Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Mortgage Question: Principle vs. Escrow

who's talking here?

Denise C 1
kpcmom 2
NYer 2
jjfingrainalready 1
rose8304 3
AuthorMan 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
KWPlanner 3
Cicero 1
JBelle 3
KBM'SMOM 1
chunksNbones 1
dirtygert 1
jtcitrus 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

Every year my monthly payment changes. The bank goes through the escrow payments and what have you and decides that we should pay more into it because of taxes or homeowner's insurance or whatever. If I were to make some extra payments towards my mortgage (not a lot, maybe $100 to $200 every month or so) would it be better to go towards the escrow or the principle. If I put it towards the principle, they house may be paid off a year or so early or if I ever refinance, I may have slightly less to refinance. If I put it towards the escrow, then the next time they refigure my monthly payment, it will be lower, not higher. I am not an expert, so I could be missing some key info, that's why I'm asking. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

Principle. 

KBM'SMOM --- 17 years ago -

we pay extra to the principle on our home so it will be paid off faster 

JBelle --- 17 years ago -

In our case, paying extra to the escrow helps only if you expect to receive a bill for the shortage. Our mortgage company does not factor in extra payments made when they re-calculate our escrow every year. My advice-pay down the principal!! Hope that makes sense. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Principle. 

kpcmom --- 17 years ago -

Principle. If you pay an extra $100 month, I've heard that you can pay a 30 yr. mortgage in almost half the time. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

In our case, paying extra to the escrow helps only if you expect to receive a bill for the shortage. Our mortgage company does not factor in extra payments made when they re-calculate our escrow every year. We do actually get bills but they have the option of paying the extra now all at once or spreading out over two years. They've refigured our payment twice and both times it went up although this year's was not by much. I would just really love to get my monthly payment down and thought that if it was the escrow that raised it so much, that would be the way to lower it. After we'd been in the house for a year, they refigured it and it raised our payment by $300 a month and that was after we asked them to spread it over 24 months instead of 12!! Our house is new construction, so our property taxes were way higher by then. 

dirtygert --- 17 years ago -

principle and pay as much as you can extra. I only wish I would have do so earlier. 

KWPlanner --- 17 years ago -

Rose, it's hard to give a definitive answer based solely on the information you gave. From a mortgage standpoint, when it comes to applying excess available cash flow, you will almost always want to have it applied to principal. However, the true correct answer depends on your overall financial picture. Before you consider using excess cash to pay down your mortgage, make sure you can answer 'yes' to the following questions: 1. Do I have a basic emergency fund of $1,000 socked away in a very liquid account? 2. Do I have no credit card debt or auto loans outstanding? 3. Do I have a fully-funded emergency fund, which is the equivalent to 3-6 months of living expenses? 4. Am I making full use of all retirement plans available to me, such as a 401(k), traditional IRA, or Roth IRA? Only until you can answer 'yes' to these questions should someone consider using excess monthly cash flow against the principal of their mortgage. Hope this helps. I'd be more than happy to help you in greater detail if you'd like. Just let me know! 

kpcmom --- 17 years ago -

They've refigured our payment twice and both times it went up although this year's was not by much That's exactly why, when we refinanced, we chose to escrow our own taxes/insurance. If it was too low, they would cushion our monthly escrow to make sure they weren't out extra money during tax time. It there was an excess, they would send us the check and figure our monthly too low. We got tired of the yo-yo every year. 

JBelle --- 17 years ago -

The first year we were in our house (also new construction) we knew the escrow was way under-calculated so we paid extra each month. When our escrow analysis came the next year, our company did not factor in the payments we made and still raised our total monthly payment because their #s still showed a shortage (even after I called and argued). Call your co. and ask if you aren't sure. I'd hate for you to make payments to escrow only to have them used but ignored when it comes time for your annual escrow analysis. 

NYer --- 17 years ago -

Always to the principle. That will reduce your interest on outstanding balance. Paying towards the escrow will just temporarily reduce those payments. 

NYer --- 17 years ago -

The first year we were in our house (also new construction) we knew the escrow was way under-calculated so we paid extra each month. When our escrow analysis came the next year, our company did not factor in the payments we made and still raised our total monthly payment because their #s still showed a shortage (even after I called and argued). They could not have completely ignored your additional payments. Perhaps they applied them to principle instead. It could be that you still paid more because even though you paid additionally, you still didn't pay enough. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

Paying towards the escrow will just temporarily reduce those payments. That's what I was looking for. I wanted to have lower payments which would free up some money to do those things that KWPlanner mentioned. Then when I'd done all those things, I could apply that money towards the principle. To KWPlanner: 1. not really 2. I only have an auto loan, no credit card debt 3. No 4. I do have a 401K 

JBelle --- 17 years ago -

They could not have completely ignored your additional payments. They didn't. They were applied to the escrow account and kept us from receiving a bill for the shortage but the extra payments did not keep our mortgage co from raising our escrow payment (and total payment) the following year which is what I'm reading that the OP is wanting to do. It could be that you still paid more because even though you paid additionally, you still didn't pay enough.  Also not the case. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

I cannot imagine paying more into escrow over principle. If you have a couple of extra hundred each month, pay the principle down. Putting into escrow does not save you anything, it just gives the bank more to play with. 

KWPlanner --- 17 years ago -

If you have $100 or $200 extra each month right now then start working on the basic emergency fund ($1,000 in the bank). Even if you have $0 right now, you could conceivably have this done by the end of the year. Until you have that done, along with the other items I listed, I wouldn't worry about paying down your mortgage. Let me know if I can answer any questions for ya! :) 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

Principle because they will refund you the overage in escrow at the end of the year. This it would be pointless to send in extra money to escrow. They base each years escrow on what they expect to pay out for the year based on what they just paid out the prior year regardless of if you paid in an extra $500 or whatever. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

KW, are one of those Dave Ramsey affiliated planners? Cause that all looked familiar... Always pay off debt on depreciating assets FIRST. Your home retains/grows its value for the most part and the interest is deductible (if you can beat the standard deduction). Cars drop in value quickly and charge higher interest generally. and nothing depreciates faster than a burger you buy on credit in a weak moment because you didn't have any cash. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Principal, and try to get a 15-year note if you can. With a 30-year note, you spend the first seven years basically paying interest, and almost nothing toward your actual debt. 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

all I know is that we are going to pay down our credit card debt before we pay anything extra on the house And those suckers raised our payment $300 this year. We re-fi'ed last year and our payment has DOUBLED since then (we didn't escrow before). No wonder people are losing their houses. UGH. 

KWPlanner --- 17 years ago -

KW, are one of those Dave Ramsey affiliated planners? Cause that all looked familiar... Although I am not an ELP (Endorsed Local Provider) for the Dave Ramsey program, I have taught his course at our church for the past five or six years. Another one will be starting soon, so keep your eyes out!) I use his principles with all of my clients and it works wonders! all I know is that we are going to pay down our credit card debt before we pay anything extra on the house That's the right approach, chunks! Just make sure, though, you have an emergency fund established as well. More times than not the credit cards will be used to pick up the slack if an emergency comes up, and you're right back where you started! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground