years ago -

Insurance is just that, insurance. I worked in insurance for 10 years as a financial analysis manager. On an individual policy, you bet you would see rates based on health condition. On a group policy, no. Risk is based on the group as a whole. You will have some employees who are older in poorer health than the 19 year old receptionist. Claims for the 19 year old will, historically, be much less than the 60 year old man. Premiums take all of those differences into account. Take this a step further....should women between the ages of 14 and 42 be charged more for health insurance? They are in the child bearing years. Pregnancy is not a disease, it is arguably an elective choice. You would have to raise the premiums for ALL women in this age range to assure you cover all of those who may have a baby. Should I pay more? We will not be having any more children, yet I fall in that age range. Do you see what I mean? You really can't pick and choose on the premiums. If they could, they would only choose healthy people. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

If it's a medical condition making them that way then no.. ie hypothyroidism I know people who pay significantly more for health and life insurance because they have high cholesterol levels - thin people! Purely genetic. Even when they shell out to the pharmo's for some stupid statin drug - they still don't get a break. It's like double jeopardy. Seems fair to me that if you represent a higher risk, then you pay a higher amount. Regardless of your weight. It just so happens that statistically leaner is healthier. Doesn't matter if you're fat now and claim to have no heath problems. Pffft! Let's here the report in 20 years after putting your body through all that extra work to maintain that heft, the heart problems, the organ failures, the joint problems..... I've seen too many "stong as an Ox" fat people die young because their body simply gave out. My step-dad was one of them. Healthy as can be when my mom married him. By the time he died at only 64, he had suffered neuropathy, diabetes, congestive heart failure, several mild strokes, debilitating joint troubles with his knees and ankles and kidney trouble....oh, and he sure didn't feel very good either. I won't even tell you how much those medical bills added up to when everything started "failing". Should he have paid higher premiums than someone who is more conscientious about their health? Absolutely. 

Breath --- 18 years ago -

Being an overweight person, I don't think that I have anymore health problems than anyone else. I DO NOT go to the doctor because of my weight. The only reason I have been treated by a Doctor is because I have a bad back because of being hurt on the job, not because of my weight and because I am having anxiety attacks. Neither has anything to do with my being overweight. I think that when people assume that since we are overweight that we go to the doctor all the time or need special care because of our weight is just crazy! If you are going to make us pay more then you need to make smokers pay more, people that have STD's pay more, people who do drugs pay more, people who have mental problems pay more...I could go on and on. I just think that is crazy. 

mommato3 --- 18 years ago -

I do think they should. I also think smokers should have to pay more and people who test positive for illegal drugs. when someone is overweight their vital organs like the heart have to work so much harder. those organs eventually give out and get tired. I feel that the insurance they pay more for should offer them weightloss surgery or a health plan with a weight doctor. When the weight is taken off, the premiums decrease. Stop smoking, lower premium. Sorry but that is how I feel. 

4x4mom --- 18 years ago -

I think insurance companies should be more PROACTIVE with weight isssues. They should cover more programs, offer healthy lifestyle info etc. I know my moms insurance company I am wanting to say Cigna or Aetna used to cover Weight Watchers classes. Also maybe a plan that covers a portion of a gym membership. If you start charging over weight people more money, then chances are things will get much worse as they will not be able to afford insurance and end up in the ER's etc and then you will be complaining that your tax dollars are covering them etc. I am overweight, but I work out, eat right (well most of the time), dont smoke, or drink excessively, good cholesterole, etc, but we are findning out that myt hyroid and hormones are off. You cant always assume that overweight people are fat lazy unhealthy people just because you are not. 

iwaveatcows --- 18 years ago -

hypothyroidism i'm hypo but NOT overweight. my husband's insurance (which we don't use, we use mine) offered discounts for wellness programs/activities. it is kind of strange though--i know a lot of obese folks that are *not* sick ever. Now maybe they take prescription meds for other problems. I don't know if we should penalize those folks because we don't know WHY they are large (well some are from just plain over eating, but you know what I mean--there are some legit reasons some are largish) but I really think folks like me who are in the gym 6-7 days/week should get some "credit" or whatever. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

As a chunky heifer I agree, we should pay more. Very very very few are obese because of medical conditions such as steroid use. Hypothyroidism will NOT guarantee you are obese, it is how you manage it that does. So yes, if we choose to be overweight then sure, charge us. If we choose to smoke charge us. If we choose to work overnight shifts at work - charge us (overnight workers are more unhealthy by statistics). If we choose to live near power plants that emit higher levels of chemicals in the air, charge us. All of these are choices in how to live that impact our health. I have no problem in charging for those. 

SandFace --- 18 years ago -

thought: Annual physical to evaluate health with a health rate scale/health score. Your score is submitted to insurance company and your insurance rate is based on your score. In return, your insurance company pays 100% of an annual physical. If you choose to not get a physical, then you get charged the highest rate. If you know you could lower your insurance rate, it might give people an incentive to live a healthier life sytle. win-win 

Spawn_of_Santa --- 18 years ago -

Maybe, but first we have to decide what obese is. The current system was developed in the 18th century and is WAY out of date. according to the current scales.. Brad Pitt is borderline overweight and Russell Crowe is obese. When I was in the Navy I weighed 220lbs, was a weight lifter (I could lift and carry over 600lbs) and a long distance runner (I ran 10 mile orienteering courses in high school --i sucked, but I did finish the courses). BUT according to the Navy I was fat. So until we get a good definition of what obese REALLY is, then I say no. and anyway, giving more money to the insurance companies is a horrible idea. It would be like giving free nuclear fuel to Iran or N. Korea... They would abuse that privilege as well. Additionally, with the state of care that insurance companies provide today, they are doing little to help people NOT be obese, so why should we give them a bonus? 

Spawn_of_Santa --- 18 years ago -

Oh, and another thing, if you're listening to insurance companies saying that YOUR rates will go down if we charge more to the obese... Yah, that's the same LIE they told us about mandatory car insurance too. MY RATES haven't gone down! have yours? 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Nice debate fellas!!! I just want to see more money going back into my pocket....One way or the other.. 

Spawn_of_Santa --- 18 years ago -

The best way to put more money in your pocket is to develop a TRUE universal health care system... Everyone focuses on Britain and Canada, but Germany's system is damned sight better than either and there is NO REASON why we couldn't develop one. In fact, we did a study on this my senior year in undergrad and decided that the money that fed govt saved from disability alone would offset about 40% of the cost!!! 

ts_the1 --- 18 years ago -

Let's face it.......living in this world as we know it today is not going to be easy or cheap. Everything is going up and the employers can't keep up by continuing to up our pay because they now feel it's not their responsibility. That's the issue with my employer and medical insurance. They bluntly told us that our deductibles, out of pockets and co-pays have increased because they think that the ones who use it, should be the ones to have to pay. Therefore, if you don't use it, then you don't have to worry. I am very fortunate that I work somewhere that my medical benefits are paid for at 100% and it's a PPO through UHC. However, my deductible is $1,000 and my out of pocket is $3,000. So, needless to say when I had to have 2 surgeries that I did not beg the docs for last year, paying these fees up front truly hurt my pocket book. And let's talk about car insurance - now they are doing surveys to find out how much time you spend on the road. They want to know how many miles you drive to and from work and if you are like me and drive 500 miles a week, your premium will sky rocket. Their thought is if you spend more time on the road you are more likely to be in an accident. What happen to the statistics that most accidents happen a mile from your house? Personally I think healthcare is so screwed up and needs a major overhaul. Someone needs to start with the greedy medical industry. I mean when a doc charges astronomical fees for what they do, it's no wonder the insurance companies can't keep up. GREED, GREED, GREED........that's what it is all about. In the small City where I work, there are 8 million dollar houses and the majority that live there are doctors. Get the picture??? 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

Maybe, but first we have to decide what obese is. The current system was developed in the 18th century and is WAY out of date. I agree. At 5'9" Im supposed to weigh like 158lbs or something like that. OMW I would look nasty sick anorexic at that weight. Im a big boned girl....at 180 Im pretty thin for my height. So therefore they can use the charts the Drs office uses and it be right for everyone. Id have to starve to death to get to 158. If u sit around and eat and get fat then yes Id agree....BUT thats like a buffet trying to charge overweight folks more because they are overweight and they "say" they will eat more. Hell Ive seen skinny folks eat me under the table. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground