Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

CSCOPE... What you need to know

who's talking here?

Bellarue 5
marybees 1
JAMS 1
OneEyedManRedux 7
geigerforhumbleisd 5
funkadelic 4
Identity Crisis 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

In February, Texas announced that the state, along with the Texas Education Service Center Curriculum (TESCCC,) would enact major changes to the controversial curriculum management system dubbed CSCOPE. The system received a litany of complaints from faculty members and parents alike concerning its lack of transparency (parents were allegedly not permitted to review lesson-plans), lack of oversight from the State Board of Education, and for allegedly imposing oppressive working conditions for faculty members.

CSCOPE was created so that teachers could frame their year around teaching points required by the state. Lessons, which are written by CSCOPE staff and current and former teachers, can be updated and delivered online, making it more cost-effective than standard textbooks.

To note just how off-color some of the CSCOPE curriculum is, consider that the Texas CSCOPE Review, an independent watchdog group, uncovered an out-of-date, optional CSCOPE lesson-plan on terrorism — “World History Unit 12 Lesson 07″ — which allegedly likens the Boston Tea Party to “an act of terrorism.”

The system also recently asked students to design a flag for a new socialist nation.

To glean greater insight, David Barton and Pat Gray, along with teachers Mary Bowen, Stan Hartzler and Texas State Sen. Dan Patrick discuss what is truly going on within their state’s education system.

Barton explained that CSCOPE is referred to as “instructional material” and not “curriculum,” therefore is not subject to regulation by the State Board of Education. The historian also brought in artifacts of Texas public school curriculum to showcase just how different it is today and to mark, year-by-year, the increasing application of political correctness in lesson plans.

Using a chart, Barton documented and mapped out core CSCOPE material, which eliminates national values, Americanism or rather, American exceptionalism, the study of federalism and majority rule (the core of our constitution) along with patriotic symbols like the Liberty Bell. Christopher Columbus, Rosh Hashanah and Christmas are all relegated to the dustbin along with American military history. Equality and a belief in justice is replaced by “fairness” and instruction on American propaganda and imperialism.

Teachers complained that they were expected to deliver the curriculum verbatim and only on days allotted by the CSCOPE lesson plan. Even if students were unable to absorb the lesson, teachers were allegedly directed to progress to the next lesson regardless. Teachers were “asked to sign a contract that would prevent them from revealing what was in the CSCOPE lessons or face civil and criminal penalties.”

The controversial program’s website states that CSCOPE is a comprehensive online curriculum management system developed and owned by the Texas Education Service Center Curriculum Collaborative (TESCCC), a consortium composed of the 20 ESCs in the state.” It goes on to explain that the CSCOPE system provides curriculum framework for grades kindergarten through 12 across a broad range of subject areas.

CSCOPE has been adopted by some 75 percent of Texas schools and the aim was to implement a national adoption of the management system. However, CSCOPE reportedly refused when Common Core Standards sought to purchase the system as the national curriculum standard. It is by far and away, one of the more hotly contested topics in the current education debate and much mystery still remains as to CSCOPE’s core tenets.

It is noted that secular progressivism, further, the notion of communal life and collectivism, is at the system’s core. Other points of contention concerning CSCOPE curriculum include lesson-plans positing that Christopher Columbus was an “eco-warrior” and, when referring to the famed explorer’s journal, all references to God and Christendom were removed.

Students are also posed with hypothetical scenarios concerning historical figures and have allegedly been asked to take a position on population growth. Students were even subject to a lesson framed around the idea that “Christianity was a cult”.

Hartzler, who taught math for nearly four decades, retired early because of CSCOPE. He said that he was written up nearly a dozen times for not following the system’s lesson plan and maintains that CSCOPE is dumbing-down American students. He said he tried his best to follow the lesson plans, but simply could not.

Bowen, who is currently forced to use CSCOPE in her school district, feels that schools are now more like factories that send children out into the real world from an assembly-line that has not even given them the basics. Bowen said that the lessons were mediocre at best, often “riddled with errors” and that “tests were invalid.”

“There’s tremendous coercion. It’s an incredibly oppressive environment.” She added that there have been teachers who were fired for speaking out to the school board.

Bowen also explained that teachers spend “one out of every five” days testing students, and that those tests provide data for the government’s use.

President Obama will look to move forward with implementing CSCOPE or such systems within a short time-frame. The panel said concerned Americans should send letters to the Attorney General and that emergency legislation should be enacted to help teachers push back. 

funkadelic --- 13 years ago -

Students were even subject to a lesson framed around the idea that “Christianity was a cult”.

A cult is a system of religious beliefs and ritual, you could say superstition as well. 

Identity Crisis --- 13 years ago -

This is really upsetting. I guess I need to start checking out private schools and homeschool ideas. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Organized religion IS a cult. 

geigerforhumbleisd --- 13 years ago -

One man's lesson plan is another man's propaganda. This same goes for the text book bias debate. Lesson plans, curriculum, text books, etc. all have some bias either due to ideology, publisher constraint, knowledge gap, etc. Instead of focusing on what facts, dates, or events children are taught or not taught, the focus should shift to essential critical thinking, reasoning, and logic. One problem is a classroom can be a dangerous place for unconventional thinking if a teacher asserts authority via text book or ideology. Schools should be a safe academic space for children to express ideas and opinions counter to what lessons or facts are presented, and teachers, administrators, parents, and school board members should work to ensure that safe space. If a parent is uncomfortable with a lesson plan or with a homework or class assignment, there should be a reasoned discussion on the matter. Let's not reach to the lowest common denominator and start shouting anti-this or anti-that. Education is an emotional and personal investment in a child's future, but that doesn't mean we can't use reason to solve these problems. As long as there is local control and a "one size fits all" system, there is going to be natural conflict. But I don't believe bowing to the whims of popular opinion on what or who should be included or excluded in a lesson plan or curriculum is going to be conducive to a child's learning potential ultimately. Parents have final authority on their children, and true learning pulls from many sources, texts, people. They will all have different opinions on what is an accurate reflection of history or events or cultures. The best we should do is foster critical reading and thinking. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

One man's lesson plan is another man's propaganda

....let me guess, One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter.... right?

all have some bias either due to ideology, publisher constraint, knowledge gap, etc.

They should have an liberty/ American exceptionalism bias.

They will all have different opinions on what is an accurate reflection of history or events or cultures.

Really? So you are promoting the idea that all cultures are equal??? That is not employing critical thinking.

You sound like you are saying that it does not matter what trash we teach the kids, as long as we teach them to think critically, then they will see through all the crap we are force feeding them.....

Ya right..... I suppose you also believe all kids are equally intelligent. 

Bellarue --- 13 years ago -

Huffman is teaching it. It is being taught all around us. Lord help our school district. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Lord help our school district.

Well if the above is any indication of the quality of School Board candidates we are blessed with, then indeed we will need some devine intervention. 

geigerforhumbleisd --- 13 years ago -

I'm not here to change your mind. It is already made up. I'm just presenting an alternate opinion. We can be all for American exceptionalism, but it is still a bias. The point is to present as many sources and opportunities and let them decide for themselves via critical thinking and reading. You would want both sides presented in the evolution vs. creationism (now "intelligent design") would you not? The point is not to present one culture above another nor is it to suggest all cultures are "equal." The only equality is the thoroughness of standards applied, not suggesting American culture and Third World cultures are equal in human rights, economics, religious liberties, etc. There is right and wrong in this world. Limiting a student's potential to one worldview because of fear or ignorance or desire for exceptionalism is wrong. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

is right and wrong in this world.

OK then teach that....

You want it both ways. you want unbiased ecucation and then you state that there is in fact right and wrong....

Either you teach everything without bias or you teach right and wrong with bias.

The point is not to present one culture above another

Should we not present to OUR children that our culture is better??

You are a typical politician, talking out of both sides of your mouth....

Take a stand on something real, but don't expect me to swallow the BS you post above. 

geigerforhumbleisd --- 13 years ago -

Take a stand on what? Jingoistic indoctrination for the sake of jingoistic indoctrination? You missed my point completely. I stand for freedom from tyranny, no matter what religion, creed, or colors it wears. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Jingoistic indoctrination

Ok so now we seem to be getting a clearer picture of the real Geiger.... Apparently you believe that teaching our kids that America is unique in the world for our freedom and values is "jingoistic".... Good to know...

I suppose in your mind the Founding Fathers were slave holding racists that stole the country from the Native Americans and there is nothing of value that Western civilization has brought into the world. 

funkadelic --- 13 years ago -

I suppose in your mind the Founding Fathers were slave holding racists that stole the country from the Native Americans and there is nothing of value that Western civilization has brought into the world.

2 out of 4 ain't bad. That's all star money in baseball. 

Bellarue --- 13 years ago -

 

Bellarue --- 13 years ago -

 

geigerforhumbleisd --- 13 years ago -

Some of the Founders owned slaves. Many Americans took land under Manifest Destiny. Some Americans were racist. Those are facts. That does not discredit nor slight any contributions they have made to culture, politics, etc. of this country. The Constitution and Bill of Rights are two of the most important documents in history. I believe America is exceptional and is a leader in the world. That does not mean America is exempt from criticism of history or policy. Again, you miss my point. "Indoctrination" can come from either side. We cannot call ourselves a free nation when we attempt to limit a student's sources. 

Bellarue --- 13 years ago -

 

funkadelic --- 13 years ago -

"Indoctrination" can come from either side. We cannot call ourselves a free nation when we attempt to limit a student's sources.

You're going to confuse the Kingwood branch. 

Bellarue --- 13 years ago -

 

funkadelic --- 13 years ago -

"I personally believe that God, Jesus Christ created everything. When teaching science in public school, I never discussed evolution or creation unless a student asked. Then, I stated that I supported creation and generally advised young kids to discuss it with their parents."

JCV

That's scary and NOT science. LOL 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

"Indoctrination" can come from either side. We cannot call ourselves a free nation when we attempt to limit a student's sources.


This is simply your way of telling us multi-culturalism is paramount in your view.

All education is a form of indoctrination. Do we not peform indoctrination when we teach our kids the scientific method?
Some would say that it is better to open your heart and let the Earth Goddess tell you how she works. Should that also be taught in our science classes???

It is not really a debate about indoctrination. It is a debate about what kind of indoctrination.....

It sounds to me Mr. Geiger, that you are not aware of this simple truth. 

geigerforhumbleisd --- 13 years ago -

Ok so now we seem to be getting a clearer picture of the real Geiger

I didn't know I was presenting myself any other way.

It is not really a debate about indoctrination. It is a debate about what kind of indoctrination.....It sounds to me Mr. Geiger, that you are not aware of this simple truth. 

Yes. You want your specific standards in place that aren't based on reason or science. You want standards based on nationalism and religion. As a flag waving American, I support your desire. However, it's not fair to give students a slanted view of history without the opportunity to question or assess it. My argument is not about your standards, but about your application. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

aren't based on reason or science

Is it not reasonable to teach our children to revere and admire the amazing accomplishments of America?

However, it's not fair to give students a slanted view of history

I think you are confusing children with college students.

And you are by no means clear just what exactly you would like to teach our children. Yes I get it, you want to teach critical thinking, and by all means we should encourage it, but I also believe (at the ages we are talking about) we should teach them that some ideas are simply TRUTH.... Leave it to their Progressive college professors to break them of that..... 

marybees --- 13 years ago -

Glen Beck is covering CSCOPE now on his website.Some interesting stuff.Iam weary of any school or program where parents have no real access to the curriculum being taught 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground