Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Re: the Bush 1991 Classroom Speech...The Outraged Dems "Then"

who's talking here?

randyjet 10
qpc 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
ladybeachbum 1
Mabbers 6
txdaddy 6
Vedette 1
AFWife 2
david 4
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 1
fishlady 2
Meme2my5 1
OH SNAP! 2
Allimama 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
voice of reason 1
ladyjane 2
*momof5* 3
Bringit 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

link Flashback 1991: Gephardt Called Bush's Speech to Students 'Paid Political Advertising' By Noel Sheppard (Bio | Archive) September 3, 2009 - 10:45 ET As Barack Obama prepares a nationwide broadcast to America's students next Tuesday, it has been revealed that Democrats complained in 1991 when then President George H. W. Bush broadcast a speech from a Northwest Washington junior high school. In fact, the House Majority leader at the time, Dick Gephardt (D-Mo.), said "The Department of Education should not be producing paid political advertising for the president, it should be helping us to produce smarter students." Such was reported by the Washington Post on October 3, 1991 (h/t KY3 Political Notebook via Chuck Todd): House Democrats criticized President Bush yesterday for using Education Department funds to produce and broadcast a speech that he made Tuesday at a Northwest Washington junior high school. The Democratic critics accused Bush of turning government money for education to his own political use, namely, an ongoing effort to inoculate himself against their charges of inattention to domestic issues. The speech at Alice Deal Junior High School, broadcast live on radio and television, urged students to study hard, avoid drugs and turn in troublemakers. "The Department of Education should not be producing paid political advertising for the president, it should be helping us to produce smarter students," House Majority Leader Richard A. Gephardt (D-Mo.) said. "And the president should be doing more about education than saying, 'Lights, camera, action.' " Two House committees demanded that the department explain the use of its funds for the speech, an explanation that Deputy Secretary David T. Kearns provided late in the day in a letter to Rep. William D. Ford (D-Mich.), chairman of the House Education and Labor Committee. Education Secretary Lamar Alexander was out of town. [...] Rep. Patricia Schroeder (D-Colo.), chairwoman of the Select Committee on Children, Youth and Families, said it was outrageous for the White House to "start using precious dollars for campaigns" when "we are struggling for every silly dime we can get" for education programs. Rep. Martin Frost (D-Tex.) said that if Bush feels obliged to use government funds to hire outside consultants "to make him look good," then he should fire some of the public relations experts on the White House payroll. "Then the president might be more sympathetic to unemployment benefits," Frost said, referring to Bush's threat to veto legislation to extend benefits. Makes one wonder if today's media, with the economy in what they've repeatedly called the worst recession since the Great Depression, will question Obama's use of education funds for his upcoming speech. After all, when you look at Education Secretary Arne Duncan's letter concerning this event, one has to assume it's costing the Department a great deal of money.  

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

Ooooh! BURN! 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

That's 3 comments about it. Did they burn up the talk show airwaves? Did they scream about indoctrination? Did anyone urge anyone to keep their children home from school? Not even close to what is going on here. Lame attempt to say that the reaction was the same from liberals when Bush did it, when in truth no one really paid any attention to it. Hell, nobody could even remember if a president had done it before, if it had been controversial it would have been remembered. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

No MW, but then they weren't lucky enough to have KU..lol.. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, I love how they're making it out like these situations are similar. FIRST, who cares if a few politicians postured about it? That's what they do. SECOND, I haven't seen any indication the public gave a rat's arse one way or another, including dems. THIRD, his presentation went on as scheduled without people calling up the schools crying about it. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Ooooh! BURN! Not hardly. Bush was then running for re-election at the time. Obama is NOT. You also forgot to say how many schools refused to put Bush's address on. I'll bet that there were NONE which decided NOT to show it. You also forgot to mention how many parents objected to it. In short, it is hardly the same in any way, other than a few Democratic leaders objected to it. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

FIRST, who cares if a few politicians postured about it? That's what they do. yep SECOND, I haven't seen any indication the public gave a rat's arse one way or another, including dems. so you feel the communications outlets of 1991 were even close to what we have now? i would imagine those that did complain prob did it to their neighbors and or the school. i would also imagine those complaints are not immediately available as the means of retrieving them would be extremely cumbersome now...in other words, google really wasn't all that back then. THIRD, his presentation went on as scheduled without people calling up the schools crying about it. again, another amusing assumption. you, nor I, have no idea of knowing if this happened or not. i am not going to say that it did happen because there is really no way of knowing. i do give it the possibility, well probability, that it happened. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

Not hardly. Bush was then running for re-election at the time. Obama is NOT. You also forgot to say how many schools refused to put Bush's address on. I'll bet that there were NONE which decided NOT to show it. You also forgot to mention how many parents objected to it. In short, it is hardly the same in any way, other than a few Democratic leaders objected to it. extremely short sighted of you randy. how would one go about proving that parents objected or anything else? the main form of communication back then would have been the newspaper or tv news. do you really believe that info is readily available now? 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

Not hardly. Bush was then running for re-election at the time. Obama is NOT. You also forgot to say how many schools refused to put Bush's address on. I'll bet that there were NONE which decided NOT to show it. You also forgot to mention how many parents objected to it. In short, it is hardly the same in any way, other than a few Democratic leaders objected to it.  And I'll bet hardly anybody had a problem with Clinton addressing school children, either, even with all his socializing. Even if he spoke today, not many people would think he'd go beyond the do-well-in-school message. Doesn't the country's surprising reaction highlight how much people have come to not trust Obama and his agenda? Even if his comments are truly innocuous, people have an uneasy feeling about him. You have to say, the exercises his team were proposing the kids do after his speech were different from what any previous president would have put forth - Although they later retracted these, for many people it added to the Chairman Mao feeling they'd already been getting. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

of course - they had a REASON to be upset, it was President Bush you know and he was just EVIL and everything he did was wrong and and and...... blah blah blah. There is always justification for the democrats to act out but they are so upset when someone does it to them. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I agree with ladyjane. You act like the mistrust is the problem of the people, rather than a problem with this administration! 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

the main form of communication back then would have been the newspaper or tv news. do you really believe that info is readily available now? As a matter of FACT it is. Most papers have put their archives on line. Also I have a very good memory about politics since I have been active in it. I do NOT recall any such protest on the part of many people about Bush doing this. I know I sure didn't care one way or the other. Plus the big news back then was Perot and the deficit, NAFTA and the economy. There were a LOT more important things to worry about than Bush talking to kids in school. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Well there it is randy said it didn't happen lock the thread the end all knows all has spoken, since randy says all papers are archived I will do some research this weekend and see how the liberal states treated the speech. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I will do some research this weekend and see how the liberal states treated the speech. I was living in northern CA at the time, a rather liberal state, and I don't recall any such outrage there. I was in SF, Oakland area. There is also NO question that Bush was in his campaign for re-election. I don't think you can compare that time with Obama now. 

david --- 17 years ago -

You don't recall I will look up the liberal states newspapers and see what it says, we all know all those kids are going to make the difference in the election, acorn wasn't there registering voters so I'm sure they didn't vote in the election 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

As a matter of FACT it is. Most papers have put their archives on line. Also I have a very good memory about politics since I have been active in it. I do NOT recall any such protest on the part of many people about Bush doing this. I know I sure didn't care one way or the other. ok then. you convinced me, i trust YOUR memory. everyone knows as you get older, the memory gets better...right? 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

I was living in northern CA at the time, a rather liberal state, and I don't recall any such outrage there. I was in SF, Oakland area. There is also NO question that Bush was in his campaign for re-election. I don't think you can compare that time with Obama now. if you think this is anything more than a photo-op with these kids, you are even more misguided than i thought. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

everyone knows as you get older, the memory gets better...right? Really? Well hot damn. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

if you think this is anything more than a photo-op with these kids, I think that Obama's own life history is a great lesson for kids. He came from a single mother family whose father left him at a very early age. Worked hard in school, made his way on his own with scholarships, went to one of the top law schools in the world. Turned down the opportunity to be a millionaire out of law school to do what he wanted in law and public service. Unlike our last Pres, who was born into wealth, got ahead on his family connections and wealth, and screwed around for a couple of years partying while others were fighting and dying in Vietnam. Then he goes to Harvard Business School, bankrupts two businesses, gets bailed out by his family and friends, avoids prosecution for insider trading by using his connections with the administration. I would rather kids learn from Obama's life story than Bush's. I think that Obama saying work hard, stay in school has more effect by his own story than Bush's. Don't you? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

everyone knows as you get older, the memory gets better...right? You didn't see Space Cowboys did you? THAT PROVES we get better! 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

I think that Obama's own life history is a great lesson for kids. He came from a single mother family whose father left him at a very early age. Worked hard in school, made his way on his own with scholarships, went to one of the top law schools in the world. Turned down the opportunity to be a millionaire out of law school to do what he wanted in law and public service so he is talking about staying in school or his life? Unlike our last Pres, who was born into wealth, got ahead on his family connections and wealth, and screwed around for a couple of years partying while others were fighting and dying in Vietnam. Then he goes to Harvard Business School, bankrupts two businesses, gets bailed out by his family and friends, avoids prosecution for insider trading by using his connections with the administration. I would rather kids learn from Obama's life story than Bush's. HUGE difference between you and I. I do not begrudge people who are born into wealth. I think that Obama saying work hard, stay in school has more effect by his own story than Bush's. Don't you? i don't either are more effective than the parents and/or teachers of the children. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

You didn't see Space Cowboys did you? nope. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I do not begrudge people who are born into wealth. I don't either. I DO judge them on what they DO with that wealth and opportunity. Bush was more like the idle rich in his early life than the Kennedys. He sure didn't bust his butt on his last job either. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

You didn't see Space Cowboys did you? nope It is a Clint Eastwood film and I suggest you rent it. You can be sure it is free of liberal taint if Eastwood does it, and it won't pollute your mind or outrage you. It might piss off some MIT grads though. My Dad would have hated it for that. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

so he is talking about staying in school or his life? I don't know yet since I haven't read the speech, but I think that BOTH would be an inspiration to lots of kids who ARE at risk. He can truthfully say, look what CAN happen in this country. AS some black leaders have pointed out, there are NO more excuses folks. It is YOUR choice NOW! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

ok then. you convinced me, i trust YOUR memory. everyone knows as you get older, the memory gets better...right? how old are you, txdaddy? so you feel the communications outlets of 1991 were even close to what we have now? While I agree that constant communication is 100% to blame in this scenario, I also know people didn't get up in arms over stuff then, like they do today. I remember in 7th grade the teacher handing out flyers about boycotting Proctor and Gamble products because the owners were devil-worshippers! Can you imagine what would happen if a teacher handed that flyer out today? We live in a bizarre world where paranoia has replaced commonsense. I hope we're able to reverse it at some point in the very near future. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

We live in a bizarre world where paranoia has replaced commonsense. Exactly. With immediate information, how awesome and detrimental at the same time? Who doesn't look at pharmaceutical commercials and think, "Hey...I have some of those symptoms!" Not entirely necessary anymore to think for yourself. LOL. 

qpc --- 17 years ago -

I was in high school in 1991 and Bush's speech was not televised in our classrooms or at an assembly. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I was in high school in 1991 me too, I graduated that year. BUT, if it was televised in the fall, then I would have missed it since I graduated in May. 

Bringit --- 17 years ago -

The point of the thread was the Dem's protested Bush's speech to the school students. But, it is ok for Obama. Right? because he is a Democrat! 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

But, it is ok for Obama. Right? because he is a Democrat! Only if you're a democrat. Each is president is gonna "get it" from the other side. Always has. Always will. 

Bringit --- 17 years ago -

Only if you're a democrat. Each is president is gonna "get it" from the other side. Always has. Always will. Exactly. Thanks JMABS 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

The point of the thread was the Dem's protested Bush's speech to the school students. But, it is ok for Obama. Right? because he is a Democrat! Thank you. Internet wasn't internet like now...neither was technology... Either way, I'm still not for addressing the kid's in school, it can wait until they get home. (As I said, my 4th grader has 7 subjects & tests almost daily and has had to overcome some learning obstacles the last couple of years so there is no time in the school day for this). 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Very interesting. Are republicans now turning to "but the democrats did it too"? 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Are republicans now turning to "but the democrats did it too"?  

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

JMABS, you crack me up!!! 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

You said crack. Heh heh. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I think the only place they did not play Bush's talk was in the Peoples Republic of Berkeley. 

ladybeachbum --- 17 years ago -

I'm so tired of Obama antics that I want to turn him off at any mention, but know he is the man to watch. Bush may have gotten us in war out of our borders but O's much more scary right here in the US. This school thing is just smoke for something bigger. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground