Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

OK, here is the scenerio........(sp?)

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
Lilteapot 1
RRay 9
QueenCassie 1
Fancy 1
Texas Girl 1
mikesgal 1
©Hanson♥ 2
Ann72 1
steinhoister 3
Darrell 1
mdawg 1
amb07 1
MonzaRacer 1
AuthorMan 1
browneyes 1
ladybeachbum 2
Rachel 2
Queen Aeval 1
Katie D. 1
Brennan 1
get_the_lead_out! 2
MoJo 1
~harpo~ 1
Fin and Feather 3
WiennieLover 1
Zoli 3
~sassy~ 4
clever 2
~Songbird~ 1
Shana 1
Campbellskid :^) 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Please tell me what YOU would do..... A thunderboomer of short duration, and harsh winds blows thru kingwood last week. YOUR big ol sweetgum tree falls into YOUR neighbors back yard, and flattens the fence, damages the shrubs, (luckily missing the garage and the home.) and literally fills his backyard with a tree. What do you feel is an appropriate response....... Thanks for answering.....looking forward to this one.  

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

Figure out a way to sue 'em... 

WiennieLover --- 18 years ago -

YOU should clear away the tree and then fix the fence and maybe the shrub. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

YOU should clear away the tree and then fix the fence and maybe the shrub. Insurance would cover that, wouldn't it? 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Figure out a way to sue 'em... NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO thats not the right thing to do..... ;) 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

If I am not mistaken it is an act of God so they can't sue you... I think I would buy pizza and cokes and have a tree cutting party! 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

I would feel it was my responsibility to clean up the mess, then pay to fix my neighbor's fence (would actuallly make hubby get out there and do it himself,lol!)> Buy them a new shrub if needed. 

Queen Aeval --- 18 years ago -

Well... I would go speak to the neighbor, clean up the mess, and repair/replace the fence. Then I would reevaluate my trees, and see if more needed to go to avoid the same thing again. I don't know what I would do about his shrubs. It takes a while for things to grow. 

©Hanson♥ --- 18 years ago -

I'd pay to have the tree removed and the fence repaired or rebuilt...but that's just me. Now, I have a neighbor that doesn't think that way....:-( 

~harpo~ --- 18 years ago -

I would feel it was my responsibility to clean up the mess, then pay to fix my neighbor's fence (would actuallly make hubby get out there and do it himself,lol!)> Buy them a new shrub if needed. Ditto 

MoJo --- 18 years ago -

same here I would feel it was my responsibility to clean up the mess, then pay to fix my neighbor's fence (would actuallly make hubby get out there and do it himself,lol!)> Buy them a new shrub if needed. Is this your tree or did your neighbors fall on you? 

Brennan --- 18 years ago -

I think I would buy pizza and cokes and have a tree cutting party! i like rachels idea. was the fence in good shape? if it needed repairs then i would say split the cost. 

mikesgal --- 18 years ago -

I would have the tree and debris removed and repair the fence. 

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

If I am not mistaken it is an act of God so they can't sue you... You can sue anyone for anything... Once I tried to hang myself and the rope broke, I sued the rope company and got a huge settlement...got a bunch of new rope too... 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

My neighbors tree fell in my yard. She is an older lady, no man. (wealthy widow type) I went over to her home, offered to pay half of the fence, and her the other half.... and repair it myself.......and her comment to me......incredibly....was "Well its NOT MY fence" I just about fell over myself.. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

hahaha Once I tried to hang myself and the rope broke, I sued the rope company and got a huge settlement...got a bunch of new rope too... 

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

lol 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

Well its NOT MY fence" Wow.... 

clever --- 18 years ago -

That's a nice neighbor you have there Ray.. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

I can guarantee you if one of my trees fell in the neighbors yard I would fix it immediately//// Matter of fact, if my neighbor had someone ELSE'S tree fall in their yard, I would be over right away to help them fix it.... I am not sure how I am going to handle this one. I went and bought enough lumber to replace the entire fence anyway....I dont want to make an insurance claim. 

ladybeachbum --- 18 years ago -

I always thought that the owner of the tree was responsible for all damages and your insurance would pay. The insurance couldn't go against you because it was an act of God. If she says it isn't her fence, then insurance wouldn't pay for it, I bet. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

CLever.......maybe its just cuz she is old.....and alone....I dunno. 

Zoli --- 18 years ago -

Ok so if my neighbors huge tree fell across my roof and smashed it in, who is responsible for the repairs? My ins. co. or theirs? I would have thought theirs. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

I've heard of this kind of thing leaning two ways. If the tree "looked" healthy and storm winds actually blew it over, then I believe it's considered an act of God and the neighbor can not sue. If on the other hand, the tree looked to be in poor health and you just never got 'round to tending to, or removing it, then I believe legally you are liable for any damages. Good thing it only hit the fence. IMO, fences should be split between neighbors. Good luck! 

ladybeachbum --- 18 years ago -

Totally went back to read again..it was the neighbor's tree. She should pay! I would probably be helping her but those old lady's won't turn loose of their money! You are a great neighbor, Ray. 

Zoli --- 18 years ago -

btw, first thing we did when we moved into our home was to make sure all threatening trees were cut. 

©Hanson♥ --- 18 years ago -

Ray....You sure you're not living behind my neighbor....ugggg 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Zoli the only damage really that was done.......was a fence, and a few shrubs......400-500 hundred with me fixing everything.........I will try and get her to pay half, which I think is more than fair, this fence was not new, prob....20 years old and in decent shape for its age. no one was hurt, dogs n birds are OK. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

fences should be split between neighbors. Good luck! That is what I thought the neighborly thing would be...You both share the fence so why not the cost if anything happens to it? 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

I would feel it was my responsibility to clean up the mess, then pay to fix my neighbor's fence Ditto. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

That is what I thought the neighborly thing would be...You both share the fence so why not the cost if anything happens to it? Absolutely right Clever. Ray I hope the neighbor doesn't try & stick you with a new fence when the right thing to do is slpit the cost of the fence to begin with, since you both benefit from it. Keep us posted. Do you consider it to be an act of God, meaning, was the tree otherwise healthy in appearance? 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

The tree was rotten to the core. I grabbed a center section of it and still have it......it crumbles in your hand if you put pressure. It did however have a full head of hair.....(leaves) 

MonzaRacer --- 18 years ago -

Cut the tree up and throw it back in her yard, then tear down the bad part of the fence and throw it in her yard. Put up your new section. When she comes over to complain, just tell her it was her tree and now her fence, cause you just gave it to her as a gift... 

Zoli --- 18 years ago -

Your being very nice about it, not sure I would be so nice, but with an elderly neighbor I would let it go I guess. I am just curious to know, if it landed on your roof and your roof smashed in who would be responsible? Maybe worth a call to the home owners. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

It did however have a full head of hair.....( If the tree "looked" healthy to the naked eye, you should not be responsible. I just googled the tree question and the first response I got was that my neighbor is responsible for HIS shed under an act of God situation. Because you're neigbors, splitting the cost should be the fair thing to do but it would be unfair of the neighbor to stick you with everything. Not saying that's what they're going to do - I just hope they're fair people. 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

I’ve found some neighbors are more likely to help out as long as they are not able to determine a fault in the situation and this being your tree she might feel like it is your problem as well. Don’t feel bad you did the right thing by asking. Just remember when she asks about the shrub, let he know it is not your shrub. 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

Save me the 2-4 inch logs for the bbq pit, it should blend well with the talla (sp?) we cut yesterday. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

this being your tree she might feel like it is your problem as well. but it's not his tree 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

she should be, at the very least, splitting the cost 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

Sorry ray. Miss one post and ya have it all wrong.. she should be, at the very least, splitting the cost agree, and once again Ray is different from others. lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground