Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Centerpoint/Utility ROW Ownership

who's talking here?

SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Infidel II 2
tdbrueggen 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

Behind my house runs a Centerpoint/City sewer ROW/Easement. For over a year since I moved in I have mowed and maintained it to keep it nice, as do my neighbors on both sides. People walk back there all the time, walking dogs, riding bikes, etc. Recently I have planted a few fruit trees back there, with the full intent that whoever walks back there can help themselves. I just enjoy gardening.
Now I've been ordered by Bear Branch Trail Assoc. to not only remove all the fruit trees, but all cease mowing "their" property. According to them it is supposed to be "wild" area (snakes, critters, poison ivy, you know, the good stuff). Just to clarify, it backs up flush to my fence, not through the trees like in most areas.
Anyway, my question is, who really owns/governs the ROW/easements. The letter I received from BBTA says that they "charged themselves with maintenance" of the easements, not that they actually own them. If I charge myself with maintenance of the street in front of my house, can I install speed bumps and issue traffic tickets? I don't think so.
In effect I have charged myself with maintenance of the easement out back, and have planted the fruit trees in the eyes of improving the property, and benefiting the community. They do not inhibit the power lines in any way. I suppose if the city sewer was to be dug up I may loose them, but that's the risk that I knowingly took in planting them. However they do no inhibit any access to the sewer manholes/maintenance.
I know I am technically in the wrong, as far as planting trees on property that is not mine, but I want to hear it from, and deal with, the entity that truly owns the easement. I've been bullied enough by both my HOA and trail association, and will not let it continue. I'd like to call their bluff, but they have already threatened to "rip out the trees" at my expense.
Can anyone help point me in the right direction here? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I'd call Centerpoint and see what they say...They have standards about planting trees in the vicinity of power lines. But you have to find out who owns what first..Here's info from Centerpoint..


Centerpoint Energy 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

Thanks for the info. I looked into it, and Centerpoint has a list of recommended trees that can be planted under/around power lines. It does not say that variety is restricted to only this list, but rather just a few recommendations. What they all have in common is a mature height of 15-20'. Good thing my fruit trees won't exceed 10' tall.
The easement is 40' wide. The lines run on the opposite side from my fence. There is a wall of trees on the other side of the lines. So from a line to a tree is probably 10' or less. My trees are 10' off of my fence, so at least 20' from the plane of the power lines. Then the lines are 25-30' high. Trigonometry puts my fruit trees about 30' or more from their lines. The 20' space between my trees and the poles is the area that I left clear for passage with a service truck. My fruit trees will never be a risk of dropping limbs on a power line, unless an updraft yanks them out of the ground and tosses them upward, at which point we've got bigger problems :)

But back to point, I want to know who the final judge is. I've already spoken with BBTA about it, and it seems that they will bend to Centerpoint. After all, Centerpoint has gone through and cut out a bunch of dead trees, leaving the debris piled in the woods. Now BBTA is trying to bill all of us, so they can clean up after Centerpoint. Why not just let the wood rot? That's a whole different argument though. I think I'll post a comment about that actually. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

Typically, the original owner of the land has the right to decide how a right-of-way (ROW) will be maintained and outlines those requirements in the deed conveying the ROW rights to the grantee, in this case, Centerpoint. Most of the time, it is the grantee who has or wants to have the maintenance rights, because they do not want others to plant trees that may interfere with subsurface facilities, such as sewer lines or gas pipelines and may present safety issues (e.g. roots interfering with cathodic protection devices or causing corrosion to the lines).

Centerpoint may have assigned the maintenance obligation to BBTA, but any such arrangement may not be of public record. The easement granting the ROW would be of public record and may show who has the maintenance obligation. It may also show if the ROW grants both above-ground and subsurface rights, which is important as to what can be planted there. Lots of variables and unknowns without further documentation to refer to . . . 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

Infidel II: you say the easement granting the ROW would be public record. How would I obtain this record? From what I can gather, Centerpoint has no problem with people planting trees in the easement, as long as it does not interfere with their maintenance, or risk interfering with the lines. They even have a schematic on their website that shows trees up to 20' tall being planted directly under their lines. They also provide a list of recommended trees that stay short. Even further, in the FAQ's section, they point out that with fruit/nut trees, they will consult with the landowner before trimming/removing the trees.
It seems that Centerpoint must have dumped maintenance duty on BBTA, which in turn makes BBTA think that they "own" the ROW. But I don't think that's how it works. If that was the case, then Centerpoint would be able to make BBTA go out and trim trees away from the lines, but Centerpoint handles that. It seems that Centerpoint pawned off maintenance on BBTA so that Centerpoint wouldn't have to deal with the public when people complained that the ROW was grown up and looks like crap. It's a nice endless loop they've established. If you call Centerpoint they'll say it's not their problem, and to contact BBTA. If you call BBTA, they'll complain about how Centerpoint abuses the ROW, and how BBTA has not choice but to let it be a natural area, as maintenance costs would be prohibitive.
I love how BBTA throws out the term of "prohibitive costs" after they have wasted away all of their available funds on projects that were obviously cost prohibitive from the beginning. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

tniggs,

You could try http://www.cclerk.hctx.net/ as a starting point. At work, I usually ask one of our landmen to find copies of ROWs, leases, fee tracts, etc., and I do not perform those searches myself. But, I think there's typically a grantor/grantee index, so if you know the grantee's legal name (one of the Centerpoint entities), you may be able to find it, or you may be able to search by the legal description (Township, Section, Range, outlot, etc.), but that's about the limits of my understanding of how to find it.

As a general matter, only the owner of the land and any grantees of ROW rights has continuing rights to use the land in question, unless it's an exclusive ROW, in which case the landowner has no rights to use the land while the ROW remains effective. So, it really depends on what restrictions the landowner or ROW grantee wants to impose or what the conveyance deed granting the ROW details as to how the land can be used and how it must be maintained. Good luck. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
politics
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground