Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

MSNBC takes notes from FOX in it's coverage of the troop pullout.

who's talking here?

smartypants 5
likeke 3
Fallon 2
SoupIsGoodFood 1
david 1
Meme2my5 2
evolved 1
Ogre2 7
Dr Aborto 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

MSNBC was given exclusive coverage of the pull out by the military.

THAT I think is hogwash in and of itself.

But the constant "AMERICAN COMBAT TROOPS ARE OUT OF IRAQ" is a much finer brand of hogwash.

There are still 50,000 men and women in Iraq. Including Spec Ops guys who will be doing counter-terrorism missions with Iraqi forces.

That, to me, is combat.

MSNBC - Bunch of D@MNED LIARS. 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

MSNBC - Bunch of D@MNED LIARS.

That bears repeating. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

I want to know what happened to the daily body count MSNBC, and CNN were showing until O was sworn in. And the endless photos of the coffins coming back with flags draped over them.

What all that stopped when O was elected?

All journalist, and I use the term loosely, report with a full agenda now. It is very hard to find any news story that just reports the facts. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

My only worry is for those still there. They are in greater danger now. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

My only worry is for those still there. They are in greater danger now. 


And so are everyone of the Iraq's who helped our troops. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

MrMark posted this a few days ago. Aren't there just as many stationed in Germany? Does that mean we're still at war with Germany? 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Germany is not in danger with Al Qaeda, so the the military there aren't in the same kind of danger. That is like comparing apples and oranges. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Are we at war in Japan, South Korea, Turkey??

Silliness wins again. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

[i]There are still 50,000 men and women in Iraq.[/i]

Ogre, do you think it's in the world's interest that we remain there? 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

Does that mean we're still at war with Germany?

No, those troops are holdovers from the Cold War when we were waiting for 10,000 Ruskie tanks to come screaming across the Hinterland. Cold War policies still in place and all.

Ogre, do you think it's in the world's interest that we remain there?

Smarty, that's a very complicated question that has many, many levels. But I'll try to boil it down to chat board level. World interest? No. Iraq's best interest? No. U.S. best interests? No. Iran's best interests? yes.

Let me explain. Who now is the strongest nation in that region? Iran. All we did was hand regional supremacy to the Iranians when we invaded. That's it. All we've managed to do is destabilize the region. No matter how many individual Iraqi schools and clinics we may have built while over there, the Iraqis are in a much more perilous position than they ever were under S.H.

have we hurt Al Queada? No. In fact we've helped their cause by giving them that much more propaganda to play with. I can't find anything that says how many Al Queada leaders we've taken out. But I have found that we've killed the #3 guy at least three times. Not the same guy, just three different guys who were #3. All we've done is increase the chances for promotion in the organization.

I have to wonder how many BILLIONS of dollars we've spent on each Al Quaeda leader we've taken out by initiating this stupid conventional war when we could just as easily sent Spec Ops in quietly and put .50 cal bullets in their butts.

Basically, if were going to "Save the Iraqis" we should have done it in 1991 when we were the to begin with and not do YET ANOTHER half-assed job of taking over another country.

All this war was and is is lives thrown away and American resources flushed down the toilet. Eventually, $3 TRILLION dollars, flushed.

Don't get me wrong. SH was a b@stard. BUT, he was powerful because WE MADE HIM THAT WAY! We need to get out of the nation building business. We kinda suck at it. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

[i] Who now is the strongest nation in that region? Iran.[/i]

Hmmm...they may be. I'm not sure. I do agree that they are the most potentially dangerous nation in the region. I think maybe Saudi Arabia may be as strong if not stronger, but in a different way.

[i] we could just as easily sent Spec Ops in quietly and put .50 cal bullets in their butts[/i]

So, we can do that now, right? That would make keeping forces there the wiser decision. Iraq is a mess, perfect for Al Qaeda.

[i] U.S. best interests? No. [/i]

I think it's in our interest to stay until the country is stable, and we need to try to restore infastructure like electricity that we destroyed. The Iraqis will be even more vulnerable to fundamentalist garbage if they don't get some semblance of normal life back. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Iran's best interests? yes.

Explain please. 

likeke --- 16 years ago -


That, to me, is combat.


without combat pay.... nice 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

So, we can do that now, right?

Element of surprise is gone. They're expecting us.

I think it's in our interest to stay until the country is stable

Then we'll be there effectively forever.

Explain please.

The ONE regional threat to Iranian power was who? Saddam. He's gone. the next person to rule (yes, RULE) Iraq will be an Iranian puppet. A warlord whose power base behind the throne will be Persian. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

without combat pay.... nice

They'll get something else, haz duty pay or whatever. Either way, Spec Ops is all volunteer, you KNOW what you're doing. 

likeke --- 16 years ago -

didn't obama say that combat was over? 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

didn't obama say that combat was over?

Yes, but I always have to wonder if the Insurgents agree. 

likeke --- 16 years ago -

oh. kinda like a mission accomplished 

david --- 16 years ago -

I think it's in our interest to stay until the country is stable, and we need to try to restore infastructure like electricity that we destroyed. The Iraqis will be even more vulnerable to fundamentalist garbage if they don't get some semblance of normal life back. 

funny how things change when their guy is president 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

oh. kinda like a mission accomplished

Not quite, but sorta. I think we're closer to Mission Accomplished/End of Combat today than we were 7 years ago for sure.

funny how things change

I don't recall anyone from any party saying we should just bail on Iraq now that we're there. The argument has always been should we be there to begin with. I still say no.

But if we bail on them now we'll simply wind up with another Afghanistan.

Me, being a pessimist, thinks that will happen anyway because the Iranian intelligence service has proven to be better at their job than our intelligence services have proven to be at theirs.

We're not done with Iraq. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

[i]I think it's in our interest to stay until the country is stable

Then we'll be there effectively forever.
[/i]

I didn't word that well. I'm thinking about the US presence in Germany. I'm in favor of that, keeping in mind that some of that presence is to handle medivac, not necessarily military only.

If we have a presence in Iraq, we will have expats and chances to, maybe build relationships that aren't adversarial, when we are doing things that are helpful to Iraqis. Part of the justification (at least unofficially) for being there was because SH was so horrible to his own people. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

Smarty, I hope you're right. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

It's not that I don't think we're perfectly capable of blowing that too. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground