Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Does this seem messed up to you?

who's talking here?

Fallon 6
KWMommaX3..now 4! 1
~sassy~ 2
ExLady In Blue 2
Perfection 4
Meme2my5 4
Hiro Protagonist 11
Ogre1 3
Shenanigans 2
mommie21g1b 1
Wynter 1
textualchocolate 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

When the United States Supreme Court returns from summer break and begins a new term in October, it will have a new Justice and a new, important question to decide. In two cases, Sullivan v. Florida and Graham v. Florida, the Court will address whether it is constitutional to sentence a child to permanent imprisonment for an offense committed during a temporary, and especially challenging, period in human development: adolescence. The two cases have not been consolidated but likely will be argued on the same day this November. Both cases ask the Court to address whether the differences between children and adults that led the Court to strike down the death penalty for children also make permanent imprisonment a constitutionally permissable. Terrance Graham at age 15. Used with permission of Mills Creed & Gowdy, P.A. Graham Terrance Graham was sixteen years old when he and a co-defendant tried to rob a store and the co-defendant hit the store manager with a pipe. Terrance was charged with armed burglary and attempted armed robbery. He had no prior criminal record and, in exchange for a guilty plea, was sentenced to three years probation. At seventeen, Terrance was accused of committing a home invasion robbery with two 20-year-old men. He denied involvement in the crime but admitted that he had violated probation by missing his curfew. No jury trial was held; the trial judge found by a preponderance of the evidence (not beyond a reasonable doubt) that Terrance committed the home invasion robbery and violated his probation. The trial court sentenced Terrance to life in prison with no chance of parole for the original armed burglary charge. Terrance's lawyers appealed his sentence in state court, arguing that it violated the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. When the Florida courts denied relief, he appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing that his sentence to die in prison for a non-homicide committed as a juvenile is unusual because only about seven percent of the juveniles nationwide sentenced to life without parole were sentenced for non-homicide offenses. Graham also challenges his life without parole sentence as a violation of international law. Indeed, the United States is the only country in the world where children are sentened to die in prison. What do you think? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

edited. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Seems really wierd that kid got life. I don't get how that stuff works sometimes. I guess he must have had some really bad representation. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I guess he must have had some really bad representation. That would be my guess 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Either that, or the laws on the books are written in such a way, that the judge was able to give this sentence on his own. Some crimes fall under Federal guide lines. And there isn't any leeway under those. I mean for us to read this it is insane. But there are tons of facts we are not getting. What else did the judge know about this kid? He is now hanging out with older men and still committing crimes. Home invasions are not shop lifting. You go into someone's home, when you know they are there, means you have no qualms about taking the homeowners out. This kid could already be a hardened criminal. We are not talking about a kid who had a great life to begin with, I imagine. It just makes me sick that so many young great lives are thrown away like this every day. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

This kid could already be a hardened criminal. We are not talking about a kid who had a great life to begin with, I imagine. It just makes me sick that so many young great lives are thrown away like this every day. I guess what I'm really trying to find out is if people think that it is O.K. for juviniles to get life for a non murder offense. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

That is a hard one. I mean if the course the person is taking is clearly leading him to killing. Why put an innocent person at risk? I am NOT saying a judge should look at a shop lifter and give him a life sentence. However, if a 15 yr old already has a rap sheet a few feet long, and he is clearly not changing his path. ANd he gets mixed up in yet another violent crime, yeah. I can see where it can happen. To me there is a difference in a 15 yr old committing a crime like this and getting life, than a 10 yr. old doing the same thing. At 15, some of these kids have seen more and been a part of more violence than most of us can grasp. And it is such a waste. One of these kids, if given the chance, could be the one who finds a cure for diabetes. It is just such a sad sad thing. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

Considering people can drive drunk kill someone, walk free and do it again, yes this is harsh. However, if he had been set free he more than likely would have eventually killed someone, probably an innocent person. Would you want your spouse or child to be his victim? I really believe our tax money would be better spent trying to rehabilitate these kids, and I mean send them to a place like happy hill farm. He probably had deadbeat losers for parents and never stood a chance. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I guess what I'm really trying to find out is if people think that it is O.K. for juviniles to get life for a non murder offense. If they break the law that the State has then yes. If I want to change the law, then I work to do so. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

He wasn't a boy scout or anything but basically he had a first offense and broke probation and ended up with life in prison. I think the 3 strikes program can be unreasonable at times nevermind 2 strikes before your 18. The other case is very interesting too, but has a lot more issues involved and the crime the kid was convicted of was worse. Basically in that case a 13 year old borderline intelligence kid, got convicted of sexual assault. The physical evidence was destroyed, and there was only "voice identification" from the victim. He had no priors, and came from abusive home. Both cases are from Florida. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

If I want to change the law, then I work to do so The case is going before the Supreme Court to decide the issue. The judge had the sentencing leeway to nail the kid with life, but that doesn't make it the right thing to do. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

You have to look at the first one again. That one in conjunction with the second crime, shows a pattern of escalating violence. I mean B&E crimes are one thing, but Home Invasions are taking it to a whole new level. It is sad to say, but I bet if you had all the facts on the first case, you would most likely agree with the judge. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Wasn't the 13 yr old charged with raping an 80 yr old woman and beating her? Maybe because their crimes are violent crimes and their violence has escalted is why they were given a life sentence. No one likes to think there is no redemption for teens, but sometimes there are exception. They didn't get better each time they did a crime, they got worse and more violent.And one of those boys were involved in a violent gang rape of a young teen girl, from what I remember. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Judges are elected in Florida correct? Then if the people there disagree they can vote them out. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

At sentencing the judge said something to the effect that the kid had broken the trust of the state by violating probation, and since he had apparently chosen crime as his career, the judges only choice was to protect the citizens of the state by sentencing him to life. The thing of it is, he wsn't convicted of the home invasion, he was just suspected, all the kid admitted to, was breaking curfew. I'm sure he probably did it, but the judge didn't mind sending the kid away forever just on the implication. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

which kid admitted to breaking curfew? The way I heard it reported was one raped an elderly woman, the other was involved in teen gang rape, and their crimes violence had escalated. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Here's the 13 year-olds case. Granted this is one side of the story. Joe Sullivan is one of only two thirteen-year-olds in the country sentenced to life without parole for an offense that did not involve a killing. In 1989, Joe was a mentally disabled thirteen-year-old child living in a home where he was regularly subjected to physical and sexual abuse. On the day of the crime, two older boys convinced Joe to participate in a burglary. The three boys entered an empty home and one older boy took some money and jewelry before the three left. That afternoon, the elderly homeowner was sexually assaulted in her home. She never saw her attacker. One of the older boys, who may have been the true assailant, accused Joe of the sexual battery. Both older boys received short sentences in juvenile detention. Thirteen-year-old Joe Sullivan was charged and tried in adult court. Joe was tried by a six-person jury in a one-day proceeding; opening statements began sometime after 9 a.m., and the jury returned its verdict at 4:55 p.m. During trial, the prosecutor and witnesses made repeated, unnecessary reference to the fact that Joe is African American and the victim is white; one witness repeatedly said the perpetrator of the assault was a “colored boy” or “a dark colored boy.” Biological evidence collected from the victim was not presented at trial and was destroyed before it could be subjected to DNA testing. Joe’s appointed lawyer — who was later disbarred — did not object to a "voice identification" of Joe by the victim (who was blindfolded during the assault) that she had first rehearsed with the prosecutor before repeating it for the jury. Joe was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without possibility of parole. Even though Joe was the youngest person in the country sentenced to die in prison for a non-homicide, his lawyer filed a brief on appeal saying there were no issues to challenge in his case. Joe was sent to an adult prison when he was just fourteen, and he was repeatedly and brutally victimized by older inmates. He has been diagnosed with multiple sclerosis and uses a wheelchair. Lawyers from the Equal Justice Initiative challenged Joe's sentence in the Florida state courts as cruel and unusual punishment, but his petition was denied. The U.S. Supreme Court will now evaluate whether life imprisonment without parole violates the Eighth Amendment when imposed on a young adolescent 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

which kid admitted to breaking curfew? The kid that is in jail for the 2 robberies just admitted to breaking curfew while he was on probation. It is believed that he took part in a home invasion while on probation which is why the judge sentenced him to life. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I would like to think the judge based his decision of what the police officers said too. I imagine this kid was getting in with gang bangers. If so, you know the crimes were not going to get less, more more violent. I'd like to see this outrage over a judge giving a child rapist 10 days. That makes me sick. And it keeps happening. Oprah should take up this cause and put these pos judges on the public stage. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

i would rather see adults getting harsher punishments for their crimes. life/death penalty for child molesters seems more appropriate than life for teens. chances are though, that even if this kid is put back out on the streets, he's just gonna commit more crime. they should let him go so when he does it again they can follow the three strikes rule. you give a person enough rope and they'll hang themselves. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

you give a person enough rope and they'll hang themselves But how many innocent have to die first? 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

The problem MW, is that teens who commit crimes always says they didn't do it. i am thinking there is more evidence than the defense lawyer is releasing. Of course, a teen who breaks into a home should not be give a life sentence, but a teen who rapes an elderly woman and beats her and this not being his first crime maybe should be. Just don't think we are hearing all the evidence. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

But how many innocent have to die first? i'm right there with u, but some are more concerned with the criminals instead of the victims. w/ 3 strikes, at least u can say he shows a pattern of violence, and needs to be locked away w/o the courts being bogged down by appeals 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

not being his first crime maybe should be He had no previous offences was/is dim-witted and was 13. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

I think the Supreme Court will reverse it. They are usually more for criminals than victims. But I think if they feel this is his first offense, they will reverse it.Sometimes teens are just as vicious and evil as adults. I guess we will hear all the evidence now. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Here's the problem with juvenile cases. All records are sealed as to previous incidents. Now, I don't believe they're sealed for a judge during the sentencing phase, but I could be wrong. With adults, I don't care if you got a summons for spitting on the sidewalk and it was thrown out of court. If a police officer runs your record, that spitting on the sidewalk charge is going to come up, along with every bench warrant, misdemeanor and felony you have ever been charged with. Now, if you've never been convicted of any of those aforementioned crimes, all it does is prove you have a prior arrest history, but it kind of gives you an idea of what type of person you're dealing with, too. The previous charges are reviewed when you present your case to the district attorney. In juveniles, that's not the case. Sure you might know them from the neighborhood and know their reputation, but when you take a juvenile into custody and charging them, it's like they have a clean slate. It's like the first time the system's ever seen them, even though the juvenile officer might know better. My bet is, there is plenty more history that we don't know about, because it's in sealed records. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

My bet is, there is plenty more history that we don't know about, because it's in sealed records. Even so, it still leaves us with the original question, should a juvenile get life for a crime that didn't kill anyone? As young as 13? 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Even so, it still leaves us with the original question, should a juvenile get life for a crime that didn't kill anyone? As young as 13? And all I can say to you is, I don't know, because I do not have all of the facts of the case. All I have is a reporter's opinion of the case. 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

I think the Supreme Court will reverse it. They are usually more for criminals than victims. Can you substantiat this? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I don't know ALL the details of these cases, and I certainly do no know the laws of the states which were involved (These would NOT be federal cases), but I expect the SCOTUS to return both these for re-sentencing, if not for full-trials. In the first case, a "preponderance of the evidence" is not the legitimate standard for a criminal case. That violates the 4th Amend. In the second case, where to start, just from what is above... procedural errors that become prejudicial (the racial information), evidentiary issues (the rehearsed voice i.d.), representation issues (the disbarred attorney)... the status of the defendant as mentally disabled, the whole idea of a 14 y.o. being put in the madhouse that is an adult prison... I don't know, this is one of those cases you hear about where everyone and everything is dirty, the judges, the lawyers, the witnesses, the defendant, the victim the jury... I mean really, HOW did this kid get a fair trial? I dunno. I expect an overturn and re-trial. SCOTUS almost never frees anyone from prison. Usually they re-try the case with instructions handed down from on-high. Either the whole case, or what is more prevalent, the sentencing phase. In some case, the re-sentencing frees the defendant/convict. I do not agree with putting children in adult prisons. There is no way a 14, 15, or 16 y.o., no matter how street-saavy or hardened they may be can deal with a prison environment. What's the cut off? I don't know, I can't sit here and say that everyone under 17 needs to go to juvie, I don't know if that will work either. But a 14 Y.O. down in the pens and on the yard? I do think that falls into the category of cruel and unusual. And a mentally challenged 14 y.o. only makes it worse. Kids who commit crimes need to be punished. They need to be punished quickly, affirmatively, and and it actually needs to be a punishment! Maybe they even need to be punished for life, I don't know, these cases seem extreme. But until a person is able to at least defend him/herself, they shouldn't be thrown to the wolves. That just says something about our society that we'd do something like that. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Kids who commit crimes need to be punished. They need to be punished quickly, affirmatively, and and it actually needs to be a punishment! Maybe they even need to be punished for life, I don't know, these cases seem extreme. But until a person is able to at least defend him/h Crimes amongst kids escalate because they don't learn crime doesn't pay from the git-go. When they end up doing hard time down the road because their life of petty crime was never nipped in the bud when it should have been, you can thank a liberal judge. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Even so, it still leaves us with the original question, should a juvenile get life for a crime that didn't kill anyone? As young as 13? If the laws of the State allow it, then yes. Parents need to educate their children, if they fail them, the children are the ones who pay. I also believe that a parent should have the same punishment as their child. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

If the laws of the State allow it ... AND it proves to not be unconstitutional. After all, any law CAN fly in the face of the Constitution, and it can stand for a very long time until someone has standing enough to take it before the SCOTUS (which has VERY limited jurisdiction to hear original cases -i.e. cases that haven't gone before another court). That is appears to be the main question before the SCOTUS. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I would love to see the "parents" start getting some jail time too. They have these children with no means to support them, they abandon them to their family to raise. The dad, if he is even aware he has a child, is non existent in the child's life. That bs way of life has got to be stopped. It is not fair to the child, or the rest of society. Honestly I don't know what the answer is either. More education? More money thrown at the situation? Something needs to be done. We have entire generations that are continuing this lifestyle. And it just makes me ill. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Honestly I don't know what the answer is either. More education? More money thrown at the situation? Something needs to be done. We have entire generations that are continuing this lifestyle. And it just makes me ill. And our throwing money hasn't deterred them. So perhaps it is time to do a disincentive and punish them. If you can't learn by being nice........ 

KWMommaX3..now 4! --- 17 years ago -

Marcellus- do you post ion the click2houston.com website as well? 

textualchocolate --- 17 years ago -

Supreme Court should and probably will overturn. Same old stuff. Crime coverage increases (if it bleeds it leads) and crime rates reduce are stays about the same. Get the frightened frazzled and talk the law and order talk. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

They have these children with no means to support them This is just one reason why I think everyone should support abortion rights. It's cheaper to abort an unwanted child than to support them on welfare or in the prison system. Course, I also think you should have to pass a bloody test to be allowed to reproduce. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground