Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you think promotions should be based on seniority?

who's talking here?

randyjet 1
planemom 1
AuthorMan 1
Baroness 1
david 2
justforfun 1
Perfection 7
Meme2my5 1
Nightstorm 2
zapper007 1
RedMulch 1
Dr Aborto 1
Work in Progress 2
The Livable Forest Gump 1
Gang Starr 1
Bornanraisedkw 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think promotions should be based on seniority?

Is it fair for someone to receive a promotion based on seniority only.

Yes Vote
 
 10.5% (4)
No Vote
 
 89.5% (34)
david --- 16 years ago -

Is it fair for someone to receive a promotion based on seniority only. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Seriously?

In this day?

Um NO.

Performance. Give me a chance to succeed and if you want to keep up, then do it. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

You could work at a place for years and never do a good job. Why should that person get a promotion and his only contribution was showing up for work? 

RedMulch --- 16 years ago -

No..but does it happen? Yes 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Equal opportunity, not equal outcomes. Don't fence me in 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I would love to hear from someone who votes yes. 

Baroness --- 16 years ago -

I do think that a long-term employee's value over time should be considered versus a newcomer with all the energy in the world, trying to make a great impression to start with. It's easy to give your all in the first few months of starting a new job, versus delivering a consistently superior performance in the long run. But, in the end, a heck of a lot more than seniority should figure into selecting a person ready for promotion. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

If they are qualified for the job, then seniority should be the determining factor. I worked in a union job at the refinery, and the top job was not given only on seniority, but they had to be qualified to do it.

In the airlines the equipment is given by seniority since all pilots are equally qualified, unless they bust the upgrade or new equipment. If you don't make the grade, you don't get the job. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I think that in most industries, performance matters A LOT more than seniority. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

I think it should be by performance but a lot of big companies do it by seniority. In my early 20's I worked at the Sears Service Center for 2 years. Didn't matter if you were the slowest and least productive. The longer your there the more you made. 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

Absolutely. No young wippersnapper or fressh-talking smartalec should ever be promoted over a white-haired senior.

Why do you think they are greeters at WalMart. Not because they are competent. That's because they are older than dirt...lol 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Also for promotions it really isn't about how well you do the job you are currently in, but rather how well you will do the job you will be promoted to.

Sometimes people are great technicians at one level but fail at another. The key is finding the right level for everyone so they are being utilized to their fullest and most efficiently.


Sure, people like more money that comes with a promotion but studies have shown that job satisfactions and feeling like you belong mean more than money.

So no, seniority shouldn't because that may not be what is best for both the business AND the employee. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

You have to give the business owner some credit in deciding who would fit best in what position. If he is the one taking the risk to build the business, he sure as heck needs the freedom to choose the right people for the job! And like you said, it has nothing to do with how you are doing in the present job, and everything to do with how your performance would be once promoted. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Alli.Sneaks.On you are right on the money there.

If you require promotions to be based upon seniority then you remove the need for the owner to exist therefore the government can more easily step in.

It is all progressive if you ask me. 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

Performance.

Ability and performance trump seniority or "working hard" when less competent. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Way too many seniors are getting the hs degrees.

There are a lot of smart Freshmen, Sophs and Juniors out there! :-) 

Gang Starr --- 16 years ago -

Where I work at to move up too the next level is based on senority but there are couple of other factors that come into play if you move up or not. They are:
Attendance and discipline record. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So nothing about performance? Doesn't matter if you work harder, work smarter, come up with great ideas?

Just show up for work and keep your mouth shut and you move up? 

Nightstorm --- 16 years ago -

Silly question for a poll. I assume all who said "yes" are just trying to be controversial. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 16 years ago -

I voted "No", but depending on the generation of the person making the promo. The old saying goes.....
Age has it's priviliges 

Nightstorm --- 16 years ago -

Age has it's priviliges


It shouldn't when it comes to filling an employment position. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Nightshade, so what do you think about Gang Starr's employer? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

All seniority proves is you haven't screwed up enough to get fired. In places where seniority is the only measure used for promotions, work ethic and abilities are ignored. 

david --- 16 years ago -

As an Example AT&T (union) post a Rec for a position let's say assistant manager the union contract says the job should be filled by an internal candidate and the position would go to the employee with the highest seniority... Job performance is not a factor.... 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Job performance is not a

It should be a factor. I have seen people in jobs who were promoted because of their seniority when they should not. It doesn't do the company any good. It should be the best person for the job. JMO.. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground