Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Could gov't heathcare save the auto industry?

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 2
CommonSense 2
crrc 1
Cicero 1
david 1
~sassy~ 2
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 6
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
PS 2
Hiro Protagonist 11
*maryc 2
Warren Peace 2
MomofTwins* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

GM's loss per car: $700 GM's cost per car for health care: $1,500 GM profits if we remove health care expenses: $800. If these numbers are correct would one possible solution be to take healthcare out of their hands? 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Maybe they could just get rid of the union!! 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Maybe they could just get rid of the union Yes.... we know...all unions are pure evil. I guess no one likes the 40 hour work week, or worker safety rules or any of the other myriad protections that unions helped make a reality. Let's trash them all!! 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

Great point Marcellus. Healthcare costs and retiree healthcare costs are killing a lot of companies. That's a big part of the reason why labor is cheaper in so many other countries, because the employers don't have to pay healthcare costs. Yes, their taxes may be higher, but imagine your pay check without any health insurance coming out. Imagine no co-pays, no insane perscription costs. HUGE money savings. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

It could be used as a trial program. Instead of throwing billions at them for them to piss away, take the healthcare of their employees out of their hands. If it works there it could be expanded. Allow them to compete with auto-makers from other countries that don't have to worry about their employees healthcare. 

david --- 17 years ago -

imagine your pay check without any health insurance coming out. Imagine no co-pays, no insane perscription costs and imagine waiting years for an mri or surgery, imagine having a dr look at you that really doesnt care, imagine the govt saying no because your to old. no thanks the insurance I PAY for is fine. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

and imagine waiting years for an mri or surgery, imagine having a dr look at you that really doesnt care, imagine the govt saying no because your to old. no thanks the insurance I PAY for is fine. So, why be against a test in this cicumstance? If it doesn't work, or if the workers find it unacceptable after a pre-determined amount of time,throw it away and start over. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I guess no one likes the 40 hour work week, or worker safety rules or any of the other myriad protections that unions helped make a reality. Let's trash them all!! Without unions today - the rules governing safety would not be changed - especially since safey is now governed by the Federal goverment (OSHA). Without unions today - wages would be based on merit - some would go up others would go down. Without unions today - newer employees would have an opportunity for advancement which today unions deny them since promotions in union shops are based on seniority not merit. Hmmm, I don't see much reason to keep paying union dues - unless I really like paying for the union bosses to party it up in Miami Beach on my dues. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

Yes.... we know...all unions are pure evil. omg, i think i could actually hear you saying this in my mind. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

unions helped make a reality. I said that unions helped make these things a reality. Pointing out that OSHA exists does not preclude the fact that the forming of unions set the stage for any of the gov't worker protection to take place. Unions (like most things) have plenty of problems and downsides, but that doesn't negate the protection and upward wage push that they have provided throughout their history. There are 2 sides to every coin, to blame unions for all the problems in any industry is painting with waaay too broad a stroke. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

My best freind is a life long postal worker. They can't get rid of a bad employee if their lives depended on it....thanks to the union. Unions were created out of a need for fairness in the work place, we have laws for that now. Down with Unions. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

As Chunky is fond of saying though...let's stay on point. Would gov't healthcare be a possible way to save the auto industry? Would it be worth trying as a pilot program? The way we've thrown good money after bad I think it would be a useful alternative approach to the crises. If it worked, you could show conservative critics that gov't healthcare could help businesses reduce their costs and improve their bottom lines. If it could help businesses it would do a lot to reduce opposition. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I said that unions helped make these things a reality. Pointing out that OSHA exists does not preclude the fact that the forming of unions set the stage for any of the gov't worker protection to take place. Unions (like most things) have plenty of problems and downsides, but that doesn't negate the protection and upward wage push that they have provided throughout their history. There are 2 sides to every coin, to blame unions for all the problems in any industry is painting with waaay too broad a stroke. Unions have outlived their usefulness. I agree that when they started they were very very effective and very needed. However, now that our Government has taken over these duties the union offers no real benefit to either the employees or the employers. Well, unless you are someone who doesn't work hard and now you get raises and promotions on seniority not meri or you do a lousy job and can't be fired because of union interventions in the termination practice. 

crrc --- 17 years ago -

Just don't take it out of my check !! 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

As Chunky is fond of saying though...let's stay on point. Would gov't healthcare be a possible way to save the auto industry? Would it be worth trying as a pilot program? The way we've thrown good money after bad I think it would be a useful alternative approach to the crises. No, throwing money in to a bad business model is NOT an effective way to do business.  

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

However, now that our Government has taken over these duties the union offers no real benefit to either the employees or the employers. Well, unless you are someone who doesn't work hard and now you get raises and promotions on seniority not meri or you do a lousy job and can't be fired because of union interventions in the termination practice. I'm sure there are many union members that would disagree. This thread was not started to debate unions though. Would gov't healthcare be a possible way to save the auto industry? Would it be worth trying as a pilot program? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

If these numbers are correct would one possible solution be to take healthcare out of their hands? You clearly state If these numbers are correct . By that, I assume you do not believe they are but rather tossing out ideas. Since this is a theoretical discussion based upon IF's - what about this. GM's loss per car: $700 GM's cost per car increases in staffing related to unions and overbearing contracts: $5,500 GM profits if we remove union caused expenses: $4,800. I mean, if you can pull numbers out of a hat, so can I. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

No, throwing money in to a bad business model is NOT an effective way to do business Taking the healthcare costs out of the equation would change the business model. 

PS --- 17 years ago -

Maybe GM needs to follow Toyota's health care model. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Taking the healthcare costs out of the equation would change the business model Taking unions out of the equation would change the business model as well. Again since this is a theoretical discussion, all options should be on the table. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Great point Marcellus. Healthcare costs and retiree healthcare costs are killing a lot of companies. That's a big part of the reason why labor is cheaper in so many other countries, because the employers don't have to pay healthcare costs. Yes, their taxes may be higher, but imagine your pay check without any health insurance coming out. Imagine no co-pays, no insane perscription costs. HUGE money savings. Getting a bigger pay check is not going to work, because the same people that can't afford to pay their house note now, because they got a loan for more than they should, are going to be the same ones spending that "saved" money like there is "no tomorrow" and then looking to the government for a hand out when they are old and have none of that "extra" money. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

The numbers I found are out there. I did not check their voracity. The purpose was a theoretical discussion, about the cost of healthcare and if removing that cost would take a failing business and possibly make it profitable. Could it? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Maybe GM needs to follow Toyota's health care model And their union model as well. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

As Chunky is fond of saying though...let's stay on point. But you know I don't know how! lol 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Taking unions out of the equation would change the business model as well The union salary is not far out of line of the industry. The healthcare and retirement costs are what drives the union contract cost up. Take the healthcare out the cost comes down. 

MomofTwins* --- 17 years ago -

The company pays people NOT to work because of the union - how about we fire those people? 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

My best freind is a life long postal worker. They can't get rid of a bad employee if their lives depended on it....thanks to the union Postal Service = Government. You only get fired from a government job if you...well I can't think of anything that would get you fired from a government job. Unions have outlived their usefulness. I agree that when they started they were very very effective and very needed. This is coming from someone who tld workers in Michigan to come down to the south to get auto industry jobs in January, despite the fact Toyota, Honda, etc are laying people off and idling assembly lines as well. Having right to work (for less) laws in a state lowers wages for EVERYONE, an average worker makes $5,333 LESS. Even when adjusted for cost-of-living they still make less. Without unions today - the rules governing safety would not be changed - especially since safey is now governed by the Federal goverment (OSHA). Workers in right-to-work states are 51% more likely to die on the job and have much higher injury rates than their counterparts in other states. Look up the data yourself on the Federal Bureau of Labor Statistics website. If these numbers are correct would one possible solution be to take healthcare out of their hands? I was actually going to type up a post along these lines when I had the time, I'm glad I'm not the only one who sees a problem. Whether you work for Toyota or Ford, everyone pays into, say, Medicare. The difference is Ford also pays $1000's in health insurance that will cover them, their kids, and their spouses. The beneficiary and his/her spouse will continue to get benefits into retirement and the widow/widower will be covered. This means they will never take a penny out of the Medicare system. Toyota workers, however, will. Those working at Ford, GM, Chrysler, Mitsubishi and others (including you and I) who give their employees health benefits are subsidizing the others. YOU are paying for health insurance for Toyota employees and the Japanese bosses are pocketing the money. I will also be the first to mention that whenever you run anything through the government it will not be as efficient as private industry. So it's actually costing society MORE to cover them with Medicare than if Toyota provided good benefits through a private insurer. Joke's on you for thinking your Kentucky-made Camry is American. They are making you and I pay several hundred $/car indirectly and are laughing all the way to the bank...in Japan. They also got bailouts from the Japanese government. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Good post common. I didn't want to do the union battle thing with them. I'm glad to hear that someone else out there has had a similar thought to mine. I hope that we hear something along these lines from people in a position to make it happen. Just seems like a viable option. 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

Absurd suggestion. Why is the preferred alternative for those workers to have the government more involved in their healthcare? The better alternative is to have GM embrace the business model of US factories for Toyota, Honda, and Nissan where they are comparitively more solvent than the US brands. 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

Having right to work (for less) laws in a state lowers wages for EVERYONE, an average worker makes $5,333 LESS. Even when adjusted for cost-of-living they still make less. Workers in right-to-work states are 51% more likely to die on the job and have much higher injury rates than their counterparts in other states. Look up the data yourself on the Federal Bureau of Labor Statistics website. This comes with a trade-off. It comes down to whether or not you want more jobs at lower wages or fewer jobs at higher wages. Protecting jobs or forcing increased benefits on employers can only result in fewer jobs created. Care to ask the unemployed what their preference is? The beneficiary and his/her spouse will continue to get benefits into retirement and the widow/widower will be covered. This means they will never take a penny out of the Medicare system. I'm calling bs on the above statement. When you enroll in Medicare (everyone is eligible at age 65 if their employer paid into it - most do even though they also pay into private insurance), Medicare becomes primary and your private insurance becomes secondary. Anyone with private insurance would be a fool to turn their back on Medicare when eligible. I know of no one (not a single person) over age 65 who has not enrolled in Medicare whether they have private insurance or not. I'm sure such people do exist though. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

GM's financials are not my problem. I don't work for them and I don't own stock in their company. Hence, I shouldn't be expected to pay for their employees' healthcare. Let the company fail if it is poorly managed. There will be another to take it's place in no time. 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

GM's financials are not my problem. I don't work for them and I don't own stock in their company. Hence, I shouldn't be expected to pay for their employees' healthcare. Let the company fail if it is poorly managed. There will be another to take it's place in no time. Read my thread: You are paying for Toyota's, Honda's, Nissan's and others, and they are taking their savings straight back to the coffers in Japan. This comes with a trade-off. It comes down to whether or not you want more jobs at lower wages or fewer jobs at higher wages. Some unemployment is good for the economy. I'm calling bs on the above statement. Yes they can and will enroll in Medicare (why not?) but why would anyone want private insurance if Medicare is so great? There are a lot of large cracks in Medicare, if you fall through you either end up dead or someone else (you and I) get stuck with the bill in the end. 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

Maybe GM needs to follow Toyota's health care model The reason Toyota's per employee costs are so much lower than GM is that Toyota does not have the number of retirees GM does simply because they have not had plants in the US as long as GM has. Give them 50+ years in the US, and their per-employee costs will be roughly in line with GM since GM workers only make about $2 an hour more than Toyota employees when simply looking at salary. 

PS --- 17 years ago -

SunShine, I don't wish to open up a can of worms, but I'd like to respond to your statement. I worked for a major oil company for 32 years and retired with excellent (inexpensive) health benefits with other beneficial compensation (as an exempt employee). I'm not going to take the time out to try and develop a one-to-one comparison of the auto versus the oil companies business plans, but it appears to me, on the surface, that the American auto industry needs a new model. I understand your husband is in the petro-chemical business and I wish him well, it's tough work. Again, I'm not one to belabor a point, which has become all to prevalent on KU, I just wanted to respond. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

"When you enroll in Medicare (everyone is eligible at age 65 if their employer paid into it - most do even though they also pay into private insurance), Medicare becomes primary and your private insurance becomes secondary. Anyone with private insurance would be a fool to turn their back on Medicare when eligible. I know of no one (not a single person) over age 65 who has not enrolled in Medicare whether they have private insurance or not. I'm sure such people do exist though. " my DH is not enrolled in medicare and he is over 65, but still working. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground