Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Are schools too sensitive?

who's talking here?

Polly Ester 3
Perfection 5
Jpgirl 1
FabFive 2
witchywoman 1
MissPris 2
footballlwife 3
Kayry 1
Wicked 1
Elsa 2
abovethetreetop 11

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Question for parents,

Let's say you have a child with a difficult to manage condition or disease. Your child comes home with a short, COMPLETELY anonymous survey to see how if you understood about management and treatment of the disease/condition. The results do not go to the school,(they would not be able to read the results) but a nursing student who will use the information to come up with an pamphlet based on the information to help parents better understand disease and treatment. The schools did not allow the survey. Do you think they were right not to allow it, or would you have appreciated the survey? Thanks for any input. :-) 

witchywoman --- 12 years ago -

0 

Kayry --- 12 years ago -

Anything to assist in enhancing a child's education seems like the right thing to do! 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Thanks Kayry! 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

There are privacy laws regarding the release of medical information. Nothing is ever completely anonymous but the school literally can't afford to open themselves up to the potential for lawsuits. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

In order to do the survey, I was required by law to take a course to make sure that I understood the legalities regarding surveys and protecting the rights and privacy of those surveyed. It would have been 100% annonymous and legitimate. I am a mom and a nursing student. I want to help people, not cause them harm. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

I would be totally offended.

That is a conversation I would have with my child's doctor not with an anonymous note coming from the school. As well intentioned as it is, it seems it was the school saying I wasn't doing a good job. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

By the way, there are already tons of information easily available from doctors and online about managing conditions. 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

Did you want to send this home with high school students? 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

There is lots of info available on the web. The condition involves asthma and it can be difficult to manage. My survey would have gone home with elementary school children. It would have been 100% anonymous to the school as well as myself. The purpose would have been to see where/if any confusion existed. Statistics (and other studies) reflect that there is confusion managing this difficult condition. The purpose of my survey was to gather data and come up with education materials to help parents, not hurt or ridicule them. There were some things I did not know fully understand about the disease or the medications. Many factors are involved with asthma and the many medications used for asthma. Some of us are lucky and have access to adequate healthcare and resources such as the internet. Others do not. My survey would have hopefully reached some of those people. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

Even with good intentions, it is overstepping bounds. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Fabfive,
could you elaborate why you think it is overstepping bounds? Did I mention that the survey is optional? 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

You are talking about a medical condition, therefore there would be a physician involved.

Do you think that perhaps partnering with either a PCP or a pediatric pulmonologist would be a better way to reach these parents and also be during a time they are most apt to be willing to discuss their child's condition? 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

Imagine if you unintentionally gave out misinformation regarding the condition or medicines. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

But like I keep saying, it would be 100% confidential. The survey would go home with child. Parents have option to participate/ or not. The survey asks for no names or any other identifying information. The survey goes into a sealed envelope and I pick it up from the school. Only I read it, I do not know who you are,who your child is.

@perfection, some of these children may not have access to a PCP. Most children do attend school. If parents picked up the survey at the PCP's office, they might be afraid that it is their insurance's way of 'tracking' them. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

abovethetreetop, it seems you are seeking only opinions that support what you want to do and not the opinions that are different.

I agree with the school for not sending it home. If you are wanting to do a study especially an anonymous survey but use the school systems as the mechanism then they have every right and responsibility to protect every student.

You are well intentioned but seriously you need another means to gather your subject data. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

Good for the school for saying no to you. This is not their business.

How are they to be 100% certain how that info will be used? Why should they take time out of their schedule to explain to teachers, pass out surveys, collect them, field phone calls from parents, etc. for something completely out of the educational realm?

If you are not employed by the district and under their jurisdiction, I do not see the benefit for them to cooperate. As it is, there are too many outside issues that schools and educators are being asked to facilitate.

If you want to do something like this then ask Drs to distribute them to patients. That might be more appropriate. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Eveyone has a right to their opinion, and I respect everyone's opinion. All I am trying to do is explain in detail how the survey would have been conducted. I am a parent myself with children in the public school system. The survey was not approved for distribution. I am looking for opinions to see if people think the school was justified for turning it down. There are questions about who/what/why regarding the survey, I am simply explaining what it was and how it would have been conducted, stressing that it would have been confidential since that seems to be the overriding concern. I will also add that many of the schools(right here in kingwood) are now actually hosting health fairs to help children and parents to health services and education related to health topics. Is that out of order too? Not to mention, they have dentist come in to the schools to teach children how to properly brush their teeth and give them a goody bag with supplies. I say no education is wasted and if I as a parent can receive information that will help my child; awesome, I will take it. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

I am looking for opinions to see if people think the school was justified for turning it down.

Ok, then.

Put me in the yes, they were category on this most recent survey of yours. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Hissy fit,

Thank you for your comment. Just to clarify,the school was shown the survey and they knew that it was confidential. Also just for a quick fact, Asthma is the #1 cause of school related absenteeism. It affects the schools, the parents who have to take of work, the kids who miss school work..etc..etc. 

Elsa --- 12 years ago -

I personally would not have filled it out. I have four kids, I just would not have had the time nor the inclination because it really doesn't pertain to me. 

Jpgirl --- 12 years ago -

I agree with Hissy Fit- the school was justified for the denial. You've posted here and at KDC and not many have agreed with your POV. I understand your need to save the world but you are assuming that everybody wants or needs to be saved. As a parent of a Special Needs son ( now adult) who had asthma as a child due to allergies I would've resented anothe piece of paper to fill out from school. It just about took an act of God just to fill out all the paperwork to have the school be able to dispense meds. I am an advocate for his health and min and my dh's. I prefer to do my own research and talk to my own Doc and Not share with a nursing student my family's health info. You seem to be making an assumption that parents are clueless when it comes to their kids' health. The school said no with good reason- let it go- and move on. Find another way to save the world. When a door shuts a window opens 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

I am Not making assumptions that people are ignorant or don't know how to take care of their children. I said that there were things that I myself did not know related to the condition. I could actually throw in some statistics to back my efforts up. I am not looking to save the world, just trying to shed a little light and help if I can. This has all been very helpful and I respect everyone's opinion. Note that I asked "Are they being to sensitive" I did not come on here and rant..nor am I attacking anyone.I asked a question and elaborated on what it was that I attempted to do and addressed concerns. However, it is efforts like these and many others that helps shed light on situations for the betterment/benefit of people who can use it. I am not assuming everyone wants to or needs to be saved.
I hear you in regard to the paperwork, there is a mountain. I actually do respect and now fully understand the schools decision and their reasons. 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

abovethetreetop. I am assuming this was your research class for nursing school. If so, I would have gladly filled it out. It would have only taken a minute or two to support you in getting your degree in nursing. I once was a nursing student and did a similar study. Fortunately, I lived in a University town where the University and the grade schools worked together so that all could benefit by each others existence. It worked well and everyone was always willing to help. Good luck. I hope you can get someone to partake in your survey. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

If this is a survey for your degree, why don't you post on different community forums asking for parents of asthmatic children if they would participate and take the school out of it entirely?

As far as the schools singling out asthmatic children to receive your survey that in itself would be problematic. In doing so they are identifying children and even though the contents would be sealed, trust me, kids open things and other kids question why someone is getting some kind of document that they aren't.

I am sure your intentions are sincere, but you don't seem to understand the issues schools face regarding privacy of students and the delicacy of medical and special needs in particular. I am a student also but from the educational side, so I completely understand the school's POV. 

footballlwife --- 12 years ago -

Schools have more important things to do and something like that is too personal. Medical surveys don't belong in your kids take home folder.

Maybe try a Redi-clinic or call around for research opportunities.

Personally, as a teacher myself, we've got enough on our plates throughout the day already. I understand the need to complete your research, I just think local schools are not an appropriate mean to do so. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Thanks Wicked for the support. It is neither here or there, because the survey won't go out.

Footballwife,
I have a question then. There was an annual health fair conducted at a local school for parents and children. It was after school and there was education regarding health topics, immunizations, etc...How do you feel about that?

IMO; health and the ability to learn go hand in hand. Also, I get all kinds of "stuff" in my kids homework folder that isn't related to school. It is neverending...but they aren't in school forever is my 'comforting thought." 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Survey Monkey and ask nicely on all the local message boards and through various other social media sites. 

abovethetreetop --- 12 years ago -

Thanks for the tip about surveymonkey MissPris. I am not going to be conducting my survey due to time constraints. I will definitely keep that in mind for future projects. 

footballlwife --- 12 years ago -

I think an after school fair would be a good venue for that. I believe there is actually a community health for or low cost immunization clinic coming up.

Survey Monkey is a great tool as well. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

have a question then. There was an annual health fair conducted at a local school for parents and children. It was after school and there was education regarding health topics, immunizations, etc...How do you feel about that?


Heath fairs are put on by healthcare professionals and do not single out any particular child.

Texas Childrens does a lot of research in pediatric asthma - have you approached them about an opportunity? Also by zip code, the Pasadena area has the highest concentration of kids with asthma - have you checked the clinics there to see if they would be interested?

Maybe work with the Harris Clinics and host a meeting/class in the clinic on asthma education, the clinic may welcome more help in helping the families. 

footballlwife --- 12 years ago -

Just a silly aside, children aren't even supposed to hand out birthday invitations in class anymore. And not that it's an issue of schools being "too sensitive" rather, in my opinion, society being "too sensitive"...and it's just another way to curb distractions.

Again, that is just in my personal opinion. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground