Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Unions

who's talking here?

planemom 3
likeke27 2
ukchristine 2
TXamanda 1
rEVOLution 1
traveller! 2
allofus 6
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
keepinitreal09 1
PS 1
Danabug 6
Big Ben 2
Warren Peace 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ukchristine --- 18 years ago -

Why do unions get involved in legislation and politics that have NOTHING to do with salary and benefits for the worker. I see the CTA (California Teachers Associatione) have spent large sums to defeat Prop 8 (gay marriage.) This does not seam right to me. I would be more FOR unions if they did not get involved in agendas that to me are clearly NOTHING to do with their main purpose, negotiating with management. I know you can opt out of the political component of the dues, but I wonder how many do and if they no thier dues are being spent against their beliefs or politics. 

traveller! --- 18 years ago -

Unions definitely overstep their bounds. However it is up to the members to put pressure on their reps. to make any changes and usually no one wants anything to do with the union unless they feel they are being hurt personally by something. 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

My DH works for the rr and is part of a union, they constantly give money to the candidate of THEIR choice, not ours and there isn't much we can do about it. We also get Obama love fest news letters every month. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

I hate Unions, they make my eyes water. LOL sorry, I couldn't resist. I agree with you though. 

traveller! --- 18 years ago -

Unions are a necessary evil, but members do not take an active enough role in making their reps know what they want. I deal with them everyday and everyone complains about them, but no one questions anything they do. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

We also get Obama love fest news letters every month. we get that too... my dh nearly got kicked out of a union meeting for letting his personal political ideals out... which go against the union 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

they constantly give money to the candidate of THEIR choice, not ours and there isn't much we can do about it. well, there is something we are doing about it. i opted out of contributing to the PAC. Unions are a necessary evil yes they are my dh nearly got kicked out of a union meeting for letting his personal political ideals out... which go against the union unions are alot like the companies that they despise. both only care about the bottom line 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

well, there is something we are doing about it. i opted out of contributing to the PAC. Oh yeah! I forgot about that. lol 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

speaking of the letters... we got one today 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

What union? 

TXamanda --- 18 years ago -

we also got out flier yesterday, from the union, about what candiddates to vote for. they say there the ones who will benefit the union. I never let them sway my vote. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

plumbers local 68 

ukchristine --- 18 years ago -

To a certin extent I can understnd recommendations for candidates that the union feel would be "worker friendly"....and that's always Dem....but I cannot understand why they get involved with social issues like gay rights. That is just not right. Just on principle because unions go so far out of their purpose I am not in favour of them. They have changed too much from the times when they were necessary and useful. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Maybe some of you can explain to me why unions are necessary. 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

They do still provide benefits to the workers that are members. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

yes they do. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

if it was not for the union my husband would not have a good job and be getting an education... being in the union has helped my husbands self esteem immensely.. he was brought up homeschooled where his mother didnt teach him. He has always been led to believe that all he was good for was minimum wage jobs. or to be a rock star... he would have been working for dominos making nothing forever 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

They do still provide benefits to the workers that are members. But they raise the cost of labor....which ultimately costs jobs. Care to ask laid off workers from GM whether they would rather be working for Toyota? 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

allofus, It sounds like your husband traded one set of apron strings for another. How did the union help your husband obtain a job that he might not otherwise have had without a union? Did the union push for lower qualifications? 

PS --- 18 years ago -

Care to ask laid off workers from GM Are they laid off or do they pay them to stay at home? 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

But they raise the cost of labor....which ultimately costs jobs. So does every other business. Gas companies raise gas prices, grocery stores raise gas prices, it has nothing to do with unions. I come from a union background myself. If not for the union, I would have never gotten a raise. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

So does every other business. Gas companies raise gas prices, grocery stores raise gas prices, it has nothing to do with unions. I come from a union background myself. If not for the union, I would have never gotten a raise. Then perhaps you can explain how the American car manufacturers in this country who embrace unions are struggling while the Japanese manufacturers in this country are doing well. Surely you're aware that one reason that General Motors has been losing market share for years -- going from selling about half the cars in the country to selling about one quarter today -- is that its union contracts put them at a disadvantage compared to its Japanese competitors. Even though Toyota has factories in the United States, the American employees in those factories vote to keep their jobs by staying non-union. Toyota takes business away from unionized Detroit car makers, who are forced to lay off thousands of workers while Toyota is hiring additional workers. There may not be any big difference in pay scales but unions can create higher production costs in many other ways. Fringe benefits are just one. Work rules are another. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

If not for the union, I would have never gotten a raise. Wow. You've been thoroughly indoctrinated. Is that what your employer told you, or is it what the union told you? So you're saying that your employer would not have thought that you were worth the price if not for a labor union telling them? People on the inside looking out benefit at the expense of people on the outside looking in. Losers include not only less experienced and lower skilled workers, whose output would not cover the cost of the minimum wage, but also future workers who may find fewer job opportunities in the unionized industries. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

So you're saying that your employer would not have thought that you were worth the price if not for a labor union telling them? in my case, you must not know the history of the railroad.... 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

I know for my DH working for the rr, the union has it's benefits, the cost we pay for health care with the union compared to the cost without is enough in and of itself for me to say they aren't all bad. 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

in my case, you must not know the history of the railroad.... That is what I was thinking. haha 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Mine protects me from crazy lawsuits, in our biz education one never knows when a suit could occur... 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

When push comes to shove unions have very little power. They might help enforce work rules but do little else. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

It sounds like your husband traded one set of apron strings for another. How did the union help your husband obtain a job that he might not otherwise have had without a union? Did the union push for lower qualifications? a high paying job.. no he wouldnt. The union was willing to train him and give him schooling. Before the union he was working for 10 an hour with no respect. Now he in his 3rd year of school is running his own men and is treated with respect. He has a purpose in life.. but why am i defending it to you. it sounds like you have your mind made up and dont care what anyone says... 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Unbelievable. The reasons given for all this pro-union stuff makes it seem no different than an organized crime racket shaking down local businesses (they give me protection, I get respect, they trained me so now I owe them, I would have been nothing without them). I'd wager that every one of you and your spouses that are union members are intelligent enough and skilled enough to succeed without unions. Do you lack the confidence to succeed without unions? If there is some history of the railroad that is relevant for the way these businesses currently do businesses, then please educate me. I'll be glad to hear you out. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

Well I can say this about the union I once belonged to IBEW. 4 years ago, I was making $22.15 hr. on my paycheck along with every other journeyman electrician. My total package was way more. I did not have to pay for my health insurance and I was provided a free retirement. They also put me through apprenticeship school for almost free. Those working in the open shops were making $18-$19 hr. if they were lucky and then having to pay insurance out of that with either just a 401k or NO retirement. We found this out because we would ask the open shop electricians and they would tell us. Now don't get me wrong, I did not agree with everything the union did such as try to get me to vote democratic. As for the raises, I worked in construction, go to a construction boss and ask for a raise. It doesn't matter if your good or not, You ask for more money, you might wind up with a pink slip. I did also want to add that I am no longer in the union as I now work in engineering. But If I did ever go back to working on my tools, Id be right back at the union hall. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

It doesn't matter if your good or not, You ask for more money, you might wind up with a pink slip. so true!!! 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I'd wager that every one of you and your spouses that are union members are intelligent enough and skilled enough to succeed without unions In many unionized industries you don't have a choice you either work at a company that has a union or you don't work. The airlines are a good example. However, I have seen too many instances that when push came to shove the union couldn't or wouldn't do anything. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I know for my DH working for the rr, the union has it's benefits, the cost we pay for health care with the union compared to the cost without is enough in and of itself for me to say they aren't all bad. Are you talking about a scenario where the union and your employer negotiated for several health plans to be presented to you, and then you selected from the choices they provided? Or do you have the freedom to negotiate with any health provider of your choice? Also, take a look at your DH's pay stub. Look at the 2 columns where your portion of the health plan is limited and compare it to the employer's portion. It appears they pay more, doesn't it? Truth is you pay all of it. Add the 2 sums together. That's the total cost of your healthcare. Add your total benefits to your salary. That's the total earnings that your employer feels your labor generates. It's much more than your salary isn't it? By claiming that your employer pays for anything you receive is evidence of falling for the shell-game. You only think that way because of the way it is presented on your pay stub. Most folks would be better off paying for their own health insurance. Getting on a group benefit plan is only beneficial to the sickly who get more than they pay - at the expense of those who make healthy lifestyle choices. The same thing happens with extra union expenses that employers have to pay. It costs them money that they would otherwise be spending on additional employees, training, or other expenses. Unions only benefit those who are in at the expense of those unable to get in BECAUSE of the union presence. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Also, take a look at your DH's pay stub. Look at the 2 columns where your portion of the health plan is limited and compare it to the employer's portion. It appears they pay more, doesn't it? Truth is you pay all of it. Add the 2 sums together. That's the total cost of your healthcare. Add your total benefits to your salary. That's the total earnings that your employer feels your labor generates. It's much more than your salary isn't it? That's how we look at it. Only you also need to include the employers portion of taxes, which by itself is a whole other discussion. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground