Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Child Abused ? ?

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 1
grandma 3
QueenCassie 1
planemom 1
Joybell 5
Tylers Journey 1
Cristie 1
Meme2my5 2
JusticeForAll 2
clockwatcher. 1
TexasOma 2
*OH SNAP* 6
*Goatlady* 2
Jarhead 3
~bigla~ 1
Hardshell- 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

grandma --- 16 years ago -

I was told by a young mother today that recently her child had been slapped so hard in the face by the childs father during a visit (parents are divorced) that the 10 year old lost her voice for a few hours because she cried so much. The child reported that her dad left his hand imprint on her face for about 2 hours. The mother said when the child told this to her a police report was made. But, weeks later, she was informed by the investigator that this does not constitute abuse. I am a grandmother and maybe the laws have changed but does anyone know if this is a fact?  

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

Did she bother to take a picture of the hand imprint? That does constitute abuse and should be reported to CPS not the police. If they are divorced & she had the picture, she could get something via the court system. As a nurse, if I saw a handprint on a child's face, I am obligated to call the hotline for CPS. 

grandma --- 16 years ago -

Unfortunately, the mom said that this happened on a weekend visit and the child reported this to her when she got home a couple of days later. 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

She can still file a report with CPS....each report is logged & when there are so many reports and finally a proof, they will have something to work with. I'm not for sure on this part, but think that's how it works. She can call and ask questions & if they feel it's worth taking a report, they will. 

QueenCassie --- 16 years ago -

I would definitely report it to CPS and get it on file. She may not have photo proof this time,but at least the incident will be documented. Poor child, how horrifying to have someone- especially your own parent- hit you like that! 

grandma --- 16 years ago -

I have made several phone calls and it seems that no one actually knows the correct answer to this situation. 

~bigla~ --- 16 years ago -

I have been told by many sources that what you describe, unfortunately is just BAD parenting...CPS will not get involved for this...imo 

Tylers Journey --- 16 years ago -

We have called CPS with proof of things and they will not look at anything other then what they observe. It is very hard dealing with CPS and what they will and will not do. 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

They should report it to cps, even if they don't do anything this time, there will be a record so if he ever does it again they can respond or investigate it as a repeat offense. Also the dad may think twice before doing it again if he knows he will be reported. He should be ashamed of himself, his child will never forget this and may not want to visit him in the future. 

Jarhead --- 16 years ago -

Need Help!  

~grandma again~ --- 16 years ago -

If you know the child is being harmed and you do not turn it in to CPS, they can hold you responsible if something does happen to the child. they say to turn it in and let them find out if there is anything that needs their attention. you can go to the website for CPS and read more about it. I beg to differ...slapping of a child or anyone else is abuse. 

Jarhead --- 16 years ago -

 

Cristie --- 16 years ago -

If you know the child is being harmed and you do not turn it in to CPS, they can hold you responsible if something does happen to the child. I was just getting ready ot say that. I would call CPS myself and report the incident. 

Jarhead --- 16 years ago -

If you have a contact with BACA, they'll help you with the details and procedures. If somone was to make a run by the *sshole fathers hole and persuade him not to do that again.......... 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

I beg to differ...slapping of a child or anyone else is abuse. Right, I find it strange that if this child's father slapped someone else in the face, he would be charged with assault, but since it's his child it's ok.Nuts 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

I don't spank but 2 of my older kids got slapped by me once each. If you scream in my face your gonna get back handed..don't care who you are. They were older than 10. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

CPS considers striking a child anywhere on the body other than their butt or right underneath it child abuse. Not speaking to you directly *goatlady*. Just what I was told. 

*Goatlady* --- 16 years ago -

I do agree. It's not my normal way of dealing with things but I'm only practically perfect! 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

If you know the child is being harmed and you do not turn it in to CPS, they can hold you responsible if something does happen to the child. I think that only applies if your a teacher or a health care worker. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 16 years ago -

i am not badmouthing cps but yrs ago when i worked at a daycare. we had some kids abused by their mothers boyfriend.. the one kid i had had knuckle marks on his face and bruises all up and down his legs and torso.. we called and reported they came out took pics and talked to the kids.. made the BF leave for the weekend.. and guess what he was back on monday afternoon to pick them up.. made me sick to have to hand them over to this man.. i was disturbed that this was not enough to do something.. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

CPS is useless. We basically hand the well-being of our children over to the discretion of an agency that hires inexperienced people and has pretty much zero guidelines for what does and does not constitute abuse. When someone calls CPS, it goes to a caseworker and it is up to that caseworker ALONE to decide whether to take the children or not. It's a ridiculous agency that has no oversight and does no good for anyone, IMO. So while one person may have their kids basically kidnapped from school one day because one of them fell out of a tree and broke their arm and some social worker decided it was suspicious, another child may be left in a home where they're being beaten and/or neglected on a daily basis. There's no rhyme or reason to it. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

CPS considers striking a child anywhere on the body other than their butt or right underneath it child abuse. Not speaking to you directly *goatlady*. Just what I was told. According to state law (Texas Penal Code Chapter 9 - section 9.54 I think) a parent can use force, but not deadly force in the disciplining of a child. There is no specified limitation as to area. (The real question is what is discipline? It is different for a 10 month old than it would be for a 10 year old.) CPS does not get to choose if charges are filed - just if they investigate or not. It's up to the district attorney in the county it occurred to decide that. Not saying what happened was right. Just telling you what the law says. 

clockwatcher. --- 16 years ago -

CPS is useless. We basically hand the well-being of our children over to the discretion of an agency that hires inexperienced people and has pretty much zero guidelines for what does and does not constitute abuse. When someone calls CPS, it goes to a caseworker and it is up to that caseworker ALONE to decide whether to take the children or not. It's a ridiculous agency that has no oversight and does no good for anyone, IMO. Rings very true...I worked in a district where a student was clearly abused...she was distraught when entering my classroom She gave me pertinent info..later to find out her sister was doing the same in her kinder class--of course, teacher was reporting to CPS just as I was. I submitted my info online and was told later that her case was not near the severity of others and it was later dismissed....disheartening to say the least. This child clearly spoke out, I responded, but CPS clearly dropped the ball...what do you do? Sends clear messages to children, huh? 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

Joybell, what you don't understand is that CPS is above the law. When you send your child to public school, they become property of the state. All it takes is one phone call from a mandatory reporter and CPS will come to the school and interview your child, examine them for injuries, and even video tape or record the interview. If they feel your child is in danger, they have legal authority to remove your child from the school without notifying you first. They can also interview your neighbors, daycare workers, and/or anyone who comes in contact with your child whatsoever. They can force you to not only give them access to your child's medical history, but also YOUR medical history if you have seen a therapist for any reason. This is at the discretion of ONE social worker. You can have your child yanked from you before you ever even knew CPS was called at all. If your children are taken from you, a hearing will be scheduled. Your children will be kept in foster care until the hearing is scheduled. Once your kid is taken, you're at the mercy of how full the courts are. Imagine the horror of having to go through something like that because some teacher was forced to report your child, even though the teacher herself might not even think it was abuse. The guidelines require them to report any injuries that COULD be signs of abuse, whether they think the child is being abused or not. The guidelines say to let CPS make the determination. It's chilling when you think about it. You looked up state law. Now try to find a site that gives you the guidelines for mandatory reporting in the state of Texas and/or specific reasons CPS will remove a child from the home. I think you'll be surprised. Like clockwatcher also said, many times the child NEEDS to be removed from the home and isn't. It really does boil down to one caseworker's opinion. They DO have to run it past a supervisor before they close a case out, but that's it. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Unless they can prove actual abuse, nothing will be done...they may investigate, but it's doubtful. Slapping a child in the face may not be what you or I would do, but it's not abuse... beating a child bruised and bloody, starving a child, leaving them alone for prolonged periods of time, anything sexual in nature involving children, THAT'S abuse... Also, just playing Devil's advocate here, sometimes kids with divorced parents, can be very vindictive if they don't get their way...they're angry and they lash out against their parents however they can. Kids KNOW CPS is a real threat to their parents, and will use it. just some food for thought...I don't know this situation, I'm just giving some different perspectives. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

But it doesn't matter what YOU think is abuse. All that matters is what the social worker thinks is abuse. Granted, many parents are able to get their children back after they battle it out in court, but the children can be in foster care that entire time. Most of the times they go to relatives, but still...I've heard of horror stories on both sides. The ones that make the news are obviously the ones where CPS investigated several times and then the child dies of starvation two weeks after the last visit, but there are many others that you don't hear about. On the opposite side, in some states homeschoolers are harassed endlessly by CPS because there's this tendency to think that the reason children aren't in school is because the parents are either crazy or hiding something. It's to the point homeschoolers have joined together to set up a legal defense fund to help them in these situations. They are told to call their lawyer immediately when CPS shows up on their doorstep and to not even let them in the house because they've been known to exaggerate the state of the house to build a case. I know there needs to be a system in place to protect children, but CPS isn't working. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

I didn't look up state law, OS. I quoted it from experience. I work with these kind of cases all the time (no, I don't work for CPS). What you said about CPS is partially true. They are not well run or well supervised and they don't have "written" guidelines that you can find online (or anywhere else except internally). What they cannot do is force you to produce your medical records or remove the child from your home without a court order UNLESS exigent circumstances dictate immediate removal. I know this because my job requires CPS produce the court order to me and my employees when we respond to calls for service. They may try to bully parents into thinking they have that kind of authority, but they do not. Parents who do not educate themselves and listen to school guidance counselors and CPS workers who threaten to remove their children if they don't comply are at their mercy. My suggestion is this - if CPS shows up at your house to "interview" you and you don't want them in your house, ask for a court order. If they don't produce one, tell them they can call law enforcement. Law enforcement has the right to come in and do a welfare check on the child and report to them. If leos see exigent circumstances, they can also remove the child or require the offender to leave the residence (speaking particularly about claimed sexual abuse by a live-in parent/stepparent/other relative or deplorable conditions in the home). 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

But it doesn't matter what YOU think is abuse. All that matters is what the social worker thinks is abuse. I'm just going with what I learned taking the foster care classes a few years ago...it was in Utah, but the criteria for abuse doesn't vary that much from state to state... Texas may be completely different, I don't know since I did not take the classes here. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

I know there needs to be a system in place to protect children, but CPS isn't working. And you're completely correct about that. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

The wording varies slightly, but it makes a big difference. In some states the mandatory reporters have to suspect abuse is occurring in order to be required to report it. In Texas, it is not up to the discretion of the reporter. They are told that if there are injuries that COULD be consistent with abuse, they are required to report them and let CPS make the determination. In other words, don't trust your own judgment. Trust big brother's. Like I said, I've heard horror stories on both ends. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

In Texas, it is not up to the discretion of the reporter. They are told that if there are injuries that COULD be consistent with abuse, they are required to report them and let CPS make the determination. Again, not according to state law (from the Family Code, this time): Sec. 261.102. MATTERS TO BE REPORTED. A report should reflect the reporter's belief that a child has been or may be abused or neglected or has died of abuse or neglect. Not disagreeing with your other points, but what you have heard about the reporting requirement is also incorrect. (And the "may be abused or neglected" part applies when - for example - a child is picked up from a daycare and the parent is drunk, begins dragging the child out by his/her arms, and the daycare worker is afraid the child is in danger. And yes, this did really happen.) 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

(And that one I did look up because I didn't remember the exact wording.) :) 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

Interesting. I can't remember now where I read it the other way. The one you posted is more in line with the other states. 

Hardshell- --- 16 years ago -

grandma....Something doesn't add up with this story. If a grown man seriously slapped a child, there would be swelling, a black eye, and busted blood vessels....plenty of evidence. This is not just child abuse. Since the child was under the age of 14, it could be Injury to a Child with Intent to Cause bodily harm, or Family Violence Assault.....which are both felonies...... Maybe the mom didn't take action soon enough...or maybe it's not really what happened? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground