Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Autistic woman doesn't trust McCain

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
whatchamacallit 1
JDB2 9
smartypants 19
steinhoister 1
CommonSense 2
Perfection 1
onestepforward 1
keepinitreal09 4
zapper007 1
Party Boy!! 3
*maryc 2
Hardshell_ 2
ohmygoodness 5
whoaisme 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

I am autistic, and I don't trust John McCain to help me by MarianLibrarian Wed Oct 15, 2008 at 11:14:14 PM PDT In the debate tonight, McCain used people with autism as an example of people with special needs that he and Palin will help. I have autism, and I can't trust him to help me when he can't even get the facts about the disorder right. He said autism is on the rise. There is no clear evidence that autism is on the rise. It's diagnoses that are increasing. Why? Because we now understand more about it than we used to, due to research. People who would have been considered anything from "eccentric" to "retarded" as little as ten years ago are now being diagnosed as autistic. Obama promised funding for research. McCain did not. Seeing McCain use my disorder as a desperate ploy to draw votes made me feel somehow slimed. Throughout my childhood, my teachers and other kids called me weird and eccentric, either stupid or "a genius but with no common sense," stubborn, preachy, too needy, too insistent on following rules, over-emotional or emotionally distant, obsessive over one subject, said that I talk too much or not enough, and generally didn't like me. I didn't understand why at the time. All I knew was that there seemed to be some sort of secret code that everyone else lived by, a set of rules that everyone else magically knew except me. I didn't learn until I was twenty-seven that I have Asperger's Syndrome, a form of high-functioning autism. I recovered tremendously in the last five years, but getting a diagnosis was the most important step to figuring out why I behave the way I do, that it's not my fault, that I'm not alone, and what to do about it. It's not necessarily people with Asperger's that are in the most need of help. Sure, we could use some. What we need most is understanding and patience. If you've ever made fun of people who go to Star Trek conventions, for example, there's a good chance you were making fun of someone with AS and didn't know it. Napoleon Dynamite is another example of a caricature of someone with AS. Know anyone like that? Our biggest challenge (besides trying to say Asperger's without sounding like we're saying "ass-burgers") is getting people to accept us. We also need people to stop walking up to us and demanding we smile, or saying things like "you look like you're having a good time" or "it can't be that bad." What makes people think they have the right to do this to someone they don't know? (OK, I'm done with the mini-rant. Sorry about that.) For people with more severe forms of autism, and parents of children with these disorders, a lot of help is needed. Some need help learning to integrate into social situations, and education for parents. Some need constant supervision. Some need help with every single aspect of their lives, like eating and going to the bathroom. The divorce rate for parents of children with autism is shockingly high, and too often, the mothers end up having to care for autistic children alone, as well as providing for the family. They need help. Programs to help them need funding. John McCain's record on this issue, and for that matter Sarah Palin's before she had a child with Down's Syndrome (not a form of autism, John McCain) is not good. Does autism need a cure? If there were no autistic people in the world, there may never have been a Leonardo Da Vinci, a Mozart, an Isaac Newton, a Thomas Jefferson, or an Albert Einstein, all of whom many experts suspect could have been autistic. We can't know for sure, but it seems likely to me. "Curing" people whose brains work differently could cost us something valuable. What do autistic people and the parents of autistic kids need? Education. Programs to help with care. Research into how autism works, what the causes are and how we can recover and learn to function socially (and sometimes physically) without losing our special abilities. We need to understand why most treatments work for some but not for all. These things need FUNDING. When Obama pointed out the need for funding and research, McCain said nothing. What is he going to do to help people on the autistic spectrum, besides talk about us in a desperate grab for votes?  

Hardshell_ --- 18 years ago -

ok, ok....now calm down.....and give me a little hug... 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

by MarianLibrarian Very funny... 

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

by MarianLibrarian Is that Joe Plumber's cousin? 

Hardshell_ --- 18 years ago -

Is that Joe Plumber's cousin? nah....Marian is from the DailyKos... 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

What do autistic people and the parents of autistic kids need? Education. Programs to help with care. Research into how autism works, what the causes are and how we can recover and learn to function socially (and sometimes physically) without losing our special abilities. We need to understand why most treatments work for some but not for all. These things need FUNDING McCain wants a spending freeze. If you have a child with special needs, you better live in a rich district where they can afford to provide early intervention, because studies have shown that the earlier these children get treatment, the better chance they have of reaching their potential. But McCain won't do that. It is extremely short sighted. Then when these children are grown, they often cannot function so they depend on programs like medicaid for their health care. McCain also wants to cut that. 

*maryc --- 18 years ago -

Spending freeze is a grand idea! We don't need to throw another dime at anything. We need to address how we are throwing away money now and fix it. 

ohmygoodness --- 18 years ago -

Amen to that! 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

We need to address how we are throwing away money now and fix it. It wasn't a Democrat that lied to us so we could throw away money in Iraq. If you supported the war, you supported spending $720 million dollars a day. I know, helping disabled kids and adults who are American citizens is "wasteful". 

ohmygoodness --- 18 years ago -

I'm sorry but my husband was in Iraq and saw first hand that we were not throwing away money there. Most of the people he encountered there were very thankful that we were there helping them. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

Most of the people he encountered there were very thankful that we were there helping them. And disabled children, adults, and their families are just ungrateful! 

ohmygoodness --- 18 years ago -

huh? 

ohmygoodness --- 18 years ago -

 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

If you supported the war, you supported spending $720 million dollars a day. click here to learn more 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

I'm sorry but my husband was in Iraq and saw first hand that we were not throwing away money there. Most of the people he encountered there were very thankful that we were there helping them. You stated we are not throwing away money in Iraq because the people were thankful for the help. You are implying that by spending on programs for the disabled, it is wasteful because they are not thankful. That is your logic, not mine. 

ohmygoodness --- 18 years ago -

so we could throw away money in Iraq. I was responding to this comment. I don't feel that saving lives and protecting a nation is a waste of money. I'm sorry you feel differently but I don't really think Iraq is the debate on this thread. And disabled children, adults, and their families are just ungrateful! I'm confused, did SM mean this as a question instead of a statement? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

*maryc --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment Spending freeze is a grand idea! We don't need to throw another dime at anything. We need to address how we are throwing away money now and fix it. ohmygoodness --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment Amen to that! You agreed with maryc about a spending freeze after I posted this: What do autistic people and the parents of autistic kids need? Education. Programs to help with care. Research into how autism works, what the causes are and how we can recover and learn to function socially (and sometimes physically) without losing our special abilities. We need to understand why most treatments work for some but not for all. These things need FUNDING. My saying that funding for the disabled is wasteful because they are not thankful enough was sarcasm. 

whoaisme --- 18 years ago -

New ID so don't ask. In the last debate when McCain was talking about a spending freeze he wasn't talking about Autism. If you listened towards the end he talked about helping to find a reason for Autism. I don't care for either candidate but when you post things that aren't true you lose credibility. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

If you listened towards the end he talked about helping to find a reason for Autism. How is this consistant with a spending freeze? 

*maryc --- 18 years ago -

Hatchet first, scapel 2nd. It's really simple, but if you want to turn it around, you've got to freeze first! 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Spending freeze is a grand idea! We don't need to throw another dime at anything. Saying that right after a well though out point is made on why it's a bad idea makes you look dumb. Seriously. McCain wants to stay in Iraq. That war is not only costing us billions a month but American lives and our national security. 

Party Boy!! --- 18 years ago -

McCain wants to stay in Iraq To get the job done! If we concede defeat and up and leave, al-qaeda would take control of the entire region..is that what you want? 

Party Boy!! --- 18 years ago -

Saying that right after a well though out point is made on why it's a bad idea makes you look dumb. Seriously Dont bully people into not having their own opinions commonsense... 

Party Boy!! --- 18 years ago -

We need to address how we are throwing away money now and fix it. reform is the answer!! throwing money at the problem never works! 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

f you listened towards the end he talked about helping to find a reason for Autism. How is this consistant with a spending freeze? I'm still waiting for an answer. Anyone? 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

How about using charitable donations...Money from the Govt will not solve every problem...If I remember correctly there are no omish people with Autism...Might of been a rumor I heard though..Not to sure right now...Take care... 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

To get the job done! If we concede defeat and up and leave, al-qaeda would take control of the entire region..is that what you want? Were they there before? Dont bully people into not having their own opinions commonsense... They never answered the question, I'm not bullying anyone, just saying when you have an unfounded, indefensible opinion and you post it contradicting a valid one you look like a fool. I'm still waiting for an answer. Anyone? Take a seat, it'll be a while. 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

you supported spending $720 million dollars a day. I know, helping disabled kids and adults who are A Let's see what happens when we "throw away" that kind of money on education. Imagine, every teacher can have an aide. Every academic department can have it's own assistant to make phone calls, copy pages and record grades. Then there really might be no child left behind. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

McCain wants a spending freeze. ok, gumped down version for you...a freeze means no increases. It means that you stop increasing spending until you evaluate the budget. just saying when you have an unfounded, indefensible opinion and you post it contradicting a valid one you look like a fool. read the answers...and, please realize that you are making your self look like a....you said it, not me! If you supported the war, you supported spending $720 million dollars a day. I know, helping disabled kids and adults who are American citizens is "wasteful". do you think the foreigners that hate us so much are going to help our disabled kids and adults? Security first or the rest ceases to exist! I'm still waiting for an answer. Anyone? 1) in addition to the definition of a freeze, consider the fact that we all have our own causes. Do you believe obama is going to throw money at each so we are all happy? 2) McCain may very well increase spending on programs to help those in need, we don't yet know. We do know that Palin is an interested influence. 3) Private parties and charitable sources currently fund and/or donate to many research products. Additionally, if the income caps were removed, many more individuals would contribute....another step further, if there were a profit motivation for corporations, they would find more cures...unfortunately, your party taxes to the extent and regulates to the extent that there is no reason for researchers to sink all of their resources into finding a cure for some of these things....and, what percentage of the people in this country have these ailments? I have a very close relative with cerebral palsy. Should all of our tax dollars go to support my cause, or since there are finite resources, should we prioritize? 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

YAWNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN Amazing. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

Let's see what happens when we "throw away" that kind of money on education. Maybe we will. I still have hope. I have NO confidence that McCain will increase spending on educational programs. He and GOP are constantly harping that such "radical" ideas are part of big government, and a waste. Private parties and charitable sources are great, but they don't insure proper funding for public school special education programs. I think American schools should be way up there on the priority list. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

I have a very close relative with cerebral palsy. Should all of our tax dollars go to support my cause, Not all. I never said all tax dollars should go to this cause. This individual would probably be served through the federally mandated programs which have never been fully funded. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Not all. I never said all tax dollars should go to this cause. This individual would probably be served through the federally mandated programs which have never been fully funded. you missed the point. Somebody has to prioritize. Freezing the increases starts the process of taking a look at what is over and what is under funded. You guys chose to argue over autism. It is a function of government spending. If you keep complaining and our response is to keep on spending, then our country goes bankrupt...like many individuals and like many other government programs...such as medicare and social security. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

If you keep complaining and our response is to keep on spending, then our country goes bankrupt... The most significant cause of our current multi trillion dollar budget deficit was a lack of income to support war expenditures. Bush asked for and got a tax cut during a rash war. DUMB! During WW2, taxes on the extremely wealthy went up 90%. Had that money gone to education, who do you think would be complaining? Our great great great grandchildren, because it would take decades to spend that much on school programs? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

The most significant cause of our current multi trillion dollar budget deficit was a lack of income to support war expenditures. really? study the budget much? btw, what is the value of an education if everyone gets the same education? Everybody then does the same thing...if we are going to use extremes, lets use them right. I cannot for the life of me understand who you think you are to tell someone that they have a cap on their income...this coming from the free choice side of the fence...don't tell me what to do with a womans body, but I'll tell you that you are only allowed to make what I tell you you are allowed to make...and btw, when people stop initiating new businesses and creating new jobs because you have taken away the profit motivation, what do you suppose is gonna happen? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

really? study the budget much? Your condescension is showing. Take it out if you want to debate. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

ok, gumped down version for you and here as well. 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Security first or the rest ceases to exist! Hey JDB...Hope Biz is good...Hate to burst the bubble but one can not defense 100% against a tactic such as terrorism... We can try all we want, and say the measures we have taken have worked...But one forgets terrorism can be spread by anyone... Take for instance the D.C Snipers, those were acts of terroism... Virginia Tech...Terroism Our own Govt tells us another strike is inevitable... The war on Terrorism, and Drugs is a farce and a bottom less money pit... Some have argued that our recent financial woes are examples of financial terrorism...I believe it was Cramer who made the comparison... I do back you on your financial views though... 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

but one can not defense 100% against a tactic such as terrorism... true my friend, but should we not do our very best? Our founding principles recognize our right and structure our government to maintain a defense. We'll never stop it all and it will be back internally or from abroad. However, if we cancel our defense spending and deploy that into education, our education will be in Russian or Chinese.... btw, Cramer sells news. The financial mess rests at the feet of many, many folks and entities. No doubt about that. However, it hasn't impacted me. Not that it won't, and not that there aren't innocent victims, but I would argue that most don't do everything they can to prevent what you call financial terror. From a financial perspective, you would be surprised who causes what problems. If everyone, and I mean everyone, did their best, the effect would be a trickle up....We don't want to recognize the elephant in the room, but we must at some point, acknowledge that we will be accountable whether we choose to be or not. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I know, helping disabled kids and adults who are American citizens is "wasteful". And disabled children, adults, and their families are just ungrateful! such "radical" ideas Your condescension is showing. Take it out if you want to debate. back atcha... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground