Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Flooring opinions - wood vs. laminate

who's talking here?

ladybeachbum 1
Momsterof2 1
Jpgirl 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
kim 1
Amy 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
JustLivin 2
Kara 1
PeopleRPeople 2
OBXgirl 1
kwgraniteguy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JustLivin --- 14 years ago -

Considering redoing the floors in our home, but we are considering resale value as well... If the end 'look' was the same or quite similar, would it matter to you if the floors in your home were laminate wood look vs. actual hardwoods?

Also, any contractors on the msg board have opinions on going over tile?

Pros? Cons? Thoughts? 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

I think it depends on the housing market in your area. Some housing area warrant the extra expenditure of hardwood-other do not. You do not want to overspend.

Hubby and I are in a different position-we bought a house that we are going to stay in for at least 5years. B/c of kids, pets, etc, we are going with laminate everywhere but the bathrooms. There we are doing more expensive tile/travertine.

Why do you want to go over tile instead of taking it out? 

Momsterof2 --- 14 years ago -

We have laminate flooring and with kids it makes it so nice!! Laminate in my opinon is more durable and cleans so easy! Some new laminate it is hard to tell its not wood they even have hand scraped. My dad does flooring both natural and laminte and does an amazing job, he is semi retired now but still does side jobs, (he has done floors in the houston area for 30+ years) and has all of his contacts and can normally get you a great deal on the materials as well. give him a call at 361-746-0413 his name is Tom tell him is daughter Tara sent you! 

JustLivin --- 14 years ago -

HT - considering going over tile because of cost and ease - had someone do an estimate this morning and completely confused us. He was talking about what is under the tile making a difference in what needs to be done. A 'mudbank' ? Vs concrete. Also, ripping out old tile would be an additional cost that may not be necessary. Like you said, we don't want to overspend. Lastly, if we went with less expensive options, laminate over tile, we would be able to do more which would give the house a nice consistency between rooms and areas instead of having tile (though nice tile!) in the kitchen and extra rm off kitchen, wood in the entry and hall, and carpet in the living and dining rms. 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

between rooms and areas instead of having tile (though nice tile!) in the kitchen and extra rm off kitchen, wood in the entry and hall, and carpet in the living and dining rms.

I was going to do laminate in the bathrooms as well until I read article after article about if something overflows, the laminate will buckle.

The contractor was probably talking about subfloors, etc. We visited some homes where you could tell they didn't have a nice solid sub-floor b/c it didn't feel completely flat. Best advice though would be shop around! I completely agree about wanting consistency. Hubby and I are debating that now when it comes to the bedrooms. 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

The contractor was probably talking about subfloors,

Yes, most likely. If your home has a slab foundation you are unlikely to have a "mud base", exception possibly if the home dates back pre 60's ish. I have demoed mud base and it is a chore and a half. Through personal exp I would not reccomend laying over tile. That floor was ultimately removed and replaced. YMMV :) 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

We've done both ourselves. I'd go wood all the way- I love the look and feel of wood- and no matter what you pay for the laminate- it looks like laminate. As far as going over tile-laminate can be done - with real wood you have to do either an underlayment ( sub floor)or stringers. We've done 2 rooms upstairs in real wood and our master bedroom in laminate. In Ohio we had the entry and kitchen in wood when we had the house built- after a few years- dh and I did the rest of the first floor in wood. It was beautiful- the upkeep is the same- durability the same too. We had 2 kids, 3 dogs and 2 cats- it held up very very well. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I had wood put in, and my stepdaughter chose that time to put regular detergent in the dishwasher! had to replace a good size area of the floor..it also is high maintenance - I wear high heels a lot, and I've left little chips here and there...I have to agree with Jp, though, when it just been cleaned, it looks better than anything else could..and she's right that laminate looks like laminate.. 

kim --- 14 years ago -

Do laminate. If you have kids and dogs laminate is the way to go. Right now we have hardwood and it sucks. It scratches so easy. We had laminate in our other house its way better. The laminate today looks just like real wood but half the cost 

OBXgirl --- 14 years ago -

I think it really depends on your neighborhood whether it would be seen as something that would add to the value of your home or not. IMO, the new laminates and the pre-finished wood floors look about the same quality/wise. We really wanted to put down solid wood floors (that can be refinished) and were advised against it here because we're on a slab. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

we have laminent in our house ( it is a rent house ) and i love it.. with pets and heavy traffic of teenager and bf's work dirt and such it holds up really well. 

Amy --- 14 years ago -

Call Paul Calls with Capps flooring he is very affordable and does great work. He has several referrals right here on kingwood underground. 281-608-1280. 

Kara --- 14 years ago -

I have wood and every time I go into a space with laminate, I notice right away that it real.

The feel is completely different when you walk on it, as thought the surface is cushioned. (laminate)

When you are walking on hardwood, it is more of a solid surface. You can resurface wood, you can't with laminate.

SO the longevity of hardwood alone is worth it. Not sure how long the print on a laminate floor would hold up over time but I am guessing that the entire floor would have to replaced sooner. 

ladybeachbum --- 14 years ago -

I had Laminate at the beach before the hurricane and replaced it will tile. I wish I had the laminate back. Much easier to clean. My brother has both laminate and real wood. The real wood is a mess with the dogs. They have scratched it really bad. It was there when he bought the house and I don't think properly sealed. I want real wood but I think laminate is more user friendly. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
recommendations


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground