Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What is your opinion on telling a patient his real diagnosis?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
outermaga 1
GCan 2
cmi 1
My 3 and Me 1
sewingbee 1
MoveIt 1
Deltadawn 1
*Vanessa* 1
4zmom 1
Sue 1
ghostpost 1
Carole 1
NYCGIRL 2
SandFace 1
bbraz 1
ts_the1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sewingbee --- 18 years ago -

My family is going through this right now. The patient, who has cancer, was told the cancer was very treatable. The fact is: the cancer is treatable if caught early. Unfortunately it wasn't. The patient was given all kinds of hope and was put on chemo. We were told the true story that it really was too late to do anything. The patient is in a lot of pain so they felt the chemo would help. I would think the chemo would make them even sicker. Why would you want to spend your last days like this? Wouldn't it be better to just make the patient comfortable until the end??? It is a very difficult situation. 

4zmom --- 18 years ago -

They should be honest with the person. Maybe they have a bucket list. (things left to do or say) 

My 3 and Me --- 18 years ago -

I think the patient should be told the truth! It is up to them to make decisions concerning their health. How can one make appropriate decisions without knowing the truth. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

I remember when the doctor told my mom there wasn't anything more to do. The last flicker of hope totally faded and she stopped trying. I had her 13 more days after that. 

NYCGIRL --- 18 years ago -

I am very sorry to hear you are going thru this. My family and I went thru this almost four years ago. I lost my sister, she was 32 . She died of cancer. As a family we decided to tell her the truth. She had colon cancer (no symptoms by the way) at stage four. It had spread to both lobes of her liver. After her resection surgery( no colostomy bag thank god) we waited a day to tell her. The doctors agreed . My sister was asking questions and we answered them truthfully. She did not want anyone telling her lies, she wanted to know what her battle was. I dont think it should be hidden from the person. Chemo does make them sick, my sister did ok. It was in the latter stages where she was getting worse. She died a year after her diagnosis. Chemo is not going to help with pain. Chemo kills all your good and bad cells. hence the side affects of nausea, vomitting, diarreha. Everyone is different on how they react to it. Cancer is an ugly death... 

outermaga --- 18 years ago -

I would want to know the truth... even thought it would be SO hard. My ex-FIL is dying of cancer right now. He wanted to know the truth. He didn't want to live his last days sick from Chemo. 

ts_the1 --- 18 years ago -

There are lots of support groups for this. Especially through MD Anderson. I think it would be best for this person to talk to others who are going through this same ordeal! Enjoy every second that life allows us to have! Choose carefully and live like everyday is your last! Go sky diving, rocky mountain climbing......ride a bull named fu man chu! And yes, the chemo does make one sicker. It kills cells in your body and if you're already weak, it could take a worse toll. It's up to the individual as to how much of a fighter they are. Prayers! 

SandFace --- 18 years ago -

They need to be honest! I lived through this. Those as$hole docs won't tell a patient the truth out of fear of being sued. In return someone close to me suffered for several additional months due to the false hope. Finally, after 4 months a different doc told us the truth. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

It is not fair to the patient to keep information from them. Anyone remember the guy on Oprah that did his "last lecture"? I've seen what chemo does, and if it isn't going to help, then there is no reason to suffer through it or go through the expense. Shame on a doctor that orders it for someone it will not help. Yes, some will respond poorly when told there are no further treatments that will halt the disease, others will make the best of the time they have left. 

NYCGIRL --- 18 years ago -

Those as$hole docs won't tell a patient the truth out of fear of being sued. Not all physicians.. the ones my sister had always, always were honest with her. 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

It is their body,they are paying for a professional opinion so anything other than the truth is just plain BS and ChickenS. If I were terminal, you betcha I would want to know. I don't want to feel like I have to put up "the good fight" and suffer needlessly if I'm terminal anyway. It is my choice to give up or fight for every moment. If my time is up, why would I want to suffer and prolong my family's suffering - I'm gonna die if I'm gonna die. Truth is better and in my opinion, anything but the truth (as best they know it) is malpractice. Don't spare me - you may be cursing me to months of agony for false hope. 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

If it were me, I would want to know. If it were my loved one, I would have to tell them, but man that would be so difficult. No chemo if it there is no chance of remission, why make it more painful or drag it out longer? 

MoveIt --- 18 years ago -

So Sorry Sewingbee. I was just thinking of you yesterday. No one has the right to keep the truth from someone in this situation. I am very surprised (and bothered) that a doctor would want to do this. I would want to know- I would skip the chemo and live the rest of my time as full as I could. 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

I totally agree that the patient needs to and should know the truth. I know I'd want to know. 

bbraz --- 18 years ago -

My sister had colon cancer 10 years ago. My family has never had cancer on either side so we really did not know what to expect. She took her chemo and radiation had extensive surgery and now 10 years later is well and cancer free. At her 5 year check up her doctor looked at her and said "we never thought you would make it". Truth is we did not realize she was that sick. We never thought she would not survive so in our case it was better we did not know. I remember her being soooo sick but death was not in our vocabulary. If she had known how sick she was I believe she would not have fought as hard as she did to get back to her daily routine. Only family knows what is best for their loved one. What ever decision you made I am sure it will be the right one. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

Only family knows what is best for their loved one. What ever decision you made I am sure it will be the right one. We did not tell my mother. She went through chemo and died shortly after starting her treatments for late stage ovarian cancer. I am not sure if we made the right decision or not. We felt she would been devastated and not had any fight if she knew. She remained optimistic to the end. We knew she had no unfinished business or peace to make (because we discussed these kinds of things often in healthy times) and words of love were never unspoken, so we felt in her case it was the best thing. In my heart, I think she may have known it was not curable, but just didn't want to have to deal with facing it. She had all of her "affairs" in order and so that was not something to worry about either. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

We felt she would been devastated and not had any fight if she knew. My mom was. In my heart, I think she may have known it was not curable, but just didn't want to have to deal with facing it. She had all of her "affairs" in order and so that was not something to worry about either. This is my reality as well. 

*Vanessa* --- 18 years ago -

I agree with you Sewingbee. It is their life and they should make the choice. If it was me I would want to have 1 day happy then 10 in pain. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

My MIL was given 6 months to live when she was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. I don't think it would have been right not to tell her. She hadthe opportunity to accept death and she got to see her first grandchild the day she let go and passed away. She got to express her wishes about how she wanted to be buried. She got to tell her sons things they needed to know. We all got to go on an awesome trip to the Bahamas with no worries in the world, something we all will never forget. She got to take out half of her life insurance benefit so she could do all the stuff she wanted to do. She got to know that her kids were set on good paths and her husband would be okay. She lived for 2 years because she was a fighter. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground