Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Keystone Pipeline -- a real shovel ready project, thousands of jobs, what are we waiting for?

who's talking here?

smartypants 10
d:-] 3
Donkey Hodie 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Perfection 1
RiteWingKing 1
JohnLynch 20
Aah Grasshoppa 2
Clovis 5
FabFive 1
Emperor of Kingwood 4
Ogre13 30
Gigolo Bloodline 2
Not KU 4
Not Snake Plissken 21
Sweet Cherub 1
The Master 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Not Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

...or is someone waiting for China to make a deal and lock us out of Canadian oil? 

Donkey Hodie --- 12 years ago -

Here is a very long article about Keystone. It's long, but interesting.

tl;dr = There is opposition to it from people in both political parties, and from both environmentalists and farmers/ranchers. It's a complex issue, not one for quick sound-bites and uninformed opinions. But this is KU, so I'm sure we'll get plenty of those. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

uninformed opinions.

Yep. People jumping to conclusions with incorrect or limited data, not worrying about the consequences of being wrong. Seems to happen a lot. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

is someone waiting for China to make a deal and lock is out of Canadian oil??

I'm waiting for any deal to include having China agree to write off our trade deficit and give us an additional huge wad of money, since we and our children and our grandchildren will be taking all the risk of environmental damage so they can have oil. In free market economies, people are more likely to take risks when there's a payoff. So make it worth it! And by payoff I DON'T mean profit for oil companies. 

Not Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Yep. People jumping to conclusions with incorrect or limited data, not worrying about the consequences of being wrong. Seems to happen a lot.



NYT: Oil companies paid the most in taxes

The three largest oil companies paid the most in taxes in absolute terms of all major corporations, according to data on S&P 500 companies compiled by The New York Times.

President Barack Obama has chastised oil companies for receiving billions of dollars in tax breaks. However, the Times reports that ExxonMobil paid $146 billion in taxes; Chevron paid $85 billion; and ConocoPhillips paid $58 billion over the last five years.

In terms of their effective tax rates, the big three oil companies don?t get off easily either. Exxon had an effective tax rate of 37 percent, Chevron?s effective tax rate was 39 percent, and ConocoPhillips?s was a whopping 74 percent. The U.S. corporate tax rate is 35 percent.

In fact, the big three oil companies paid multiples more, in both total dollars and effective tax rates, than such administration favorites as Apple, Google and General Electric.

President Obama sparked a conflict with the oil industry when he called for eliminating $4 billion in tax breaks to oil, gas and coal companies.

?As we continue to pursue clean energy technologies that will support future economic growth, we should not devote scarce resources to subsidizing the use of fossil fuels produced by some of the largest, most profitable companies in the world,? read the president?s 2014 budget proposal. ?That is why the Budget proposes to eliminate unnecessary fossil fuel subsidies that impede investment in clean energy sources and undermine efforts to address the threat of climate change.?

However, last year Exxon and Chevron ranked in the top two companies that paid the most in taxes. ConocoPhillips ranked sixth in terms of taxes paid, reports USA Today. In 2012, Exxon paid $31.05 billion, Chevron paid $20 billion, and ConocoPhillips paid $7.94 billion.

?The oil and gas industry gets no subsidies, zero, nothing,? said Jack Gerard, president and CEO of the American Petroleum Institute ? the nation?s largest oil and gas lobby. ?We get cost-recovery benefits, much like other industries. You can go down the road of allowing economic activity, generating hundreds of billions to the government, or you can take the alternative route by trying to extract new revenue from industry by increasing their cost to do business.?

The president?s budget seeks to eliminate tax breaks for fossil fuels while increasing funding for programs that promote green energy use, electric vehicles, and energy efficiency. However, in terms of tax benefits, green firms are already the largest beneficiary.

According to the Congressional Budget Office, tax benefits for renewable energy and energy efficiency make up three-quarters of more than $16 billion in energy-related tax subsidies the U.S. for 2013. 

Not Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

In free market economies, people are more likely to take risks when there's a payoff. So make it worth it! And by payoff I DON'T mean profit for oil companies.


Right, but it's the oil companies taking the risks and building the infrastructure to use the plants they already built. Who do you think should make the profit then? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Right, but it's the oil companies taking the risks and building the infrastructure to use the plants they already built. Who do you think should make the profit then? 

liberals don't understand how capitalism works... 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

Who do you think should make the profit then?

I didn't say they won't make a profit. We all know they will. That is a given.

Canadian tar sands is like low hanging fruit to them. They are salivating over this. Very little cost, relatively speaking. Compared to say, exploring in Siberia. 

Not Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Wrong. Do you have any idea how expensive it is to extract that oil? Very.

Btw, Siberia is the Russians. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

Do you have any idea how expensive it is to extract that oil?

Sort of.

One of the biggest problems: Costs are soaring for many of the new "megaprojects" to tap petroleum deposits needed to replenish depleting fields.

Plans under way to pump oil using man-made islands in the Caspian Sea could cost a consortium that includes Exxon and Shell $40 billion, up from the original budget of $10 billion. The price tag for a natural-gas project in Australia, called Gorgon and jointly owned by the three companies, has ballooned 45% to $54 billion. Shell is spending at least $10 billion on untested technology to build a natural-gas plant on a large boat so the company can tap a remote field, according to people who have worked on the project.

Finding the next gusher has always been a risky business, sending oil companies beneath the ocean floor and into unstable parts of Africa, Asia and the Middle East. Now the pursuit is trickier and more expensive than ever. The easiest-to-reach oil ran dry long ago, and the most prolific fields often are controlled by state-owned companies in places like Saudi Arabia and Venezuela.


Seems to me that the most expensive part is finding a big reserve in a peaceful place. Alberta has both those things going for it, so that's why I still think it's low hanging fruit. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

...or is someone waiting for China to make a deal and lock us out of Canadian oil?

Too late. In fact that's exactly how Keystone started, as an export only pipeline. The U.S. will not, and never was going to see a single drop of that oil.

And in fact, the southern portion is complete, so no one's really been waiting.

Even FOX news has said that Keystone is a bad deal for the U.S.

Fox Article

Forbes Article

There is NOTHING about Keystone that is good for the U.S. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

There is NOTHING about Keystone that is good for the U.S. 

wrong again ogre...jobs for our people 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -


It seems that the existing leg of the Keystone has spilled more oil in its first year than any other first-year pipeline in U.S. history (HuffPost).

The Keystone XL is designed to promote exports of Canadian tar sands oil and its refined products to non-U.S. markets, especially China and Latin America.

Transcanada has used strong-arm tactics to condemn using imminent domain massive amounts of private property. Sometimes paying pennies on the dollar the value of that property.

I can just keep going.

The US won't even see an tarrifs off the export of the oil as it is moving from a free trade zone to a free trade zone and once refined being sold (mostly) to China.

The US will see a TINY amount of permanent jobs in the refining end of things and most of the jobs created by the Keystone project will be temporary construction jobs.

I can go on.

Transcanada's safety record in Canada is one of the main reason that Canada did not allow them build the pipeline there. That and it would have to cross Indigenous lands and the tribal councils of those lands refused access for the same reason.

Another reason is that there is over 1,000,000 bb per day capacity in existence today that is not being used. There was NO NEED to even build this pipeline except for the purpose of avoiding US and Canadian taxes and tariffs.

Should I continue? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

There is NOTHING about Keystone that is good for the U.S.

wrong again ogre...jobs for our people


JL - once again all you've done is parrot some pundit.

You might just want to shut up. I promise you that NO ONE on this site thinks you're anything but a clown. PERIOD. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

The State Department estimates that Keystone XL will result in only 20 permanent, operational jobs in the U.S and 2,500 to 4,650 temporary jobs.

What?s more, after Keystone XL oil makes it to Texas, much of it will be exported beyond U.S. borders without paying U.S. taxes ? never benefiting our economy or slacking our thirst for oil.

DO I NEED OT KEEP REPEATING THAT???

KEYSTONE XL BENEFITS TRANSCANADA AND CHINA. That's all. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You might just want to shut up. I promise you that NO ONE on this site thinks you're anything but a clown. PERIOD. 

they KNOW that you're the one who acts like a clown...

KEYSTONE XL BENEFITS TRANSCANADA AND CHINA. That's all.

FALSE...apparently you know very little about the oil business... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

The 20,000 job number has been debunked time and again.

AND IT IS ENTIRELY POSSIBLE that when we start shipping massive amounts of diesel fuel to China, that we will pay MORE for gas here.

The only thing Keystone has been good for is political haymaking. In fact, if it is approved this year, it will have taken just as long for approval as the Alaskan pipeline. In other words...GONE THROUGH THE NORMAL PROCESS. Which isn't good enough for some people like...Oh, I dunno...Boeher...who happens to be an investor in Transcanada (Who also happens to be a campaign supporter of Boehner!!!!) And I'm pretty sure Boehner's not the only one.

SUPPORT TRANSCANADA = SUPPORTING CHINESE ECONOMIC GROWTH. Far as I'm concerned, that's treason. And no, I'm NOT reasonable about this. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

And no, I'm NOT reasonable about this. 

LOL...you are absolutely correct...you aren't reasonable... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

FALSE...apparently you know very little about the oil business...

ROFLMAO!! CERTIFIED LANDMAN- dipwad.

Helped negotiate my father's lease.

Worked FOUR YEARS as an engineer on oil field research and exploration vessels before I got hurt.

How many wells have you helped drill, JL? I'm betting ZERO. I've done dozens of exploration wells in the Gulf of Mexico.

Spent a year studying the oil and gas industry at University of Houston before i decided to attend law school.

SO YES, I KNOW A BIT ABOUT THE OIL INDUSTRY.

YOU really might oughta shut up. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

As an investor, Speaker Boehner was privy to the authentic job creation numbers TransCanada reported to investors and Canadian regulators. It is despicable that Boehner deliberately lies to the American people for personal financial gain, but it is illegal to lie to influence investors and potential investors to drive up share price.

IT is disgusting that the SEC hasn't seen fit to investigate him. 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

Hate to disagree with Ogre, but keystone will increase jobs. Here.

I know this directly. Company I work for will significantly benefit from it and will increase employment as a result. Discussions just yesterday on this...

I can only speak to the micro affect of one BIG A** COMPANY, but there it is. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

ROFLMAO!! CERTIFIED LANDMAN- dipwad.

that doesn't mean you know anything...which you most definitely have proven here

YOU really might outa shut up.

nope...you really should...i've been in the oil business for 30+ years

who is building those pipelines ogre?

who will be getting paid for the transfers of oil ogre?

who will get paid for the construction of the NEW storage tanks ogre?

who will get paid to store the oil ogre?

who will be refining the oil ogre? 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 12 years ago -

Reference the thread where people see loved ones in heaven and apparently seek heaven as if its better than LIFE.

Why would such people care an ounce about the earth? See James Watt, ex secretary of interior whose famous use it or lose it philosophy of the earths resources gained traction.

The sooner these people are in heaven and gone the better we will be. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Hate to disagree with Ogre, but keystone will increase jobs. Here.

They key, The Master, is that it will not SIGNIFICANTLY increase jobs enough to justify doing everything else.

It CERTAINLY WILL NOT create 20,000 new jobs.

If it affects your company, great. How many jobs will it create? 1, 2, 5?

Are those jobs worth selling the country out to China?

And JL...I call BS. You are not in the oil industry, not a lick. You're a liar.

Whose building those pipelines? TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION WORKERS.

Who is getting paid for the transfers? TRANSCANADA.

Who is refining the oil?
Valero Port Arthur - and they are the ONLY American company that will make any significant amount of money off the deal. And even then it's only going to be about $15.00 a barrel.

But you people want to sell out to China... Fine... Xi?ngsh?? de x?n zh?nggu? zh?r?

Idiots. When that red flag with the five stars on it are flying over your house, don't say I didn't tell you so! 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Why would such people care an ounce about the earth

LOL...taking oil out of the ground doesn't hurt the earth... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

[We?re] probably looking at?from Montana to Houston, I don?t know, [job creation] in the hundreds...? (Robert Jones, TransCanada?s Vice President for Keystone Pipelines, CNN, November 11, 2011) 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

LOL...taking oil out of the ground doesn't hurt the earth...

Now I KNOW you're not in the oil industry.

Every oil man I've ever known has been aware of the potential harm that their industry could cause. Didn't matter if they were offshore or on. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

And JL...I call BS. You are not in the oil industry, not a lick. You're a liar.

LOL...i'm the one in the oil business...you're not

TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION WORKERS.

FALSE...and from what country are those workers in ogre?

TRANSCANADA

nope...not true...

Valero Port Arthur

that's not the only company...see...you don't know as much as you think you do...and where do the workers reside that are getting paid to work there? 

The Master --- 12 years ago -

If it affects your company, great. How many jobs will it create? 1, 2, 5?

Not sure yet. At least a few hundred. Certainly not 20k but a few hundred for each company, supplier, etc, involved... could be a lot.

Valero Port Arthur - and they are the ONLY American company that will make any significant amount of money off the deal.


No. There is another one. And another industry that also benefits....

anyway, yes, there will be an increase in jobs. As for the rest of it (China, etc) I don't know enough about it to have an opinion. Not my area of expertise. 

Not Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

It CERTAINLY WILL NOT create 20,000 new jobs.


Who told you this? The same people that said Prince William Sound would take 100 years to recover from the Exxon Valdez spill? The same ones that said the Gulf of Mexico would never recover from the BP spill? LMAO! 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Every oil man I've ever known has been aware of the potential harm that their industry could cause.

not to the earth...how many oil men do you know?...2 or 3? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Who told you this?

he's a liberal kool-aid drinker 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

By TransCanada?s own account, Keystone XL is expected to increase oil prices in the Midwest

There is one source of potential long-term job creation about which oil industry has remained silent: jobs created to clean up inevitable spills and leaks. So far, TransCanada has experienced major problems with the section of the Keystone project already completed. In its first year of operation, its so-called safe ?state-of-the-art? pipeline has already leaked 35 times! This company doesn't even know how to run a pipeline.

TransCanada, the company behind the proposal, predicted its existing Keystone 1 pipeline would leak once every seven years. It leaked 12 times in the first year. The largest of those spills, in North Dakota, was a six-story gusher spewing 21,000 gallons of oil-sands crude.

How many times has the Alaskan Pipeline leaked in the same period? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

not to the earth.

You are trying to hide behind sophistry again. SO I'm ignoring your stupidity from now on.

Who told you this?

[We?re] probably looking at?from Montana to Houston, I don?t know, [job creation] in the hundreds...? (Robert Jones, TransCanada?s Vice President for Keystone Pipelines, CNN, November 11, 2011)

And every single analyst who did not have a financial stake in the pipeline. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

There is one source of potential long-term job creation about which oil industry has remained silent: jobs created to clean up inevitable spills and leaks.

LOL...you continue to show how little you know about the oil business...there are ALREADY hundreds of pipelines criss-crossing Texas...especially southeast Texas...and there are ALREADY companies that are capable of cleaning up oil spills 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

And if you're so concerned about JOB CREATION then you should be supporting alternative energy resources:

A study by Synapse Energy Economics developed a Transition Scenario for the electric power industry based on reducing energy consumption, phasing out high-emission power plants, and building new, lower-emission energy facilities. The study estimated the number of ?job years? ? one new worker employed for one year ? that would be created by the Transition Scenario over a decade:

444,000 job-years for construction workers, equivalent to 44,400 construction workers working full time for the entire decade.

90,000 job-years for operations and maintenance workers, equivalent to about 9,000 full time workers employed over the decade.

3.1 million indirect jobs for people designing, manufacturing, and delivering materials and jobs in local economies around the country induced by spending by workers hired in the Transition Scenario.

Keystone XL is a loser. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You are trying to hide behind sophistry again

you don't even know what sophistry means...was that your word for the day? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

And if you're so concerned about JOB CREATION then you should be supporting alternative energy resources

you mean the ones that obama gave billions to that went bankrupt? 

Not Snake Plissken --- 12 years ago -

Even. Obama said it would at best create 2,000 jobs.


The "most realistic estimates" for jobs created by Keystone XL are "maybe 2,000 jobs during the construction of the pipeline."
Barack Obama on Saturday, July 27th, 2013 in an interview with the 'New York Times'



Your estimate was 50. Barack says 2,000. You're disagreeing with the messiah. LOL 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

"what are we waiting for?"

What we are waiting for is when Obama decides it will be most politically advantages to him to give the go ahead.

Yeah, he's interested in creating jobs....NOT! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground