Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Which one is better?

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
la guerita 4
Fallon 1
needrnr 1
jjfingrainalready 1
*Annie* 1
My2Texans 1
ladybeachbum 1
chunksNbones 3
Fin and Feather 1
Setta 2
Allimama 2
moltobella 6
~bigla~ 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Which one is better?

Since I don't eat meat I don't know which one is better. I had a lady explain it to me a while back but I cant remember. (I think she said those 2 were the best though)

Ribeye Vote
 
 75.9% (22)
New York Strip Vote
 
 24.1% (7)
moltobella --- 16 years ago -

Since I don't eat meat I don't know which one is better. I had a lady explain it to me a while back but I cant remember. (I think she said those 2 were the best though) 

*Annie* --- 16 years ago -

Me, I'm partial to a filet since it is so thick. I like my meat to just barely moo when I eat it. How well does the diner wish for the steak to be prepared? That can often determine the ideal cut. 

My2Texans --- 16 years ago -

My dh is a butcher and we prefer ribeyes. 

moltobella --- 16 years ago -

How well does the diner wish for the steak to be prepared? Pink on the inside but not really really bloody. blech. You know I love him if I'm willing to cook a steak. 

~bigla~ --- 16 years ago -

molto...are you a member of Sams? if not...call me...otherwise, ask the butcher to choose a roast and slice it into steaks for you...then put some in the freezer. We have NEVER gotten more tender or delicious cuts of meat from any grocery store... 

moltobella --- 16 years ago -

I'm not a member and you're talking gibberish to me. lol 

~bigla~ --- 16 years ago -

When do you need it? 

moltobella --- 16 years ago -

I don't need it necessarily. I bought a ribeye and a ny strip to cook him for tonight. but in the future.....Whenever. He loves steaks. 

chunksNbones --- 16 years ago -

I'm not a fan of Ribeye at all..too much fat on it. I prefer Sirloin.... 

moltobella --- 16 years ago -

Sirloin.... Whats that? Will it say sirloin on the package? lol 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

Most people will say Ribeye because it has the most marbeling, hence the most flavor. But my favorite cut has always been the New York Strip. 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

It really depends on how you cook it too. You can have the best cut and really screw it up lol or vice versa. 

jjfingrainalready --- 16 years ago -

A ribeye has more fat, not necessarily a ton of fat, but enough to make it juicier. A NY Strip is leaner, and although healthier, is dryer. 

Melanie --- 16 years ago -

I once asked the butcher at Sam's that very question & he said ribeye is the best do to the marbling. But I prefer filet. : ) 

Setta --- 16 years ago -

About two years ago, hubby and I had our best friends over for supper. We made ribeyes from HEB and baked potatoes with all the goodies and shrimp grilled on the pit and OMGoodness!!!!!!!!!!!!....it was the BEST steak we'd ever eaten! It was tender and the flavor...we were all enjoying it so much we didn't even visit...LOL...until after we finished! HEB hands down has better steaks over Kroger...JMO...but we've tried them both and almost every time, HEB"s steaks win the quality, tenderness and flavor prize...=) 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

I've found through trial and error that one of the biggest differences is buying "Prime" rather than "Choice". Prime costs more, but it is soooooo worth it. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Target has the best steaks you will find outside of a real butcher shop. Don't know why, but their meat is always the best. You spend more, but it is worth it. Ribeye will have more fat, ie marbling, and that is what make the flavor better. NY Strip very lean meat, less fat, makes it have less flavor and it will be dryer. I think if you eat a steak any more done than Medium Rare, you should get the cheapest steaks you can find, cause all shoe leather tastes the same:) lol 

Setta --- 16 years ago -

I think if you eat a steak any more done than Medium Rare, you should get the cheapest steaks you can find, cause all shoe leather tastes the same:) lol LOL...so true! I always soak my steak in marinade...hubby hates that, but I love it that way...with tenderizer sprinkled on it while it's soaking...and man oh man does that make it mouth watering!. 

chunksNbones --- 16 years ago -

the secret to making a GREAT steak is to cook it in butter with just a dash of salt and pepper. Nothing else needed! Yummmmmmmmmmmm. 

Fin and Feather --- 16 years ago -

Ribeye - best ny Takes to much effort to butter on each flip, but the real question is are you going to wash it before you eat it.. ;) 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

tenderlion filet, no question! medium rare...yum! 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

the secret to making a GREAT steak is to cook it in butter with just a dash of salt and pepper. Nothing else needed! Yummmmmmmmmmmm. i agree, but with mushrooms it is really great too. i cook mine in a cast iron skillet and cut it off and put the lid on for about 10 mins just before it is done. people say steaks are hard to cook, but i think they are one of the easiest things to make. 

chunksNbones --- 16 years ago -

agree, but with mushrooms it is really great too. i cook mine in a cast iron skillet and cut it off and put the lid on for about 10 mins just before oh yeah I love sauteed mushrooms, but I make them separate... The hardest thing to cook (IMO) is CHICKEN!!!!! 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

The hardest thing to cook (IMO) is CHICKEN!!!!! YES!!!! And I am really trying to eat more chicken, and my children prefer chicken- I feel like chicken is so temperamental though. You can cook it exactly the same way every time and come out with completely different results every time. 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

but I make them separate... they taste soooo good cooking in those meat juices though! that sounds so gross...LOL 

moltobella --- 16 years ago -

they taste soooo good cooking in those meat juices though! that sounds so gross...LOL Youre right. It sounds disgusting. LOL 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Many times you will see steaks at the meat counter without a grade. It has become a norm to have a standard of beef come in and not have it graded. Companies have to pay extra dough to have it graded by a usda grader. Companies pay for x will come in choice or select quality. They get a better quality and more consistent with just an order spec with out a grade. To add I believe the term is "no roll". I personally love a ribeye and give me bison any day. If you are not a big meat eater, I would assume if you do eat meat you would eat a steak well done. A fillet or a ribeye would be a good choice. A good trick to cooking a steak is add a little 7 up for caramelization:0) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground