Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Community Service Work: Mandatory?

who's talking here?

CMGs 5
RRay 1
Fancy 6
planemom 6
Aviator 1
AuthorMan 2
BaylorMom 1
BeadQueen 1
HsMommy 12
sweldo 1
justforfun 16
Forecaster 14
momof5 10
Perfection 15
brian* 2
MomTimesFive 3
OH SNAP! 16
petoskeypretty 27
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 4
Nightstorm 2
Possum 1
Party Boy!! 1
Warren Peace 18
RCSKI 1
voice of reason 1
Rubiconpete 3
lsupanda 2
Town Floozy 3
N.S. Sherlock 1
i'm a troll 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Suppose a State suddenly required all students to complete community service as a requirement to graduate: 50 hrs annually in middle school and high school and 100 hrs annually in college. Would you support it as a good idea? What about the consequences and tradeoffs? Would you expect school campuses to be transformed as various special interest groups flock to campuses to recruit volunteers? What about students who work? Would this make it harder to work to pay for school, thereby increasing the average debt of graduating college students? 

lsupanda --- 18 years ago -

I was in NIH in high school and we were required to fulfill community service work. What I chose to do I resisted, but in the end kept it up after I graduated because I loved what I was doing so much. 

AuthorMan --- 18 years ago -

I would ask the school district why they think they can make better decisions regarding non-schooltime activities than I can. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

50 hrs annually in middle school and high school and 100 hrs annually in college. What about students who work? Would this make it harder to work to pay for school, thereby increasing the average debt of graduating college students? 50 to 100 annually really isn't that much. Not enough to affect a job really. Giving an hour or two a week would cover that. I think community service is a good thing. It helps you to appreciate what you have, and feel good about taking pride in your community. 

AuthorMan --- 18 years ago -

School districts are not getting the education of our kids right at the current time. Why would we want them involved in non-school venues? 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I went back and edited the original question since seeing holes in the premise. 

lsupanda --- 18 years ago -

School districts are not getting the education of our kids right at the current time A lot of this problem isn't necessarily the school districts or the teachers. Most of it has to do with the state and the TAAKS, TAAS, or whatever its called depending on your generation. The state has put so much emphasis on this darn test that the teachers have no other time to teach anything of value. This would be a way to help children think while providing a valuable service. 

BaylorMom --- 18 years ago -

I have a son when he was in high school he did community service, not because he had to, but because he volunteered and wanted to. In college he still does community service work, again because he wants to. Community service is great, yet I don't think it should be mandated for students to do it to graduate. Nothing wrong with schools encouraging students to do community service, just don't believe to mandate it. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I think community service is a good thing. I went to a public school, the state school in LA, and we were required to do work service, ie, groundskeeping or cafeteria work,etc. It was to help with expenses and invest ourselves into our school. 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

To do it voluntarily yes. Mandated NO. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I just posed the question to my wife. She said she was required to do it in high school and HATED that it imposed obligations on her mother to take her places. Of course it was easier on her mother since she was a stay-home mom. But what about working parents? Wouldn't a requirement such as this be easier on the unemployed families than the employed families? 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

But what about working parents? Wouldn't a requirement such as this be easier on the unemployed families than the employed families? Do you mean single income vs dual income? 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

But what about working parents? Wouldn't a requirement such as this be easier on the unemployed families than the employed families? I didn't think of that but yes it would. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I think community service to get money for college is a great idea, and anyone who is serious about their education would be happy to do it. It helps the student and the community, and isn't a handout if they are working for their money. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

But what about working parents? Wouldn't a requirement such as this be easier on the unemployed families than the employed families? why would the parents have to do it if the kids are supposed to? I'd make sure my kids were doing it or they'd be paying for their own tutions. 

MomTimesFive --- 18 years ago -

To do it voluntarily yes. Mandated NO. Ditto 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

I just posed the question to my wife. She said she was required to do it in high school and HATED that it imposed obligations on her mother to take her places. Of course it was easier on her mother since she was a stay-home mom How is it any different than a dance class or sports? You have to shuttle your kids back and forth to those activities AND pay a small fortune for them. I think encouraging kids to give back to the community is a good thing. Having it mandated wouldn't necessarily be bad as long as they had some options of how to serve, OR, if they were already involved in a program like scouts, those hours would count toward their community service hours. 

Town Floozy --- 18 years ago -

This is from Obamas change.gov 'under "America Serves" link. I have no problem with myself or my son volunteering for community service. America Serves "When you choose to serve -- whether it's your nation, your community or simply your neighborhood -- you are connected to that fundamental American ideal that we want life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness not just for ourselves, but for all Americans. That's why it's called the American dream." The Obama Administration will call on Americans to serve in order to meet the nation’s challenges. President-Elect Obama will expand national service programs like AmeriCorps and Peace Corps and will create a new Classroom Corps to help teachers in underserved schools, as well as a new Health Corps, Clean Energy Corps, and Veterans Corps. Obama will call on citizens of all ages to serve America, by setting a goal that all middle school and high school students do 50 hours of community service a year and by developing a plan so that all college students who conduct 100 hours of community service receive a universal and fully refundable tax credit ensuring that the first $4,000 of their college education is completely free. Obama will encourage retiring Americans to serve by improving programs available for individuals over age 55, while at the same time promoting youth programs such as Youth Build and Head Start. 

Town Floozy --- 18 years ago -

by setting a goal that all middle school and high school students do 50 hours of community service a year and by developing a plan so that all college students who conduct 100 hours of community service receive a universal and fully refundable tax credit ensuring that the first $4,000 of their college education is completely free. Hell yea 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I have no problem with myself or my son volunteering for community service. Especially when it's for a tax credit for college. 

Town Floozy --- 18 years ago -

Amen! If you do extra service time can it be donated to your kids for their college expenses? Sign me up. 

MomTimesFive --- 18 years ago -

How is it any different than a dance class or sports? You have to shuttle your kids back and forth to those activities AND pay a small fortune for them. Are dance class and sports mandatory? 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

How is it any different than a dance class or sports? You have to shuttle your kids back and forth to those activities AND pay a small fortune for them. Are dance class and sports mandatory? never said they were. I was comparing shuttling kids from one activity to another that you PAY for, as opposed to driving them for 1 hour of community service a week. 

Possum --- 18 years ago -

I went to a public school, the state school in LA, and we were required to do work service, ie, groundskeeping or cafeteria work,etc. My sister's children's school is also public, and they too are required to do community and school service such as you described. As far as I know, it hasn't negatively affected any of them. In fact, it has instilled a good work ethic and social responsibility in them 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Are dance class and sports mandatory? If you want to pay for all of your childs college costs, then feel free to not have your kids do any community service. 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

I didn't think you were paid for community service. Maybe I'm wrong. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I didn't think you were paid for community service. Maybe I'm wrong. No, but if you read the above posts, the proposal discussed is taking from a plan to receive a 4K tax credit for college. If we don't want to do community service, then you don't get the credit. 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

No, but if you read the above posts, the proposal discussed is taking from a plan to receive a 4K tax credit for college. If we don't want to do community service, then you don't get the credit. I got it. I also think that kids who want to go to college will find a way and the ones who don't, well they never wanted to go in the first place. 

Party Boy!! --- 18 years ago -

I did it every wednesday in high school. I took special needs kids bowling. I loved it. I think all kids should be required to do something in the community 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

No, but if you read the above posts, the proposal discussed is taking from a plan to receive a 4K tax credit for college. If we don't want to do community service, then you don't get the credit. I got it. I also think that kids who want to go to college will find a way and the ones who don't, well they never wanted to go in the first place. So, you think this is a bad incentive? How is this not a good situation for everyone? 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

So, you think this is a bad incentive? How is this not a good situation for everyone? Are you asking me? I never said it was a bad thing. Read above. I said Voluntarily yes and mandatory no. I admire anyone who would do community service and see that if we took pride in where we lived then we would do it without being told or given a reward. Do it because you have pride not because you are forced or rewarded for it. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

Do it because you have pride not because you are forced or rewarded for it. why not reward them with money toward college??? Will it mean more if they aren't rewarded? I get what you're saying about just doing it...but, this is a good way to help those who don't have money for schooling...it's a great way to give back and be able to help yourself get ahead in life. It's a win win. : ) 

i'm a troll --- 18 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

momof5 --- your kids better get used to community service....for inmates its usually required. Nice...another ball-less wonder of KU. Seriously, your insults would mean so much more if I knew who you were... 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

Will it mean more if they aren't rewarded? I get what you're saying about just doing it...but, this is a good way to help those who don't have money for schooling...it's a great way to give back and be able to help yourself get ahead in life. It's a win win. : ) I get what you are saying but I was raised to think if you don't take pride in your community then what does that say about us? Like I said the kids who want to attend college will find a way, the others without ambition won't care what you offer them. 

sweldo --- 18 years ago -

I have no problem with children being involved in community service, but not mandated. Now, doing some quick math on the assumption that a child starts the program at the beginning of middle school and continues through college: 3 years in middle school plus 4 years in high school at 50 hours per year and 4 years of college at 100 hours per year = 750 hours of community service. And they will get a $4000 tax credit for this work. That equates to $5.33 an hour - $1.22 an hour less than the current minimum wage. In addition, $4000 does not go very far toward a college education anymore. Financially, this sounds like a raw deal for the kid. He would probably be better served to wait until he's 15 and start working a part-time job through high school and college. Even starting at minimum wage (which I believe Obama wants to increase) he would have the potential to earn more toward paying college costs and would accrue real world work experience that would (in addition to some voluntary community service) would make for a much stronger resume coming out of college. 

BeadQueen --- 18 years ago -

It's one of those ideas that sort of sounds good like something that we "should" do. But, I don't think we should. Schools are overwhelmed now with what they are supposed to do. The focus needs to be on fundamentals. With a graduation rate of about 75% we don't need to add more barriers. 

petoskeypretty --- 18 years ago -

I agree that the school should not be responsible for monitoring or setting up community service. But, you know how some other countries require a year in the military for every citizen? I think that such a requirement is very good for patriotism and responsibility to your fellow citizens etc. Same for community service. So, it should be a civil requirement instead of run through the education department. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Who cares if the kid is doing community service for themselves or to get a college credit? In the end everyone benefits. But it's not mandatory. You can pay for it all yourself. and so it comes out to $5 something an hour. It's 1 hour a week, and still offsets the costs, and gets the kid doing something for others. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Absolutely NOT To do it voluntarily yes. Mandated NO. To me this is another bullsh i t liberal feel good exercise commandeering peoples TIME as students have no money yet. Its bad enough how the government screws its populace after kids get into the workforce. NOW........that being said, there are many that enjoy this and WANT to do it. More power to you. Good for you. Just dont MANDATE kids to do this. That is just flat out wrong. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
services
work


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground