Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

HUMBLE ISD SHORTCOMINGS...

who's talking here?

planemom 2
Tylers Journey 2
kidsfan3 1
Work in Progress 1
FabFive 6
TONISFRIEND 1
analogkid 3
Himura Hitokiri 3
crazydazey 1
ConcernedKWCitizen 15
Emperor of Kingwood 3
Hippiedippiechik 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

I have always suspected Humble ISD was a SHAM,but I guess this confirms it.

I am curious to hear your viewpoint(s) 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

here's a hot link below 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

A CURRICULUM MANAGEMENT AUDIT 

crazydazey --- 14 years ago -

231 pages in the report. Do you have the Cliffs Notes for this? 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

sure crazy, here they are

the CLIFF NOTES! 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

III. FINDINGS

STANDARD 1: The School District Demonstrates Its Control of Resources, Programs, and Personnel.

Finding 1.1: Board policies do not direct curriculum design and delivery, provide for adequate curriculum management direction, or ensure effective quality control.

Finding 1.2: System planning is inadequate to direct curriculum management, assessment, staff development, and budgeting to ensure system-wide congruence and drive student achievement.

Finding 1.3: The organizational chart does not meet all audit criteria for sound organizational design. Many job descriptions do not meet audit criteria for current, accurate, and clear specifications of responsibilities and role relationships in the district.

STANDARD 2: The School District Has Established Clear and Valid Objectives for Students.

Finding 2.1: Humble ISD lacks a documented planning process and a comprehensive management plan that provides coordinated direction of the design, delivery, and evaluation of the curriculum.

Finding 2.2: The scope of the written curriculum is adequate at the elementary level to provide a cohesive framework of the goals and objectives for student learning; the scope of the written curriculum is inadequate at the secondary level.

Finding 2.3: The quality of the district’s adopted written curriculum is inadequate to direct teaching,to promote deep alignment, and to provide a rigorous educational program.

STANDARD 3: The School District Demonstrates Internal Consistency and Rational Equity in Its Program

Finding 3.1: Disparity exists in student achievement; student participation in advanced courses is disproportionate by ethnicity. Efforts to provide equity among schools have not yet achieved the desired results.

Finding 3.2: Design and delivery of professional development is fragmented and inadequately planned. Professional development lacks systemic monitoring, coordination, and evaluation to support district and program achievement goals.

STANDARD 4: The School District Uses the Results from District-Designed or -Adopted Assessments to Adjust, Improve, or Terminate Ineffective Practices or Programs.

Finding 4.1: The district lacks comprehensive student assessment and program evaluation planning to guide decisions for improving student achievement.

Finding 4.2: The scope of assessment is inadequate to comprehensively evaluate the taught curriculum.

Finding 4.3: Student achievement in the aggregate is at or above state averages in all subject areas as assessed by TAKS; however, achievement gaps are evident among subgroup populations.

STANDARD 5: The School District Has Improved Productivity.

Finding 5.1: The districts budget development and decision making are not fully aligned to the district mission, curricular goals, and strategic priorities, nor is there an adequate cost-benefit analysis to assure maximum educational productivity.

Finding 5.2: Policies and procedures for planning, selecting, implementing, monitoring, and evaluating program interventions impede quality control and are insufficient to ensure positive student achievement results.

Finding 5.3: Facilities are well maintained and clean and provide good space for the delivery of instruction; however, dependable access to current technology within the buildings is inconsistent, negatively impacting the utilization of available instructional resources by teachers. 

TONISFRIEND --- 14 years ago -

And this is a surprise? 

Hippiedippiechik --- 14 years ago -

And this is a surprise?

My thought exactly. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

It may not be a surprise to you, but there are a lot of people (news press, parents, teachers/staff) that think HUMBLE ISD is a terrific school district, with effective instruction which prepares students for a DYNAMIC future. 

Himura Hitokiri --- 14 years ago -

but there are a lot of people (news press, parents, teachers/staff) that think HUMBLE ISD is a terrific school district, with effective instruction which prepares students for a DYNAMIC future. 

Those people would be delusional kool-aid drinkers... 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 14 years ago -

In the work place, I have to live with the products of public education. They can't write a coherent sentence, perform rudimentary analytical analysis, communicate, understand anything about economics or government. Thats the college graduates too. But, they sure are politically correct. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

Now more money can be diverted towards administration. How many teachers will we lose to implement all these necessary changes? 

Himura Hitokiri --- 14 years ago -

In the work place, I have to live with the products of public education. They can't write a coherent sentence, perform rudimentary analytical analysis, communicate, understand anything about economics or government. Thats the college graduates too. But, they sure are politically correct. 


Oh, man, don't even get me started on the communication skills of the young generation...There are two young generations today that are completely baffled if you use the passive voice to indicate a nuance of meaning. And that's not even considering that the majority of my generation doesn't even realize there is a subjunctive mood in English, much less how to use it properly. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 14 years ago -

Want a good laugh? Ask a high school senior for the definition of bicameral government. They won't know the answer to the aforementioned, but they will tell you all about afirmitive action and racism. 

analogkid --- 14 years ago -

We certainly have found it interesting having moved here from WA state, that in our 10th grade son's AP world history and english classes, there have been no writing assignments of significance. Last year in several of his classes, he was writing papers pretty much every other week, with more significant papers due every several weeks.

So far, the objective here seems to be read the hell out of his texts and be tested like crazy week-in-and-week-out. He says there is very little class discussion of topics, which would allow for synthesis of information and to help facilitate communication skills, as well as the sharing of ideas. In fact, when he asked one of his teachers about the lack of writing, the response was that they were afraid the parents would just end up writing them anyway. Cop out!

We have actually considered extra writing at home as he is afraid that his writing skills will backslide without continuing that type of work. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

tested like crazy week-in-and-week-out

Unfortunately analogkid, the district teaches to the test. They are so concerned about testing scores that it leaves the teacher and students little time for any real communication and discussion of topics. 

FabFive --- 14 years ago -

This is really sad. 

analogkid --- 14 years ago -

Unfortunately analogkid, the district teaches to the test.

Yes, you can totally tell the teaching is very test-centric. I just can't believe you can take an AP history class and not have a bit of writing in it. While we do discuss topics and events with him at home, I think he still misses the opportunity of classroom discourse. There is so much being left out when states/districts choose to teach with this approach.

Chemistry seems very similar in that they have done very little lab and mostly have focused on reading, problem solving and, yes, tests. I understand that chemistry requires a lot of reading and working on problems, but they have done very little compared to what I remember the HS lab portion being like, or what it should be. Learning science is about the hands on experiences in many ways. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

Of course we don't live in a perfect world BUT,

What I find interesting is the mediocrity that area residents appear to be content with. Are they even aware? Where is the breakdown?

I admire the superintendent for wanting to know how the curriculum is managed and analyzing it to become a better school district ( Audit report page 5/PDF page 19), but in the meantime student learning suffers.

I'm concerned about how motivated they are. With no public outcry and no alternatives to turn up the heat (no charter school(s) that I am aware of) what is their motivation?

Walking around with big smiles and talking about all the great learning that is going on is not the solution unfortunately. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

The district teaches to the test because that determines how money and resources are allocated. If the state and federal governments don't want students taught to a test then they need to quit tying money to test results.

As far as not writing enough, DD2 had to write a how to essay in Algebra 1. Maybe the school is getting the idea that kids need more writing practice. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

the district teaches to the test.

If the district does "teach to the test" - which I know for a fact many campuses do - hypothetically speaking, there should be no problem in getting every student to 100%.

BUT as the audit shows:

STANDARD 4:

Finding 4.1: The district lacks comprehensive student assessment and program evaluation planning to guide decisions for improving student achievement.

Finding 4.2: The scope of assessment is inadequate to comprehensively evaluate the taught curriculum.

The district can't even "teach to the test" effectively. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

The district teaches to the test because that determines how money and resources are allocated. If the state and federal governments don't want students taught to a test then they need to quit tying money to test results.

I don't think it is the money/results as much as it is the GOVERNMENT (state and federal) were the REAL problem lies. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

The somehow found a crap load of money for that BIG screen for the football games when that money could have gone to education. It seems that football will always come before education in every state. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

They were sure to announce, actually, state in the articles title, that NONE of that money came from the "pot" so to speak...as usual, always covering their #*^%

They are good at playing this game...and I don't mean football.

ARTICLE ON SCOREBOARD 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

You still have to pay for the upkeep and they still should of used that money for education. How much was the warranty on that thing? 

FabFive --- 14 years ago -

This is one of the many reasons I homeschool. Our oldest skipped a grade in public school and was in the GT program.and still didn't learn anything in first grade. We couldn't move her up another grade because socially it was already borderline that would have been too much. Parents are responsible for the content of their childrens education and if you don't like what you have, you need to deal with it. I am most impressed with the person who adds writing to their sons workload. Once we started homeschooling, we realized we liked it for a lot of reasons besides our initial ones, and kept it going. I do not know how teachers, especially in younger grades, can meet the needs of 20 or 30 students. There can not be enough hours in the day. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 14 years ago -

The public school system stopped being an institution of learning and education and has become an instrument of political indoctrination and social engineering for the far left. Further, their political agenda is to proliferate and grow the public school system for the sake of gaining control over your childs education, diet, religious beliefs and ideas in the hope that it perpetuates the system, because they have the mentality that "they know best". 

analogkid --- 14 years ago -

Bob's comments notwithstanding, because I'm not even sure how I begin to address that diatribe, we homeschooled through middle school with our son, and still have our daughter homeschooling for seventh grade. So we are pretty comfortable with providing work to help fill the gaps.

We only have so many years with them and you have to take the time and effort to ensure they are as prepared as possible. Sadly, many parents are more than willing to just punt their kids over completely to the schools, as evidenced by how many parents say they can't wait until their kids start school so they can have some free time back. From there it spirals downward for many. 

FabFive --- 14 years ago -

I would like to applaud you, analog. 

Himura Hitokiri --- 14 years ago -

Bob's comments notwithstanding, because I'm not even sure how I begin to address that diatribe,

That's because you have no real answer to the points Bob addressed. Humble ISD schools are not a place of real education they're just another indoctrination center seeking funding from the DoEdu. The best any kid can get from Humble ISD, and this has been true throughout their history, is to become a good little Borg drone... Humble ISD stinks on ice, and always has, no matter what their 'scores' say... 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

Lord, with all due respect, I am not sure I can change your negative attitude towards the public schools. Not that I am trying to either. There could be a good reason and I don't know the whole story or have all the facts, so maybe you are justified in your feelings.

BUT,even though I agree with you ( that they stink) ,as responsible citizens, we need to hold them accountable and try to make it better.

They are OUR schools...we are the PUBLIC..in PUBLIC SCHOOLS!

I just find it disheartening , that so many are satisfied (or oblivious?) with the mediocrity or throw their hands up and walk away!

That is how we solve problems in this world? Wow! 

FabFive --- 14 years ago -

Trust me, as a parent who advocated like no other, for her child, you are up against a brick wall. Rather than waste my energy getting nowhere, I took matters into my own hands. I agree wholeheartedly that this system needs to change...but the dysfunction is so monumental that a person could work at this a lifetime and make little to no impact. I am not trying to be negative, because I am a take the bull by the horns kind of person, but I think you would have better luck getting welfare reform than education reform. It is so, so, so, so depressing our educational system, as a whole. To top it off, teachers are working their butts off and in many cases do not have the support either from faculty or parents and they are overworked and underpaid. I believe the union's way of job retention is stupid. The best teachers need to be paid top dollar and highly sought after and the worst teachers need to find other jobs. Lets get real world, here. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

One of the MANY reasons why we are opting to homeschool.

I was an "insider" of public schooling for years. Not wanting to send my boys into it!

Unfortunately, I don't think that Humble is alone in being inadequate. It seems to be systemic within the whole system. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

Trust me, as a parent who advocated like no other, for her child, you are up against a brick wall.


Fab, I commend you for your efforts, your child is lucky to have you as a parent.

But it was just YOU advocating for YOUR one child, if I understand you correctly.

Power in numbers is the only way to get their attention,I believe.

If everyone of the parents in Humble ISD, told the district, tomorrow, that the schools "suck" and we are not taking it anymore and we will not be sending our kids to school tomorrow unless you do A. B and C. we'd see some action!

We'd also make the news (national news, world news, actually history)! What would they do ,arrest all 65,000 of us!?

I guarantee this monster called public schools would be slammed on it's head.

Drastic changes require drastic measures,unfortunately! 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

we homeschooled through middle school with our son, and still have our daughter homeschooling for seventh grade. So we are pretty comfortable with providing work to help fill the gaps.

Analog,

I wanted to clarify....

are you saying your son started in home school, then you sent him into public school after middle?

are you saying your daughter is on the same path as your son?

when you say "fill in the gaps" are you saying the gap is from K - 7th for your son?

I find this interesting,

I do know of a family that had their kid in private school and didn't send them to public school until 10th grade or 11th... and of course the more typical scenario of starting a kid in public school then switching gears and home schooling their kid for the duration of schooling! 

FabFive --- 14 years ago -

Unfortunately not many would stand with you. If I had kids in school, I would. I think you should poll the KU crowd of those that currently have kids in public school and ask them if they are satisfied, and if not, are they dissatisfied to stand up and say they aren't happy. I think you will be dissappointed in the results. 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

Fab,

optimistically speaking... your idea to poll some folks might be a good place to start the campaign.... at KU and beyond...

OPERATION: take back our schools!

it's got me thinking...thanks! 

ConcernedKWCitizen --- 14 years ago -

 

FabFive --- 14 years ago -

No problem :) Sorry I'm not more of an optimist on this issue, but I hope you steamroll the red tape!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground