Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Is the current tax structure fair?

who's talking here?

Sandyr9111 1
AuthorMan 1
Deltadawn 1
AFWife 1
david 1
fergie 1
~sassy~ 6
Perfection 3
razumikhin 1
jtcitrus 11
MxMike. 1
river chef 3
A Simple Equation 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is the current tax structure fair?

Just wondering.

Yes - leave it alone, I like my deductions and pay my tax Vote
 
 20.8% (5)
Yes - it is what it is Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
No - it benefits the poor too much by not making them pay their fair share Vote
 
 50.0% (12)
No - remove deductions for children, if you choose to have them, choose to pay for them Vote
 
 16.7% (4)
No - higher incomes should pay more than others because they can Vote
 
 4.2% (1)
No - fairness doesn't matter, I just want someone else to pay Vote
 
 8.3% (2)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Just wondering. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

FLAT TAX - THE ONLY FAIR TAX - PERIOD 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

FLAT TAX - THE ONLY FAIR TAX - PERIOD that actually depends on how you define fair. and you should have had an "other" option Chunky 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

jtcitrus, "other" is for people who can type and put their thoughts in to words as opposed to pointing and clicking. So tell us what ya think. 

fergie --- 16 years ago -

Federal sales tax-tax everything do away with income tax period. The more you spend the more tax you pay. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

fergie --- 7 min ago - quote - flag comment Federal sales tax-tax everything do away with income tax period. The more you spend the more tax you pay. Sounds fair. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Hmmm, a fair tax looks good too Utah Senate Wednesday, August 24, 2005 Flat Tax v. Fair Tax Our federal tax system is a joke. Not a funny one, but a joke nonetheless. Our taxes are much too high, and the complexity of the code begs for mistakes, abuse, and backroom dealings. Good laws and legal systems are simple and transparent; people readily can know the law, follow the law, and watch how elected officials propose to tamper with the law. By contrast, the mess that is our current tax system creates a grotesque scene where lobbyists and elected officials can cut marginal deals in the tax code without the public having much real opportunity to weigh in. The deals only add to campaign coffers and taxpayers' burdens. The system must be simplified. Two tax proposals deserve attention at the federal level – the flat tax and the "fair tax." Steve Forbes provides a thoughtful discussion on the flat tax, which would impose a 17% tax on personal income and corporate profits. Another worthwhile proposal is the Fair Tax – which does away with the federal income tax (and many of its associated burdens), and puts in place one tax – a flat tax of 23% on all sales. Both proposals would be revenue neutral to the government and, for most people, would reduce their total taxes paid. The point of both proposals is simplification – which leads to better compliance (meaning a broader base and reduced individual rates), more efficient use of resources, and economic growth. I would take either – as either would work better than the current mess, which wastes more than $200 billion and over six billion hours each year filling out tax forms, according to Forbes's article. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Another worthwhile proposal is the Fair Tax – which does away with the federal income tax (and many of its associated burdens), and puts in place one tax – a flat tax of 23% on all sales. Sounds good to me, but would require the government cease growing AND that it learns, for ONCE, to live within its means. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Both proposals would be revenue neutral to the government and, for most people, would reduce their total taxes paid. The point of both proposals is simplification – which leads to better compliance and more efficient use of resources. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

You forgot the "of course not, but life isn't fair" option. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

You forgot the "of course not, but life isn't fair" option. That's a shame. If life can't be fair, why can't taxes? lol 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I like the flat tax for sales option. It would catch all the people who dont pay income tax and I bet you their are a bunch of those out there. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

I'm busy today [b/c I checked in on KU too much yesterday ;)]. So I'll answer in bits and pieces as we go along. Once I'm done with my serial pedantic monologue, I'll come back (wife permitting) and respond to comments and to the ridiculous assertions of the fair/flat tax people (not that those are necessarily bad ideas) [how's that for academic non-commitment] [cue classical music] Why a Progressive income tax can be considered fair: It has to do with what is known as "Diminishing Marginal Utility". In this case the "Diminishing Marginal Utility of Money" DMUM, means that as your income rises, the last dollar earned adds less and less benefit to the earner. Conversely the utility gain from the first several dollars earned is quite significant... this ties into why people are "risk-averse"; it hurts more to loose $100 than it feels good to win/earn $100. here is a graph with an appropriate curve. imagine that a person making 100k (at the far right hand side) and a person earning 20k (towards the left). A 20 % drop in wealth/income represents a much smaller detriment to utility for the person earning 100k than it does for the person earning 20k. the only way the relative "pain" of taxation under a flat tax would be equal, would be if there were no diminishing marginal utility (a 45 deg straight line). Experimental economists and behavioral psychologists and even game shows have supported in empirical tests that DMUM is a real phenomenon. Therefore, a flat/fair tax cannot in any way universally be considered the "fairest". 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Don't forget to pay your extortion money, y'all. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

the only way the relative "pain" of taxation under a flat tax would be equal, would be if there were no diminishing marginal utility (a 45 deg straight line) forgive me, i misspoke... to claim that the "pain" would be equal assumes something about the aggregate shape of that curve that we don't know. the comment about the "straight 45 deg line" is only for a "lump-sum tax" placed equally on everyone. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I'm busy today [b/c I checked in on KU too much yesterday ;)]. So I'll answer in bits and pieces as we go along. When you speak, we always listen. I may not always understand, but I listen. Admire your knowledge. :) 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

...so, Whatever income tax scheme you go with (progressive, regressive, proportional (flat)), in order to claim that one of them is more fair than the other assumes that 1) You know what the aggregate Marginal Utility Curve looks like, 2) that such a thing exists. One of the things that gets Macro-economists in trouble is the assumption that preferences can be aggregated. This is probably not true and is highly technical to demonstrate. The end result is that in both practice and even in theory, it is probably nonsensical to talk about a "fair" tax system for everyone at all. - it is likely that the best we can hope fore is a system that is "good-enough". AKA, "that which achieves the goal of adequately funding the provision of public goods without sufficiently screwing over a significant portion of the electorate." That's what I think about the "Fairness" portion of the question... but there's still the question of efficiency, and (since it was the original point of the thread) the kinds of policies I'd like to see. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

You'll notice in the above that "sufficient" and "significant" are slippery words, and that I didn't say which public goods and thankyou sassy! [blushing] 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

The income tax is 100% unconstitutional. All the money goes to pay interest on debt we've incurred by borrowing money from the privately owned and for-profit Federal Reserve! Abolish the IRS and restore our Constitutional government! Freedom for all! 

AFWife --- 16 years ago -

From the Fair Tax site: FairTax.org What is the FairTax plan? The FairTax plan is a comprehensive proposal that replaces all federal income and payroll based taxes with an integrated approach including a progressive national retail sales tax, a prebate to ensure no American pays federal taxes on spending up to the poverty level, dollar-for-dollar federal revenue neutrality, and, through companion legislation, the repeal of the 16th Amendment. The FairTax Act (HR 25, S 296) is nonpartisan legislation. It abolishes all federal personal and corporate income taxes, gift, estate, capital gains, alternative minimum, Social Security, Medicare, and self-employment taxes and replaces them with one simple, visible, federal retail sales tax administered primarily by existing state sales tax authorities. The FairTax taxes us only on what we choose to spend on new goods or services, not on what we earn. The FairTax is a fair, efficient, transparent, and intelligent solution to the frustration and inequity of our current tax system. The FairTax: * Enables workers to keep their entire paychecks * Enables retirees to keep their entire pensions * Refunds in advance the tax on purchases of basic necessities * Allows American products to compete fairly * Brings transparency and accountability to tax policy * Ensures Social Security and Medicare funding * Closes all loopholes and brings fairness to taxation * Abolishes the IRS We offer a library of information throughout this Web site about the features and benefits of the FairTax plan. Please explore! 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

* Abolishes the IRS Who do we have to bribe to get this done? :-) 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

The FairTax taxes us only on what we choose to spend on new goods or services dollar-for-dollar federal revenue neutrality Enables workers to keep their entire paychecks There are a lot of false assumptions in these statements. 1)They assume that purchasing habits will remain neutral with respect to the shifting around of tax incentives - Increasing income: obviously some peoples' income would increase more than others and the buying habits of those individuals would affect market prices. This has to do with what is called "Income Elasticity" - Essentially, how much do you change your buying habits b/c you're making more/less money. Do you buy more/less stuff (income effect)? Do you buy 'higher/lower quality' stuff (substitution effect)? It's hard to know which effect will be stronger. - Increasing all prices of new goods and services by a fixed %: not all prices will move by that percentage. The reason is that different industries face different "elasticities of supply and demand". Accountants cannot tally the mutually beneficial transactions that never occur b/c of a tax, This is why people believe in the falsehood that "the producer just passes the tax onto the consumer. By raising taxes, just as above, there is an income effect (you're effectively more poor), and a substitution effect (you substitute goods according to relative prices - which will not all change proportionately). It is not clear which effect would be stronger (income/substitution) -- the Net Effect of an uncertain move due to Income and price increases across the market: also uncertain. "but we wont be wasting all those resources on the federal income tax industry" - true. and in the long run, better for the economy. But don't ignore the consequences of dis-employing the tens (if not 100's) of thousands of people in that industry. in short the fair tax people have some good ideas, but in the short-run, be prepared for some real pain (assuming that such a thing could ever become politically palatable) 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

who in their right mind supports the fair tax. you would be taxed on 100 % of my earned income. no deductions, no credits, just tax every penny i have. how about making corporations pay their taxes, and we wouldnt have to. and i still cant figure out what is so "complicated" about a 1040 form. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

Some tax policy changes that I'd like to see (and for the most part seem possible): 1) Scrap Cap-N-Trade, and impose a small carbon tax on combustible fuel - in exchange, demand a [ahem] "revenue neutral" decrease in payroll taxes. 2) Get rid of the cap on S.S. taxable income, every one pays it on every dollar (not just the first 100k or whatever it is now) - in exchange, cut the rate by about half 3) Tax dividend payments as regular income - in exchange, cut corporate income taxes by 50-100% other things I'd like to see: move the S.S. retirement age back one year every 2 or 3 years until it is equal to a lagged average life expectancy of all workers (set to adjust automatically every decade) BUT leave the "retirement age" rules for tax advantaged accounts largely unchanged. I have other ideas, and the devil is of course in the details. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

like your ideas citrus. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

no deductions, no credits actually, there are credits for lower income (and in all practicality there would be other credits to ensure what's called "horizontal equity" - a single person making the same income as a family of 5 being treated differently). but otherwise yes no deductions. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

All the money goes to pay interest on debt we've incurred the orange is an "everything sucks for a long time" scenario  

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

thanks river! the fair tax is probably a pipe dream (especially as is... everyone loves their deductions, and there's too much invested in this system to be politically palatable. 

razumikhin --- 16 years ago -

Further food for thought regarding tax fairness... Currently, the federal government's receipts from the payroll tax (Social Security and Medicare) are essentially equal in magnitude to the receipts from individual incomes taxes (first time in history this has been true). Since the lion's share of the payroll tax (6.2% of the 7.65%) is by definition a regressive tax (it disproportionately taxes lower income earners vs. higher income earners) since it cuts out at about $106,000, it is apparent that nearly half the individual tax receipts collected in this nation is from a regressive tax. Note that this state of affairs is even less "fair" than a "flat tax." Now it may be true that the other half of the taxes collected is very progressive, thereby making the overall tax structure somewhat flat. I'd have to look into that. But wanted to point out to those that think the rich are getting soaked and the (working) poor are getting off free. It just isn't the case. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

no problem citrus, its nice to have a decent debate with someone. i dont mind a progressive tax scale. i like the idea that the burden is more proportionate that way. my biggest problem with flat or fair taxes is that they shift the tax burden from the wealthy. if i had a magic tax wand, and could enact any change i wanted, i would like to see offshore accounts taxed, and companies to face penalties for moving overseas. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

the payroll tax...is by definition a regressive tax It's not good, no doubt. that's why I posted #2 above: 2) Get rid of the cap on S.S. taxable income, every one pays it on every dollar (not just the first 100k or whatever it is now) - in exchange, cut the rate by about half hmmm... should've said SS and medicare tax and companies to face penalties for moving overseas I agree, but attack it from the other side: eliminate gov incentives to leave. 

david --- 16 years ago -

River what isn't fair about Vat everyone pays there fair share and no more huge refunds for people with 5 kids 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

I suggest before any more debate continues, that EVERYONE watch this documentary about the Income Tax. It is VERY MUCH worth the time you will take to watch it.  

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground