Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Canadian healthcare?

who's talking here?

Fallon 1
randyjet 4
sunshine1881 6
planemom 3
maverick 1
Challenger 4
AuthorMan 2
Going off air 1
Mabbers 3
justforfun 10
~sassy~ 41
ExLady In Blue 6
CoralReef 2
Perfection 40
Unichic™ 12
Possum 1
Agent of Change 1
anti-antichange 1
clockwatcher. 7
Mark 1
JohnLynch 1
NewNanna 1
evolved 8
james osterberg 1
Darwin 1
JeffSpicoli 1
*momof5* 25
allday 14

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

KINGSTON, Ontario (CNN) -- For Shona Holmes, simple pleasures such as playing with her dog or walking in her plush garden are a gift. Canadian Shona Holmes, who had a brain tumor, sought medical care in the United States. 1 of 3 After suffering from crushing headaches and vision problems, she was diagnosed with a brain tumor four years ago. She was told if it wasn't removed, she could go blind or even die. "They said to me that you had a brain tumor and it was pressing on your optic chasm and that it needed to come out immediately," Holmes said. Holmes is Canadian, but the "they" she refers to are doctors at the Mayo Clinic in the United States, where she turned after specialists in her own government-run health care system would not see her fast enough. "My family doctor at that time tried to get me in to see an endocrinologist and a neurologist," Holmes recalled. "It was going to be four months for one specialist and six months for the other." Watch Holmes talk about her experience in getting treatment » Even with the warning from U.S. doctors in hand, Holmes said she still couldn't get in to see Canadian specialists. Because the government system is the only health care option for Canadians, she says she had no choice but to have the surgery in the U.S. Her treatment at the Mayo Clinic in Arizona cost $100,000, and she and her husband put a second mortgage on their home and borrowed from family and friends to pay for it. When she recounts that part of her painful story, she weeps. "That's the stuff that I find so tragic -- having dinner with my friends and I know how much money I owe them," Holmes says, tears streaming down her face. With the health care reform debate raging in the U.S., Republicans in Washington are seizing on Holmes' story and other accounts from Canada to warn against government involvement in the health care system. The Senate's top Republican, Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, asserted several times on the Senate floor last month that a government-run health insurance option, which President Obama and Democrats want, could lead to a government-controlled health care system like Canada's. Watch McConnell talk about Canada's health care system McConnell singled out Kingston General Hospital in Ontario as a prime example of what Americans should be fearful of: staggering delays in treatment. CNN went to Kingston General and played a DVD for its chief of staff Dr. David Zelt of McConnell slamming the hospital. Zelt insists McConnell's numbers -- an average of 340 days wait time for knee replacements, 196 days for hip replacements -- are an exaggeration. "I find it very frustrating that someone of that stature would not really have true knowledge of the numbers he is actually quoting on things," Zelt told us, saying the average wait time for a knee replacement is actually 109 days, and a hip replacement is 91 days. However, Zelt does concede that in Canada's system, where every Canadian citizen is covered, there are limited resources, shortages and often delays. "In our health care system, we're looking at what we have to do to prioritize patients -- critically ill versus purely elective surgeries," Zelt said. "I'm not going to say we don't have issues with timeliness for some things. It does happen. But again take the other side of the coin -- these patients have access. They're on somebody's waiting list if they have a problem, and I think the senator would need to look at that issue. Yes it may take time, but they will get seen." McConnell's remarks have not only ruffled feathers with Ontario's doctors but also with government officials across the border. Canadian Sen. Hugh Segal, whom we met up with at Kingston's picturesque waterfront, says his "fellow conservatives" to the south are dead wrong about Canada's health care system. "The notion that we have some bureaucrat standing next to every doctor between the patient and that doctor is a complete creation, there is no truth to that at all," Segal said. Watch Canadian senator challenge McConnell's assertions » "What you have is a longer life span, better outcomes and about one-third less costs. That's what you have." What Segal, Zelt and other Canadian officials underscore is that their government-run system is driven by the value of the care and that the quantity of tests and procedures don't necessarily equal quality. "You can have a patient from the hospital with abdominal pain as an example, and you can run him through every high-tech equipment, CT scan, MRIs -- it's unlimited," Zelt said. "But then you have to take a step back and look at that. What's the cost of doing those types of investigations, and what's the value really added to the patient?" Despite Shona Holmes' horror story about her inability to get timely treatment for a brain tumor, Canadian officials and doctors insist most life-threatening cases are treated quickly. Toronto's Doug Wright can attest to that. The 40-year-old father of three young boys found out last month he has cancer -- a tumor on his leg. But he says he never had to wait more than five days to see a specialist or get a test. And from diagnosis to surgery, it will be just over a month. "The community medical system thought this process could not have been any better. I have not had to wait to see some of the best specialists in the country, who are renowned internationally," Wright said. Watch Wright talk about his treatment » An investment adviser, Wright has the money to go to the U.S. for his care, but says there is no need. But Wright recognizes one reason he has gotten such a rapid response from Canadian doctors is because he has cancer. "The bad news is I didn't have to wait for anything, because you don't have to wait when it's a serious issue," he said. Still, people can wait for months, or even years, for elective surgery. Wright's friend Rick Hession has a heart condition that could cause a stroke, but he has a three-month wait or more for an operation to help correct it. He says he can't exercise the way he would like to until he gets the surgery, but he's willing to wait. He calls it a small price to pay for free health coverage for all Canadians. "I'm OK with it, and I think most people I talk to find they really are [willing to wait]," says Hession. Watch Hession talk about waiting for treatment » The reality is that despite GOP rhetoric to the contrary, no Democratic plan now on the table calls for a Canadian-like government run health care system. But in talking to doctors, government officials and even average Canadians, they concede their system is far from perfect, but there is one statistic they are quite proud of: All Canadians have health coverage. That's 33 million people, compared with the 47 million uninsured in the U.S.  

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

First of all, the town of Kingston is about the size of maybe Hunstville, TX (roughly) and that far out. It is not very close to the big city: TORONTO. You would probably have similar red tape and longer wait times if you say lived out in Huntsville. That's a pretty darn good comparison as to where Kingston is in relation to the metropolitan Toronto area, but you can keep posting your stuff to show how dreadful the healthcare is in Canada. What do I know lol. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Hey, this isn't me writing this, it is CNN who is saying it. So are you implying that only those who live in the cities should have access to care? Wow, that's pretty rough. 

Going off air --- 17 years ago -

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm 

Darwin --- 17 years ago -

The reality is that despite GOP rhetoric to the contrary, no Democratic plan now on the table calls for a Canadian-like government run health care system. Miss that, anyone? NO Democratic plan. But, while were on this topic, let's hear some KUers their horror stories about our current US system. Who goes first...... 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

So are you implying that only those who live in the cities should have access to care? Wow, that's pretty rough. No what she is saying is that you will have the SAME problem in the US with small towns too. Not only that, you will ONLY get treated at ALL IF you have insurance. Here in Montgomery County you WILL DIE since the county has NO indigent health care. It maxes out at $30,000 after you sell off everything you own and you have to be approved by the county government. The wait times are pretty good there in Canada compared to the US. My knee surgery was only one month quicker here in Kingwood than Canada. That was for orthroscopic surgery which is FAR less involved than replacement. Plus if I had no insurance, I would NEVER HAVE been TREATED. It was even rougher when my wife had cancer and was told she would just have to die when she lived in the Valley. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

she was diagnosed with a brain tumor four years ago. You should notice it says a brain tumor, NOT BRAIN CANCER! There is a BIG difference. You can wait a fairly long time for that before it becomes critical. In short, there was NO medical reason or justification for rushing into the operation. DO you see how conservatives LIE about things? They don't tell the truth, and then they leave out vital details. Sen. McConnel flat out lied and didn't know what he was talking about too. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

randyjet, if you were in the military, why are you not covered by the VA? My fil, was not in the military longer than 4 years, yet he has VA medical coverage. It will not help your wife, but you should be covered. I am saying this because you may not be aware, my fil was not for years. But since he is getting VA his med. costs have dropped to nothing, compared to what he was paying. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

why are you not covered by the VA? I am eligible for VA care, but I have to pay FULL regular hospital rates which are astronomical. Only if I am indigent do I get free health care. I am also lucky since the VA has stopped taking in veterans from recent years who have no service connected conditions. I did use the VA when I was unemployed, but they wanted to charge me full rates because my previous years earnings were high. I told them I had NO job at the time, and they dropped that issue since I was getting unemployment from the state and could PROVE I was not working. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I love our healthcare. When I didn't have insurance I was able to find clinics that treated me. With insurance I am able to get any diagnostic test I request. With our healthcare, my mom was able to get all the care she needed to help her extend her life by decades after having 14 heart attacks while in the hospital back in the early 80s. With our healthcare I see miracles every day - babies being born, seniors being given a far better quality of life than in any country, our sick receiving world class care. Yes, I would love to talk about OUR healthcare and celebrate how wonderful we have it!!!!! Thanks for the reminder to appreciate how blessed we are to live in America. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

So are you implying that only those who live in the cities should have access to care? Wow, that's pretty rough. But, while were on this topic, let's hear some KUers their horror stories about our current US system. Who goes first...... I'll go. My mom lives in a small town in Southern Utah. She has many health issues and needs to see an endocrinologist. Guess what? they don't have one there. In order to see one, she would need to travel 6 hours to SLC or 3 hours out of state to Las Vegas, NV. The only doctor that will see patients with diabetes or thyroid issues, charges people at a minimum of $300 up front and makes them file their own insurance claims because he "doesn't want to be bothered with it." She's an American citizen, she works, and she has insurance. She still cannot get decent care because of her location. Thanks for the reminder to appreciate how blessed we are to live in America. yeah, my Mom's loving it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

momof5, your mom is free to move to a city if she chooses. Another blessing about being in America, you have freedom of choice. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

momof5, your mom is free to move to a city if she chooses. Another blessing about being in America, you have freedom of choice. lamest argument ever. Yes, because most people can just up and move when they develop health problems. No worries about their jobs, their homes, their responsibilities where they currently live. Good for you that you have no children or responsibilities, that's not the case for everyone. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

momof5 - who ever said I have no kids and no responsibilities? Wasn't me. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I just wonder when these legislative idiots are going to stop shopping and take a look at the financial situation they are putting us in. And, don't give me that 'Bush did it' crap. O is bankrupting us, not Bush. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

momof5 - who ever said I have no kids and no responsibilities? Wasn't me. so you have children? I know you have a step daughter that visits with you and her other mothers, you've told us that. Aren't you the one that says people should "live within their means" and have "personal accountability"? Guess what? That's exactly what my Mother is doing. She lives where she can afford to live and care for my special needs sister. She cannot afford to move and the closer you get to a big city that offers good health care, the more expensive it gets. So, she lives within her means, and still cannot get good healthcare. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

AuthorMan they are not ever going to stop spending our money. it is what they do. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

*momof5* --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment momof5 - who ever said I have no kids and no responsibilities? Wasn't me. As I said, it wasn't me that said that. I have made hard choices all my life and have done things that others find too scary to do. I do them because I want a better life and will do whatever necessary to get it. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I have made hard choices all my life and have done things that others find too scary to do. I do them because I want a better life and will do whatever necessary to get it. which is exactly what my Mom does in order to care for herself and a special needs child. it's sad that she has to sacrifice medical care in order to do that. Our system is SEVERELY flawed. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

Tell us somthing that is germain to what we are looking at in this country. Geezzz,with info like this ,you should work for the heritage foundation. NO one except you is still talking about Gov't run universal health care. Move along,nothing to see here. 

Possum --- 17 years ago -

95% of Canadians say they wouldn't trade their healthcare system for ours. Canadians pay an Average 35% tax and they get a Decent Health Care System for ALL; we pay 32% in taxes and get zip. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

it's sad that she has to sacrifice medical care in order to do that. Our system is SEVERELY flawed. I don't see it as a flawed system. The Constitution does not guarantee me healthcare everywhere in the country. that is not possible. I do have freedoms to choose. I can choose to live in a major city with access to healthcare and the downsides that come with that, or I can choose to live further out which is less expensive but have to consider the access to healthcare issue. There is no way to have everything. We can't get 100% of what we want. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

we pay 32% in taxes and get zip. Oh be we get lots of things...... the Murtha International Airport that serves Rep Murtha in his travels. We get Rep Pelosi commandeering a US Jet anytime she wants. We get Rep Sheila Jackson Lee speaking at Michael Jackson's memorial. We get water rights trampled to save a marsh mouse or something. We get loads for our money - just nothing of any value. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

95% of Canadians say they wouldn't trade their healthcare system for ours. Canadians pay an Average 35% tax and they get a Decent Health Care System for ALL; we pay 32% in taxes and get zip. Healthcare in this country is equated to a privilege. Why we have that mindset is beyond me. You would think, healthier citizens are more productive citizens, it's a win win. We spend money on plenty of things in this country that would be better spent on good healthcare for everyone. Instead, we have insurance companies running the show, the poorest of the poor qualifies for free or reduced healthcare, the richest of the rich can do whatever the hell they want, cause they can afford it. The middle is comprised of folks with insurance that pay high premiums and may or may not get care depending on what the insurance company deems "needed", and then there are millions of working folks with NO insurance at all and they don't qualify for any type of assisted program. Yeah, our system isn't flawed at all. 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

your mom is free to move to a city if she chooses. Another blessing about being in America, you have freedom of choice. That's about the dumbest statement ever. So, a person with a job, insurance, etc. who lives in a rural area and doesn't have access to the doctors she needs should just move closer to the doctor? What about her job, home, family? She should quit her job -- which probably provides her insurance, look for a new job -- which will likely have a waiting period before she qualifies for insurance, and hope like hell the new insurance doesn't classify her current health problems as pre-existing conditions and refuse to cover her? Wow, great solution and a great current system of healthcare!! 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

babies being born, seniors being given a far better quality of life than in any country, our sick receiving world class care. Patently false!! Our healthcare is among the worst in develped nations for infant mortality, childhood and adult obesity, senior mortality, list goes on and on. We do pay on average about $9,000 per year per person for that below standard care which is among the highest of developed nations. Nice try!! 

allday --- 17 years ago -

It's just a GOP politician doing what GOP politicians do. That is scaring the shit out of undereducated, racist, sexist, bible fearing zealots! I didn't say that was ALL repub'S but it's enough for them to keep losing for a long time. I used to be Republican until the Bible took over real issues. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

SunShine1881 --- 23 min ago - quote - flag comment your mom is free to move to a city if she chooses. Another blessing about being in America, you have freedom of choice. That's about the dumbest statement ever. So, a person with a job, insurance, etc. who lives in a rural area and doesn't have access to the doctors she needs should just move closer to the doctor? What about her job, home, family? She should quit her job -- which probably provides her insurance, look for a new job -- which will likely have a waiting period before she qualifies for insurance, and hope like hell the new insurance doesn't classify her current health problems as pre-existing conditions and refuse to cover her? Wow, great solution and a great current system of healthcare!! Now SunShine1881, that isn't legal. If you move from one group plan to another group plan there is no waiting period and no pre-existing condition clause. It isn't perfect but it isn't as horrible as you all try to make it out to be. Look, that is just your mantra of the day. Admit it, you are just repeating what you are told. Look around, read some reports from the AMA, the State HHSC reports, the Federal HHSC reports and learn something. Do your own fact checking and don't be swayed by what you are seeing portrayed in the media. If you are so easily led........... I feel sorry for you. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

evolved --- 15 min ago - quote - flag comment babies being born, seniors being given a far better quality of life than in any country, our sick receiving world class care. Patently false!! Our healthcare is among the worst in develped nations for infant mortality, childhood and adult obesity, senior mortality, list goes on and on. We do pay on average about $9,000 per year per person for that below standard care which is among the highest of developed nations. Nice try!! evolved, childhood obesity is not caused by the healthcare system, it is caused by parents who would rather sit their kids in front of a tv or video game instead of taking them for a walk. Giving them sugary sweets instead of water. Yes we have higher infant mortality, but ours is also reported. Many countries do not report theirs. Again, many of these are also caused by actions that we as people take ourselves. We cannot expect healthcare and medicine to allow us to be 100% perfect. We have to do our part. We have to exercise We have to eat right We have to take vitamins Let's see - most of us don't do those three things so we then expect healthcare to fix us. Look, we have to take some responsibility. My mom smoked during her pregnancy, so now I have issues because of it. That is not anybodys fault but hers - it wasn't healthcare's fault. We have pregnant women who think it is ok to drink, do drugs, smoke while pregnant - and they have babies who need lifelong care. And the parents now are screaming for better insurance coverage - HELLO, where were they when they themselves created this mess? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I am glad this Canadian woman felt like this was the best place to get treatment for her tumor. Too bad some of us don't feel that way about our own country. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Look around, read some reports from the AMA, the State HHSC reports, the Federal HHSC reports and learn something. Do your own fact checking and don't be swayed by what you are seeing portrayed in the media. If you are so easily led........... I feel sorry for you. chunky, what is it you do for a living? I'm pretty sure it's something to do with insurance processing at one of the medical centers downtown. Please, correct me if I'm wrong. As far as being "easily led". There is no "propaganda" when it comes to my personal experience, or that of my friends and family when dealing with insurance companies, doctors and for some, lack of insurance altogether. Nice try though. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

chunky, what is it you do for a living? I'm pretty sure it's something to do with insurance processing at one of the medical centers downtown. Please, correct me if I'm wrong. Close but no cigar. I do not do insurance processing. I work for a living just like many of you. I live paycheck to paycheck. I tithe 10-15%. I save 10-15% of my check. I give my time to causes that I support. I go to school full time as well and I have a family. All in all I am like most of you. I try to be well informed on issues and spend a lot of time looking beyond the surface. To me, that is my role as an adult, to be a questioner, to be a leader and to be informed. 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

Many countries do not report theirs. Funny, then why can't we best the ones that do report?? Noone is saying that soem people don't get fabulous healthcare and that we don't have the best physicians and medicine. I get great healthcare myself. Problem is about 50 million people don't in this country. For me that's a moral dilemna you'd think it would be for the fake-ass Christians too. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Funny, then why can't we best the ones that do report?? Noone is saying that soem people don't get fabulous healthcare and that we don't have the best physicians and medicine. I get great healthcare myself. Problem is about 50 million people don't in this country. For me that's a moral dilemna you'd think it would be for the fake-ass Christians too. Wow, so you bring religion in to a political discussion. You see, this is about politics not religion. I can separate them, can you? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

evolved --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment Many countries do not report theirs. Funny, then why can't we best the ones that do report?? As for this - let's look at the lifestyles in those countries. Less fast food. More natural foods. More exercise. More taking care of the human body. Perhaps again, the argument remains - it is up to each one of us to care for our own body first and not rely on the government to fix it once we destroy it. 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

You brought Biden into a Sarah Palin discussion...I'm not cryin'!! 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

If you move from one group plan to another group plan there is no waiting period and no pre-existing condition clause. If you change jobs there is often a waiting period, commonly 90 days before you qualify for insurance through your new company. Yes, there are options, COBRA or self-pay, but both are very expensive. There are also exclusions for pre-existing conditions: Under HIPAA, a plan is allowed to look back only 6 months for a condition that was present before the start of coverage in a group health plan. Specifically, the law says that a preexisting condition exclusion can be imposed on a condition only if medical advice, diagnosis, care, or treatment was recommended or received during the 6 months prior to your enrollment date in the plan. As an example, you may have had arthritis for many years before you came to your current job. If you did not have medical advice, diagnosis, care, or treatment – recommended or received – in the 6 months before you enrolled in the plan, then the prior condition cannot be subject to a preexisting condition exclusion. If you did receive medical advice, diagnosis, care, or treatment within the past 6 months, then the plan may impose a preexisting condition exclusion for that condition (arthritis). In addition, HIPAA prohibits plans from applying a preexisting condition exclusion to pregnancy, genetic information, and certain children. If you have a preexisting condition that can be excluded from your plan coverage, then there is a limit to the preexisting condition exclusion period that can be applied. HIPAA limits the preexisting condition exclusion period for most people to 12 months (18 months if you enroll late), although some plans may have a shorter time period or none at all. In addition, some people with a history of prior health coverage will be able to reduce the exclusion period even further using “creditable coverage.” Remember, a preexisting condition exclusion relates only to benefits for your (and your family’s) preexisting conditions. If you enroll, you will receive coverage for the plan’s other benefits during that time. That being said, if I live in a rural area and am diagnoised with something that no local doctor can treat, and I take your "move-closer-to-the-doctor approach" if I'm lucky enough to get a new job immediately, I may have to wait three months before my new employer's insurance plan will cover me. Then, they can say it was a pre-exisiting condition since I was diagnosed in the past 6 months, and refuse to cover me for another year. That is 15 months, potentially, without treatment in the fabulous system we have now.  

evolved --- 17 years ago -

Perhaps again, the argument remains - it is up to each one of us to care for our own body first and not rely on the government to fix it once we destroy it. Perhaps not..you are off topic again. The topic is healthcare. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

As for this - let's look at the lifestyles in those countries. Less fast food. More natural foods. More exercise. More taking care of the human body. Perhaps again, the argument remains - it is up to each one of us to care for our own body first and not rely on the government to fix it once we destroy it. so, you're saying that thyroid issues are something we can somehow prevent through diet and exercise? How about cancer? How about high cholesterol that cannot be changed through diet and exercise? Some things are just genetic. So based on your logic, if you don't win the genetic lottery, too bad so sad, thinning the herd if you don't have money or insurance. mmmm k. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

evolved --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment Perhaps again, the argument remains - it is up to each one of us to care for our own body first and not rely on the government to fix it once we destroy it. Perhaps not..you are off topic again. The topic is healthcare. Yes it is evolved. Healthcare means - taking care of one's health - and that means changing how we live and taking better care of ourselves so we do not need the government to fix us once we are broken. That would solve the problems of the many, then we could focus on the issues of those who truly need help. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground