Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Child's Behavior

who's talking here?

Just Kim 2
blessed 3
whatchamacallit 1
stampin' gal 1
MomofTwins 2
Scottie's Hottie 3
Danabug(BCM) 2
likeke27 3
kjones0125 1
Ann72 3
jemezchick 1
thekat 1
mykidsmom 7
Deltadawn 1
Cicero 1
Victoria 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Child's Behavior

I recently spent the afternoon with my dh's extented family whom for the most part do not have to work while having kids, but prefer to. Their youngsters are raised by nannies or daycare centers. Most of the kids I couldn't wait to leave because they were obnosious, physical, and or bratty. We are fortunate to be in a position where I can be home. We're far from riches... We get by with coupons and discount stores. I was so thankfull for the compliments given of "How is your son so behaved?" I couldn't tell you how tempted I was to say, because he doesn't have everything handed to him on a gold platter. Is a child's behavior effected if brought up in a surrounding where both parents are working?

Yes Vote
 
 69.0% (29)
No Vote
 
 31.0% (13)
Ann72 --- 19 years ago -

I recently spent the afternoon with my dh's extented family whom for the most part do not have to work while having kids, but prefer to. Their youngsters are raised by nannies or daycare centers. Most of the kids I couldn't wait to leave because they were obnosious, physical, and or bratty. We are fortunate to be in a position where I can be home. We're far from riches... We get by with coupons and discount stores. I was so thankfull for the compliments given of "How is your son so behaved?" I couldn't tell you how tempted I was to say, because he doesn't have everything handed to him on a gold platter. Is a child's behavior effected if brought up in a surrounding where both parents are working?  

Just Kim --- 19 years ago -

No, I don't agree. My children are very well behaved and me and my husband both work. I think it is what the parents teach them also. If they are giving everything on a silver platter then I they are probably going to act bratty. I think a child's behavior is effected if they aren't taught manors, morals, beliefs and just all around how to act in public. Not because both parents work. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

physical, what is wrong with having physical kids 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Yes. Nobody can raise your kids like you can. 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

No matter what anyone says, a child WILL be affected if they are away from their parents most of the day. I don't understand how a person can think that spending time with their child 4 hours a day and then some on the weekends could possibly be all they want to give to them. I was rasied in a home where both parents worked. I never lacked for anything financially. What I did learn is that I can give my children so much more that has nothing to do with any $$$$. I know that for many families this may not be a choice. I know in my heart that if something were to happen to my husband, I would eventually have to go to work. However, I know this is where I am called to be. Motherhood is a mission field where there is a LOT of work to be done before they leave the home. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

Blessed not everyone is in a position to stay home. 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

Blessed not everyone is in a position to stay home. bcm, I already stated that. YOu might want to read all of it. :-) 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

My kids might be better behaved if I didn't stay home! LMBO! Seriously when I worked I only had one child and she was always such an angel. That didn't change until 7th grade!! My 3 year old is just a little pistol!! I think so much of a child's behavior depends on the child's personality. Some children are just more high strung than others. 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

Oh shut up Amy J! YOu are a great mom! 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

I did read all of it thanks, but you still make it sound as if you think people who work are short changing there kids. I think each person has to do what is right for them! 

stampin' gal --- 19 years ago -

well, I know and have met LOTS of SAHM's and many of them have children that I would prefer my kids keep far, far away from (lol). I don't think it necessarily has to do with working moms vs. SAHM's. It is so much more complicated than that, IMO. 

Just Kim --- 19 years ago -

blessed - so if a 5 year old spends 8 hrs a day at school in Kindergarten then the school is raising them? No, they are teaching him and I am raising him. I just don't agree with ya on that one. I do agree that a child has a lot to learn before they leave the house but being a school or daycare doesn't make them anyless. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

Oh shut up Amy J! YOu are a great mom! LOL, thank you but some days this one really test me! He just cracks me up though!! He is all the entertainment I need! 

thekat --- 19 years ago -

Even if I could I wouldn't want to stay at home with my kid all day. I love them but one of us would be dead by the end of the day. That being said...I have no choice but to work, my ex has been un-employed for 8mths. My children have been in daycare since DS was 3 and DD was 6wks, it killed me to do that to them but I had NO CHOICE. I do more with my kids when I am with them than I think I would if I stayed home with them all day. I try to make up for the fact that I am not home when they get in from school. Blessed...I know that you may not have meant it that way but I did take offense to that. I'd like to know, honestly, how much time all the SAHM's spend on the computer when they could be doing things with the kids. I'm not trying to be ugly but I see a lot of the same people on here everyday all day long. What are your kids doing? When I get home from work my life is about my kids. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I think a child's behavior is effected if they aren't taught manors, morals, beliefs and just all around how to act in public. Not because both parents work. I agree. I have always worked and my kids are well behaved. They are older now. As young adults it is evident that they were taught to be respectful. I know a few kids with SAHM's and they are horrid, I want to strangle this one kid, rude, foul mouthed, etc. It has everything to do with what parents teach them. 

Deltadawn --- 19 years ago -

There is a real difference between both having to work, and if one only works by choice. The real difference in what you saw at the family gathering is how the children are being raised. Nanny or daycare, the child needs to learn consequences for poor behavior and how to have concern and respect for others. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I'd like to know, honestly, how much time all the SAHM's spend on the computer when they could be doing things with the kids. I'm not trying to be ugly but I see a lot of the same people on here everyday all day long. What are your kids doing? I spend way to much time on the computer. But although it may appear i am always here, i am not really. I have loaded and unloaded the dishwasher, washed and folded 4 loads of clothes, made 4 beds, changed about 5 diapers, fed 3 bottles, made breakfast, lunch, paid bills, colored with my 3 year old, showered (LOL, it counts), and am about to start getting dinner ready. All of this since I got up at 7 am this morning :) 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

I didn't vote, nor did I read anyone's response, but here is mine... DH and I both work and our kids to to a Montessori School. I could stay home, but I choose not to. My kids are loved at school and are getting a great education and are having fun at the same time, probably more than what I could provide at home... My kids are also well behaved because DH and I demand it. Bad behavior is learned, and yes kids who go to day care, do and will learn bad behavior, but parents can still parent without behing SAHM's or SAHD's. Also, gold platter, or not, discipline is something that should be taught whether the parents are rich or poor and is something that is taught in our home... I am glad you are a SAHM and your kids are well behaved, but the same can be said for kids whose parents both work. JMO. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

Deltadawn - I think I said the same thing, but differently. Well said. 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

Well said, Blessed. I do understand that there are people that can't stay home with their kids. In a society like ours, where everyone seems to have larger homes, multiple cars, tvs, children's activities, it takes a lot to raise a family these days. I don't know why anyone would choose to have someone else raise their kids if they didn't have to. What does that say to the child? 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

What does that say to the child? Kids don't think this way, only grownups. 

Ann72 --- 19 years ago -

don't know why anyone would choose to have someone else raise their kids if they didn't have to. What does that say to the child? Well said. That is what I have been thinking too. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

Kids don't think this way, only grownups. i disagree. my six year old son points things out to us. like how his grandma doesn't spend time with him just only his counsin. you would be amazed at what they do know!! 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

likeke27 - that is different... 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

you would be amazed at what they do know!! My kids amaze me every day!!! 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

sorry i reread and see my mistake. please forgive me. haha 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

Kids don't think this way, only grownups. Not true. My 5 year old twins say how sad it is when we pick up their friends from school whose parents work. They are sad that the kids don't get to hug their mommy after a long time at school. They also can't understand why our neighbors have a nanny and the kids' mom can't be home: "Why doesn't their mommy want to stay home with the kids?" Kids see it all. Not to make anyone feel guilty, but this is true. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

lol, thanks. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

momoftwins - I am sorry, but I don't think this is a thought that children develop on their own (without help or without hearing it from an adult). It's just like children in 3rd world country's who have no idea that they are poor or have no education at all... Most are happy just being kids... 

kjones0125 --- 19 years ago -

I voted "no" because although some might say there is a correlation, I don't believe it. I've volunteered in my son's school and I've seen kids of both SAHMs and working moms have discipline problems. Kids misbehave to push buttons and test their limits. It's how the parents respond to the child's behavior that makes the difference. It's not the quantity of time you spend with your kid, it's the quality of time. The Chronicle published an article about this recently and I can't find it on their web site; however, here's a link to same story from msnbc.com web site. daycare and behavioral problems? 

Ann72 --- 19 years ago -

They also can't understand why our neighbors have a nanny and the kids' mom can't be home: "Why doesn't their mommy want to stay home with the kids?" I know what you're talking about. My kid sees it within his class too. I have been teaching him that not everyone can stay at home. There are different family situations. 

Victoria --- 19 years ago -

I do believe what is taught at home matters....Me and my husband work and are trying to teach my son discipline. I have a different case my mother takes care of my kids and sometimes spoiles them too much....we try to leave her home as soon as we get out of work because if my son does something bad in our presence and she is there he hides behind her and I really don't want my son to be the bad kid that does not know how to act. 

whatchamacallit --- 19 years ago -

OK, you guys this subject is close to me in many ways. I am a stay at home Mom, I homeschool and I care for other peoples children in order to be able to stay home. I love being home with mine, love being with other peoples children and have to have my income. This is what I have found. Children act badly when they feel they are not first in their parents lives. I know the relationship between parents is important too, but children need to know that they are most important to the parents as a unit. It doesn't matter if you are married or divorced the kids need to know that what you do is for them too and that they are a very high priority. Not with money but with QUALITY TIME and attention. Children can feel this way whether they are school all day, or homeschooled, or cared for by a Nanny, or in Daycare. It is more dependent on the priorities the parents have than on where the child spends their day. If a child is not being given proper attention at home by the ones that are supposed to love him AND is in a daycare/school situation where strangers are taking care of them all day there will be problems. With some (NOT ALL) child care providers and teachers there is no emotional investment,it is just a job. Kids can feel that. They are subjected to that everyday and come home to parents that are worn out from the days events and can't or don't care to give them what they need and want. It is hard on everyone. If I were to go to work out of the home we would be much better off financially than with me doing child care. It is just not worth it to me. So I drive an old car and dress in less than designer clothes and scrape by trying to make ends meet each month. It is not for everyone and very hard to do, but I do it because I think it is right for us. I see children all the time that are very well behaved in all the situations you guys have noted and I see others that are not. It is the relationship with the parents and what the parents teach them that really matters most. As a care giver I can help with this type situation, a little, but not fix it completly. It is up to the parents. There are no suitable substitutes. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground