Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why can't we get specifics on the healthcare proposal?

who's talking here?

Fallon 3
planemom 1
AuthorMan 1
Going off air 1
R.E.B. 3
~sassy~ 11
rEVOLution 8
Perfection 2
brian* 2
Wilstar77 2
Agent of Change 1
anti-antichange 2
Mark 3
mommie21g1b 1
Wynter 2
james osterberg 3
JeffSpicoli 2
Zombie Slayer! 1
Missus Cravitz 16

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

President Obama said it would be transparent, said it would not add 1 dime to the debt yet we cannot get any specifics. For a plan that is because of a crisis, yet will take 4-5 years to implement something smells fishy to me.  

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

You can read the full text of the bill here: http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h3200/show 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

For a plan that is because of a crisis, yet will take 4-5 years to implement something smells fishy to me. I don't think you heard him right. It was announced that the president's plan would be made public next week. Once the bill passes both houses and the President signs it, it will take affect. The Public Option, which is just part of the bill, is what he said will take about 4 years to implement to "get it right". In the mean time they'll try other things to cover people, like what McCain proposed during the election for example. 

brian* --- 17 years ago -

For a plan that is because of a crisis, yet will take 4-5 years to implement something smells fishy to me. Me too. Not enough specifics yet and way too much pooh-poohing of critics. I don't care about the political rhetoric. Let me see it as it is written, and I'll be able to better decide if I think it's a good bill or not. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 17 years ago -

There are six different bill proposals. I do not think they have one single bill yet. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

THen why the OMG HURRY HURRY SIGN THE BILL! OMG WE HAVE TO SIGN THE BILL! bs? Get one proposal, let the public read it, and let the public tell their congress/senate reps what they think. Without being called racists, nazis, brownshirts, etc. I wont be holding my breath. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

The opencongress.org http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h3200/show allows you to track the bill and changes as they get made..it also has recent pro and no article links at the bottom. It would make more sense to form study groups, and read chapters of the bill, then to read all the stuff flying around. It's like siding with Roger or Ebert before seeing the movie yourself. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

There are six different bill proposals. I do not think they have one single bill yet. It's all here: http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h3200/show Go to the top right hand corner of the page and click on the title: OFFICIAL BILL TEXT comment on about 1036 pages. You can also sign up to log on and view the comments people are making on the actual text, or make your own. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

hmm, so we need 6 bills? Riiiigggghhhhtttt. Is this so we will get bored, or tired of reading, or actually have no chance to ever understand 6 bills, and we can all shut up and let the government do what they want? 2010 is coming, and we will see how many go back to DC if they sign this. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Why can't we get specifics on the healthcare proposal? This is done by design. If you can't understand it, it's far easier to just accept it than to try to understand it all. We need a book, Health Care reform for Dummies. But it too would be over a thousand pages. They have been working on these documents for decades and have finally gotten to a place where they could run with it. So don't be fooled by this whole play with words games and smoke and mirrors they are using to get this passed. They know exactly what they are doing. Cap and Trade is next. Stay tuned, January 2010. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

or actually have no chance to ever understand 6 bills, Hit it right on the head with that swing. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

This is done by design. If you can't understand it, it's far easier to just accept it than to try to understand it all. HAS ANYONE READ THE OFFICIAL TEXT? THAT WOULD BE WHAT THE PRESIDENT REFERRED TO IN HIS SPEECH. IT'S AVAILABLE. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

Fallon what was the month of August all about? AS for the author of this thread, you are well aware of the progress made thus far and what needs to be completed by next Tuesday. This thing has been talked to death,but it is not going to die due to anymore delays. Sorry,but the stalling tactics are a thing of the past and the GOP is no longer much concern to the Dems. The train is pulling out. You know this yet you are looking to get people to react to recycled concerns.As far as the timing,it's just another stalling tactic,quite a childish question I might add. We will have some type of major reform in The Presidents first year and anyone within driving distance is of no concern, at all,to the Dems.I suggest you move on to the next agenda item. I have great faith that you will be opposed to it as well. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Like I said from the get go, the Dems are in charge, let them say the he!! with all of us, and pass the bill and stfu already. Why not, they won right? I mean why do they care that even the majority of the Dems are against this? 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

This is to James Osterberg...  

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

What I can't figure out is this: if the public not for profit option will take FOUR YEARS to implement, but the private insurers will be required to cover anyone regardless of health status immediately and no longer be allowed to have a lifetime maximum, what is that going to do to premium prices for the next four years? They are going to skyrocket, resulting in outrageous medical expenses for us all. I pay more per month for a 6 million maximum, but most policies that are employer based only have 1 or 2 million maximums. I believe this plan is going to cost us all immediately. The insurance companies aren't going to eat into their profits for our benefit. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

HAS ANYONE READ THE OFFICIAL TEXT? Many congressmen and women have read it, or had their assistants read it for them, who are well versed in the language used in these documents. I will never understand why they let lawyers right these things up in their special language that only they speak. Everyone that reads it gets a completely different interpretation of what they are reading. Then you throw on the fact that there are six different versions of it and you begin to realize that there is a shell game being played here. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

it is not going to die due to anymore delays. That's the sad reality of this is that they are going to use the "I won, deal with it" tactics and just make this thing happen. O has already threatened congress not to get in his way of this and yet all we can talk about is some yahoo screaming out the truth. While inappropriate timing it was far less harmful than the President threatening our congress in front of the entire country. 

JeffSpicoli --- 17 years ago -

hmm, so we need 6 bills? Riiiigggghhhhtttt. Only the House version has passed thus far. Senate bill is still in the works. I explained the legislative process to you yesterday. There are different Senate committees working on it, each with their own areas of emphasis. Each committee's version will then go to a conference committee for final reconciliation. The both the House and Senate bills will be reconciled and both houses will vote on a final version. 

JeffSpicoli --- 17 years ago -

The train is pulling out. As dogs bark in the night. 

brian* --- 17 years ago -

Cap and Trade is next. Stay tuned, January 2010. Very bad idea. Very bad. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

hmm, so we need 6 bills? Riiiigggghhhhtttt. Only the House version has passed thus far. Senate bill is still in the works. I explained the legislative process to you yesterday. There are different Senate committees working on it, each with their own areas of emphasis. Each committee's version will then go to a conference committee for final reconciliation. The both the House and Senate bills will be reconciled and both houses will vote on a final version. All that legal talk still does not explain why each area of government has six different versions or variations of health care reform. In my opinion, this means we have only seen the tip of this health care reform, there are other versions out there that our congress has not even read yet. If I'm wrong I apologize but that's the way I'm seeing it. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

Then you throw on the fact that there are six different versions of it and you begin to realize that there is a shell game being played here. All that legal talk still does not explain why each area of government has six different versions or variations of health care reform. The versions are being created by the committees. It's part of the process not a shell game. I think that's how everyone "gets a say" and a chance to address the topic from differing committee viewpoints. I explained the legislative process to you yesterday. There are different Senate committees working on it, each with their own areas of emphasis. Each committee's version will then go to a conference committee for final reconciliation. ahah. I think you have uncovered the confusion. We all need to go back and review the legislative process.... 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

When O said illegals would not be covered under health care reform, he neglected to tell us that only three weeks prior, his party voted down a bill requiring the lawful ability to confirm one's legal status. If you have no right to check into ones legal then anyone who applies is entitled to health care - illegal or otherwise. And even if this were NOT the case, no one in their mind could possible believe illegals would ever be refused health care if they showed up at a hospital in need of care. Obama can not be trusted! 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

legislative process.... To the great masses on here,this will never happen,it's pitiful. It's much easier to grab headlines from one's favorite news source.Don't need to make it in depth,so just watch CNN. don't need to know how anything really works?,we got your FOX! Fabricated Bullet Points. This is the foundation of our political knowledge. It's a waste to go through life Uninformed,bigoted and lazy. We all have grave concerns for or children on every subject,maybe we should teach them to pay attention and not make the same mistakes as their parents have. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

And even if this were NOT the case, It isn't,this will always happen . Then and now,we pay either way. It' your misimformation,tell it however you want. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Those were cute videos, I actually learned something new today. But I still do not understand why there are several different versions of health care floating around Washington. When I say versions I don't mean "copies" I mean different wording all together. Maybe I misunderstood when I heard a congressman complaining about this but that was my take on it. That there are not one, not two, but six (I think was the number) of these bills floating around. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

He better have a detailed plan on where the money will come from before he gets us into this huge government monster. Just saying, we'll get the money from the Medicare waste, or we'll get it from somewhere, don't worry about it, is not good enough. The thing is, even if he took all of Medicare's funding and put it towards Obamacare, it wouldn't be enough. Every large government program I have ever seen has gone way over budget. We are talking 5, 6 even 10 times over the proposed budget. I don't trust his estaments on it costing a trillion over the next ten years. It is going to cost way more than that. There are so many unknown factors invoved (Like exactly how many people are going to be dependent on Obamacare) that a realistic cost can not be made. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

But I still do not understand why there are several different versions of health care floating around Washington. When I say versions I don't mean "copies" I mean different wording all together. Here's my understanding: Each committee reworks it, and reports back, so it will look different. Then once they've all reported the changes get reconciled into one bill and voted on. This came from yahoo answers, and I have no idea is this is a reputable source. So scholars, intervene. ************************************ The different versions are all online at the Library of Congress, US Senate, and House of Representatives websites. They're a bit hard to navigate, so I'll post the links below: Here's the text of the bill as introduced in the House: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c1… It was referred to the Ways and Means committee. Here's the official report of what they did to it: http://waysandmeans.house.gov/legis.asp?… It was also referred to the House Education and Labor committee. Here's the official report of what they did to it: http://edlabor.house.gov/markups/labor/h… It was also referred to the Energy and Commerce committee, Oversight and Government Reform committee and the Budget committee. They have not reported their official versions back yet, but you can read the latest versions and see all the amendments and who voted for and against them on the websites for the various committees: http://www.house.gov/house/CommitteeWWW.… The Senate has been slower so far and do not have a main version with a bill number introduced. However, the Health Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee recently approved a draft of an unnumbered bill named "Affordable Health Choices Act" http://help.senate.gov/BAI09A84_xml.pdf More details on the Senate version will probably have to wait until they return from the August recess, as the Senate Republicans held up Obama's timetable to have something presentable before the Senators return to their States in August. If you're not familiar with the details of the process, the Senate will introduce a version and refer it to a bunch of committees who will then report back. At the same time, the remaining House committees will report back. Each house will reconcile their own bills and vote on them. Once both houses have passed a version of the bill, a committee to reconcile both versions will convene and create a single bill. Both houses then have to vote again so they can pass the same bill for the President to sign. The long process leaves a LOT of room for various problems, negotiations, compromises, chances to try to ram things through and sneak them in, etc. For more information, see both the original "how a bill becomes a law" school house rock and also the Simpson's spoof version. Both are surprisingly accurate to the actual process. Notice that the links I gave you are not really in printable format with page numbers. Those are places that are useful for looking around and digesting the bill. If you want the straight read through of the 1017 page official bill as initially introduced in the House (before the markups by the various committees), here's the link: http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/… Note that given the number of words per page, this is really the equivalent of about 600 pages in a book. Still pretty long though, especially in such dense language. When people read it, they generally make heavy use of the table of contents and use their staff to help digest it and point out important parts to them. Too often, important sections go unread, unfortunately. Source(s): Updated information on congressional actions can be found here: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?… * 4 weeks ago 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

He better have a detailed plan on where the money will come from before he gets us into this huge government monster. He stated in his address that a lot of the money would come from our current insurance providers and drug companies. Which is all fine and dandy except I did not hear any mention of preventing these companies from raising our rates to prevent you or I from ending up being the ones who pay for this just like we do with Uninsured Motorist insurance. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

It' your misimformation,tell That's why Wilson shouted you lie...cuz he knew the administration would not be asking for legal status confirmation. If this is true, Obama is trying to pull a fast one and I hope to hell it comes back to bite him in the Azz. But again, regardless, Illegals will continue to receive health care. Those here and all those yet to come - because unless they are required to verify legal status, no way to say they won't be covered. You continue to believe the shyster and I'll continue to disbelieve. I can live with that just fine. :) 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

President Obama said it would be transparent, said it would not add 1 dime to the debt yet we cannot get any specifics. For a plan that is because of a crisis, yet will take 4-5 years to implement something smells fishy to me. I know you are just stirring that old post full of w itch's brew again but I will respond. You can't get specifics when there is not a lone bill with all the final specifics out there. Timeframe is reasonable considering the magnitude of the issue. He better have a detailed plan on where the money will come from before he gets us into this huge government monster. It would have bode you well to actually listen to the man speak the other night. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

It would have bode you well to actually listen to the man speak the other night. I did. He spent 50 minutes blowing smoke at us. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

He stated in his address that a lot of the money would come from our current insurance providers and drug companies. Which is all fine and dandy except I did not hear any mention of preventing these companies from raising our rates to prevent you or I from ending up being the ones who pay for this just like we do with Uninsured Motorist insurance. True. I think this falls under the details to be worked out...which is why all the committees are going in and editing. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I did. He spent 50 minutes blowing smoke at us. And one lone man had the balls to call this man on his lies. Has another president been as disliked as O? Not that I've seen 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

For a plan that is because of a crisis, yet will take 4-5 years to implement something smells fishy to me. This statement was made because that was what the President was selling that particular week on getting this plan sold to the public. That it had to be done before flu season hits or some other crisis. Knowing all to well that even if passed by the end of this year it would take years to fully implement. 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

I listened to the whole 50 minutes. Doesn't sound like it from your post here. 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

You can't get specifics when there is not a lone bill with all the final specifics out there Very true. The speech referred to the bill that is still out being looked at by committees. That is the legislative process. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground