Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

For those opposed to childhood immunizations

who's talking here?

blessed 1
whatchamacallit 3
stampin' gal 1
Fallon 4
randyjet 10
planemom 2
karenact 1
Texas Girl 2
Zionist NightOwl 5
random 1
JustMeBeingMe 1
Mabbers 1
SchoolMom 1
Queen Aeval 3
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 3
AFWife 1
Marthax2 1
pamperedpaws 2
luvmylars 1
rEVOLution 6
MxMike 2
MomTimesFive 1
3boys 1
Paige Paige 5
banner 3
zapper007 1
Former CofC Member 1
prissy4ever 3
Shenanigans 1
mommie21g1b 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Queen Aeval --- 17 years ago -

I got this article, and it made me wonder how you will have to handle your choice when enrolling your children in school. Are there similar waivers here? NY parents grilled in 'religious sincerity test' Pete Chagnon - OneNewsNow - 2/11/2009 6:00:00 AM A family in New York is fighting for the rights of parents to opt their children out of vaccines. Ron and Rita Palma of Bayport, New York, have been fighting for the right to opt their children out of the vaccines that public schools require children have before attending school. Parents are allowed to opt out of the medical requirement if they cite objections on religious grounds. The Palmas did so, citing their Catholic faith as a reason, but they were met with resistance from the Bayport-Blue Point Union Free School District. Rita Palma explains. "I handed in my letter, handed in my application, and they called me in and insisted that I come in for a face-to-face interview," she shares. "Now I know other people in the community who have gone through this, so I talked to some lawyers. I knew that they [school officials] were within their legal boundaries, and I really didn't think that it was going to be all that much of a problem. You know, my feelings were true, my beliefs fit squarely with the law -- so I complied." But Palma says she and her husband were grilled for two hours by the school's attorney, David Cohen. She refers to the session as a "sincerity interview." Following is an excerpt from that meeting: Cohen: "If you believe God is on your side, does that mean he's not on the side or can he be on the side of somebody who believes in immunization?" Rita: "Mr. Cohen, I wouldn't know. I know my deepest, most spiritual beliefs. I don't know the belief system of others and..." Ron: "And nor do we control God." Rita: "Yeah." Cohen: "Okay." Rita: "I wouldn't know." Rita says the attorney concluded that her beliefs were not "sincere" enough and decided to deny her vaccine waiver. She is now taking her fight to the New York State Capitol. Intimidation In an interview with OneNewsNow, Rita Palma claims David Cohen, the school's attorney, tried to intimidate her in the questioning process. "He has been named in enough publications where I'm sure he has experienced some pressure -- and some not-so-nice pressure -- from other sources criticizing his actions," she says. "My assemblywomen actually wrote a letter to my school district...criticizing their actions." Rita is currently working with state lawmakers to pass New York Bill A00883, which would amend existing law to ban so-called "religious sincerity tests." "Rather than appeal this decision, the route that I chose to take is to change the law," says Rita. "[I hope] to really compel school districts to accept the [opt-out] letter at face value, and make it illegal for school districts to close the door and ask you what your belief system is all about." Rita is also working to help pass New York Bill A00880, a bill that would make medical waivers accepted at face value. According to Rita, she handed the school a medical waiver from her doctor that would exempt her son from vaccines, but the school rejected that as well. OneNewsNow asked Rita if she had considered private school or home school. She replied that her children really like their current teachers, and apart from the vaccine issue they have no complaints. Rita also explains that private school would put undue financial pressure on the family; but if they do decide to switch schools, she wants the choice to be hers -- and not something the public school forces them to do because of the vaccine issue. Rita operates the website MyKidsMyChoice.com, which assists parents who also wish to opt out of childhood vaccines.  

MxMike --- 17 years ago -

The way they push so hard to get EVERY CHILD vaccinated is a little scary. 

Queen Aeval --- 17 years ago -

I immunized mine. I was young and didn't really have much information that in certain cases it wasn't safe. Now though I have to wonder. How many meds in the past have had the FDA say they are safe, only to have children born with no arms or legs? I don't know much about immunizations, but I have heard that they are linked to all kinds of troubles. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

If you research the ingredients that the government is willing to admit are included in some of the vaccines, you will know why some parents choose not to have this done to their children. You can get a waiver here for school admission. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

I know a couple of people whose children have been negatively affected by immunizations. I did have my kids immunized, but I was nervous about doing it. 

Paige Paige --- 17 years ago -

I have one fully immunized (5)and one who is not (6). Yes, we have a waiver and it has been accepted everywhere when enrolling. 

Paige Paige --- 17 years ago -

www.generationrescue.org for a safe immunization schedule. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I never knew the Catholic Church was opposed to immunizations. I can understand why they would be denied a waiver if the Church does not have that position. It is simply foolish NOT to have them, and it carries a number of disabilities with it if you don't. Don't EVER join the military if you are opposed to it. If you are in the military you have NO option for you OR your kids. I can understand the reservations since the problem with mercury preservatives in the vaccines. I think that has been taken care of now. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Don't EVER join the military if you are opposed to it. If you are in the military you have NO option for you OR your kids. For sure, no telling what you will be getting...used as a guinea pig! 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

For sure, no telling what you will be getting...used as a guinea pig! Dh was supposed to get a normal round of shots during his four-year stint. Got an anthrax shot instead. Those have a different set of reactions. LOL. 

Queen Aeval --- 17 years ago -

I remember walking down that line of people holding immunization guns... OUCH! 

prissy4ever --- 17 years ago -

MY DD IS EXEMPT from the state of texas. when asked i reply " I DO NOT BELIEVE MY GOD WANTS ME INJECTING MYSELF OR CHILD WITH DISEASE CAUSING MICRORGANISMS." usually shuts them up lol... 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 17 years ago -

we do not imm--and 3 of my children attend public school and my 3 yr old ds will attend private school in the fall believe me if they want to try they will get a fight from this momma!!! I will home school before they tell me what I can and cannot do with the things that are shot into my children. I do have to get a letter from the TX dept of health and human services so they can attend public school--no biggie though I may at one time get some of the imm but right now we don't 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 17 years ago -

I remember walking down that line of people holding immunization guns... me to when I joined 

Marthax2 --- 17 years ago -

I can kind of understand the military though, because they have stations all over the world and if you go in to a leading measles country, it's better to be safe than sorry. There is also the point that by then you have a better immunity to the stuff. One question Wanda gave me yesterday is why do we inject children with the same amount of product in every child. It does not matter one way or the other how much they weigh. I never really thought about that, I just always assumed they would give them the correct dosage. You know like giving them Medicine (Tylenol, Motrin Antibiotic!) 

prissy4ever --- 17 years ago -

good for you 12 stone 

prissy4ever --- 17 years ago -

its a parental choice and should not be construed as neglect 

Texas Girl --- 17 years ago -

I can kind of understand the military though My DH was a military brat and he has marks on his shoulder where they gave him the small pox vaccine a bunch of times. Do you really think that was necessary? They do owen you and your family when you're in the military. 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 17 years ago -

They do owen you and your family when you're in the military. yep! its a parental choice and should not be construed as neglect exactly!! I can kind of understand the military though, because they have stations all over the world and if you go in to a leading measles country, it's better to be safe than sorry. mabey this is why we had 5 kids?? we both are/were in the service!!! I wounder what thwy loaded us up on!!! 

SchoolMom --- 17 years ago -

great...my husband is joining the air force next month and my son has not had his shots. I will put up a fight! 

MxMike --- 17 years ago -

I will put up a fight! GOOD! For the sake of the children, look up what they put in these things! There is a film online somewhere of a scientist explaining the effects of contents they found in vaccines. Pretty interesting. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Before anyone makes the decision on what to inject their child with they need to do some research on that product. First of all what's in it. I know that many vaccines contain animal parts, viruses, you name it. I don't know about you but I'm not all for using my child as a lab test rat to see what's going to happen and that's what these products do. You need to investigate the company who distributes the vaccine and what the side affects and statistics were among other children. If our government was not so deep in bed with these companies I might trust them more but I don't. Bush was the leading recipient of donations from big Pharma companies in the amount of over $900k dollars. That is frightening. Also Google Jenny Mcarthy and her crusade to find more healthy ways to immunize children. Ron Paul on vaccines Jail or vaccine? Bull Crappppp!  

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Any government that says it's OK to get an abortion at will and on the other hand forces its citizens to inject infants and children with dangerous products that we have no idea what they are or what they will do to our children, scares me... 

3boys --- 17 years ago -

When I had my children I was very young, and didn't realize I had the option. Immunization it is what you did no questions asked. My children though have never really been sick the common cold here and there, but thats it. I have 2 different friends that made the choice not to immunize there children and they are always sick and in the hospital. Maybe it is a considence but 6 out of 9 kids that are always ill those are some bad odds. Its a parential choice I do agree with that! 

pamperedpaws --- 17 years ago -

Don't EVER join the military if you are opposed to it. If you are in the military you have NO option for you OR your kids. I believe Humble ISD has changed their handbook within the last couple years, since TX started allowing rejections based on conscientious views, BUT....in the section about vaccinations that listed the "required" vaccines, it used to read that vaccines were not required for those children whose parents were active duty in the US military, or for medical and religious reasons. My children do not have their vaccinations for several reasons, and we get an affidavit from Austin that we have to order and get notarized every 2 years. I never understood why it was okay for military children NOT to get them. Here's info about rejecting vaccines if you are in the military for yourself or your children...this is a pdf you can download from the TX Dept. of Health and Human Services. reject vaccines 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Keep in mind that often time the Doctor will not make a record of bad side effects, as if it were an admission of guilt. Why do you think you have to sign a release? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I will put up a fight! I can tell you will lose. The service does NOT put up with prima donnas. Your husband will be discharged if you don't. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Also, if you do NOT have vaccinations, you will have to stay within the US since most countries require vaccinations for entrance. They don't require smallpox any more though since it has been eradicated. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I never understood why it was okay for military children NOT to get them. The reason is that ALL military children DO GET THEM. They have NO choice. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I think vaccines serve one he!! of a purpose. I do not want to see so many of those childhood illnesses coming back. I know in Houston, and other cities, that have a large amount of out of country visitors, our kids are exposed to a lot of things. I am not saying give an infant 10 shots at a time. But I know most good doctors do not do this anyway. At least my children's doc did not. She broke the shots up. And mercury is no longer in the vaccines. So is there a risk, yes. But the risk of not is pretty darn big too. I mean we, as a country, travel more now than ever before. And other people are coming to our country in huge numbers. The public schools are an excellent breeding ground. I was not willing to take that risk with my children. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

You are dead on randyjet. The military does not give a rats a** about your feeling on anything:) lol They tell you to do it, you will do it. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

great...my husband is joining the air force next month You should know that your husbands ratings on his ER or OER will take into consideration how YOU AND YOUR children behave. He can and WILL be disciplined if YOU or your kids screw up. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Good advice rj. Not many understand this. You are not joining a club. It is the military. I personally think it is worth it. You will not believe what you pay for groceries on base. And the BX is amazing!:) So look on the positive side, while you are rolling that sleeve up:) 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

'religious sincerity test' Did you mean religious SANITY test??? 

pamperedpaws --- 17 years ago -

The reason is that ALL military children DO GET THEM. They have NO choice No, not ALL military children have them...we know plenty of people in the military that do not give their children vaccines. They are actually exempt, at least in the state of TX. This is what I don't understand, why they are exempt. If you look at the link I posted....this is a pdf on the TX Dept of Health and Human Services outlining the requirements and who's exempt. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

Also, if you do NOT have vaccinations, you will have to stay within the US since most countries require vaccinations for entrance. Did you mean for a longterm visit, such as living there, and/or for a military stint? The passport application doesn't ask for vaccination information, and the only thing my husband or I, as civilians, have ever needed for travel to Europe, Mexico, Canada, South America, or Israel was our passports. We weren't ever asked immunization questions at Immigration either. 

blessed --- 17 years ago -

I immunized my first 3 children. And then I learned what I was doing to my kids. One thing parents don't realize is that immunizations is what keeps those peditricians in business. You have to make the decision on your own tho. Homeschooling sure made our decision not to immunize much easier. 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

The reason is that ALL military children DO GET THEM. They have NO choice No, not ALL military children have them...we know plenty of people in the military that do not give their children vaccines. They are actually exempt, at least in the state of TX. This is what I don't understand, why they are exempt. If you look at the link I posted....this is a pdf on the TX Dept of Health and Human Services outlining the requirements and who's exempt. pampered is right - it is the overseas issues with the kiddos. I always felt bad when DH had to get his yearly shots & then get the "protective" ones for the middle east - so much was not known especially when they 1st started giving them out. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

Paige, who is your pedi?? Do they support your decision on immunizations. I am a new mom, pregnant with my second and am spreading out the vaccines but still feel like it's a lot. My doctor is ok with me spreading them out but is always scheduling me apts just to get shots. She has never been sick (knock on wood) so the only reason she has ever been to see the doc is shots. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

And mercury is no longer in the vaccines. I can understand the reservations since the problem with mercury preservatives in the vaccines. I think that has been taken care of now. Note, however, that mercury is still in flu vaccines. Since it's considered an adult vaccine and not just a childhood vaccine, manufacturers haven't seen the need to remove it. They make flu vaccines without it, but you have to specifically request them. Not to hijack the thread, but. . . I didn't realize there was mercury in the flu vaccine, and my 13 y.o. son received a flu shot in the fall before school. Within a week he developed sudden and severe stuttering. We cannot find any other cause for it--no anxiety or stress issues, etc. CT scan was normal. He's now in speech therapy; the therapist believes, based on the characteristics of it, that it is neurogenic in origin. We see a neurologist next month. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
health


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground