Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Air purifier recommendations vs whole house purifier recommendations

who's talking here?

sheltielover 6
AwesomeTattooedDragon 6
tinman 7
Celebrity 1
TinktheSprite 4
kwgraniteguy 2
AC Guy 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sheltielover --- 14 years ago -

I know many think these are a waste of time and money. With 2 shelties and a better half with serious allergies, I want to do anything I can do help with the house. I have to stay away from the ionizers and ozone stuff.
Would appeciate any first hand reviews of either...trying to decide what's best. 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

Regardless of what kind of house you live in, the a/c system was designed to completely change the air out in your house at least four times an hour, if you leave the fan on that long. That means every cubic foot of air in your house is sent through your system four times every hour.

Unless you can find a stand alone system capable of that volume, then you would be mistaken to not take advantage of the fact that the air handler in your attic is already doing all of the hard work.

You just need to take advantage of it.

Whole house purifiers will always be superior to anything you can plug in and stand up in a room. The stand alone unit may work just fine in that room, but it won't offer anything for the other rooms, especially if the doors are closed. 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

We have Honeywell air cleaners and they help tremendously with my DD's allergies. Start in the bedroom where you spend the most time and add on from there. They need to be cleaned more frequently if you have pets. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I had them in every room, but little by little, they all broke- I just forgot to replace them-I'm glad you reminded me about them- 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

We also use top quality or second best a/c air return filter AND replace it every other month instead of every 3 mos like recommended. During pollen season we replace the good quality filter monthly.It is amazing to see what those filters catch! 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

The state of the art has changed radically in the last several year.

UV lights to kill living bacteria. HEPA grade filtration. Energy reovery ventilators for humidity control as well as electrostatic and electronic active air filtration are some of the options.

It is quite possible to install a filtration system capable of bringing your house to an operating room level of clean. Unfortunately, the minute you open your front or back door you undo most of it, but it can be achieved.

But...like anything else, you have to crack a few eggs to make an omelette. 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

I wish we could afford a whole house UV light filtration system. 

Celebrity --- 14 years ago -

My son's holistic dr. only endorses Austin Healtmates. They are pricey, but supposed to be great! 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

AC Wholesalers

I have used these folks before and plan to use them for a filter system soon. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I've never heard of whole house filtration systems! This is news to me!! 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

KWgranite

Those are good filters, but there is a recurring cost involved in replacing the media. In some instances, those filters can cost as much as 50-60 bucks to replace, my cost.


Think of it like you would a printer for your computer. You know if you pay very little for the printer, you're going to pay a lot for the ink every time you need some.

The better option is to get some sort of filtration that is washable and reusable. Electrostatic and UV are the two that come to mind.

Aprilire has been a leader in IAQ for a long time and it's hard to go wrong with their products. just be careful and don't get caught in a trap that ends up costing you way more than it should. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

thanks for that info, tinman! 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

TM, there used to be a WH filter that was (i think electrostatic) supossedly the dirtier they got the better they worked, not seeing them anymore. Any ideas? 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -


The better option is to get some sort of filtration that is washable and reusable. Electrostatic and UV are the two that come to mind.


Electrostatic are "ionizers". Do electrostatic types cause soot residue and emit OZONE? 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

JennyJenny....

Ionizers are machines that actually burn or turn the dust into another form.

Electrostatic filters actually use static electricity to attract the dust and other particulates to the electrically charged filament in the filter housing. The particulates remain in their present state until such time as they are removed from the filter.

As long as the power stays on to the filter, the particulates will stick to the filaments.

Once every couple of months, you take out the rack of filaments, wash them off with a garden hose, let dry thoroughly, and then replace.

Like I said before, the state of the art is actually ever changing. I know that my colleagues in the business say that Trane has the best over all whole house system on the market. I installed one for my brother and he said it was the best move he ever made. 

sheltielover --- 14 years ago -

Wow! Thanks for so much info! Tinman, you've confirmed my thoughts about doing a whole house system. Will check into some of the ones mentioned. I'd definitely want one that can be washed out and replaced.

Any other thoughts are greatly appreciated! 

sheltielover --- 14 years ago -

Just checked the site for Aprilaire...looking good!

kwgraniteguy....the wholesalers seem to have some good prices on this Aprilaire. If you buy it from them, how do you get it installed?

I only found 3 companies in this area who say they carry the Aprilaire products. Any recommendations? 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

Sheltie

Aprilaire is distributed by several major supply houses in the area that all licensed hvac companies can buy from. They just have to know that the supply house they purchase from has that line.

You can also get most of their line from Sears.

I would be very careful buying anything more than media filters on line. You are also going to take a whoopin on installation if you already have the item. That is if you can find a qualified installer.

Remember, a/c companies make profit markup on both the product and the installation. You'll be hard pressed to find someone willing to make their qualified mechanics available for an install only when they can be out there making a profit on both the materials and labor.

If you are dead set on going that route, then I suggest you wait until this winter when companies are dying for projects for their guys to do just to keep them busy.

Good Luck!! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I'm so glad this thread was bumped!! I couldn't find it- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

so, is the final opinion to use the Aprilaire products? I want to make sure i get the right thing- 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

Tattoo

Personally, and I really mean personally, I would buy from Trane. Period. They have really been in the forefront of IAQ for quite some time and their product line is consistently superior to the rest of the industry year in and year out.

They have every gadget, bell and whistle you could ever want in terms of IAQ.

Anyone with a valid license and a check book can buy the equipment and, supposedly, install it.

On scale of 1-10, I would give April Aire a 7. Trane and Lennox would be a 9+.

Of course, just like everything else, you get what you pay for. 

sheltielover --- 14 years ago -

Tinman, you have again confirmed my thoughts...I couldn't imagine a company installing a unit that I didn't buy from them.
Also, we have already upgraded our ac unit a couple of years ago...through a friend who is now out of the country working. So, I'm just interested in the air purifier unit that could be put into the current system. So, I should check Trane and Lenox for systems too?
Gee, you are so helpful...could I hire you :-) 

AC Guy --- 14 years ago -

I've installed whole house air purifiers for many customers. Some that had severe allergy problems. They are all pretty close in the results lennox has one that produces no ozone. you should be able to get one installed for around $1000 depending on the brand. THEY WORK GREAT! 

AC Guy --- 14 years ago -

Lennox has the best in my opinoin because it cleans the air and produces no ozone. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I lost the internet, just got back on- $1000. is a lot of money.... We both have terrible allergies-Tinman and AC, so much great info-I'm just confused, now- I wish ya'll would get together, and put your wise minds on this!!!!! 

sheltielover --- 14 years ago -

oh, man...the ozone producers..forgot about that. My mom has small unit for her downstairs and produces the ozone..suppose to get rid of more stuff in the air. We visited last month and we couldn't stand the smell of it. The purifier had 2 settings so she put it on the no ozone. Definitely something else to think about... 

tinman --- 14 years ago -

Sheltie....if all you really want is something to clean the air then you probably should stick to electrostatic air cleaners along with a good, hepa media filtration system.

You'll be hitting the high points in IAQ by installing those items and you'll notice an appreciable difference in your indoor environment.

Best of all, these items can be installed in concert with your current system without fear of technology conflict.

I am not as familiar with electrostatic cleaners as I once was. Honeywell used to have the state of the art electrostatic air cleaners. I'm not sure who does now, but I can't imagine that the technology has changed that much since I was really into that part of the business. 

sheltielover --- 14 years ago -

Okay. I'm checking into Trane, Lenox and maybe Honeywell to see what they have to clean the air, but also kill stuff too. I've read a lot about the hepa filter.

Will post my info.

Thanks so much!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground