Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I just received this e-mail. Unbelievable indeed!

who's talking here?

planemom 4
Momofboys 1
Mandy 1
Coco 1
ghostpost 1
EagleEye 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
oneyedman 10
voice of reason 1
tinman 5
Nebucasneezer 1
Puss In Boots 4
thankfulformyfour 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

A Message from Daniel Ledoux

A recent Tribune article said the following in a report on the April 18th candidate debate:
“Sitton was the only candidate in favor of expanding the sports program. He estimated that the district spends about $4.9 million on sports for 17,000 athletes." “Kids at the high school level involved in sports fail one-third the time than those that are non-athletes. Kids that are involved in sports at the junior high level fail half the time of non-athletes,” said Sitton. “Instead of cutting, can we find ways to involve more kids?”

Unbelievably, Robert Sitton proposes spending more money on athletics at a time that HISD is facing a $20 million projected budget shortfall. Apparently, Mr. Sitton’s solution to failing students is not to improve educational standards, assist our teachers or refocus our efforts on struggling students, but rather, spending increases for the sports programs.

Ok, fair enough proposal, but let’s review Mr. Sitton’s math. If we currently spend $4.9 million for 17,000 students then that is an extra $288 per student enrolled in sports programs. If we expand this to include just another 20,000 students, that is 5.7 million more we need to find in the budget. The obvious question is then, “From where will Humble ISD find all this extra money in a climate where teachers are losing their jobs?”

Mr. Sitton has yet to answer this question. Perhaps his solution would be to cut the reading programs in the middle schools, or maybe the AP science courses in high schools. I am sure he could find several million dollars to fund more sports if he were to eliminate the entire mathematics programs from the elementary schools.

We can no longer afford this kind of thinking in Humble ISD. Raising student performance cannot be achieved by short changing the core curriculum that is at the heart of a solid education.

Robert Sitton, if you are determined to spend more money we do not have to improve student achievement, may I offer a much better solution? I suggest that we direct our efforts to the CLASSROOM and not on the GRIDIRON. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Unbelievable that Ledoux would send it to you or that Sitton supports expanding the sports programs? 

Nebucasneezer --- 15 years ago -

lol. I am guessing Sitton didn't really think that through before speaking. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Unbelievable that Ledoux would send it to you or that Sitton supports expanding the sports programs?

Both I guess... I did not know Ledoux had my email address and I did not know Sitton was so daft. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Here is a link to the article in question.

Wonder how he got your email address? Not sure we need to be expanding extra-curriculars if we don't have enough money to pay for teachers. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Wonder how he got your email address?

I am guessing from the TEA party. I get their e-mails.

Not sure we need to be expanding extra-curriculars if we don't have enough money to pay for teachers

Exactly! And we certainly should not be electing someone to the school board who does not know that. 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

from what I have been told (and I have done NOTHING to prove or disprove this so don't bite my head off!), athletics provides revenue for the district with ticket sales and such. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

athletics provides revenue for the district with ticket sales and such.

It doesn't. If sports were self funding there wouldn't be such a big deal made when discussing cutting sports. Boosters do use the money from ticket sales and concessions to offset the cost of the activity but they don't cover it all. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

athletics provides revenue for the district with ticket sales and such.


nonsense. the money goes to booster clubs and the taxpayers are funding that huge waste of money they call a stadium.

all sports programs need to end. when there is only so much money to go around, academics must be top priority. besides, their sports programs aren't based on ability alot of the times. screw that. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

athletics provides revenue for the district with ticket sales and such

And what about every other sport??
Tennis and lacross don't really pack 'em in. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

all sports programs need to end. when there is only so much money to go around, academics must be top priority.


I agree academics are always the first priority but couldn't disagree more that all sports programs need to end. Being involved in sports helps keep students engaged and active in their school community. They also help a lot of students who would likely have let themselves fall behind academically if they didn't want to remain eligible for sports. I disagree with Mr. Sitton's emphasis on sports at this time, but I don't disagree with him that students that are involved in sports are much more likely to be involved students. I know this because I was one of those kids. When I was in High School I went through a rough patch and got away from sports. It wasn't a coincidence that when I got active again that it turned me around academically, and helped me in many other ways. Sports should always have a place in the schools, they just shouldn't have the first place, and they shouldn't be paying big bucks to coaches etc. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Being involved in sports helps keep students engaged and active in their school community.

Could not agree more!...Lets keep what we can, but it's a bit insane to think of expanding the programs right now. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

nonsense. the money goes to booster clubs and the taxpayers are funding that huge waste of money they call a stadium.



First of all...to set the record straight, the booster clubs, for the most part, are non profit groups set up to help off set the expenses not covered by the school district for their respective activities. There are many, many school sponsored activities that are largely funded by the respective booster clubs. The Kingwood Fillies is one that comes to mind. They are not non-profit, but are funded largely by the booster club. In that respect, the activity is self sustaining.

All ticket sales to all athletic events in HISD go to the school district. That's right....all. The booster clubs run the concessions and maybe some other form of fundraisers.

The District is pretty strict on how the boosters clubs operate and there is a chain of command and audit authority that the school district commands. If the booster club in question does not keep their paperwork up to date with the District and IRS, then they are de-certified.

As for Robert Sitton's statement. All I can say is this. He knows that an engaged kid is a motivated kid. If it takes athletics to engage a kid, then so be it.

I can promise you this. If a kid does not want to learn, adding teachers to the school is not going to make him want to learn more.

If you happen to get him or her engaged in an activity such as athletics, debate, drama, or what ever, you will find that they will be self motivated. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

If you happen to get him or her engaged in an activity such as athletics, debate, drama, or what ever, you will find that they will be self motivated.

Sure,valid point and I agree with you. But we are not talking about that. We are talking about Sitton's desire to ADD more sports programs in a shrinking budget environment.

It shows a fundemental lack of understanding of what is happening in the district, state and country right now. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

Oneye....it's hard to argue with your logic. On the surface it certainly looks like that's exactly what he's doing.

I've known the Sitton family since the 70's. Robert graduated from Humble High with my wife. He's been a coach, teacher, and he also sat on an HISD bond committee. I have not doubts that he knows what he is talking about.

Now, could that mean that what it appears he said is really what he said? The answer is yes. And if it's yes, then I would be very surprised.

Nothing is impossible.

To me, his quote means that the more kids involved in athletics, the better those kids do in school. You can increase the number of kids in athletics without increasing the cost. The infrastructure is there, the personnel is there, why not try it?

In fact, if it saves some teachers jobs who also coach, isn't that good too? 

Mandy --- 15 years ago -

My 2 cents about Sitton. I know nothing of him now, HOWEVER, he coached my son(now a freshman in college) in baseball and he was AWFUL!! My kid was a good athlete and was a varsity football starter until he graduated last year. This man screamed and yelled so much at my son, he wanted to quit. I wouldn't let him, made him ride it out, but when it was over, he refused to ever play again. I remember this man very well, and I never vote for school board, but I will this year, just because this man made my son and myself miserable for an entire baseball season. I actually video taped this man screaming at all those little boys. Wish I knew where that tape was hidden!!!

Anyway, just my 2 cents!! 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

When is the next opportunity to hear the candidates? 

Momofboys --- 15 years ago -

@Mandy, I think the coach you are referring to is the brother of the candidate not the candidate himself. 

Coco --- 15 years ago -

I had Robert Sitton as a history teacher in the 1980s; he was also the baseball coach then. He was always very nice and respectful to the students-- a very easy-going demeanor. So, I'm not sure that Robert Sitton is the same coach that Mandy is referring to. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Look, he may be a real peach, but that does not qualify him to lead the district.

His idea to expand sports programs WILL have consequences on the budget already 20 million in the hole. He does not seem to grasp the situation we are struggling under in HISD. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

He does not seem to grasp the situation we are struggling under in HISD.

I'm starting to think that too. 

EagleEye --- 15 years ago -

Wow, looks like politics as usual here for Daniel Ledoux. I will no longer support him as I have seen him go on the attack and his statements get more and more negative. Mr. Ledoux has spent the majority of his adult life in Europe, and it sounds like the European elitist attitude has caught up with him 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Hmmm. Expanding the sports programs??? Don't think so. This candidate may have just cost himself a lot of votes with that statement. It's one thing to say that you support the current sports programs, but entirely something else to say the word "expand" when teachers are losing their jobs. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

his statements get more and more negative

Really?
Sounds to me like this is information people should know in order to make an informed decision.
So pointing out your opponents deficiencies and lack of knowledge and actual statements is now considered negative campaigning?

If you have some other example of negative campaigning I would love to hear about it, but I have not seen anything like you are describing. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

but that does not qualify him to lead the district.


I'm not for Sitton, but how exactly does Ledoux's background in shipping make him qualified? 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

but that does not qualify him to lead the district.

If you read my post this was made in reference to Sitton being a nice guy.

Being nice is just great and I don't know Sitton so I take the previous posters word that he is a real wonderful fella. But being wonderful alone does not qualify in my book as enough to lead.... I am sure he has other qualities that may qualify him, but obviously not his grasp of the budget situation in HISD. In my estimation, that's kind of important right now. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

This all cracks me up.

I went to the Tribune site and looked this article up. I just couldn't believe that anyone could be dense enough to make a statement like that in times like these.

Well, I was right. The Sitton made the statement, but the quote was out of context. Here is the paragraph immediately preceeding the one outlined in this thread.

Scarfo, Ledoux, Sitton and Rosenberg also agreed that extracurricular activities were necessary. Scarfo, Ledoux, and Rosenberg supported charging a fee of about $150 to all participants and setting up scholarships for students who couldn’t pay.

The reporter states that Sitton is in favor of expansion, but there aren't any direct quotes attributed to him.

The fact is, within the context of the paragraph I just highlighted, all of the candidates are in favor of expansion. As long as the participation fee is paid, who is hurt by expansion?

In fact, in true bureaucratic fashion, the candidates also agreed to offer scholarships to the disadvantaged.

So again, I am not for or against any of the candidates. I will say, however, the author of the article has stirred up a hornets nest by publishing their opinion instead of a direct quote.

That bothers me. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

The fact is, within the context of the paragraph I just highlighted, all of the candidates are in favor of expansion

I'm sorry.....how do you come to that conclusion with your bolded paragraph. Alll three say that extra curricular is "necessary" and all supported charging a fee. How exactly is that in support of "expansion?"

The reporter paraphrasing Sitton's comment doesn't mean that he didn't say it. Why not email the reporter for clarification. This is not the reporter's "opinion." 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

AWM

Look within the context. If the players are willing to pay, then the politicians are willing to expand. Heck, they're even willing to give some if it away for free.

As for the paraphrasing, look up the definition. "restatement of a text or passages, using other words"

The reporter attributed a direct quote to Sitton, via paraphrasing, and did not verify the attribute.

A reporter should quote directly. That leaves no room for misinterpretation, which is what is happening here.

A reporter should not write, "Sitton was the only one in favor of expanding the sports program". There is no direct quote, but there is, "restatement of a text or passages, using other words"

So in reality, the reporter was reporting what he understood, but not what was precisely said.

That is exactly what Sitton's opponent is hitting on. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

tinman, I am reading the paragraph and in no way shape or form does it suggest that all three support "expansion." I don't know what you're talking about as far as "context" is concerned.

Scarfo, Ledoux, Sitton and Rosenberg also agreed that extracurricular activities were necessary. Scarfo, Ledoux, and Rosenberg supported charging a fee of about $150 to all participants and setting up scholarships for students who couldn’t pay.

The words speak for themselves.

Anyway, you are mistaken on the reporter's use of paraphrasing. It is done everyday by every major newspaper in the country....as it is taught that way in every journalism school there is. It is impossible to put every single statement into a direct quote format...it renders the story choppy and unreadable.

Anyway, the point here is....to learn about the candidates in detail....Sitton's website makes no mention of this "expansion" philosophy at all.

And in case, you think I am a Ledoux supporter, I am not. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

You know what....you're right.

The whole ordeal ain't worth arguing over. I know Robert's brother David.

Truth is, being on the school board is about as thankless as it gets.

The thing that riled me the most was Ledoux's use of a reporter's paraphrase in order to negatively portray his opponent.

To me, that shows a lack of character.

It was fun parsing words with you.... 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

all of the candidates are in favor of expansion.

That is not correct in the slightest. I was at this debate (it was sponsored by the Kingwood TEA Party).
The question that elicited these responses was about CUTTING the extracurricular programs... And it is absolutely correct that Sitton was the only one of the candidates that answered that we need to EXPAND the sports programs. The other candidates responses were made in response to the possibility of CUTTING the programs.

Who here is trying to take things out of context? 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

:)

For the record, Sitton's financial/money management knowledge (Edward Jones) and his fervent support of the Humble Educational Foundation sets him apart from some of the other candidates. IMO, places him firmly ahead of Ledoux in the "commitment" category. But that athletic expansion is troublesome.

I will continue to research the other candidates. Unfortunately, most of the websites are filled with fluff and very little substance. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground