Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Fact check: Would Obama hike taxes on small businesses that employ 16 million?

who's talking here?

JDB2 8
randyjet 4
planemom 1
CyberSage 4
NoNameNoLastName 2
CommonSense 1
R.E.B. 2
Bliz 1
fishlady 15
Lillabeth 1
bruiserbetty* 4
onestepforward 1
Nightstorm 4
RiteWingKing 24
Squareduck 1
Warren Peace 16
jtcitrus 9
Captain Sensible 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

From CNN - The Statement: Speaking during a campaign stop Monday, Oct. 20 in Belton, Missouri, Republican presidential nominee Sen. John McCain criticized Democratic opponent Sen. Barack Obama's proposals on taxes. "The Obama tax increase would come at the worst possible time for America, and especially for small businesses like the one Joe dreams of owning," McCain said. "The small businesses Senator Obama would tax provide 16 million jobs in America." Get the facts! The Facts: McCain's criticism appears primarily aimed at Obama's personal income tax proposals — which he says would give tax cuts or leave taxes the same for individuals who make less than $200,000 or families that earn less than $250,000 — but increase them on people making more. Roughly 85 percent of small businesses are taxed at the owner's personal income tax rate, according to an editorial in the Wall Street Journal. Most of those businesses earn less than $250,000 a year. The McCain campaign uses figures from a National Federation of Independent Business survey to back up its claim. The survey says 12 percent of business owners who employ between one and nine people earn more than $200,000 a year — as do 27 percent of those who employ 10-19 people and 50 percent of those who employ between 20 and 250 workers. Obama says $200,000 is the lowest income level at which an individual would see a tax increase under his plan. But in assuming all of those business owners would see an increase, the McCain campaign appears to suppose that all of the business owners making between $200,000 and $250,000 would file their taxes individually, not jointly with a spouse or other family member. And roughly 15 percent of small businesses aren't taxed based on the owner's personal income rate, as the Journal notes. Based on those facts, it's impossible to know exactly how many of those business owners would see a tax hike — but it surely would not be 100 percent. The McCain campaign uses census figures to estimate how many people work for the businesses it says would be impacted — an effort McCain spokesman Brian Rogers acknowledges is "admittedly a rough estimate." The NFIB says the number of jobs small businesses create is "impossible to calculate," in part because some people only work at small businesses part-time while holding down full time jobs with a bigger employer. The Verdict: False. McCain uses an overly broad interpretation of the NFIB survey's figures — applying Obama's tax plan to those figures in a way that is highly unlikely to match reality. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

good article. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

Pelosi, Reid, and Obama will do exactly as they please, and we will have to like it. 

randyjet --- 18 years ago -

I am quite surprised that 85% of small business owners are not incorporated and are taxed at their owners personal imcome tax rate. That is simply foolish. I know that a flight instructor friend of mine who incorporated to protect herself and her assets, and she was the only employee of her company. I wonder why others do not do this simple not too expensive step. They would accrue a lot of benefits by doing so. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

So Obama favors taxing small businesses whose impact on jobs would be harmful, but the incremental difference below 100% of this bracket is "impossible to calculate". Is that supposed to be comforting? 

Lillabeth --- 18 years ago -

85% of small business owners are not incorporated Wow, that was the first thing we did. Can't believe that number is so high. 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

Pelosi, Reid, and Obama will do exactly as they please, and we will have to like it. They will, but American's won't like it. Pelosi promised change when the Democrats took over Congress 2 years ago. Today, her Democrat controlled Congress has a 12% approval rating. Obama has put himself on quite a pedestal. has has promised a lot to Americans. When he can't deliver, America will come down hard on him. Biden knows this. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Did you even bother to read what NoName posted????? !!! If they get informed enough, they will vote for Obama, and that's something they don't want to do. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Pelosi, Reid, and Obama will do exactly as they please, and we will have to like it. The only people doing exactly as they please is the McCain camp and their so called "facts." You demonstrated this in your post. 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

I thought payroll expense was an expense. If a business hires more people wouldn't they have a higher payroll expenses thus lower taxes. I don't see the correlation of higher taxes, fewer jobs. Could someone explain. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Obama has put himself on quite a pedestal. has has promised a lot to Americans. When he can't deliver, America will come down hard on him. Biden knows this. I disagree. I think Obama will get a pass from voters and historians much like FDR did. He's a sympathetic figure and I think he's capable of hanging on to that identity because he is extremely likeable. Since the dawning of the TV broadcasting era, national elections have tended to swing toward the more likeable candidate: 1956: Eisenhower/Stevenson 1960: Kennedy/Nixon 1964: Goldwater/Johnson 1968: Nixon/Humphrey (Humphrey was linked to Johnson and the Vietnam war) 1972: Nixon/McGovern 1976: Carter/Ford 1980: Carter/Reagan 1984: Reagan/Mondale 1988: Bush/Dukakis 1992: Bush/Clinton 1996: Clinton/Dole 2000: Bush/Gore 2004: Bush/Kerry 2008: Obama/McCain Based on likeability, Obama gets the nod in this one. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I thought payroll expense was an expense. If a business hires more people wouldn't they have a higher payroll expenses thus lower taxes. I don't see the correlation of higher taxes, fewer jobs. Could someone explain. Generally, you have to make money (or believe in the prospect of making money) in order to hire people. To hire someone, you need to believe you can cover the cost of labor and assorted taxes collected from consumers with your excess $. Payroll costs are more than just salary. It's also not solely about taxes. Other variables include the rising cost of labor when entitlements get factored in. Starting next July, the cost of labor will have risen over 40% over 3 years for jobs that pay either minimum wage or are indexed to minimum wage due to legislated increase. These jobs tend to be service/manufacturing jobs and are often small businesses. Obama also wants to raise minimum wage an additional 45% over 2 years AND index it to inflation. One of the problems with this is inflation tends to rise WITH the cost of labor. Are you seeing the cumulative effect yet? If you owned a small business, or even a large one, how enticing is it to be hiring under these circumstances? 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

I follow your logic on the minimum wage but not on higher taxes. A higher minimum wage may actually hurt the people it intends to help through lower employment. Tax policy can assist in higher employment numbers. Increase the overall business tax but give an additional tax credit for hiring additional workers would increase employment. 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

but give an additional tax credit for hiring additional workers would increase employment. But do you know what happens when you do that? Companies see that as a chance to lay-off existing workers. Then they can hire new people and get the tax credits. 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

But do you know what happens when you do that? Companies see that as a chance to lay-off existing workers. Then they can hire new people and get the tax credits. It all depends on how the law is written. 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

What about Obama raising the unemployment tax that the employers pay along with their share of employment federal taxes that he wants to raise and social security????? You don't thing that is going to matter to jobs in the long run? 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

What about Obama raising the unemployment tax that the employers pay along with their share of employment federal taxes that he wants to raise and social security????? You don't thing that is going to matter to jobs in the long run? 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I'm glad you joined this chat fishlady. Since you are a small business owner, which candidate seems poised to influence a more favorable business environment? 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

I actually went to read the obama plan in detail..every word and he is planning on getting his money from the businesses, big and small by raising their taxes......you can see it anyway you want but any which way small business's, even those that make under 200,000 will see an increase in their payroll taxes.......I have been open for 6 months and have paid almost 15.000 in payroll taxes at the current rate! That is me matching, it is a lot! I would have to either increase prices or decrease my workforce if it was to go up anymore. I do know McCain wants to encourage small businesses to grow without punishing them......and I obviously support McCain because I do not believe in the "share the wealth" that Obama is so fond of........if I ever make that much I made it with hard work, long hours and plenty of stress on my family life and I shouldn't be punished for it, if anything hard work should be rewarded and I think it is a sad day in this country when working hard, putting yourself through school working two jobs, living in a crap apartment, eating ramen noodles and mac and cheese for 4 years to get that degree for that job that you have to work to years to prove yourself for, pay back all those college loans to get that high (much deserved salary) just so you can have more of it taken away........do not think so. If you want to give it away it should be your choice....... a charity of your choice to help a family member to go on a much needed vacation to save for retirement ANY WAY YOU choose. Just because you make over 250,000 doesn't mean you don't deserve EVERY penny. LOL.....that's what you get for asking my opinion but in short answer.... it scares the crap out of me to have opened a business this year and Obama and the democrats having control over congress next year with what all they want to tax small business owners on. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

what restaurant do you own, fishlady? just curious. 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

The Kingwood Catfish Place on Northpark 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

The Kingwood Catfish Place on Northpark that is right, i remember you saying that once. my mom loves your place and she is not easy to please because she can throw down in the kitchen. i have never been. i do not like fried catfish. :) 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

I make homeamade fried chicken strips, blackened grilled chicken, shrimp and will (as of Friday) carry broccoli cheese soup and chicken and dumpling soup along with fresh salads. I try and have something for even the non fish lovers.. 

Captain Sensible --- 18 years ago -

The Kingwood Catfish Place on Northpark fishlady I love your fish. The best I have had. Your take on Obama is so true. We should all be scared. Wake up America. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

now your talking my language. i love fish, just not catfish, ever carry any salmon??? i need to come check it out. what time do you open for lunch? 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

We open at 11am and I only carry catfish, BUT I will have to give you a sample of the fish. It is not like just anyones catfish....no mud taste, all white flaky meat, NO strong fishy taste. I have so many people that do not like catfish or fish and love mine. Hope to see you soon. I will be working all during lunch on Friday. 

fishlady --- 18 years ago -

Thank you Captain Sensible! 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I'll stop by this weekend fishlady. I'll probably try to pick up a small order for the LSU - Georgia game. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Obama says $200,000 is the lowest income level at which an individual would see a tax increase under his plan. Obama is going to raise taxes on people making less than $250,000 if he removes the pay cap on FICA. However, because it's a payroll tax and not an income tax I guess it count as a tax increase. 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

FICA (Payroll Tax) is a very regressive tax. When the republicans state that the rich pay all the taxes they exclude FICA. This is just another tax. Over 1.3 trillion has been used to pay for general government. Small Business and Working people (as myself being a professional) are the most hurt by this tax. It has a fixed rate and cuts off at 102K. The rich have a max amount that they pay and unearned income is not taxed by FICA. I think we should have no limit on the and reduce that contribution required by small business. I think this would help fishlady. My wife has her own business. With FIT and FICA we have over a 40% TAX RATE. Warren Buffet has a 15% tax rate on dividend income. How is this fair. 

Squareduck --- 18 years ago -

Obama has put himself on quite a pedestal. has has promised a lot to Americans. When he can't deliver, America will come down hard on him. Biden knows this True Dat Homie! And how will they deal with this? hmmmmmmmmmmmm SCREWING us somemore! 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

Obama is going to raise taxes on people making less than $250,000 if he removes the pay cap on FICA He will suspend it at 102K then pick it up over 200k. How many employees does fishlady making over 200K. Actually I don't think there should be any income hole. In fact unearned income should also be taxed. Then we can reduce this high rate and make it a little more fair. 

jtcitrus --- 18 years ago -

Everyone is debating raising taxes on small businesses. But why raise taxes on any business? ever? all it does is deplete the pool of capital available for reinvestment and cause them to raise prices. which counteracts the tax cuts he wants. And I disagree NonameNolastname: if people were truely well informed they'd vote against Obama because the Republicans don't have much of a chance at getting a majority back in either house. One party in control of all three houses is NEVER good. 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

it does is deplete the pool of capital available for reinvestment and cause them to raise prices Human labor actually creates wealth. It Produces goods and services. Why should we tax that instead of passive investments. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

Pelosi, Reid, and Obama will do exactly as they please, and we will have to like it. Call me names if you must, but we all know what will happen to taxes when these 3 operate with veto-proof and filibuster-proof majorities. Ireland? New Zealand? These people never heard of 'em. A leopard is much more likely to eat your young than he is to change his spots. 

jtcitrus --- 18 years ago -

because any time you impose a tax you distort the market. The argument for taxing labor is that labor is relatively inelastic... meaning that the amount of labor supplied is relatively insensitive to changes in wages. therefore the overall market distortion caused by taxing labor is less than that caused by taxing other things. 

jtcitrus --- 18 years ago -

... the "pie" can grow bigger faster if the wedge between what people pay and companies receive (the tax) avoids distorting the market as much as possible. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

Me vote for Obama? Actually, no. Not if he were the most fiscally conservative man on the planet. Not with those views on abortion, and his loathing of America. 

RiteWingKing --- 18 years ago -

"taxes distort the market." All taxes distort the market. People become less productive when they are unfairly taxed. Lets concentrate wealth a little more like Mexico. Screw the middle class. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Human labor actually creates wealth. It Produces goods and services. Why should we tax that instead of passive investments. If you're hinting at favoring a consumption tax rather than a tax on productivity, we would be in agreement. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground