Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Lawyer Argues for Andrea Yates Release

who's talking here?

AFWife 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
OH SNAP 2
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Bornanraisedkw 1
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

Ten years ago today, Andrea Yates called 911 after drowning her five children in the family's bathtub and admitted to the first police officer to arrive at her Houston home, "I just killed my kids."

Now, Yates is being treated in a minimum-security mental hospital in Kerrville, Texas, from which her longtime lawyer, George Parnham, says he's "highly optimistic" she will be released after her recommitment hearing in November.

The first step is to secure the recommendation of her doctors. "I think that this year the doctors will recommend a regimen of therapy in a community-based outpatient facility," says Parnham.

Controversial as her case has been, Yates' attorney and friends argue her mental health is much improved after years of treatment and medication for postpartum psychosis and other conditions. Initially committed to the maximum-security North Texas State Hospital Vernon Campus, Yates was transferred to Kerrville in 2007. Kerrville State Hospital, which sits on a hill overlooking the Guadalupe River, has no fences and no guards, but patients are required to stay within designated boundaries. Yates has one roommate and access to a woodshop, an arts and crafts clinic, classrooms and a physical therapy building.

"When this first happened, she was severely mentally ill and would experience extreme sickness at around this time each year," says Parnham.

But with therapy and treatments including anti-psychotic and anti-depressant medication such as Effexor, one friend who regularly visits Yates says, "She's come full circle and she's really well."

High school valedictorian Yates now spends her days reading, sewing aprons and creating cards for the hospital's gift shop.

"Talking to her is like talking to my daughter. She's always asking questions about my ski trips and family vacations," says Parnham.

The highly publicized trials of Yates in 2002 and 2006 focused the nation's attention on postpartum psychosis and the nation's insanity laws. During her first trial, Yates' attorneys argued that she suffered from severe postpartum psychosis and delusion. She believed Satan was inside her ,and that killing her children would save them from hell. Although she was initially found guilty, the appeals court later overturned the verdict.

In her second trial, Yates was found not guilty by reason of insanity. At the time, defense lawyer Parnham described the verdict as "a watershed event in the treatment of mental illness."

Encouraged by the case, Parnham made it his mission to wage a crusade on behalf of women's mental health problems. He reached out to the Mental Health Association of Greater Houston to form the Yates Children Memorial Fund in June 2002 to educate women, their families and their doctors about postpartum psychosis and similar illnesses. The organization has since distributed more than 500,000 pamphlets to raise awareness about women's mental health, created training programs for medical professionals and sponsored an international symposium on postpartum depression.

"When I saw those five tombstones that shared the same date, I thought what a waste of their lives if nothing good could come of this tragedy," says Parnham.

Andrea Yates' former husband, Rusty Yates, has also made strides toward improving his life and raising awareness about mental illness. He stayed married to Andrea until four years after their children's deaths. They remain friends, and he continues to visit her, according to acquaintances who know them both. Rusty has remarried and now has a 3-year-old son.

According to his blog, Rusty enrolled in law school in 2009 "to improve the way in which our society responds to crime, particularly for mentally ill defendants, and to improve our health care system, particularly for mentally ill patients." He also says of Yates. "She is doing well, all things considered. ... She's been medically stable for five years."

A decade after the tragedy, Parnham believes that doctors now will recognize Andrea Yates' improvement. "No one loves those kids more than this woman -- the real culprit was mental illness."

After years of waiving the right to the hearing, Parnham plans to go before the court this year to argue that Yates is no longer dangerous to herself or others, and that her mental condition will not deteriorate if she is released. A judge or jury will eventually determine whether Yates meets these standards. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

What would happen if she got pregnant? 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

that is the question? would she be allowed to keep the kid? oh i dont even want to think about it? 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 15 years ago -

Can she please get her tubes tied, burned off ?... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

[i].She believed Satan was inside her, and that killing her children would save them from hell.



I think he's still there.


If they ever let this woman out, they are nuts. And it's not b/c I don't think some can be rehabilitated. I think it's possible in some cases. But notice the amount of drugs and therapy and controlled, easy life style of doing crafts and such that she now has? Is real life going to be like that? I think not. As long as there is any chance she is a danger to society or others, I say no way. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Rusty and Andrea Yates should have both gotten the death penalty. He is as responsible as she was. 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

Rusty and Andrea Yates should have both gotten the death penalty. He is as responsible as she was.

Bingo! 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

Rusty and Andrea Yates should have both gotten the death penalty. He is as responsible as she was. double bingo..

if you read everything that happened to her and not just the time she killed the kids.. she DID try this another time, she filled the bathtub up with water but someone came to the house so she didnt follow through with it.. ( that was from from the police interview with her ).. he should have done more IMO.. he knew she was sick she needed more help and this may have been prevented. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Now, ladies, Rusty may have been a doofus, but he didn't kill anyone. I agree she needed help that he didn't seem to get her. BUT sometimes when you are that close to someone, you become accustomed to radical behavior and it becomes the norm, as in co-dependency. It becomes very hard to guess when or if someone could cross that line to criminal behavior. I do think he dropped the ball when he should have had her committed. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I watched and read almost everything related to this trial trying to understand whywhywhy????

She had postpartum after the first child and should not have had anymore children without being completely supervised. Neither one of them cared that there was a risk to the children. This is no different than a drunk driver getting behind the wheel and killing someone only in this case there were two drunk drivers. It sickens me that he has another child and that he is trying to become an attorney. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

She'll be fine until she decides she no longer needs her meds...


Is it fair to punish someone because they're severely mentally ill? I don't know...

Is it fair to put the public or family members, etc, at risk if she decides to go nutso again?

Where would she go? what would she do? Too many unknowns... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Where would she go? what would she do? Too many unknowns...


Yep, that's my concern as well. She has to be micro managed, controlled and someone has to take that responsibility to look after her with that high degree of supervision. She needs to stay institutionalized.. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

She has to be micro managed, controlled and someone has to take that responsibility to look after her with that high degree of supervision.


She should have to be released into her attorneys care since he thinks she should be released. He said he talks to her like a daughter, fine he should put his money where his mouth is and sign on as her legal guardian talking full responsibility for her. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

She's exactly where she needs to be. I agreed with the not guilty by reason of insanity verdict. She is a very sick person and I absolutely believe she loved her children and thought she was doing the right thing for them, as horrible as it is to think about. She's also extremely lucky that her mental illness was taken into account and she was spared the death penalty. Given her degree of mental illness, however, she doesn't need to be released into an out-patient program. That would be a huge mistake, IMO. I believe she will always be a danger to herself and others without 24/7 supervision. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

She should have to be released into her attorneys care since he thinks she should be released. He said he talks to her like a daughter, fine he should put his money where his mouth is and sign on as her legal guardian talking full responsibility for her.

I wonder if he'd be comfortable letting her babysit his grandkids. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I wonder if he'd be comfortable letting her babysit his grandkids. 


bingo

I wonder if Rusty Yates would be willing to let her watch his son? He says she has been sane for 5 years. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I don't think she's going anywhere anyway. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I don't think she's going anywhere anyway.

Not too mention, no one in the general public is going to accept her and she'd be at risk from other nut cases that want to seek their own type of justice for her crime.

Seems like a bad idea all the way around... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I'm surprised this lawyer is so much in her court. Fine, he has a relationship with her, great. But to expect the general public to ever embrace freedom for Andrea Yates is beyond dumb. And him saying she is ready for release makes me want to puke. This is why some lawyers get a bad rep.

Baby killers, whether mentally ill by legal definition or not, should not be free. Period. He should know better. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Baby killers, whether mentally ill by legal definition or not, should not be free. Period. He should know better.

I agree with you.

The fact that she has to be so heavily medicated to be able to function, means she can't be left to her own devices. Folks with this type of mental illness are notorious for saying they "feel better" and stop taking their meds once they aren't forced to take them.

Then what? We have enough homeless, mentally ill folks on the street, we don't need to add to it. Plus, she committed a heinous crime...mental illness or not, she's a danger to herself and others if not medicated. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground