Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

First Grade Spelling Test Question

who's talking here?

momma0204 1
ilovemykids1030 1
Fallon 3
randyjet 1
HIAAK 3
Fancy 1
fabulous 1
Mygirl01 11
Homeschool mom 1
HsMommy 2
Betty 1
Unichic™ 1
justcat 3
Mommyto3kiddos 4
ladybughomeschool 1
Danabug 1
PHSMOMOF2 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

Do you think it is right for a teacher to mark a word incorrect if the word was spelled correctly but capitalized? This is first grade.  

Danabug --- 17 years ago -

Yes, she is teaching him spelling and correct use of words and punctuation. It sucks for the kid, but that is part of learning. 

HIAAK --- 17 years ago -

I think she should as well because the correct spelling is with it capitalized... 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

So on a spelling test if the word is bad and the child writes it on his or her paper as Bad, the teacher should mark it wrong? She asked the child to spell the word bad, which the child did and it was correct. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

Yes, she is teaching him spelling and correct use of words and punctuation. It sucks for the kid, but that is part of learning. agreed ! 

HIAAK --- 17 years ago -

if the word is bad and the child writes it on his or her paper as Bad, the teacher should mark it wrong? She asked the child to spell the word bad, which the child did and it was correct. same scenario if she asked him/her to spell Monday and they spell it monday is it wrong? Yes because that is not the proper way to spell it. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

I’m a first grade teacher and I do not agree with marking it wrong. The point of first grade writing is to teach children to get their thoughts down on paper. At that age getting their ideas from their head to the paper is a task in itself. The process by which a child thinks of a topic to write about and gets it down on paper has a few steps. First thinking of the topic, second organizing it into beginning middle and end and then finally writing it down. There is so much their little brains have to do, that constantly correcting spelling, capitalization and punctuation creates a sort of mental block. Not only are they trying to get their ideas down, now they have to worry about spelling, capitalization and punctuation. Spelling, punctuation and capitalization are things that should be thought through mini lessons before the actual writing session, but should not be corrected until about second grade when the children have mastered putting their ideas on paper. Now, if you do have the particular word in question on your word wall, then you can point the word out and suggest they change it. There are many other issues to tackle in children’s writing at this age such as spacing, beg middle and end, main idea and so on. Children will learn to spell, the will learn to capitalize and punctuate, but these things are like the windows and doors on a house. First you need the foundation and then the extras. Now if only I could get the parents of my kids to understand this, they would not be so stressed out. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

Monday and they spell it monday...that is not the proper way to spell it Monday is a day of the week, not the same thing. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Do you think it is right for a teacher to mark a word incorrect if the word was spelled correctly but capitalized? This is first grade. Both my children's teachers do this too. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

We aren't talking about words that should always be capitalized like days of the week, months, People's names and so on. Just your everyday average vocabulary word. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I’m a first grade teacher and I do not agree with marking it wrong. I defer to the expert! I would hope that others would too. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 17 years ago -

my first grader doesnt even do spelling words and tests yet! 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

So, should they be telling the child it is a spelling and puntuation test? Because in my brain if you spell a word correctly, it isn't wrong if it has a capital letter at the start. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

I defer to the expert! I would hope that others would too. not an expert at all, if I was an expert I would not be in graduate school right now. Im simply stating an opinion. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

my first grader doesnt even do spelling words and tests yet thats great. They will love to write then. Spelling tests can often frustrate young ones and make them not want to try at all. Good for their teacher. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

My sons teacher did this in first grade. By first grade they have to start getting the foundations down. You do not capitalize certain words. And it quickly becomes a habit. In second grade the teacher was even more strict. So it was a good thing his first grade teacher prepared him for what was coming. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

By first grade they have to start getting the foundations down. You do not capitalize certain words. And it quickly becomes a habit. you would be surprised how many kids dont develop a habit, if they have strong writing skills, and by that I mean fundamentals. Then caps, punct and spelling is something there is no need to worry about until second grade. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

You do not capitalize certain words. What words do you not capitalize? I am lost on that one. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I was referring to words like and, hat, words that are not days of the week, or months, etc. Obviously you do not capitalize every word, especially on a spelling test. My youngest is having a heck of time getting this whole capitalize the first letter of his name but not the others. But he has to learn it. Why not email your sons teacher and ask her if she has been talking to the class about this. I imagine she has. I am a big believer in teaching the basics, and getting the kids as strong of a foundation as you can give them as early as they are able to learn. I say this because the foundations make all the other learning that is coming their way much easier to grasp. It has been easy for my oldest, but I know beyond a doubt that for my youngest this is going to be a nightmare. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

Ok got it but all the words on her test that she capitalied could be correct because they can all start a sentence they were not words like that. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Oh then I would email and tell her you want a list of the noncap words and cap words for the next test. 

Homeschool mom --- 17 years ago -

Did she have a practice sheet to use for homework? How were they written on that? 

Betty --- 17 years ago -

Maybe she should only count off a few points but not the whold word. I guess we don't make the rules. I think they are a little too hard on the first graders. I have a DGD that is in the first grade. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

Did she have a practice sheet to use for homework? How were they written on that? Yes she had a list and yes they were all written in lower case. As part of her weekly homework she has to write a sentence for each word, and the sentences she wrote all had those spelling words at the begining. Spelling word which, when on my dd's homework she put Which way to the store? When do you get home from school? So, as she was "practicing" her words she was doing it in upper case, so I can see where the confusion was. 

Fancy --- 17 years ago -

My sons 1st grade teacher did not mark them wrong for capitalization. In fact if they threw a capital letter in somewhere in the middle or end, she was fine with it. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

She does get to take the real test on Friday, Thursday's tests are to test out of the Friday test and this is the first time she has not gotten a 100 and she was in tears on our way home, and I can't explain why she missed the words to her. 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

Mine was not counted off for Caps in first grade,but it had to be correct in the sentence they had to write. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

i don't think they should be counted as wrong 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

whoops, double post 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

She sounds like a smart girl,I am sure when she calms down,she will understand.. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

it had to be correct in the sentence they had to write. I expect that if she is constructing a sentence that all rules they have learned so far would apply, but I am at a loss on the "spelling test" that was counted wrong for improper capitalization. 

HIAAK --- 17 years ago -

I don't know maybe there is a difference with the private school that I went to and public school. My dd went to the same school for a while and although she was in 1st grade she was doing 3rd grade public school stuff helping the neighbors kids out with their homework... 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

She sounds like a smart girl Thank you, I like to think so too. She has all 100's in spelling for the entire year and today's 20 did a whopper on her ego! 

fabulous --- 17 years ago -

here is some perspective- My 1st grader just got this week's spelling test sent home today- they do spelling words and then a dictation sentence...everything together gets counted into a grade- 100%...sometimes optional bonus words can give a 102% or 104%. Starting at the beginning of this sememster, They get 1/2% counted off per letter that is incorrectly capitalized. However, that is new for this semester-, so I guess that they have differentiated between him "learning" how to spell and getting used to the tests (we didn't do any spelling tests in kindergarten), and having to accept getting penalized for having incorrect capitalization, which is important and very valuable to be learning. I'm glad that he is learning this early on and I hope that this 1/2% will cause him to be aware of his writing. Hard to explain to a 1st grader, though- being a kid is so hard... ;) 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I would not count off if my first grade daughter capitalized a spelling word by mistake. In some children, it takes longer to differentiate lower case "b" from lower case "d". They compensate by using an upper case B. I would simply bring it to her attention and correct it in ink. I would not take away points. To be fair, however, in a classroom situation where 20 kids are involved, it might be necessary to bring it to the childs attention this way. It is hard to do one on one correction with so many kids. 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

We did not have spelling words this week.Maybe because 3rd's science fair projects are due,and a short week.He did tell me they are changing how they do theirs as well. 

momma0204 --- 17 years ago -

Yes she had a list and yes they were all written in lower case. Did she have a practice sheet to use for homework? How were they written on that? If I was the teacher, I would expect that the words be written exactly as shown on their spelling list. As a parent of a 1st grader, I make my DS practice his spelling words just as his teacher showed them on the list. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
parenting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground