Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

How furious would you be if your kid had this assignment?

who's talking here?

hummer 1
ExLady In Blue 2
Perfection 1
Laurabeth 1
kidsfan3 1
Work in Progress 3
Dorothy Parker 1
itstxdaddy 1
FabFive 1
FluffyPenguin 1
Semper 1
KingwoodGirl87 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

An unidentified French teacher has been suspended after she issued a very unsettling homework assignment to her class at at the college Antoine-Delafonte in France. The students, which were reportedly around 13 and 14-years-old, were asked to pen their own suicide notes.

“You’ve just turned 18 and have decided to end your life. Your decision appears irrevocable. As a final effort, you decide to explain the reasons for your act,” the assignment read, according to the Telegraph.

“In setting out your self-portrait, you describe all the disgust you feel for yourself. Your text must bring up certain events in your life at the root of this feeling.”

Parents were understandably shocked to hear about the suicide note assignment and wrote to the headmaster and local school authority lamenting: “We are horrified that this type of topics should be proposed to children between 13 and 14 years old.”

The Telegraph has more details:


One parent, Béatrice Goupilleau, told Le Charente Libre, the local newspaper, that her son was embarrassed to let her see his suicide note and the teacher’s comment, which read: “Not precise enough.”

Another, Hélène Ferrari, said: “What shocks me is linking autobiography with suicide, it’s really over the top.”
Christophe Clément, president of the FCPE parents’ union in Montmoreau, said such a subject is “practically inciting (pupils) to commit suicide.”


Jean-Marie Renault, the local education authority head, said the teacher had been officially notified of his suspension, adding: “Telling a pupil that he is about to end his life and that he must recount it appears troubling to us.”

Geneviève Fioraso, France’s higher education minister, said the topic was “dangerous” without “context” but did not condemn the teacher’s actions.

Others rallied behind the teacher, including students.

“He’s our favorite teacher, the best we’ve ever had in this school. We don’t want him to be punished,” one student said.

Some parents too came to the teacher’s defense. “What do you think they talk about in the playground? The images they see on TV are far more shocking,” a mother said.

“Suicide is part of daily life. Perhaps the teacher wished to raise their awareness of the issue,” said another parent.

A group of parents later released a statement saying the media coverage of the incident was “over the top and inappropriate.”

What do you think? Was the homework assignment appropriate? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

wow 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

"Wow" is all I can say, too. 

kidsfan3 --- 13 years ago -

WOW here too! Have I said lately how much we enjoy homeschooling? :) 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

“Suicide is part of daily life.

really? daily life huh? wow.

i think the teacher may had the idea of having the students really look inside themselves to see who they were, but his approach to take the look within was completely wrong. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Idiots. They aren't just in America. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I used to teach high school writing. We were always looking for high interest prompts to teach different writing skills and styles. And there is nothing more interesting to a teen than him/herself, so we often let them write introspectively.

However, the ideas that an assignment like this generates is NOT something that you want a teen to start thinking about! At best, it's an assignment that will get them thinking in terms of blaming everyone else around them for normal teenaged "angst." At worst, you now have a kid contemplating suicide.

Thoughts like that can plant a seed, that left unchecked can grow into something. 

KingwoodGirl87 --- 13 years ago -

thats horrible....13 and 14 year olds you have got to be kidding me...was that part of the actually curriculum? 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

That's pretty disturbing...especially at that age. :( 

FluffyPenguin --- 13 years ago -

While I may not agree fully, I understand the reasoning for something like this. I had to do something similar in high school where I had to write my own obituary.

Death is such a sensitive subject regardless of age. We assume that by the time a child is full grown they will be able to accept the end goal of life.

If getting to the root of problems is where the teacher was headed she went about it the wrong way. 

Laurabeth --- 13 years ago -

I know I'm the oddball out here, but I wouldn't have a problem with the assignment as long as it had a follow up with a clear purpose. Suicide in teens has exploded recently.....what better way to deal with this issue than head on! It gets the students talking, maybe sharing thier inner feelings and problems.....I would hope that there was a clear purpose and follow up for students that may have expressed real issues or prior forethought about suicide.
If we were totally honest about it..,,,,most kids know about suicide....so why not discuss it? Remove the stigma, and get the issues out there. Let them know there is help....there are better days ahead...... 

ExLady In Blue --- 13 years ago -

I think it would be stupid, at any age, even to a 30 year old, or 40, 50, or 60 year old college student.

And you can talk about suicide and death, without asking everyone to describe why they would kill themselves. I especially thought the part about the teacher instructions, which stated, "Your text must bring up certain events in your life at the root of this feeling.” 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I know I'm the oddball out here, but I wouldn't have a problem with the assignment as long as it had a follow up with a clear purpose. Suicide in teens has exploded recently.....what better way to deal with this issue than head on! It gets the students talking, maybe sharing thier inner feelings and problems.....I would hope that there was a clear purpose and follow up for students that may have expressed real issues or prior forethought about suicide.
If we were totally honest about it..,,,,most kids know about suicide....so why not discuss it? Remove the stigma, and get the issues out there. Let them know there is help....there are better days ahead......


I think you have to be VERY careful. I'm assuming that this teacher was not a trained psychologist or had any authority whatsoever to be discussing this with teens.

I would not want a teacher with a differing paradigm from our own possibly telling my kid that suicide is a viable option. We don't know the teacher's take on it! All signs point that his/her (there are some contradictions within the piece as whether the teacher was male or female) judgment was lacking. 

hummer --- 13 years ago -

I recall having assignment on what would I want my obituary to look like. 

ExLady In Blue --- 13 years ago -

hummer --- 5 min ago - quote - hide comments

I recall having assignment on what would I want my obituary to look like.


I think there's a big difference between asking you to reflect on your accomplishments in life, versus why you would want to end your life prematurely. And, yes, I said accomplishments, because no one is going to put in the paper . . .

John Smith, former husband of Suzy Smith, Heather Smith, Jane Doe-Smith, and Roberta Smith. Obviously, while John was able to find someone to marry, he had a difficult time staying married to them. Of course, if he wasn't such a cheating ba$tard, he might have been able to keep his first wife around. John is survived by all of his ex-wives, and his ungrateful children: John, Jr. (now married to Heather, originally his step-mom), Bradley and Michael Smith. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground