Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question for Christians and non-Christians alike

who's talking here?

Carla 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Red Heifer 3
Laurabeth 2
jtcitrus 1
Dr Aborto 2
Work in Progress 8
FabulousFinder 1
itstxdaddy 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Infidel II 4
justinCASE 1
Lets Be Fair 1
civilized 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

You know how I'm always rattling on about postmodernism? Well, I'm actually trying to develop a study on it for some friends who want to know more about it. Let's just say that it is of true interest to me how it shapes and creates our perceptions of religion, science, and especially reality.

But I wanted to ask a question to see how KU defines some things. You are kind of a microcosm of differing western world beliefs.

So my questions are:

1. Can we know what is "true" or "real".

2. How do we, or should we determine what is "true" or "real".

Your answer will probably reflect which worldview you ascribe to.

And just for the record, I'm not looking to argue with you (at least on this thread. All bets are off on the other ones!) I just want to know what you think. If I get an answer that is especially applicable, I may ask your permission to use it, with all identifying info removed, of course. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

1. Can we know what is "true" or "real".

2. How do we, or should we determine what is "true" or "real".

Your answer will probably reflect which worldview you ascribe to.


dang it, i left my magic 8 ball at home. you can answer all questions of the universe with the magic 8 ball ya know. 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

1. Yes.

2. Read the Instruction Manual. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

dang it, i left my magic 8 ball at home. you can answer all questions of the universe with the magic 8 ball ya know.

lol, your worldview would either be spiritism, or Fisher Price. Not sure which! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

"Outlook not so good" 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

1. We can based on our belief system, or get close based on those core moral beliefs. Physical/scientific things can be proven in the physical world. Funny thing is, even that changes at times, lol. There are lots of things that we know are true, but can't prove it. Even love can't be proved physically, but you can see indications, and we know how we feel.

2.True and real will go back to your moral/spiritual/religious beliefs. They are going to be subjective based on what you chose to believe. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

So my questions are:

1. Can we know what is "true" or "real".

Yes

2. How do we, or should we determine what is "true" or "real".


Through experiences and a relationship with God. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Through experiences and a relationship with God.

Just for clarification, would you tell me more about "experiences?" For instance, if your experience differed from scripture, would you consider experience to be more more valid?

Have you ever had an experience that made you change your whole view of the world? 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

Since I subscribe to "Objectivist" teachings, my answer to No. 1 is a definite "yes". I believe in what we can perceive and measure in the physical world. Otherwise, you can fall into the realm of moral relativism, i.e. where even acts of infanticide, genital mutilation, honor killings and the like are justified based on cultural norms, instead of condemning those acts because there is an objective truth that such acts are wrong.

We know what is true or real through observation and the use of logic.

Of course, I am still fascinated by the thought of whether there is another reality that we are not aware of. Stories like Plato's Allegory of the Den suggest that the true reality is out there to observe, if you just take those steps to confront it head on. But, you'd need to read the story to get the full picture. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

By the way, I think that the Matrix borrowed heavily on the ideas in Plato's story. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Since I subscribe to "Objectivist" teachings, my answer to No. 1 is a definite "yes". I believe in what we can perceive and measure in the physical world. Otherwise, you can fall into the realm of moral relativism, i.e. where even acts of infanticide, genital mutilation, honor killings and the like are justified based on cultural norms, instead of condemning those acts because there is an objective truth that such acts are wrong.

We know what is true or real through observation and the use of logic.

Of course, I am still fascinated by the thought of whether there is another reality that we are not aware of. Stories like Plato's Allegory of the Den suggest that the true reality is out there to observe, if you just take those steps to confront it head on. But, you'd need to read the story to get the full picture.


Very interesting, and surprising response. I wasn't expecting an objectivist! Would you consider your views to be pretty close in line to Ayn Rand's? She's the only objectivist teaching that I'm familiar with. Especially Atlas Shrugged.

And yes, Plato is VERY crucial to the understanding of postmodernism. I guess more fairly, his ideas are crucial to understanding the whole progression of western thought. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Have you ever had an experience that made you change your whole view of the world?


Yes 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

By the way, I think that the Matrix borrowed heavily on the ideas in Plato's story.

lol! yes! I was planning on showing clips of that movie to teach postmodernism, but I totally see the Den connection, which ties right in. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

The Matrix is actually really interesting, in that it borrows from Judeo Christian motifs as well.

And then the subsequent movies kind of break down those motifs. . .

I have to think about it more to articulate it completely, but it really fits in. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Question 1 and 2 have the same answer. There is no Truth or Real. Truth and Real is what we perceive it to be, it's the reality that we give ourselves. All of my friends and family could be part of my imagination for all I know, but I perceive it to be true because it's what I know. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Question 1 and 2 have the same answer. There is no Truth or Real. Truth and Real is what we perceive it to be, it's the reality that we give ourselves. All of my friends and family could be part of my imagination for all I know, but I perceive it to be true because it's what I know.

Can you expand on what this means for your understanding of science?

And then separately on what this means for your understanding of religion, especially Christianity? Or if you are familiar with another religion, how does it relate to that? 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

Would you consider your views to be pretty close in line to Ayn Rand's? She's the only objectivist teaching that I'm familiar with. Especially Atlas Shrugged.
Yes, I have read many of her works, including Atlas Shrugged, the Fountainhead and the Virtue of Selfishness (the last one has purposefully provocative title; you have to read it, to understand). But, I also subscribe to the Objective Standard, an Objectivist magazine, and I read Reason magazine as well, although it's more devoted to the Libertarian Party ideals and more practically and politically oriented. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Can you expand on what this means for your understanding of science?

And then separately on what this means for your understanding of religion, especially Christianity? Or if you are familiar with another religion, how does it relate to that? 


0 

civilized --- 14 years ago -

"If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away". 

FabulousFinder --- 14 years ago -

What does it take to make something true and/or real? Are we talking do I believe its true/real? Or is it more that I can prove it is true/real? "real" in reality or "real" to me?
I've got a pencil in my hand. I tell you its real. You touch the pencil. You're quite sure its real too. Someone else comes along and sees us playing with said pencil...but they see no pencil. You and I just convinced ourselves so well that we DID have a pencil, that the pencil became real to us. So who knows the "truth" us or that other guy who thinks we are just fiddling with thin air? 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Study comes from Desire
Desire comes from Hunger


I thought you were going here:

"Try and understand,
Desire is hunger is the fire I breathe..."

--"Because the Night", Bruce Springsteen and Patti Smith 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

There is knowledge, and then there are certain elements of faith that are just a matter of trust and not are inherently not knowable. I find it arrogant of man/woman to think they can know God with certainty. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

The Bible is the truth and it is our instruction book on how to live. All the answers to our questions can be found in the pages of the Bible. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

Unless you are a Muslim, and then the Koran is the instruction book on how to live and the answers to all questions can be found in the pages therein.

Or, if you are Jewish, then the Torah is the instruction book on how to live and the answers to all questions can be found in the pages therein.

Or, if you are Mormon, then the Book of Mormon is the instruction book on how to live and the answers to all questions can be found therein.

I think education, observation and reasoning are the keys to learning how to live, and I have many shiny books that answer many questions. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

And those instruction books are one's truth, but aren't empirically true; by their terms they require faith. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

1. Can we know what is "true" or "real".

Objectively, no. Our understanding of reality will always be through the filter of our brains, bounded by the extent to which we can abstract from our experiences, and limited by the fundamental failings of logic.


-but that's not to say that there isn't an independent/objective reality.

2. How do we, or should we determine what is "true" or "real".

Empirical investigation, deduction/induction, and logic.... but all done with an understanding of the caveats and assumptions we impose on the world.



People of faith will also say, revealed knowledge. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

These are some really good responses! Thank you everyone.

I'd love for some more comments if anyone hasn't weighed in! 

Carla --- 14 years ago -

1. Can we know what is "true" or "real".

Yes.

2. How do we, or should we determine what is "true" or "real".

If something is true, there will be multiple references supporting it.

Is someone telling the truth or a lie? Their previous behavior will give you an idea on whether or not they can be trusted. Does what you know as a fact support what they are saying. Are their words and actions congruent?

If you are talking about a historical fact, nothing exists in a vacuum. There will be support in other places.

When it comes to the motivation of individuals, then it gets more complicated.

Sometimes people don't know why they do what they do.

Sometimes their internal compass is so whacky that it's hard for others to see the logic.

Sometimes there are other motivating factors that we don't see.

For example, I never understood all the crazy stuff that went down in the '60's and the Civil rights era. Not that it wasn't a just cause, because it was, but it seemed like people just flipped out.

One time I was watching a talk show and they were discussing it. One man was pretty stoic, but when he started talking about the murder of Emmett Till, he almost broke down in tears.

I didn't understand until then what an emotional impact it had on the nation as a whole and that was the catalyst for the Civil Rights movement.

Just like the bombing at Pearl Harbor and the exposure of what went on during the Holocaust had an enormous impact on that generation. They were committed to *never* again allowing a dictator like that to come to power again. The foreign policy of the U.S. was vastly different after WWII up until the Boomers came of age in the '70's.

Just like the 9/11 attack had an emotional impact on my generation. I think it's heartbreaking that just a decade later, textbooks are being rewritten to whitewash the motivations behind it.

I think part of the issue we are experiencing today is that first, people for the most part don't recognize truth when they see it, and because of that, it is impossible for them to discriminate between the truth and a lie.

I also think that with the explosion of the internet, the ease of publishing, and the exponentially greater number of media outlets out there, the media has abandoned journalistic ethics and are more concerned about being first rather than being right.

They have tossed journalistic objectivity out the window and if they can skew something to be more sensational to attract more eyeballs, they will do it.

You saw that in the 2000 election when news stations were so anxious to be the first to call it that they actually skewed voting in some areas.

You see it with the Trayvon Martin case with the media publishing erroneous and inflammatory information to shape the story a particular way.

People don't know what a "reliable" source is anymore. It's not enough to hear it, you should verify that it is actually true before passing it on. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground