Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Nathaniel Ctr. Rabbi Mort & Messianic Judaism

who's talking here?

Red Heifer 1
JimBecka 2
AMDG 2
Zapper009 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JimBecka --- 10 years ago -

I had lunch the other day with Rabbi Mort and he said some interesting things about the Messianic Jewish movement.

Though large numbers of Jews are accepting Jesus (Now between 15-20 congregations in Jerusalem alone), some non-Jews involved in the movement are going the other way (Renouncing Jesus and embracing mainstream Judaism).

Interview With Rabbi Mort 

JimBecka --- 10 years ago -

I appreciate the comments and emails about the video. I felt it would be appropriate to respond to them.

1) Christians and Jews do not mix.
Explanation: Actually, Jews and Christians worshipped together until the end of the Fourth Century when the Roman Catholic Church issued an order that Christians worshipping with Jews would be punished. Also, Jesus and the Apostle Paul never advocated breaking from Judaism. In fact, Paul reaffirmed his Jewish faith at the end of his life.

2) The Old Testament Does Not Apply Today.
Explanation: The New Testament is based on the Old Testament. The Sermon On The Mount (Matthew) was based on the five books of Moses. Also, the old Testament (Tanakh) is misunderstood when segments are take out of context (I.E., Orthodox Jews today say that Deuteronomy 14:21 tells them that mixing meat and cheese is not kosher. But, the Scripture is really encouraging Jews to avoid a pagan ritual common at that time. At the time the scripture was written, all Jews were familiar with the pagan practice).

3) Jews Killed Jesus.
Explanation: A group (or sect) of Jews did kill Jesus. But, few religious Jews would have taken part in the crucifixion. By Jewish Law, it was an illegal act. Also, Jesus was extremely popular with religious Jews. Remember, Jews wrote the Bible, consisted of his first followers, and gathered around in masses.

4) We are no longer under the law.
Explanation: Though we are saved by grace, Biblical Laws show us how we should live. Some Baptist feel that making a profession of faith without leading a fruitful life is acceptable.

5) Judaism today is much different than Second Temple Period Judaism.
Explanation: There are similarities between modern Judaism and Second Temple Period Judaism. In the Second Temple Period the Pharisees believed in the Oral Law and the Sadducees did not. In modern time Orthodox Jews believe in the Oral Law (which became the Talmud) and Messianic Jews and Karaite Jews do not. 

Red Heifer --- 10 years ago -

First of all, I wonder about those "15-20" Messianic congregations in Jerusalem. Sounds high.

Second, to be clear, the views of Messianic Jews is way outside even the most liberal strains of organized Judaism. No Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, Reconstructionist or other organized Jewish communities, all of whom represent virtually all of the Jewish community, accept the divinity of Jesus or the New Testament. Mind you, I am not rejecting anyone's right to believe what they want and worship the way they want. What I do want to make clear is that Messianic Judaism is not widely accepted, as the poster implies. Interesting issues, though, and I congratulate Jim and Messianic Jews on their faith, as I do most everyone. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

1) Christians and Jews do not mix.
Explanation: Actually, Jews and Christians worshipped together until the end of the Fourth Century when the Roman Catholic Church issued an order that Christians worshipping with Jews would be punished. Also, Jesus and the Apostle Paul never advocated breaking from Judaism. In fact, Paul reaffirmed his Jewish faith at the end of his life.


Jim - not sure I am buying this.

First part is the Catholic Church did not make any such rule, the Romans did after Constantine's conversion. Blaming the Catholic Church for this change in Roman law, would be like blaming the Jews, for the preceding 300 years when it was punishable by death to be Christian, yet lawful under Roman law to practice Judaism.

I am also not sure how welcome Christians were in Jewish worship for the 300 or so years leading up to Constantine. A prevailing Jewish view of Jesus was he was a blasphemer - and He was working with Satan. 

Zapper009 --- 10 years ago -

RU just trying to stir up hate???

What's ur point???? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

What's ur point????

that for me Zapper ??? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground