Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Gastric Sleeve Vs Lap Band ? Have you had either procedure?

who's talking here?

checkingitout 12
haleyj134 5
Amy 1
Polly Ester 2
Perfection 14
HARP 1
jtcitrus 2
tinman 7
RedMulch 1
YoMomma 2
LoveMyDoggies 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Sinister 1
TinktheSprite 1
nicnic 3
Lets Be Fair 4
RockstarSuperNova 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

Considering the sleeve; however, I would REALLY like to hear from others that have experienced this procedure.

Thank you in advance for your time. 

RockstarSuperNova --- 13 years ago -

A friend of mine works for a doctor that performs these surgeries, and she says the sleeve is the way to go. Just be sure to check your doctor out really well beforehand. There are some quacks in that field. 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

can you recommend the doctor she is employed by? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I had the DS (duodenal switch) which is the sleeve plus an additional malabsorptive component.

A lot of which procedure is best for you is based upon a few factors such as how much you need to lose, your age, your comorbidities, your adherence to schedules and your desire to change.

There are 4 basic procedures each different with different risks and rewards.

1. lapband - least invasive, least long term success

2. gastric bypass - some long term success, has side effects of dumping which are very unpleasant. People receiving this can undermine themselves and learn to overeat again and often will regain weight or have another procedure. You have to watch vitamins with this procedure as you tend to dump more than you retain. Common vitamin deficiencies in B, A, D, K, E

3. Gastric sleeve - typically provides about 18-24 months of weight loss before sleeve starts to expand and you can regain weight unless you have learned to go low carb and low calorie. Since the sleeve is only restrictive once you stretch out the sleeve you can regain. The sleeve doesn't have a lot of negatives with nutrition other than with the calorie reduction you will need to supplement to ensure you get enough. Typically sleeve patients stay on less than 1000 calories for the rest of their lives to maintain.

4. DS - this is the most invasive and most risky of the procedures. It involves a sleeve then a basic rerouting of the intestinal track at the duodenum so it reduces the intestines to just a few centimeters. What happens is like with the sleeve you are on food intake restriction in quantity (about 4-6 ounces at a time) then it bypasses the parts of the intestines where most of the calories and nutrition are absorbed (the malabsorptive part).

Risks with this surgery - HUGE. Lots of vitamin deficencies unless you supplement a lot every day. Protein requirements are huge, about 200 grams a day (normal is 60). Very low carb is required as the only part of the intestine retained is the part that absorbs carbs (do to anatomy that had to happen). But if you are looking to lose a lot, it is a great procedure and you have to be committed.

I had a DS and lost a ton of weight and have kept it off easily . But I also take 60 pills a day of high dose individual vitamins and drink a lot of high protein shakes to stay healthy.

If you would like more info let me know. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

checkingitout, I used Dr Speigel for my procedure but I use the Davis Clinic and their dietitian there (Dana McDonald) for my vitamin and follow up needs. 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

I worry about this surgery. Is it really worth it? Does it affect your ability to work and enjoy the activities that you are used to.
For those who have done this, would you do it again? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I would do the DS again in a heart beat Lets Be Fair.

One thing I didn't add - with the bypass, sleeve and DS, they are proven to reduce/remove diabetes, cholesterol issues and apnea immediately.


I did have a lot of food intolerences post surgery and still do today. They come and go and do so without warning so I am vigilant about what I eat.

I did learn to eat differently sometimes but other times I still crave my double baconator like the rest of the world LOL.

The recovery time for the bypass/sleeve/ds is about 4-6 weeks. Food intolerences can and do last longer depending upon the person.

Like I said, for me, the DS was the best decision. Long term weight loss, I can NEVER regain weight.

I will always have to monitor for other issues like bowel obstructions but now that I know that, I am aware. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Lets Be Fair - because of the risk of malnutrition with the DS it is not one I recommend to someone who isn't going to be compliant. People have died from malnutrition post surgery because they really thought the amount of vitamins we have to take was a joke and didn't do it.

Basically their body ended up eating its own organs.

But they are the exception rather than the rule. I also know a lot of people who are 10+ years post surgery and are doing great.

Heck, there is even a local Kingwood physician (and I will not name them, who has had the DS years ago. 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

See my friend had lap band and I waited to see her success and there was none! Now awhile back she had the sleeve and really looks awesome!!!!! I've been thinking and preying about this I have a real peace about it! I love my life and had my weight! I have a good 80 lbs to loose and feel defeated! Now I need to decide on a great doctor! I know there are quacks out there' 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

Excuse spelling I'm on the phone with auto correct 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I would do lots of research on the subject AND the doc you are considering. These are serious surgeries with real risk of complication, infection, etc. People have died. Not trying to scare you but have to consider the seriousness of it.

Eating healthy and excercising can still yeild the same results. :) 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I had the gastric sleeve done in Mexico back on 8/23/12. As of this morning, I have lost 180 pounds.

Best move I have ever made.

I am finding that I cannot over eat and the folks that I know who are 1-2 years post op also report that they are maintaining their goal weights and not gaining.

My typical intake on a daily basis is as follows.

1 egg and a piece of toast for breakfast

1/2 a sandwich and a few chips for lunch

For Dinner : Usually about 4-6 ozs of what ever entree Mrs. Tinman makes. Easter Sunday I had a slice of brisket and some freshly prepared green beans.

The sleeve is done in a way that the part of the stomach that is left does not stretch like your normal stomach would after lap band procedures.

I can tell you that the only lifestyle restriction I have is how much I can eat. I was back to work five days post op and haven't missed a day since. The biggest challenge for me is protein intake and, of course, water intake.

I would recommend the VSG procedure every day and twice on Sunday. Since I have no experience or knowledge of the Duodenal Swith, I can't tell you which is better. 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

Tinman, it sounds like it was a success for you. My question is, if you had eaten the food and amounts you are eating now, would you have been able to lose the weight without the surgery?
I don't know. I have a friend considering this surgery and I keep telling him that he is still going to have to.change his diet. 

HARP --- 13 years ago -

Tinman, it sounds like it was a success for you. My question is, if you had eaten the food and amounts you are eating now, would you have been able to lose the weight without the surgery?
I don't know. I have a friend considering this surgery and I keep telling him that he is still going to have to.change his diet. 


As Tinman's daughter, I thought I'd answer this question to give a different perspective. I have ALWAYS been of the mindset that my dad could have changed his eating habits many times throughout his life. I was always encouraging him to make the change, and when I initially found out he wanted the surgery, I expressed my opinions again. However, almost 8 months out from the surgery I am so glad he made that choice. It has been a life changer, and I am absolutely convinced it saved his life.

To answer your question, could he have lost that weight if he started eating as little as he does now, absolutely, could he have made that choice on his own to start eating that little...well he tried for years and never was able to fight temptation. This surgery basically allows you to start over and retrain your body without having to fight temptation on a daily basis. Personally, for my dad, the surgery was the better option for him and for our family. Now he has the energy to enjoy my 3 month old :) 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Lets Be Fair --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

Tinman, it sounds like it was a success for you. My question is, if you had eaten the food and amounts you are eating now, would you have been able to lose the weight without the surgery?
I don't know. I have a friend considering this surgery and I keep telling him that he is still going to have to.change his diet.




That is a very, very, very good question. In fact, it's one that I asked myself before my surgery and also after.

I was of the opinion that my body just wasn't capable of losing weight on a restricted calorie diet. I had tried them all and found that I just wasn't able to succeed on any of them.

Once I had the sleeve procedure and found that the weight came off easily once my caloric intake decreased, then my question was answered.

If you are disciplined enough to adhere to a low cal diet, then you don't need this surgery.

But, if you have that kind of discipline, you probably aren't 200 pounds over weight either.

This procedure only helps those who are out of options and can't seem to make a change any other way.

I would 100% recommend that anyone needing to lose big amounts of weight should try very hard to do it via calorie control and exercise.

But, if that is not working, then the sleeve or DS is a very workable solution that not only saved my life, but would save the life of whom ever has the procedure done. 

Sinister --- 13 years ago -

Tinman.....why did you go to Mexico? 

Amy --- 13 years ago -

I have had both. I hated the band but love the sleeve. DONT go to Mexico. I though about it but after I read horrible stories I decided not too. I also would not recommended Dr Spiegal. Read his reviews. Texas Gastric Banding was where I had mine done, 242/45. 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

I'm interested in recommended doctors so I can set up an appt to educate myself more!!! 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

Thanks Harp and Tinman, I am happy for both of you. Life should be enjoyed and we should enjoy every minute of it, especially our grandchildren. Good for you :) 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

Thank u to those involved in this conversation bc I know it's a sensitive topic and honest opinions and experiences help desperate people like me make an educated decision! 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Sinister --- 2 min ago - quote - hide comments

Tinman.....why did you go to Mexico?



I chose to go Mexico for several reasons. Not the least of which was cost.

I got estimates for the surgery locally and every one of them was in excess of $20,000.00.

My limited hospitalization policy would not have covered it.

So, I was a cash buyer.

I researched the options and had pretty much decided on going to Costa Rica. I have visited the country before and felt very comfortable that the facilities and expertise were on par with the US. My mother has had procedures done there and just raved about the post op care.

Then I ran into an old high school buddy who is a COH cop here in KW. He was about 10 months post op with the sleeve and looked incredible. He told me that he and his four brothers all used a doctor in Tijuana named Mario Almanza.

After doing research and reading on line about him and others, I was convinced he was the one for me. He has over 10,000 VSG surgeries under his belt. I figured with that much experience, no matter what happened to me on the table, this guy has seen it, dealt with it and won't panic.

I was right. He does between 10-15 of these procedures a day, several days a week. There were 14 in my group and I have kept in touch with most of them and 100% of the folks I stay in touch with are experiencing the same success I am.

BTW....the surgery cost me $4,500.00 and with air fare, five star accommodations, food and 100% expenses for my best friend and my wife, I was all in for under $7,000.00.

I will be more than happy to give you all the info you want if you or someone in your life is interested. I just don't want to bore everyone on here with the details. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I had my procedure in december 2010 and have lost 240 pounds with no regain.

my typical day is:
double strength protein shake
3 eggs with extra butter, 3 slices bacon
cheese and crackers
protein bar
lunch is typically seafood of some type
nuts
some chocolate just cause it is good
protein bar
another double strength protein drink
cheese and crackers, deli meat, pickles, hot peppers
Dinner is typically a protein and maybe a little carb such as mac/cheese or mashed potato
evening snacks include biscotti, ice cream, pickles, deli meat, cheese

When put in to myfitnesspal I typically consume between 3000-3500 calories a day, 175-210 grams protein and around 100 grams of carbs.

But, I also take 7 doses of pills a day.

The key is finding what you need and what you are willing to work with.

The sleeve has a lot of success because of the restriction. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

There are great medical resorts in Mexico that have super reviews. The key as tinman said is to do your homework and ask questions as you are.

There is also a website called obesityhelp.com that has different sections for each procedure where you can ask specific questions too.


Definitely check out your surgeon. Every surgeon has good and bad reviews. Be sure you interview the surgeon before you commit to anything. This is your body and only you should decide what you want/need 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

What changes or how do these procedures affect normal absorption of minerals and vitamins etc..? 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

Perfection, I admire you for being able to do that every day. I don't think I could be that disciplined.
I just 3 meals a day and sometimes one snack. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Lets Be Fair, I love to eat so that's one of the reasons this was the best choice for me. With some of the others ya can't eat as much as I would feel deprived.

8675309 - each of these run risks of mineral/vitamin/nutrition absorption to a varying degree. They all require at least annual if not semi-annual blood work to monitor.

Even my daughter who is 35 and has a band has 18 vials of blood done annually to ensure she is getting the right nutrition in.

The bypass does have a small malabsorption component so there is risk. The DS an even greater risk.

The sleeve has a risk because of the calorie restriction so you have to ensure you are eating the right foods to get the proper amounts in and/or supplement.

Ya gots to follow up for the rest of your life because of the change you are making to your body. 

nicnic --- 13 years ago -

i had the band done 11-11-11 ive lost 80lbs my goal was 100 but i guess my body has decided we are done!!!I used the same doctor as Amy 242-45 Dr.Richard Wikenfield also research Dr.Richard Collier he is in conroe,alot of people feel if youve had a surgery that you have taken the easy road to weight loss but im here to tell you thats not true im not gonna lie any of these procedures take a commientment and willingingness to do as your doctor tells you I only wish i would have had the sleeve done instead but only because it is pretty much maintenance free compared to the band other than that i have no regrets and are very happy with were i am today :-) 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

I only wish i would have had the sleeve done instead but only because it is pretty much maintenance free compared to the band other than that i have no regrets and


R there any other reasons you wish you would have had the sleeve? Would you use Dr. Wikenfield again? What do you know about either of the doctors you referenced? 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

Texas Gastric Banding was where I had mine done, 242/45.


Amy, would you use them again? Would you recommend them? 

LoveMyDoggies --- 13 years ago -

I had lap band done by Dr. Richard Collier in 2008. I would recommend the doctor but not the lap band for anyone that needs to lose more than 100 lbs. If anyone wants more information please feel free to PM me. 

nicnic --- 13 years ago -

yes i would recommend either doctor,as far as why i wish i would have had the sleeve i work 2 full time jobs and its very hard for ME to get in when i need a fill they office only does fills on monday and wednesday i have had to have some saline taken out before and i wont lie when that happens it is very painful i cant even put it into words for these 2 reasons i wish i had the sleeve and now my medical plan wont cover re-doing it because now that i lost the weight i dont meet the requirements to have it done like i said i am happy with where i am today i just wish i wouldnt have been so scared and would have done the sleeve 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

nicnic you have done amazing. You should be proud of yourself.

Ditto to tinman and lovemydoggies too.

Whichever you choose it's a lifetime commitment 

nicnic --- 13 years ago -

Thanks Perfection not sure if you know this but you have been one of my biggest or should i say littlest supporters,always giving me info and a encouraging word :-).....and I am very proud of myself and like I said Im very happy with where I am today and so very thankful that was I able to receive this tool to help me get where I wanted to be and I agree 100% they are all a lifetime commitment but so worth it...imo... 

haleyj134 --- 13 years ago -

I had gastric sleeve done on December 14th. I went to the Davis clinic in my opinion they are the best of the best. Dr. Primomo did my surgery I would do it over again in a heart beat no regrets. 

haleyj134 --- 13 years ago -

Guess i should add dehydration has been my biggest problem. With the sleeve they remove the part of your stomach that tells your brain your hungry its called(grelin). With this gone I do forget to eat and drink alot so I have to remind myself to drink water and take all my vitamins. I haven't had any food tolerance issues. I chose not to eat bread to much it just feels me up to much and I dont get to eat the "real" food part :) Surgery is a lifestyle change no matter which one you decide. You will find yourself making better food choices just because you can eat more salad and veggies when compared to a hamburger and french fries. I wish you much luck and if you have any questions please don't hesitate to ask. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Guess i should add dehydration has been my biggest problem. With the sleeve they remove the part of your stomach that tells your brain your hungry its called(grelin). With this gone I do forget to eat and drink alot so I have to remind myself to drink water and take all my vitamins. I haven't had any food tolerance issues. I chose not to eat bread to much it just feels me up to much and I dont get to eat the "real" food part :) Surgery is a lifestyle change no matter which one you decide. You will find yourself making better food choices just because you can eat more salad and veggies when compared to a hamburger and french fries.


Congrats! 

checkingitout --- 13 years ago -

Dr Spiegal had bad reviews, Collier had great reviews and Primomo had good but was newer at this surgery.

Now, does the staff help you get qualified with your insurance or do you get stuck fighting with them?

Do all of the above make you attend seminars? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Spiegal did not require a seminar. My insurance required three months supervised diet, psych eval, and then normal pre-op heart tests.

A lot depends on your insurance and what sort of coverage you have. His office did everything for me even the appeal (I didn't have comorbidities so they initially denied it even though I had the bmi).

Pick the surgeon you personally feel comfortable with, their job is to repair you not to be your friend. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

You need to go visit some web sites such as Gastric Sleeve Talk dot com, or one of the several VSG pages on facebook.

You'll read plenty of advice about insurance, seminars, and such.

Personally speaking, I would not opt for the surgery locally. I will never understand why you need permission from a doctor in order to get a treatment you want.

I read all the time about folks who are desperate to have this surgery and are turned down because a nutritionist or some other quack decides that they don't need it.

Really? A nutritionist?

I am seeing where it takes anywhere from 4-8 months to get all of the paperwork done and pre-op psycho babble work done along with the nutritionist blessing.

After all of that time, it appears as though there is still a 50/50 chance that someone who doesn't really know you is going to turn you down.

Do your homework and have this surgery done abroad. I did, my friends did, and everyone went abroad and posts on the gastric sleeve talk web site will tell you that going abroad was a great decision on their part.

You can have the surgery, lose a lot of the weight you need to lose and get on with your life in less time that it will take you to get the blessing of some doctor at the med center. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground