Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question to Left: If You Love America, Why "Transform" It?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
smartypants 1
steinhoister 1
NoNameNoLastName 4
Mabbers 1
david 2
~sassy~ 3
rEVOLution 1
Wilstar77 2
believer 6
oneyedman 1
anti-antichange 1
zombie slayer 3
another name* 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

Perpetual criticism is not a sign of affection. If you met a man who said he would like to "transform" or "remake" his wife, would you conclude that he: a) thought very highly of his wife and loved her? Or b) held his wife in rather low esteem and therefore found living her rather difficult? The answer is obvious: Those who wish to remake anything (or anyone) do not think highly of the person or thing they wish to remake. Little is as revealing of Barack Obama's and the left's view of America than their use of the words "transform" and "remake" when applied to what they most want to do to America. I among others pointed this out during the presidential campaign when Obama frequently promised he would "transform America." That is why those of us attuned to the importance of words and who hold America in high esteem were so worried about an Obama election. Americans on the left frequently attack critics for labeling them "unpatriotic" and/or accusing them of not loving America. The first charge is false to the best of my knowledge. I have searched in vain for an instance of a normative conservative or Republican spokesman calling Democrats or liberals "unpatriotic." The second, however, is a more complex question. It is not an attack on the left to say that their own rhetoric suggests that they love a vision of America considerably more than they love the reality of America; that they love what America could be rather than what it is. Otherwise, how to explain this liberal vocabulary of "remaking" and "transforming" America. You don't yearn to transform or remake that which you love. Many years ago, the prominent Jewish writer, my friend since childhood, Rabbi Joseph Telushkin, helped to clarify -- in a non-partisan way -- a major difference between liberals and conservatives. "Conservatives," he said, "romanticize the past; liberals romanticize the future." The romanticizing of the future has been a distinguishing characteristic of the left since Karl Marx. Leftist ideologies have secular eschatologies. The further left one goes the greater the belief in revolution, the need to overthrow the contemporary order. That is why Marx so hated religion -- he and Engels saw it as the "opiate of the masses" because religion, in their view, taught people how to deal with their (abject) condition rather than to become revolutionaries. But one day -- one great day - "all men will be brothers" in the stirring words of the revolutionary song that ends Beethoven's Ninth Symphony. The problem is that compared with such a future utopia, no actual society could possibly compete. Certainly not racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, unequal America. In light of those frequently made criticisms of America, I have often asked representatives of the left why they criticize America so much if they love it so much. "Precisely because we love America, we criticize it. You criticize that which you love," is the nearly universal response. But, of course, it isn't true. If you constantly criticize your spouse, for example, it is difficult to imagine that you really do love him or her. And perhaps more important, it is very unlikely that your spouse feels loved. That is why after being routinely described as racist, sexist, imperialist, etc., it is difficult to be able to tell that America is loved by the left. This is not written in order to indict the left, let alone the president, for not loving America. No one can measure an other's feelings. Furthermore I do not question the sincerity of anyone who says he loves America. What I question are the actions and rhetoric of those who claim to love America yet want to transform and remake it. By: Dennis Prager  

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

That is one of the MANY things that bother me about Obama! He has (supposedly) risen from less than perfect circumstances, to become the President of the United States!...and yet he hates our country and the people that allowed him to get there and thinks that HE can do better! 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I think we need to evolve as a society. There are many things that need improving and there are many things that need to be created. By changing with the times and situations we have a better chance to survive. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

So if you love someone, and they develop a nasty crack habit, we should accept the crack, perhaps become their dealer? If we loved them, then i guess we would not try to help them change. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

maybe we should bring back slavery, and dissolve their rights, you know, take away their right to vote, marry, hold property, WOMEN too, the dang hefers!! What do they need rights for? 

believer --- 17 years ago -

I think we need to evolve as a society. Examples of your type of "evolve" have been the sanctioning of murder through the abortion of babies in their mother's womb and the euthanasia of old people. Seems more like digression to me. 

believer --- 17 years ago -

So if you love someone, and they develop a nasty crack habit, we should accept the crack, perhaps become their dealer? If we loved them, then i guess we would not try to help them change. So if you love someone, and they develop a nasty perverse sex habit, we should accept the perverseness, perhaps become their enabler? If we loved them, then I guess we would not try to help them change. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

So if you love someone, and they develop a nasty perverse sex habit, we should accept the perverseness, perhaps become their enabler? If we loved them, then I guess we would not try to help them change. That is awesome, you agree that we SHOULD help them change. That you can love something and STILL want to change some of the bad stuff. :D 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Somehow...I just don't think either side of party lines desire crackheads and prostitutes on every corner. But to listen to KU... 

believer --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

another name* --- 17 years ago -

believer, do you have any perversions? do you look at adult pictures, or porn? Gay people's "sin" as it were is NO GREATER than your or my sin. 

another name* --- 17 years ago -

I definitely believe this country needs a transformation. Back to the Constitution. I believe that the last eight years admin got us so far away from the Constitution that this is why Barack Obama is using the strong arm of the government to get us back to the Constitution. There ARE times when government is important. And this is one of those. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Because the world changes, and if we don't change with it, our beloved America will fall into oblivion. Question I have to you is - how far back do you want to go? Where do you draw the line from which "change" became bad? 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Those who wish to remake anything (or anyone) do not think highly of the person or thing they wish to remake. The Constitution is thought by many to be a living document, able to change according to the peoples' interpretation of it. It was written in flexible language which allows for social and technological change over time. Thomas Jefferson wrote, "I am not an advocate for frequent changes in laws and constitutions, but laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the human mind. As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries are made, new truths discovered and manners and opinions change, with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also to keep pace with the times." People in this country love ideals such as liberty and equality contained in the Constitution, but the interpretation of the ideals has changed, and yes, this country has undergone transformation over time as a result. The ability to change is one of this country's greatest assests. I cannot imagine America would be better with women unable to vote or owning another human still legal, among other things. Interpretation of the ideals set down in the Constitution is what has changed, not the ideals themselves. We still hold true to them, and try through our laws to implement them fairly for all. I love my children dearly, but I do not expect them to behave as children when they are adults. It is only because I love them so that I work to transform them into civilized, compassionate, responsible human beings. If I didn't love them, I wouldn't care what they were, and what they became. Wanting change, therefore, does not always represent a lack of regard for someone or something. In fact, it can be an expression of the highest regard. 

believer --- 17 years ago -

That is awesome, you agree that we SHOULD help them change. That you can love something and STILL want to change some of the bad stuff. :D Yes, I do agree with you that we should help them change from their perversion. Gay people's "sin" as it were is NO GREATER than your or my sin. Yes, that is true. However, it doesn't justify their sin. 

another name* --- 17 years ago -

there is no justification for sin. Not yours either. What if a whole group of very hateful and so-called Christian people targeted YOU because of one of your sins? They heckled, harassed, threatened, took out ads, sponsored bills, ostracized, bullied all these horrible things that people do to gay people. Leave them alone. It is not for us to "crucify" them with hate. Absolutely not for us. 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

So if you love someone, and they develop a nasty crack habit, we should accept the crack, perhaps become their dealer? If we loved them, then i guess we would not try to help them change. change. evolution. the circle of life. the older i get, the more i am for change! 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

 

believer --- 17 years ago -

They heckled, harassed, threatened, took out ads, sponsored bills, ostracized, bullied all these horrible things that people do to gay people. I haven't seen this type of action from Christians. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

They heckled, harassed, threatened, took out ads, sponsored bills, ostracized, bullied all these horrible things that people do to gay people. I haven't seen this type of action from Christians. You gotta be kidding me. It looks like you need to watch a different news channel. Google "gay hate crimes", then we will talk. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I think we need to evolve as a society. There are many things that need improving and there are many things that need to be created. Such as..... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

The problem is that compared with such a future utopia, no actual society could possibly compete. Certainly not racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, unequal America. In light of those frequently made criticisms of America, I have often asked representatives of the left why they criticize America so much if they love it so much. "Precisely because we love America, we criticize it. You criticize that which you love," is the nearly universal response. The same counter argument can be made. There is a romanticized perception of the past that does not match the realities of our past. As for criticism, there are two types - constructive and destructive. Obviously you don't engage in destructive criticism toward something or someone you love. However, constructive criticism is a positive thing, as its final goal is the improvement of the beloved person or thing. Lack of constructive criticism translates to stagnation. Destructive criticism translates to destruction, as its name imply. You can't bundle both together and state that criticism is bad. You need to be careful with generalizations. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Rev I love that video! 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I think we need to evolve as a society. There are many things that need improving and there are many things that need to be created. Such as.....  We need to get away from burning fossil fuels. Lets move forward and develop better technology to harness wind, solar and hydrogen power. We embargo Cuba for 50 years and nothing happened. Castro is still in power and the people are the ones who suffer. Let's talk to the leaders we don't agree with and try to find a common ground. We teach our children to not Bully and be civil to one another. We should do the same as adults. We gotta bring back science in the forefront. Stem Cell Research, Global Warming, Pollution and Education are important issues that need to be made priority for the benefit of mankind. These are just a few, can anybody think of anything else. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

These are just a few, can anybody think of anything else. Yeah, getting rid of Obama...which is coming in 3 & one half years lol ;D 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, getting rid of Obama...which is coming in 3 & one half years lol ;D Obama is currently the status quo. The people spoke and embraced his message. If you love America, why do you want to change it? Why do you criticize the status quo? 

david --- 17 years ago -

The "embrace" is over look at the number of people that watched his last speech people are seeing obama for what he is a radical socialist that will lead america to another depression I've asked so many times what has obama accomplished while in office besides debt and making america vulneeable to attacks 

steinhoister --- 17 years ago -

I've asked so many times what has obama accomplished while in office besides debt and making america vulnereable to attacks The bush fear machine seems to have worked on you... 

believer --- 17 years ago -

You gotta be kidding me. It looks like you need to watch a different news channel. Maybe you need to be the one to watch a different news channel. 

david --- 17 years ago -

I see stein avoided the accomplishment part of the ? Its we know its nothing 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground