Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why do we need national health care when we have this?

who's talking here?

randyjet 8
Sandyr9111 2
AuthorMan 1
david 1
~sassy~ 9
Perfection 5
LilMarJed 1
summygood 4
*maryc 1
voice of reason 1
JohnLynch 2
NewNanna 1
mommie21g1b 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Welfare reform opens Medicaid to millions By Dennis Cauchon, USA TODAY MARIETTA, Ohio — Jeremy Carpenter, 20, is a mechanic at a used car lot. His wife, Jessica, 21, stays home with their infant son and often cares for two nephews. Before welfare reform, this working family would have been mostly or entirely without health insurance. Today, the Carpenters have complete government-financed medical, dental and optical care. So does Jessica's sister, a Wendy's restaurant manager, and her husband, a carpenter. "I don't know what we'd do without 'The Card,' " says Jessica Carpenter, referring to a prized piece of paper twice the size of a driver's license that entitles her family to nearly free medical care. The expansion of Medicaid to cover the working poor has fundamentally broadened the nation's safety net and changed the lives of low-wage workers in the USA. It also has put enormous strain on federal and state finances and made taxpayers the health insurance provider for millions of workers at Wal-Mart, McDonald's and other low-wage employers. The success of welfare reform in moving people off of cash assistance and into low-paying jobs has, for better or worse, moved the nation a step closer to a government-run national health care system. The change has occurred mostly in poor and working-class neighborhoods, out of view of the affluent and well-insured. But here in Washington County, a relatively poor area along the Ohio River and the Appalachian Mountains, the change is startling. Dramatic numbers The county had 427 families on cash assistance in 1997 when welfare reform began. Today, it has just three. During that time, the number of people on Medicaid rose from 4,020 in 1997 to 7,316 today. "People who left welfare went into jobs paying $5.15 to $7.15 an hour," says Michael Paxton, the county's welfare director. "Medicaid and food stamps and child care assistance make it possible for people to work at low wages." Health coverage has been a costly side effect of welfare reform. Medicaid spending has soared 85% since 1997, to $295 billion last year. The program's growth has outstripped that of Medicare, the government insurance program for seniors. Medicaid enrollment surpassed Medicare's in 2001 and now covers 5 million more Americans. Many states now spend more on Medicaid than anything else, including education. Tennessee and Missouri recently scaled back Medicaid coverage. But, overall, state legislatures largely have protected and expanded Medicaid spending, even during the recession earlier this decade. One reason: Every $1 in state spending on Medicaid generates an average of $1.44 in federal matching money. Medicaid and the related Children's Health Insurance Program covered an average of 46.8 million Americans a day in 2004, up more than 13 million from when welfare reform passed in 1997. The program covered 61 million people at some time during 2004, nearly 20 million more than in 1997. "Without saying so directly, the Republican-controlled Congress has retooled Medicaid from a program that helps mostly the poor and disabled into one that tackles the issue of working Americans who don't have health insurance." WHO? THE REPUBLICANS? "This is not a mistake. It was the explicit intent of Congress to expand coverage to working families," says Ron Haskins, co-author of the book Welfare Reform and Beyond. "The original sin of social policy was tying Medicaid directly to welfare. Now, it's tied to working." States determine who qualifies for Medicaid, so eligibility varies. In Minnesota, for instance, a family of four with annual income up to $54,000 qualifies for Medicaid. A single adult without kids can earn up to $17,000 (about $8.25 an hour full time) and get Medicaid. This brings nearly universal coverage to fast-food workers, nursing aides and other low-income workers. Visible effects Ohio has stricter rules than most states. Adults without children don't get insurance unless they have exceptionally high medical bills. Even so, Medicaid enrollment has grown from 1.1 million in 1997 to 1.7 million today, or about 15% of the state's population. For those who qualify — generally children in families earning up to $40,000 and parents in families earning up to $20,000 — Ohio's package covers a wider range of services than in most states. The Medicaid boom can be seen in medical clinics opening in poor neighborhoods. A dental clinic aimed at Medicaid patients opened here in Marietta, a block from the welfare office. In Springfield, the Rocking Horse Center, a modern pediatric clinic, opened in 1999 in the poorest neighborhood of the central Ohio city and now serves 6,000 children. It doubled in size this year with a federal grant secured by Sen. Mike DeWine and Rep. Dave Hobson, both Ohio Republicans. The non-profit center has three workers who use computers connected to the state Medicaid system to qualify people for coverage. "There's no doubt children are receiving better medical care because of this money," says pediatrician James Duffee, the clinic's founder. Without the Medicaid expansion, 12% to 14% of patients' medical bills would be unpaid, instead of the current 3% to 4%, Duffee says. Republicans and Democrats have supported efforts to expand health insurance for poor children and parents, Duffee says. "Our motto is: Not from the left, not from the right, but from the spirit." Medicaid costs also have risen because of aggressive efforts to get eligible people to sign up. States have simplified paperwork, made renewals automatic or less frequent and even sent workers door-to-door to sign up eligible families. The welfare office in Athens County, west of Marietta in eastern Ohio, used billboards to advertise Medicaid, which is called Healthy Start and Healthy Families in Ohio. "We wouldn't dare have billboards saying, 'Come down and sign up for welfare,' even though Medicaid is a form of welfare," says Jack Frech, county welfare director. "This program doesn't have the stigma of welfare or food stamps." Medicaid advocates hope that added coverage will prevent higher costs in the future through reduced emergency room visits and other social problems. New Hampshire added mental health coverage this year. Colorado added weight-loss programs — $399 for a 12-week plan — and alcohol and drug rehab to its benefit package July 1. "It is cost-effective to have Medicaid cover more things because our hospitals are groaning under the weight of so much uncompensated care," Colorado House Speaker Andrew Romanoff says. Beats company coverage Many workers choose Medicaid over insurance offered by their employers because it is less expensive. Wal-Mart workers pay $273 a month for the company's family medical coverage and get fewer benefits than Medicaid. (Medicaid is free or nearly free for recipients. Specific out-of-pocket costs and the range of services covered vary by state.) Wal-Mart does not encourage its employees to use Medicaid, spokesman Dan Fogleman says. "But our employees are cost-conscious, and they do what's best for their families," he says. Delaya Short, 30, of Chesapeake, in southeastern Ohio, had dental problems so severe that she could hardly chew before she went on Medicaid. Her husband is a welder on a barge, and their family of five could not afford his company's medical insurance. "My life changed when I was told I could get The Card," she says. She had a root canal and fillings. Her children got their teeth cleaned and caps on their teeth. Her 7-year-old daughter got an ear infection a few months ago. "With The Card, I didn't have to worry about what it would cost to take her to the doctor." Heather Root, 28, a mother of three from Marietta, worries about losing The Card, which, in the past few months, has paid for her children to be treated for meningitis, ear infections, bipolar disorder and other problems. She doesn't know how much that medical care cost. She never saw the bill. Her husband recently went from a $7-an-hour job as a roofer to a $13-an-hour maintenance job in a factory. "I dread getting a letter saying I'm off The Card," she says.  

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I don't understand if Medicaid works THIS well why we just add everyone to the low cost program. Seriously, I don't understand. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

I think just like CHIP it should be on a sliding scale depending on income. My DD was on CHIP a few years back and me making $22K a year paid the same as my sister with no job. I would have gladly paid a monthly fee or a bit more for visits but it was all the same. I think in the instance of lower paid works that would help. They can afford something a month if they choose to afford it just not $400 a month. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I think Chip should be available for every child and parents should pay for it, a minimum of say 20 up to a maximum of 100 a month per child depending on income. That way, every child would be covered even if the parents didn't get it at work or couldn't find a policy. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I don't understand if Medicaid works THIS well why we just add everyone to the low cost program. Seriously, The reason I oppose it is on a number of grounds. One it is too expensive since it BUYS private insurance plans. In other words, the private insurers get a BIG cut of the TAX dollars that I pay. Look at your DH's paycheck and you will notice the FICA, Medicare and Medicaid deductions. I am already paying for others health care while I can get NONE. It makes MORE sense and is cheaper for the government to run the insurance than pay billions of dollars to executives, advertizing, and other overhead. THAT is why over one third of all of our health care dollars goes to NON-medical costs. I am for at least the Kerry/Obama plan which would put the uninsured into the Federal Employees Health care plan. We would be in a separate pool, and the existing agency would expand and handle the program. That would be cost neutral since I would be paying my entire premium, as would others who join. I would even be willing to pay a bit more to help subsidize others who could not afford to pay the higher rates that I would be paying. Again, that would keep the plan revenue neutral and no cost to the taxpayers. Any further expansion WILL cost more. I would hope that we could get rid of Medicaid and take the insurance companies OFF of government welfare. Putting ALL of the programs under this would have consequences that I have no idea as to the cost, so I hestitate to advocate that. My GUESS would be that we could also eliminate Medicare by doing that as well, but given the higher rates of sickness in that pool, I have NO idea of the actuarial consequences and how the reserve funds would be invested or managed. The BEST and cheapest would be a universal health insurance plan in which the pool would be the entire population of the US. Doing it piecemeal gives actuaries a lot of work to do. 

summygood --- 17 years ago -

It would be great if everyone could qualify for this, but not all can. My DH makes a good living, I work part-time and raise our child. Because my DH is with a small business we have to get independent insurance, and it's outrageous! We pay $1200 a month for all 3 of us and we're all healthy! It's just too much. Insurance companies do not care about us they care about $$$$$$$$! Someone needs to create some sort of regulations. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

We pay $1200 a month for all 3 of us and we're all healthy! hence, the issue we face today in this country that must be addressed. we have the ability to get good care but most can't afford it and even those with insurance, many insureds aren't covered for many things or have astronomical out of pockets. we've got the technology but the cost of it must be reined in because we are heading towards third world status. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

they just can't afford the astronomical and skyrocketing costing that it is in this day!!!!! The reason for this skyrocketing cost is the fact that the people in this pool are the ones who use MORE medical care. It makes NO sense to put all the sick people in one pool, and expect THEM to pay the premiums to make that pool economically viable. That is what the Texas State insurance pool does with those who cannot get regular insurance. That put the premiums WAY out of reach for me. THAT is why the entire population of the country has to be the pool to make it economically viable so that one segment does NOT bear ALL the burden as we do now. The insurance companies want to only insure the healthiest people since they will MAKE LOTS of money. In this arrangement that means the ones who are sick cannot afford to pay premiums for their little group of sick people. This makes NO sense at all, except for the insurance industry. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Someone needs to create some sort of regulations. They ARE "regulated" by the politicians to whom they give campaign contributions. When I was growing up in Hartford, we had an insurance commissioner who was a bad joke. HE did whatever he was told to do by the insurance companies, and he was a DEMOCRAT. The only thing he did was to ensure the big profits of the insurance companies. He did that so well, that he had enough money to run for Congress and won. That was old Bill Cotter, one of the biggest zeros to ever walk the halls there. Since my family was all in insurance industry, we all laughed at this guy because of his supine posture. We were all Republicans at the time too, but the insurance companies LOVED their Bill. 

david --- 17 years ago -

So randy what made you turn from republican to democrat? 

summygood --- 17 years ago -

many insureds aren't covered for many things or have astronomical out of pockets. It cost us $1200 a month, but it doesn't even cover maternity. I had to get COBRA from my old job to have the baby. I cannot find a worthwhile ind. policy that has maternity on it. We would like to have another baby, but I'd have to get a full time job and put my baby in daycare...how screwed up is that? It would be a huge risk to pay out of pocket. If something went wrong even something relatively minor, it would bankrupt us. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

We pay $1200 a month for all 3 of us and we're all healthy! If they allow you to join the Federal Employees Health care plan as Kerry wanted, you would pay HALF of that. You would get the SAME coverage as Federal Employees and have to pay ALL of the premium which would run around $500/mo in your category. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

So randy what made you turn from republican to democrat? It was a war called Vietnam, it forced me to read, and study history and real facts of economy and politics. When I volunteered for the military, I was a Goldwater supporter. When I got out I was a radical socialist, and still am to some degree. Though I have modified some of my ideas through experience and life and study. 

summygood --- 17 years ago -

It's better than what we've got now! 

NewNanna --- 17 years ago -

If something went wrong even something relatively minor, it would bankrupt us. That's true for an awful lot of working people which is why I'm in favor of congress passing healthcare reform. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

It was a war called Vietnam So a war that was started by Dems and escalated by Dems caused you to become a Dem? I don't understand that logic. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

JohnLynch, there is no logic to politics, no matter what side of the fence you are on. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Did you even read what you are a poster of frassy? Do you want them to work or do you not Yes I read it....and you think going outside what's already in place is going to make health care cheaper? How? I say it makes more sense to improve upon whats already here. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

The reason I oppose it is on a number of grounds. One it is too expensive since it BUYS private insurance plans. In other words, the private insurers get a BIG cut of the TAX dollars that I pay. Look at your Then just let the Government be it's insurer...isn't that the plan anyway? I'm not following..... 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

So a war that was started by Dems and escalated by Dems I suggest you do what I did many years ago and READ some history of Vietnam. It was actually Eisenhower and Dulles who got the US directly involved in Vietnam. Truman violated FDRs ideas to decolonialize the former colonies which had been overrun by the Japanese. He made the mistake of supporting the French in Indochina when they tried to restore their rule. But it was totally the Eisenhower era that got the US into Vietnam. At the end of 1954, the US was paying over 80% of the bill for the French in Vietnam and Nixon had threatened to have the US intervene militarily. The Geneva Accords were signed, and the US refused to sign or honor them. As for Johnson, I still cannot bring myself to go to a Jefferson, Jackson,Johnson dinner. Though I hsve to say, I don't hate LBJ as much as I once did after reading Caro's biography of LBJ. That even nearly got me to shed a tear for the little LBJ when his family fell on VERY hard times. For political education, especially of Texas and WWII and the whole era, you NEED to read all three books that have been published so far. One thing you might like is that Caro blasts the liberal Texas myths about Coke Stevenson. He wrote extensively about the truth of the matter. He describes LBJ warts and all about how he stole elections, the deals he made etc..The LBJ library was NOT kind to him as he was doing his research, and it was only after Lady Birds death, that they finally became more cordial. You will also learn a bit about the Republican party in Texas along with all that too. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Then just let the Government be it's insurer...isn't that the plan anyway? I'm not following..... What happens is that the US government buys a health insurance policy from lets say Travelers Insurance Co. They simply pay Travelers the price of the premium for that policy that Travelers writes on the Medicare client. The govenment does NOT administer or follow the health care of the client. Travelers pays all the bills that are covered by that policy. The government does NOT pay those bills. If the government were the insurer, THEN they would pay the hospital, doctors,etc. directly. THAT is why I want a single payer. It is simpler, cheaper, less paperwork, and the government is the insurer. That was the compromise that was reached to get Medicare. That the insurance companies would get LOTS of government money to write and run those policies. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I don't understand that logic. One of the most interesting ironies in Caro book is the election for Senator between LBJ and Stevenson. The election was of course stolen by LBJ, but since it was simply a party primary, and it was a STATE election, AND given the fact that state rights was VERY much in force, Stevenson lost his suit about the election because the Feds had NO juridiction in it. By denying blacks, brown and other undesireables the right to vote, Stevenson denied himself any relief when he needed to enforce HIS rights in the US Constitution. It gets even better when LBJ signed the Voting Right Act, it made LBJs shenanigans impossible any more, since the Federal government now had the right to enforce the US Constitution in state elections too. Had that act been in place back then, Stevenson would have won, and LBJ would have lost. LBJ had used that little quirk in US law to get to the top, and then cut that away after he had made it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I really need to stay out of this discussion tonight. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I really need to stay out of this discussion tonight. So you're gonna leave me confussed? lol 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

So you're gonna leave me confussed? lol For the sake of my sanity and the fact that I don't have hours to spend on here tonight - YES. Happy confusion. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

I suggest you do what I did many years ago and READ some history of Vietnam. I have. If you are referring to aid given to the French, it was Truman who first got us involved in Vietnam. Even though he was a Dem, I personally don't consider giving monies and advisers to a situation the starting of a war. The US militarily involvement began in mid 1961, under the Kennedy administration, when Vice-President Johnson returned from a fact-finding mission with the conclusion that South Vietnam could be saved from Communism by prompt American action. Then in January of 1962, the United States began sending large amounts of material to Vietnam along with larger numbers of American military advisers and helicopter pilots. By mid-October of 1962 the helicopter crews had begun to take the initiative in firing at the Vietnamese and less than a year later, the armed helicopters were often assigned to fly strafing missions. In 1964, Johnson greatly escalated the War because of the Gulf of Tonkin incident which has had the word "fabrication" attached to it. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Too many ticks will bleed a dog to death. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

For the sake of my sanity and the fact that I don't have hours to spend on here tonight - YES. lol chunk. I do believe you just called me thick headed....but it's all good...I happen to fully agree with you on matters such as these. Just tell me one thing. Do we build on what we know or start over? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Then in January of 1962, the United States began sending large amounts of material to Vietnam along with larger numbers of American military advisers and helicopter pilots. By mid-October of 1962 the helicopter crews had begun to take the initiative in firing at the Vietnamese and less than a year later, the armed helicopters were often assigned to fly strafing missions. In 1964, Johnson greatly escalated the War because of the Gulf of Tonkin incident which has had the word "fabrication" attached to it. ...wow, just wow. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

lol chunk. I do believe you just called me thick headed....but it's all good...I happen to fully agree with you on matters such as these. Just tell me one thing. Do we build on what we know or start over? LOL no, not calling or implying you are a "thick head". 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

It would be great if everyone could qualify for this, but not all can. My DH makes a good living, I work part-time and raise our child. Because my DH is with a small business we have to get independent insurance, and it's outrageous! We pay $1200 a month for all 3 of us and we're all healthy! It's just too much. Insurance companies do not care about us they care about $$$$$$$$! Someone needs to create some sort of regulations. Not being nosy, but unless you make over $12,000 a month then you qualify for the kids to be on CHIP. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Not being nosy, but unless you make over $12,000 a month then you qualify for the kids to be on CHIP. So why then do we need UHC????? 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

$12,000 a month Chunk did u add a zero there??? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

No Sandyr9111 I did not. One of the qualifiers for CHIP eligibility is income based, that is very true, however there are other ways to qualify, one of which is that if the cost of insurance is 10% of the gross monthly income then kids qualify for CHIP. Since she said she pays $1,200 a month, her gross monthly income could be $12,000 or less and she would qualify for the children to be covered. There are other ways that also are not "income" based such as loss of job, loss of parent, etc that also qualify a child for coverage. I really need to stop looking in on this tread. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

really need to stop looking in on this tread. I have a feeling you know much more than you're willing or able to say. Am I right? 

LilMarJed --- 17 years ago -

So why then do we need UHC????? CHIP is only for kids. Depending on each state, it is hard for adults can get on Medicaid. There needs to be something on a national level so that those who are not covered now can buy coverage at a reasonable cost. 

summygood --- 17 years ago -

Not being nosy, but unless you make over $12,000 a month then you qualify for the kids to be on CHIP. We do not make near $12000.00 a month, you don't think that this $1200.00 a month payment isn't tough on us??? You've got it wrong, it sucks. My DH does not make an astronomical amt. of $$$. My child isn't the mass amt. of our insurance program, it's me and my DH. Do you have to have ind. insurance? Doubt it, we are being robbed, it's sucks. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground