Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*Obama sells out again agreeing to lift a Ban on Commercial Whaling

who's talking here?

randyjet 7
Mommee 3
Mabbers 4
justforfun 1
rEVOLution 9
Warren Peace 3
Ogre1 4
MxMike. 1
Baldeagle 1
A Simple Equation 1
needrnr 1
LiveFreeOrDie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I know that a lot of people could care less about saving the whales but after seeing how they treat these animals I find it disgusting that our government wants to lift the ban on whaling. It's equally disgusting how the FDA allows the treatment of the animals that we eat but what can we do? http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2010/06/05/obama-backing-deal-lift-global-ban-commercial-whaling/ Obama Under Fire for Backing Deal to Lift Global Ban on Commercial Whaling Environmentalists, already peeved with the administration’s handling of the Gulf oil spill, are accusing President Obama of breaking his campaign pledge to end the slaughter of whales. The Obama administration is leading an effort within the International Whaling Commission to lift a 24-year international ban on commercial whaling for Japan, Norway and Iceland, the remaining three countries in the 88-member commission that still hunt whales. The administration argues that the new deal will save thousands of whales over the next decade by stopping the three countries from illegally exploiting loopholes in the moratorium. But environmentalists aren't buying it. "That moratorium on commercial whaling was the greatest conservation victory of the 20th century. And in 2010 to be waving the white flag or bowing to the stubbornness of the last three countries engaged in the practice is a mind-numbingly dumb idea," Patrick Ramage, the whaling director at the International Fund for Animal Welfare, told FoxNews.com. Several environmental groups have joined forces to pressure Obama to withdraw his support for the deal before the whaling commission votes June 20 in Morocco on whether to lift the ban that was championed by President Reagan. The groups have run ads in major newspapers highlighting Obama's campaign promise in 2008 to "strengthen the moratorium on commercial whaling," adding that "allowing Japan to continue commercial whaling is unacceptable." "We ask you to honor your promise, stop the sellout, and save the whales," the ad reads. The White House did not respond to an e-mail seeking comment. Under Obama's deal, the three whaling countries would be allowed to keep hunting whales for a 10-year period in reduced numbers. The whaling countries in return would agree to tighter oversight of their operations, including participation in a whale DNA registry. "We recognize that these measures do not meet the needs of those who want a complete end to whaling now, but neither can it be characterized as a whalers' charter," the whaling commission said in a press release announcing the proposal. "We believe that it is undeniably better than the status quo." Meanwhile a colleague of Peter Bethune, the Animal Planet star awaiting trial in Tokyo after a collision between his anti-whaling boat and a Japanese ship, says the environmental activist is doing what the international community refuses to do -- save the whales. The 1986 moratorium unquestionably reduced the number of whales killed each year. But it's not as clear by how much. Some estimate that an average of 38,000 whales were killed each year before the moratorium reduced it to an average of 1,240. Ramage said as many as 60,000 whales were killed before the moratorium -- a figure that he says has been cut to about 1,700 per year. "To say that the moratorium doesn't work, that is a conscious effort to mislead or a complete misreading of the facts," Ramage said, adding that "throwing it overboard in the name of good feeling and cooperation and conciliation with Japan is jaw dropping." Joel Reynolds, senior attorney and director of the Natural Resources Defense Council's marine mammal protection program, added that the deal is "a step backward, to a time when it was acceptable to kill whales for profit." "The moratorium has done more to save whales than the revival of commercial whaling ever could," he said in a written statement. "We will do everything we can to stop it – and to persuade the Obama administration that it should too." The whaling commission says it developed the proposal to improve its performance on whale conservation and the management of whaling. "Given the wide range of views of our members, it had to be a compromise proposal," said Cristian Maquieira, head of the IWC. "And that inevitably means that no one gets everything they want. "Given the criticism we have received from all sides, we are probably not far off the correct balance. If we did not believe that this proposal was good for whales and considerably better than the present situation then we would not have put our names to it."  

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Damned environmentalists. They're ultimately to blame for the oil spill. Kudos to O for putting them in their place. Palin's FB: Extreme Enviros: Drill, Baby, Drill in ANWR – Now Do You Get It? Share Wednesday, 02 June 2010 at 14:17 This is a message to extreme “environmentalists” who hypocritically protest domestic energy production offshore and onshore. There is nothing “clean and green” about your efforts. Look, here’s the deal: when you lock up our land, you outsource jobs and opportunity away from America and into foreign countries that are making us beholden to them. Some of these countries don’t like America. Some of these countries don’t care for planet earth like we do – as evidenced by our stricter environmental standards. With your nonsensical efforts to lock up safer drilling areas, all you’re doing is outsourcing energy development, which makes us more controlled by foreign countries, less safe, and less prosperous on a dirtier planet. Your hypocrisy is showing. You’re not preventing environmental hazards; you’re outsourcing them and making drilling more dangerous. Extreme deep water drilling is not the preferred choice to meet our country’s energy needs, but your protests and lawsuits and lies about onshore and shallow water drilling have locked up safer areas. It’s catching up with you. The tragic, unprecedented deep water Gulf oil spill proves it. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Extreme deep water drilling is not the preferred choice to meet our country’s energy needs, but your protests and lawsuits and lies about onshore and shallow water drilling have locked up safer areas. It’s catching up with you. The tragic, unprecedented deep water Gulf oil spill proves it. Ditto 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Bottom line is that it's all about some folks making a heck of a lot of money. Period. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Bottom line is that it's all about some folks making a heck of a lot of money. Period. I don't get it, is that politicianese? :P 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

LOL What I meant was that either oil or whaling, it's all about the rich getting richer. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

What I meant was that either oil or whaling, it's all about the rich getting richer. Just kidding. Remember, I've been dumbed down. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

"To say that the moratorium doesn't work, that is a conscious effort to mislead or a complete misreading of the facts," Ramage said, adding that "throwing it overboard in the name of good feeling and cooperation and conciliation with Japan is jaw dropping." I think that is a good response and I am glad that Obama has enough sense to make science the basis for policy instead of emotion. There is NOTHING WRONG with killing whales for their meat and other products. We have done it for thousands of years. Eventually I hope that whales will return to levels that will allow for sustainable harvesting of them. I am against killing wolves NOW in the lower 48 and against aerial killing in AK that Palin is so HOT to do. Eventually, I hope that the wolf populations will get to such levels as to allow their hunting once more. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

LOL What I meant was that either oil or whaling, it's all about the rich getting richer. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I don't know why it just reposted what I said 16 minutes ago, I typed a paragraph in response to randy's statement. I'm not retyping it all right, LOL This site is a pain in the @ss 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

All about the money... "The poor get poorly paid to hold a ladder while the rich get ricocheted into the stratosphere" 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

There is NOTHING WRONG with killing whales for their meat and other products. I'll be disagreeing with you on that RJ. By that logic anything a society has done for a long time is a good thing.. you know, like burning/hanging witches, female castration, and slavery. this is the 21st Century, there is no product that the whales produce that hasn't been replaced in CIVILIZED countries. And at least in Japan the number of people who actually eat whale are in the single digit percentages. Subsistence whaling by indigenous people (including coastal whaling in Japan)is not an issue, they take few whales. but the Japanese whaling fleet down in the Antarctic takes about 50 Humpbacks a year, that's 50 whales that will never breed again. And since the humpback population worldwide is only about 80,000, EVERY SINGLE WHALE is important. Especially since whales breed only ever two to three years and then take a year to give birth. What is equally offensive is that every bit of whale found in Japan is from "research activities". So those ships that are marked "research" down South.... they're just another form of lie. Additionally, the Japanese claim that whaling is integral to their culture and they've been doing it for hundreds of years. Also a lie. Until the Black Fleet forced Japan was under the policy of Sakoku, or seclusion. The United States, through the person of Commodore M. Perry starting in 1853 forced Japan to open its borders to trade. Before that Japan performed small scale coastal whaling NOT large-scale factory whaling they are practicing in the Antarctic. So all this Whaling as research, whaling as economic necessity, whaling as culture cr@P is just that CR@P. No one NEEDS to whale any more. A hundred years ago, yeah, there were few choices for some things. Today, the only reason it is done is greed, and stupidity. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

And since the humpback population worldwide is only about 80,000, EVERY SINGLE WHALE is important. Especially since whales breed only ever two to three years and then take a year to give birth. Eventually there will be enough whales to allow people to take them again. At what level do you think is right? From what I can gather your position is NEVER under any circumstances at any time. I think that is absurd. Whaling is hardly like burning your co-thinkers, unless you are swimming and are worried about whalers. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

No one NEEDS to whale any more. A hundred years ago, yeah, there were few choices for some things. Today, the only reason it is done is greed, and stupidity. Ditto ditto! 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Ogre1 Thank you for posting the common sense explanation that I was wanted to post but I don't know enough about the topic, I just know I don't like it. Whales are not cattle or chickens, they are extremely intelligent mammals and I just think that if they have to be hunted there should be a more humane way of doing it that shooting an RPG harpoon into their backs and having to suffer such a horrific death for no reason. Like you said, there's no necessity for killing them these days and they certainly are not over populating the oceans. 

Mommee --- 16 years ago -

I think that anything that is in the ocean, needs to stay there...especially if it is over 1 ton! Maybe start eating shark? lol 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Maybe start eating shark? lol Sadly that's a whole other tragedy... Shark Finning 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Maybe start eating shark? lol Shark steak is awesome. 

Mommee --- 16 years ago -

I wonder if other countries get all mad about us eating cow? I mean, we breed them to eat them...so it's so not the same...but still, I wonder... 

Baldeagle --- 16 years ago -

Animals put on earth by god for man!!!!!!!!! 

Mommee --- 16 years ago -

Whales are just cool tho. Sharks are scary, so I can't help but have less pity on them. And I agree that God gave us animals to eat, but also to look at and adore :) (tho that's not in the Bible.) 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Whales are not cattle or chickens, they are extremely intelligent mammals That is NOT the question, and I doubt that I would be eager to eat whale in any case. The Real question is do WE have the right to DICTATE OUR views of what is the right thing to eat to others? Absent a threat to the existence of some species, I think that eventually hunting whales is perfectly legitimate. I am a BIG dog lover and I love dogs. I would not think of mandating a world wide BAN on eating them and impose penalties for eating them. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Animals put on earth by god for man!!!!!!!!! For man's survival, not greed. But you're correct. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I am a BIG dog lover and I love dogs. I would not think of mandating a world wide BAN on eating them and impose penalties for eating them. All valid points but there are far more dogs in the world than there are whales. Whales have a specific duty in the balance of our oceans, dogs don't hold a lot of balance in mans survival. There might be some question as to over population of whales in the oceans but I don't think we are even close to that being an issue. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

There might be some question as to over population of whales Again that is NOT the issue. The issue is what is the sustainable harvest of whales? Some folks think that there is NO such point. That is simply not rational or scientific. Then you have the question of whether on not the US should dictate what other nations should view as legitimate food. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

From what I can gather your position is NEVER under any circumstances at any time My position is that there is absolutely NO REASON to take a whales of any sort on a commercial level. And it is completely intellectually dishonest to compare a slow-breeding apex animal like a whale with a fast breeding species like canines. As to sharks, that is a whole other can of worms (or bucket of chum?). They are likely the most over fished sport fish in the world to start with, and then you have the commercial poaching of sharks for their fins, which is completely out of control. Don't like sharks? Think about what happens when an Apex predator is hunted to extinction. The creatures it predates then explode and generally wreak havoc on US. People don't realize, or don't want to realize that we do depend on a certain balance with nature. Don't believe me? Ask an Australian how they fell about rabbits. Just because a critter isn't Disneyesque cuddly doesn't mean that critter isn't important to you and me! And not just because we can make some sort of financial gain from it!!! To be completely honest, I think a world-wide moratorium on commercial fishing would NOT be a bad thing. Then years, park the boats. It would cost governments some money (a good bit of money) but may avoid a potential disaster before the turn of the century. Fisheries are much like land crops. If you don't rotate out your crops, eventually the soil is used up and won't grow anything. The same is true with fisheries. If you keep going back to the same pond (Even if that pond is the Pacific Ocean), eventually there won't be any more fish. We're fishing out the Tuna, one of the most important food sources in the world. We're destroying the Atlantic Salmon with our aquaculture techniques. They used to catch 500 lb Halibut, 100 years ago. Now if they catch 80-100 lb fish they're happy. AND THAT'S STUPID because they're catching immature fish that haven't even bred yet. Never mind what things like the oil spill will do to the Gulf for the foreseeable future. SOME scientist think that we keep up current growth levels of commercial fishing we'll have completely fished out the current commercial breeds within fifty years. Those that we haven't killed off with pollution that is. One very good resource to learn about this is the Moneterey Bay Aquarium. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

My position is that there is absolutely NO REASON to take a whales of any sort on a commercial level Since I am not a marine biologist, I can hardly say whether there is a sustainable level of commercial whaling. My guess is that there is, and I think that simply saying never to it is not realistic nor scientific. I have no question that the worlds oceans are being overfished, but that again, is something for experts to determine as to the yields and time, not just gut feelings and prejudices of some. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

The administration argues that the new deal will save thousands of whales over the next decade by stopping the three countries from illegally exploiting loopholes in the moratorium. What the heck kind of math is that? Lifting the ban (letting them hunt whales) will actually increase the population? That's stunningly similar to the logic of plunging us into a massively debilitating debt in order to save the economy. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

This is a HUGE challenge for environmentalists. Do they continue to walk in lockstep with this administration, or do they cling to their credibility as environmental activists? 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Just in case anybody missed it - Japan, Norway, and Iceland were identified as the villains in this article. It says they are the only nations that still hunt whales - despite the current ban. So this administration takes the position that the way to increase the population - is to lift the ban. Please tell me what I'm missing here. Isn't that like saying the way to curb illegal drug use is to make it legal? Or the way to decrease illegal immigration is to open our borders? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Or the way to decrease illegal immigration is to open our borders? By definition that would eliminate illegal immigration. My guess is that there is I'm not marine biologist either, but I doubt 80,000 of any species is sustainable. Remember we are talking about the entire world. So that's not a good indicator of the population of a particular area. And Whales of one location almost never cohabitate with whales of another. As to the politics involved. I disagree with the rationale. What we need to do is use our Navies to enforce the ban. Confiscate ships that are violating it, and sell them for conservation efforts. We also need to get idiots like Sea Shepherd and Green Peace out of the way so that real work can be done to end the harvest. I mean, really, have you ever seen a more pathetic bunch of losers than Sea Shepherd? Really, Sea Shepherd, you AIN'T PIRATES no matter how many times you try to make yourself out to be, you don't have the nads! 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

You think this is bad, watch this... Earthlings  

LiveFreeOrDie --- 16 years ago -

Whales are not cattle or chickens, they are extremely intelligent mammals and I just think that if they have to be hunted there should be a more humane way of doing it that shooting an RPG harpoon into their backs and having to suffer such a horrific death for no reason. Like you said, there's no necessity for killing them these days and they certainly are not over populating the oceans. Ditto +1 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

So this administration takes the position that the way to increase the population - is to lift the ban. The fact is that there has been NO complete ban ever. There has been limited harvesting going on all the time. Thus to get a reduction, one has to come to agreements that will reduce those hauls. One never gets all that one wants in negotiations. Also, there is NO way to enforce a complete BAN with the US going it alone, unless you want to go to war. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Also, there is NO way to enforce a complete BAN with the US going it alone, unless you want to go to war. I'd be happy to get a crew together and go a-privateering! Nothing says that Congress can't issue Letters of Marque! Give me a couple of Frigates and free reign! 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Give me a couple of Frigates and free reign! Sign me up! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground