Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I thought we put HISD's "new age" grades to rest!!!

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
getreal 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
pinkismyfavoritecolour 1
LiveFreeOrDie 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
zeppo 2
esquala 2
kapoocheeno 1
texanbrit 2
JRG79 1
LitlJay 8
Ma4under10 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

How come my daughter got a report card filled with 3's and 4's today? On top of that, the grading is totally subjective! The teacher told us that she was under orders to be chintzy with 4's, or our daughter would have gotten more of them!

My DD met and exceeded every district and state standard for her grade level at this point. Why didn't we get a report card full of A's, or better yet, some useful, objective NUMBERS?

I thought this nonsense was crushed last year! Who was involved in that and can fill me in on what happened? It looks like the district just handed out some lip service about going back to letter grades. 

texanbrit --- 15 years ago -

Oh no, there not changing it all?!?!

Have they not heard the saying, "if it ain't broke done fix it?"

You know I sometimes think they do these things just to make it look as if they're doing something... 

esquala --- 15 years ago -

LJ - where does your daughter go to school? My son is a sophomore at Quest Early College HS, and I've been seeing these grades since he started. I don't really get them. I know they have something to do with mastery learning style of teaching, but that's about all.

Chintzy with 4's......that doesn't mean they're grading on a curve, does it? And if not, who would order a teacher to do that, and why?

I guess I need to be filled in, too. :) 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

Woodland Hills Elementary. It's not a curve. It's just subjective and unscientific. The teacher gives what they want, as long as they don't hand out too many 4's.

I hope this makes other parents squirm as much as it does me. 

pinkismyfavoritecolour --- 15 years ago -

I went to Quest High School and graduated from there in 2007 and our grades were 0-4. Its actually not that bad of a system. Gives students incentive to have at LEAST a B at all times. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

A through F gives kids good motivation to make at least a B, too.

I fail to see what changing from letters to numbers accomplished except to remove the "F" stigma from failing students.

What will they do once the "0" gets stigmatized??? 

texanbrit --- 15 years ago -

" as long as they don't hand out too many 4's."



So for the poor kid/s who really deserve those grades, the teachers are still not allowed to hand too many out? 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

That's the impression I got from DD's teacher during her report card meeting today. One kid has to be head and shoulders above the class, and he/she is the only one who gets them. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

So I guess that almost is a curve, then. Just without any accurate math to muddle it up for them. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

What ever happened to giving kids the actual grades THEY EARNED? 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

What ever happened to giving kids the actual grades THEY EARNED?

That's why I started this thread. I thought they promised a group of parents last year that they would abandon this nonsense. Clearly they haven't. 

JRG79 --- 15 years ago -

They probably didn't give too many 4's because they were told parents need to see growth over the year. That's the impression I got while I was teaching. If they give 4's now there is nowhere to go so to speak. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

What ever happened to giving kids the actual grades THEY EARNED?

That's why I started this thread. I thought they promised a group of parents last year that they would abandon this nonsense. Clearly they haven't.



This has been going on for decades, 15 yrs ago my DW was told to change an "f" to a "c" by the Principle. She refused because that was her last year to teach before we started our family. On her last day at the school picking up her stuff, she checked the computer one last time, yep the grades were changed for her!! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

All this makes me LOL. They just gotta dink with stuff, even if it works. They change stuff, it fails, and they never go back to what worked for years, but instead just keep changing things up rather than admit it just didn't work. That kind of thinking is why we have so many issues.

Kinda off the subject but not, there was a big story about public college ed. after a study was done by a nonprofit group called Complete College America. The study found that of every 100 students who enrolled in college in Texas, 79 went to juco. Of those, 2 actually got their associates degree on time. Even after 4 years, only 7 graduated. Of the 21 who enrolled in a four year college, 5 graduated on time. After 8 years, only 13 earned a degree.

The study showed Texas has a shockingly low graduation rate. The CCA report concluded without "urgent" intervention, today's young people will be the first generation in American history to be less educated than their predecessors. SCARY.

Sorry, rant over. The writing is on the wall tho. Parents have to really stay involved in their kids education. Keep asking questions and demanding real answers. 

zeppo --- 15 years ago -

Quest high school has been doing this for years.

0=not submitted, late.

1=pool level of comprehending material.

2=some understating of material, some
completion of assignment goals.

3=satisfactory comprehension and analytical skills regarding subject matter.

4=Shows mastery (honors level) of subject material and analytical skills.

Anything below a 3 will not be passing. You will have to complete additional assignments to prove that you have gained sufficient understanding of the material.

Quest also requires seniors to complete a community action plan. Identify an issue/problem and create a solution, then become active in their community to achieve desired solution. They call it community involvement.

In 2003 a group of Quest High School seniors along with the HISD Board President Dr. Guy Sconzo helped design the new Atascocita high school. The students also identified issues with the current school operations. This lead the way for freshman through senior integrated home room (houses), to create a more cohesive school environment. Meeting once a day, each student would be assigned a “house” and stay with that “house” for the entire high school experience. By creating this bond between younger and older students, it helps to facilitate a better learning environment. By reducing the normal hierarchal stresses of high school.

“The 425,000 square foot building is designed around eight houses or small learning communities. Students spend the majority of their school day within their houses where they attend core academic classes of English, math, science and social studies. This arrangement allows house principals, counselors and teachers to work together to personalize learning for students.”

More information available on the
Atascocita high school web page.

http://www.humble.k12.tx.us/domain/2816 

getreal --- 15 years ago -

This system started with all 2nd graders last year; from what I understand this grading system will follow them through Elem. school and when they go to middle they will revert back to the A,B,C. etc system. I hated it. Most teachers I spoke with did not like it either. The district just made the change and didn't even give it a trial run. I think it will be really hard for kids to transition to what a percentage grade/letter grade. My question to the district was if it is such a better grading system why isn't it going to follow them all the was through college??? I never got an answer.... 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

I have heard from friends that a B in one school may not be the same as a B at another. How can this be? That schools with an over all lower grade average for their students will give a B for lower accomplishment than at a school with a higher over all grade average. Is this true? 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

Guy sconzo is the is the district superintendent, not the board president.

I will refrain from sharing my opinions of Dr. Sconzo here until I hear (from him) how much of a hand he had in this nonsense. 

zeppo --- 15 years ago -

LitlJay,
you are correct. 

esquala --- 15 years ago -

Actually Quest has a 1-5 system now. Maybe it has something to do with the early college part. The 5's are the A's/mastery level.

Could this new system have something to do with getting more kids to qualify for schools making Exemplary status? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

does this new system have anything to do with the 1st graders writing book reports and spelling the way it sounds to them, instead of correctly? I have a 6 yr. old granddaughter, who wrote a book report while she was visiting me-My daughter checked it over when she was done, and was shocked that she let the spelling go- she told me that that was fine, the school taught that way-(my dg couldn't even read it!) 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

The district told us (teachers) that the standards-based report cards did not move up to third grade this year due to lack of funding for professional development and STAAR, but that the change IS coming. :( 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

Lack of funding? To go back to a century old, proven grading system?

I'll bet there was no budget shortfall for varsity athletics, especially football.

What was it that someone told me a few weeks ago? Academics don't have ticket sales or generate revenue? Maybe that's why. *sarcastic eyeroll* 

Ma4under10 --- 15 years ago -

I think that sometimes it's hard to understand a new system when it's not the system we used when we grew up. If your child gets a "75" on a report card in math, what does that really mean? It's hard to tell them how to improve when it's so general. The reporting system specifically looks at each skill taught in math and then scores kids on how they are progressing toward mastery. It's meant to provide parents with a lot of information on how to help their students improve. I know with my daughter, last year she was getting average grades but until I was told exactly what skills she needed help with, I couldn't help her. Now it is much more helpful. There are many states doing this type of report card. It's just something new and it's hard for some to accept. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground