Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

No refusal weekend

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 5
SleightOfHand 20
Laurabeth 16
TexasOma 2
RedMulch 1
Gigix4 1
Work in Progress 3
LiveFreeOrDie 2
cooterbooter 1
thankfulformyfour 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
MandyPants 2
SmoochieAndTheBean 1
Infidel II 11
Gentlecurves 1
PeopleRPeople 1
LillyDivine 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

cooterbooter --- 14 years ago -

I bet some of you are slappin your knees and sayin it keeps drunks off the road. Stop and think.

Did your rights lessen because its the weekend? Whats to stop me from downing a bottle of crown and some beers and run over someone? By the time the cops get there it will be to late.


Are ypu being brainwashed for security over liberty? 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

don't drink and drive and it won't be a problem...be responsible. 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

I think someone has already been hitting the bottle. Guess it is noon somewhere. 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

No refusal weekend?

Does this mean I'll get laid?



I thought the same when i read the topic.
Great Minds 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

I bet some of you are slappin your knees and sayin it keeps drunks off the road. Stop and think.

Did your rights lessen because its the weekend? Whats to stop me from downing a bottle of crown and some beers and run over someone? By the time the cops get there it will be to late.
-----------



Apparently you are too young (and naive) to understand what No Refusal is. First off, you already are not allowed to refuse a chemical test when a police officer has reasonable belief that a person is impaired, hence you loose your license for refusing. Second, No Refusal only supplies a dedicated Judge, prosecutor and nurse. A police officer still is required to prove the case befor the Judge. The prosecutor draws up a search warrant, faxes it to a Judge who reviews it and may or may not sign it. Once you have a search warrant, the nurse pulls the blood. 

LillyDivine --- 14 years ago -

Cooter you can refuse, but its the law that if you do they can automatically take you to jail. Im all for peoples rights but drinking and driving is just plain stupid and wreckless.
Cabs in kingwood are about 20 bucks. Thats a lot cheaper than a DWI. 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

It's a search warrant. They can force DNA from someone, what's the difference? And yes, they have refused to sign blood warrants. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

No refusal weekend

JMHO - No refusal should be the law ALL the time, not just on some weekends. 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

It is the law. You cannot refuse. It is implied consent when you have a Texas DL 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

The judge only see the complaint, not the arrestee. The field sobriety test has multiple phases that can weed out medical conditions. If you know you have not been drinking then don't refuse the test, again you are not allowed to refuse. BTW, if you can't walk a straight line, how do you drive in a straight line? 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

There really isn't anything to worry about. The complaint is that the person was impaired preventing him from operating a vehicle safely. If you weren't stopped for weaving, speeding etc or involved in a crash, good luck proving impairment 

Gentlecurves --- 14 years ago -

You took the words right out of my mouth-'thankformyfour!' 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Here is my issue: I have a medical condition that occasionally causes vertigo. Say I'm driving just fine, but if I have to walk a straight line I'm not going to pass that.


If I were you, I would be sure to carry documentation stating your medical condition. I remember having to respond to a lot of impaired drivers, because they were diabetic or suffering from other medical conditions.

Just a thought. 

SleightOfHand --- 14 years ago -

Especially diabetes. Low blood sugar looks very much like alcohol intoxication and if the officer isn't prudent, a wrong arrest could be made. 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

I have the right to drive my precious babies around town without being hit by some drunk jerk who takes their lives.

Nobody has the right to drink and drive.

The only people who get worked up about this are the ones who drink and drive. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

I have the right to drive my precious babies around town without being hit by some drunk jerk who takes their lives.

Nobody has the right to drink and drive.

The only people who get worked up about this are the ones who drink and drive.




Excellent Post !!!!!! 

sunshine1881 --- 14 years ago -

I'm sorry, I've seen the results of drunk driving too many times and seen too many innocent lives ended. I wouldn't mind having a needle stuck in my arm mistakenly if the program saves even one innocent life.

With that being said, most cops out running traffic, and especially DPS are trained to spot the difference between intoxication and a medical issue. For that matter, I was field sobriety tested a couple of years ago during a traffic stop and one of the first questions he asked me was if I had a medical condition that would make me appear inebriated or hinder by ability to complete the test. He even asked me if I had contacts in because that can affect some of the eye tests. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

This article lays out the reasons why many people are against sobriety checkpoints and being treated like criminals, until you prove your innocence. You can also find it on Reason's website at:
http://reason.com/archives/2010/10/11/abolish-drunk-driving-laws

Radley Balko | October 11, 2010

Last week Austin Police Chief Art Acevedo advocated creating a new criminal offense: "driving while ability impaired." The problem with the current Texas law prohibiting "driving while intoxicated" (DWI), Acevedo explained, is that it doesn't allow him to arrest a driver whose blood-alcohol content (BAC) is below 0.08 percent without additional evidence of impairment.

"People sometimes focus on how many drinks they can have before they'll go to jail," Acevedo told the Austin-American Statesman. "It varies….A person may be intoxicated at 0.05, and you don't want them out driving." Acevedo wants to be able to arrest people with BAC levels as low as 0.05 percent, and he may have support for that idea in the state legislature. John Whitmire (D-Houston), chairman of the state Senate's Criminal Justice Committee, told the Statesman Acevedo's plan "might be one way to go," adding, "Some people shouldn't be driving after one drink—probably below the 0.08 limit—and this could address that."

Bill Lewis, head of the Texas chapter of Mothers Against Drunk Driving, agreed. "I don't see how it would hurt," he told the paper. "The level of 0.08 is where we know most people are good and drunk...and there are people who are driving at less than the limit who probably should not be. It might keep some people from driving [drunk] again."

Acevedo, Whitmore, and Lewis are right, although probably not in the way they intended. People do react to alcohol differently. For many people one drink may well be too many, while experienced drinkers can function relatively normally with a BAC at or above the legal threshold for presuming intoxication. A person's impairment may also depend on variables such as the medications he is taking and the amount of sleep he got the night before. Acevedo et al.'s objections to the legal definition of intoxication highlight the absurdity of drawing an arbitrary, breathalyzer-based line between sobriety and criminal intoxication.

The right solution, however, is not to push the artificial line back farther. Instead we should get rid of it entirely by repealing drunk driving laws.

Consider the 2000 federal law that pressured states to lower their BAC standards to 0.08 from 0.10. At the time, the average BAC in alcohol-related fatal accidents was 0.17, and two-thirds of such accidents involved drivers with BACs of 0.14 or higher. In fact, drivers with BACs between 0.01 and 0.03 were involved in more fatal accidents than drivers with BACs between 0.08 and 0.10. (The federal government classifies a fatal accident as "alcohol-related" if it involved a driver, a biker, or a pedestrian with a BAC of 0.01 or more, whether or not drinking actually contributed to the accident.) In 1995 the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration studied traffic data in 30 safety categories from the first five states to adopt the new DWI standard. In 21 of the 30 categories, those states were either no different from or less safe than the rest of the country.

Once the 0.08 standard took effect nationwide in 2000, a curious thing happened: Alcohol-related traffic fatalities increased, following a 20-year decline. Critics of the 0.08 standard predicted this would happen. The problem is that most people with a BAC between 0.08 and 0.10 don't drive erratically enough to be noticed by police officers in patrol cars. So police began setting up roadblocks to catch them. But every cop manning a roadblock aimed at catching motorists violating the new law is a cop not on the highways looking for more seriously impaired motorists. By 2004 alcohol-related fatalities went down again, but only because the decrease in states that don't use roadblocks compensated for a slight but continuing increase in the states that use them.

The roadblocks are also constitutionally problematic. In the 1990 decision Michigan v. Sitz ,the Supreme Court acknowledged that stops at sobriety checkpoints constitute "seizures" under the Fourth Amendment but ruled that the public safety threat posed by drunk driving made them "reasonable." In the years since, the checkpoints have become little more than revenue generators for local governments. When local newspapers inquire about specific roadblocks after the fact, they inevitably find lots of citations for seat belt offenses, broken headlights, driving with an expired license, and other minor infractions. But the checkpoints rarely catch seriously impaired drivers. In 2009, according to a recent study by researchers at the University of California at Berkeley, 1,600 sobriety checkpoints in California generated $40 million in fines, $30 million in overtime pay for cops, 24,000 vehicle confiscations, and just 3,200 arrests for drunk driving. A typical checkpoint would consist of 20 or more cops, yield a dozen or more vehicle confiscations, but around three drunk driving arrests.

Checkpoints are only the beginning of what California DWI attorney Lawrence Taylor calls "the drunk driving exception to the Constitution." The Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination has been turned upside down by state laws that instantly suspend the licenses of drivers who refuse to take roadside breath tests. Those breath tests are also fraught with problems. Most manufacturers of breath test machines have refused to turn over their source code, meaning DWI defendants can't assess the machines' margin of error, which can be a significant factor in a case where the difference between 0.80 and 0.79 for a first offense can be $1,000 or more in fines, mandatory alcohol awareness classes, and loss of driving privileges for up to a year.

Blood tests are far more accurate, but by the time a driver is pulled over, questioned, taken to the nearest hospital, and had his blood drawn, his BAC may be significantly different from what it was when he was driving. Perversely, the time lapse can have the effect of protecting guiltier motorists. Imagine a driver pulled over or stopped at a checkpoint after having "one for the road," knowing his house is a short drive away and the last drink won't kick in until he's sitting on his couch. At the time he is stopped, he is under the legal limit. But his BAC is rising, and it tops 0.08 by the time his blood is drawn at the hospital. By contrast, a driver who is impaired when he's pulled over, but who stopped drinking an hour or so before, benefits from the delay, since his BAC is falling by the time he arrives at the hospital.

Many states have tried to solve this problem by claiming another invasive power: They are now allowing police to forcibly take a blood sample on the side of the road.

These ever-expanding enforcement powers miss the point: The threat posed by drunk driving comes not from drinking per se but from the impairment drinking can cause. That fact has been lost in the rush to demonize people who have even a single drink before getting behind the wheel (exemplified by the shift in the government's message from "Don't Drive Drunk" to "Don't Drink and Drive"). Several studies have found that talking on a cell phone, even with a hands-free device, causes more driver impairment than a 0.08 BAC. A 2001 American Automobile Association study found several other in-car distractions that also caused more impairment, including eating, adjusting a radio or CD player, and having kids in the backseat (for more on such studies, see the 2005 paper I wrote on alcohol policy for the Cato Institute).

If our ultimate goals are to reduce driver impairment and maximize highway safety, we should be punishing reckless driving. It shouldn't matter if it's caused by alcohol, sleep deprivation, prescription medication, text messaging, or road rage. If lawmakers want to stick it to dangerous drivers who threaten everyone else on the road, they can dial up the civil and criminal liability for reckless driving, especially in cases that result in injury or property damage.

Doing away with the specific charge of drunk driving sounds radical at first blush, but it would put the focus back on impairment, where it belongs. It might repair some of the civil-liberties damage done by the invasive powers the government says it needs to catch and convict drunk drivers. If the offense were reckless driving rather than drunk driving, for example, repeated swerving over the median line would be enough to justify the charge. There would be no need for a cop to jam a needle in your arm alongside a busy highway.

Scrapping the DWI offense in favor of better enforcement of reckless driving laws would also bring some logical consistency to our laws, which treat a driver with a BAC of 0.08 much more harshly than, say, a driver distracted by his kids or a cell phone call, despite similar levels of impairment. The punishable act should be violating road rules or causing an accident, not the factors that led to those offenses. Singling out alcohol impairment for extra punishment isn't about making the roads safer. It's about a lingering hostility toward demon rum.

Radley Balko is a senior editor at Reason magazine. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Loki......ahve you been spending too much time with REV? LOL

As far as the needle thing....they force us to have vaccinations, via needle, to participate in public offerings such as school, so why not be subjected to testing to use public roads????

Would you feel the same for other sobriety testing? Or is it just a needle thing for you? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

There are LOTS of things the gov't could do for our safety, no doubt about it. And I think they like to instill fear in people to drive us to their door begging for more "protection". It's a slippery slope issue. Sounds good on the surface, but when you look at what you give up, it's just scary.. Look at the TSA and all they do for your "safety", and they've yet to nab one villanous terrorist...

No, thank you. 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

It's a constitution thing to me. I kind of like the idea of our country following it.

Drinking and driving is against the law, I kind of like the idea of law enforcement enforcing it.

If someone is stupid enough to get behind a wheel while inebriated I don't care if they have to give the person an enema to prove he/she is drunk. If proven sober, they can go home...

The aren't going to jab a person with a needle on the side of the street. If the person fails a standard field sobriety test then it is escalated to the next level.

DON'T DRINK AND DRIVE....simple. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

It's a constitution thing to me.


So are you against vaccinations as well? 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

If someone is stupid enough to get behind a wheel while inebriated I don't care if they have to give the person an enema to prove he/she is drunk. If proven sober, they can go home...


So, would you be okay with a field enema when you get stopped at one of these checkpoints, even if you didn't have a drink that night? That's the point many on here are making, not that we ought to protect inebriated drivers. Get the cops back on the roads, instead, to monitor traffic real-time and pull over those who are driving erratically.

The aren't going to jab a person with a needle on the side of the street.

Read the article I posted above. They are doing just that, i.e. jabbing needles in folks arms on the side of the road. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Vaccinations have nothing to do with the fifth amendment (self incrimination).


You said you were against the goverment shoving needles in you.....so that's why I asked Loki. See.......needles....needles are used for blood draw, and needles are used for vaccines........soooooo..... since the government makes those that go to public school take vaccine (via neddle, see here's the needle thing again), are you against this, and refuse to vaccinate yourself or your children? 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

I'm protesting how it's done.


How would you like to see it done Loki? 

sunshine1881 --- 14 years ago -

too many innocent lives ended.

Same can be said for many many other things in our lives. Smoking, excessive food intake, trampolines...


Your examples are off the mark. Smoking, excessive food intake and trampolines only hurt or kill the people who chose to do them. They know the risks and choose to do it. Totally different from driving your family home from dinner and being hit head on by a drunk. Those are the innocent victims I'm talking about. The drunk driver is endangering the lives of others -- therefore the government does have a right to step in.

They are doing just that, i.e. jabbing needles in folks arms on the side of the road.

In Montgomery County they have a specially equipped large vehicle called the BAT mobile. It's a sterile environment manned by nurses. They're not just jabbing needles in people's arms along 59. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Many states have tried to solve this problem by claiming another invasive power: They are now allowing police to forcibly take a blood sample on the side of the road.


What states have approved it? And are the police officers certified phlebotomists? If not then it would not hold up in court anyhow.... 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

the government makes those that go to public school take vaccine

But, you do have the right to home school your children, in which case no vaccinations would be required.

The Constitutional threats at issue are the rights against unreasonable searches and seizures (4th Amend) and the right against self-incrimination (5th Amend). I can't speak for Loki, but I am against the government intruding into my private life, stopping me on the road without cause, jabbing needles in me, fondling me at security checkpoints (e.g. the airport) and treating me like a criminal, when they have no reasonable suspicion or probable cause that I have committed any crime. Those protections (4th and 5th amendments) are so fundamental to living in a free society, we named the first ten the "Bill of Rights" and people in countries around the world, like China and Iran (not the governments, but the people) consider us the envy of the world for those freedoms. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

In Montgomery County they have a specially equipped large vehicle called the BAT mobile.


Sweet....but I highly doubt it's sterile.......clean, but not sterile. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

It's a sterile environment manned by nurses.

I hardly feel like my rights were trampled on less by a sterile needle or a clean enema tube (see enema post, above). 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

Infidel, I don't drive erratically nor am I ever inebriated behind a wheel which is why this doesn't bother me. I would pass any field sobriety test before an enema or being poked with a needle.

The checkpoints don't mean an automatic field sobriety test...if issued a field sobriety test and you pass, you go home.

I thought innocent until proven guilty was how our system is supposed to work.

and how do you suggest one who reeks of alcohol when stopped at a check point proves his innocence without doing a field sobriety test? 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

I have no doubt that if this was to be contested up to the supreme court that it would be ruled unconstitutional.

(I did a search on this and didn't find any cases... but I could be wrong... I'll wait and see...)


We've already lost on the 5th Amendment argument, as the Supreme Court has ruled that this right only applies to testimony by the accused (or a wife, under the Spousal privilege); it does not apply to a blood test which is not testimonial in nature, the results are just objective data. (Of course, results of breathalyzers are not very reliable, nor is the source code made available to be able to know the real margin of error. Likewise, blood tests are not completely infallible.)

But, there may still be some 4th Amendment arguments against these kinds of things. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

If people would just be responsible for their own actions.....we wouldn't even be arguing about this..... :( 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

I would pass any field sobriety test before an enema or being poked with a needle.

The problem lies in who is doing the testing. If someone is tired or on medication, the cop may not believe that story and may move forward with more invasive testing. You said you'd be happy to get an enema. Is that still the case, knowing that those doing the testing are human and prone to error? 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

How is a moron weaving in and out of traffic hopped up on adrenaline and testosterone (and probably on a cell phone too) any different than a drunk as far as danger goes? Both are dangerous as hell.


True, just like the idiot on his phone this mornng in front of me that almost took out two cars.... 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

"I don't do anything wrong, so what do I have to worry about?".

That kind of thinking leads to tyranny.


Well said! 

sunshine1881 --- 14 years ago -

Well, again, as Laurabeth said, if people would just grow up and be responsible for their own decisions we wouldn't have to worry about any of this because no one would drink and drive. Now wouldn't that be utopia? 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

That is like the most scary comment ever "I don't do anything wrong, so what do I have to worry about?".


Now while not the most scariest comment I've ever heard....it does rank pretty far up there. I do have to agree with that. all because it doesn't directly, inyour opinion, affect you, doesn't mean that it should just be ignored.

Yes, I totally understand that many of our rights have been taken away, or better yet, changed all in the name of safety. Some are understandable as the world changes, others are not. But the dilema remains......we have drunks, tokers, texters......whatever, on the orad, killing others because of their bad driving. So how do we stop this, or attempt to lessen it guys?

You speak out against it, but what are your solutions? 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

Now wouldn't that be utopia?


Of course.......but we as a society, will never acheive that. 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

that removes many freedoms for minor safety improvements.

I don't think that getting as many drunks as possible off the road as minor. If it saves a life, I am willing to give up a little of my rights, but that's just me.


Computers can detect erratic driving and coupled with intelligent road technology, the car could pull over automatically.


Don't really care for that idea....I mean what if I driving erratically away from some crazy whacko shooting at me....and my dang car pulls over and leaves me a sitting duck! LOL!


Sometimes there are no good solutions
I agree.......so what at least, would you want them to do different?



I wish that drunk drivers or impaired drivers would have an automatic one year suspension.....instead of a slap on the wrist. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground