Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Vitamin C working like a Zpac

who's talking here?

Jen 1
la guerita 1
eterry2 1
jjfingrainalready 1
AFWife 1
rEVOLution 1
Cookin' Queen 1
Iluvdzny 1
jtcitrus 2
Cold Fire 1
Puss In Boots 5
Ares 2
Red Dawn 2
horseymomma 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Iluvdzny --- 15 years ago -

Has anyone heard that taking vitamin c works like a Zpac? I swear the PA we saw at the Walgreens clinic last week told me that but I can't remember how she said to take it. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Don't believe there is any scientific proof anywhere that claims that Vitamin C can kill an infection. It can lessen the duration of symptoms of a cold, for instance, but I would run as far away as I could from that PA... 

Cookin' Queen --- 15 years ago -

Know of someone who takes lots of vit c and never gets sick. She is in college and is around lots of people who are sick at times. Her father is a doctor and tells her to do this. Taking a lot of vit c doesn't hurt the body as it is water soluble and the body rids itself of an excess. Going to find out how much she takes and if her dad has her take any other vitamins. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Taking vitamins is not bad. But claiming they are good for you and then claiming that they can clear up Zpac-type illnesses is just WAY OUT THERE. Do some research on vitamin D, I think you will find it also helps. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

First of all...
Don't listen to that PA because they know nothing about pharmacokinetics or the mechanism of action of azithromycin.
ZPac has been overused, and most bacterial infections are now resistant to it (particularly in the local Houston area). The exception being mycoplasma infections. Mycoplama lack a cell wall, and therefore don't respond to penicillins, which prevent cell wall growth.
ZPac, however, prevent protein synthesis, and is therefore the first line antibiotic for possible mycoplasma infections (laringytis, sinus infections, walking pneumonia, etc.)

Vitamin C is not a replacement. 

Cold Fire --- 15 years ago -

A Z-pac will likely perform the same as Vitamin C... and do NOTHING. Most upper respiratory infections are viral and antibiotics do nothing but increase bacterial resistance. The only indications for antibiotics are for pneumonia, strep pharyngitis and otitis media (actually, the Europeans don't believe in treating otitis media with antibiotics). Most sinsusitis is viral and does not benefit from antibiotics.

The widespread prescription of antibiotics is a deleterious cultural phenomenon. People go to medical providers demanding antibiotics for self-limited viral conditions. Yes, your disease sucks, but no, an antibiotic will not help. The medical provider usually assents and gives out a prescription for a worthless antibiotic just to make the patient happy and keep them returning for future services.

The end result is that in 20 years we will have no antibiotics that are effective in treating anything, especially severe disease processes.

Although your kid has a fever of 104, the best treatment is usually to give them appropriately dosed tylenol (15mg/kg) every 4 hours and motrin (10mg/kg) every 6 hours.

If you are concerned in any way about their condition, do take them to a medical provider for evaluation, but realize that often times antibiotics do nothing but expose your child to allergic reactions, diarrhea and other undesirable side effects. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

You can thank Dr.s for the resistance issues. Most are too lazy to use a microscope to determine the cause of the illness. Heck, most don't even have a microscope in their clinic! 

eterry2 --- 15 years ago -

Well, I used to take Zycam at the first sign of a cold and it helped. But, I read about it making you lose your sense of smell. So, now I take Airborne and it seems to help. And that is loaded with Vit. C and other nutrients.

I have a cold/congestion/laryngitis and it's helping. 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Are you sure the PA didn't say Zycam because I can't imagine them comparing Vitamin C to the Z-Pak???

Z-Pak is a crazy strong antibiotic that flushes your system faster than you can get to the bathroom! 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Add:

Vitamin C and Echinacea are great home remedies to help prevent you getting full blown sick from a cold as long as you take them when you first start to feel the symptoms. They are also helpful to someone who doesn't have insurance and although it may take longer to get better, they do help.

The Vitamin C helps boost your defenses as the Echinacea is a potent yet natural antioxident that helps flush the bugs out of your system. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

WOW Horseymomma, do you know all doctors or "most of" them. What a crappy statement. We all get that you are anti-establishment (ie, trying to get Kingwood Medical Center to change some maternity policies) but your statement is offensive AND inaccurate. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Easy there, I'm a nurse-midwife student and my hubby is a Dr.
Definitely not anti-establishment.
I consider myself pro-improvement, thank you.

How many times have you or anyone been prescribed antibiotics without your Dr. confirming if it was a bacterial infection or what type of bacteria?

We have 2 microscopes at home.
They come in quite handy! 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Here, this site was recommended to me by a naturopath.

Natural Partners - VitC 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

AlwaysWithMe,
I am also pro informed-choice and anti informed-consent.
You might want to consider switching sides and join me instead of attacking. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

If I recall correctly, you are the first one who "attacked" doctors as being lazy....making a blanket statement like that serves no good purpose.

I am informed and dilligent in my choice of doctors, and regarding "sides"...I am on the side of good health and making my own choices. I can smell a self-serving statement from a mile away. Build yourself up if you want, but you don't have to make derogatory comments at the expense of medical professionals..

And BTW, I am not attacking you personally, so I don't really understand why you feel the need to defend yourself. I took exception to your ridiculous statement that "most foctors are lazy."

Have a great evening. 

Jen --- 15 years ago -

always wondered if vit C worked,,,, 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

I said "most" and not "all".
And that is actually quite accurate. 

jjfingrainalready --- 15 years ago -

always wondered if vit C worked

I take a dose everyday as a preventative and double that dose if I am not feeling well. And I only get sick every 4-5 years. But would I ever try to replace a necessary antibiotic with Vitamin C? No, that is ridiculous. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Oh yes, because 'Most" makes such a difference.

Pffft. 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

First of all...
Don't listen to that PA because they know nothing about pharmacokinetics or the mechanism of action of azithromycin.


I know PA's that are better educated than Dr's...Nurses too. 

la guerita --- 15 years ago -

i very rarely take any medication
when i get sick, which is maybe once every three years and i work with homeless people. never get the flu shot or any of that mess- i just take lots of vitamin c. in about two days max i am better. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Dogs create their own vitamin C. Which is one reason they heal so quickly.

Unlike humans, dogs typically do not need additional vitamin C (ascorbic acid). Dogs, as well as many other animals, manufacture vitamin C through their glandular systems. A healthy dog typically produces about 18mg of vitamin C for every pound of body weight (for example, a 50-lb. dog produces about 900mg per day), providing a continued concentration of ascorbic acid in the dog's system.


I learned by watching documentary Food Mattersthat some doctors are now looking at Vitamin C to fight off cancers and other ailments.

It's no secret that the healthiest societies are those who get their vitamins from their food and from supplements.

Vitamins can do amazing things and far safer than using synthetic man made drugs.

 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

I still think Vitamin D is far superior to C for boosting the immune system.

C doesn't do much for me. But then, maybe that is because I already get enough from food. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

None of this back and forth matters.

The fact is that vitamin supplementation does nothing for you unless you've been deficient in that particular vitamin for while (the body stores and makes a lot of nutrients based on supply and demand). There is no Substitute for a healthy diet, and changing your diet will have a far more profound effect than taking a supplement will: even in the treatment of acute symptoms.

To paraphrase:
"Eat Food (not food-like substances), not too much, mostly PLANTs... then go play outside." And to be fair, you could probably eat mostly meat if you could afford to eat that much HEALTHY meat (note: Healthy does not equal lean)

The only time in life when vitamin supplements are unquestionably beneficial is during pregnancy, and to a lesser extent during breastfeeding. This is due to changes in the behavior of the digestive tract during the former, and increased demand for particular nutrients during both. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

I was tested and found to be severely deficient in Vitamin D (after an endocrine issue) and being a man I was not pregnant nor breastfeeding.
:)

There are many medical conditions that can lead to deficiencies. Many go un-noticed for the most part.

So, prudent supplementation is a good thing for many. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

prudent supplementation is a good thing for many.

I agree:
vitamin supplementation does nothing for you unless you've been deficient in that particular vitamin for while

and you're right, I should have added the caveat that there could be many reasons for the above condition to be true. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground