Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should those on unemployment be drug tested?

who's talking here?

smartypants 1
randyjet 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Red Heifer 2
Perfection 8
AngieKaye 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
Gigix4 2
Ms Purseonality 2
~bigla~ 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
kidsfan3 2
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
crazypinetrees 1
I roll around kingwood 2
txsassy 1
PokerFace 2
Lets Be Fair 1
Three Greens and a Red 1
Unpopular Poet 1
DILLIGAFFAN 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should those on unemployment be drug tested?

With the article on CNN Money noting the lack of applicants due to failed drug screening and also those wanting to stay on unemployment rather than accept the jobs, should those on unemployment be drug screened so they are ready for jobs?

Yes screen them Vote
 
 92.2% (59)
No Vote
 
 7.8% (5)
Perfection --- 14 years ago -

With the article on CNN Money noting the lack of applicants due to failed drug screening and also those wanting to stay on unemployment rather than accept the jobs, should those on unemployment be drug screened so they are ready for jobs? 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Makes sense to me that if drug screening is a component now of most jobs, and being on unemployment requires you are actively searching for jobs - that being able to be screened would be a requirement. 

~bigla~ --- 14 years ago -

I am randomly drug and alcohol screened at my job...It is a costly endeavor for the number of abuses they find but I understand the need. I voted yes because I know that there many instances where money from unemployment helps the receiver remain unemployed... 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Yes, they need to be drug free or there is little chance they will ever get a job. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Yes, they need to be drug free or there is little chance they will ever get a job.


Exactly so how can they be actively seeking employment if they are doing a behavior that will exclude them from being hired.

If they choose that behavior they should be excluded from compensation for being unemployed 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

i am curious who said no and why.. i am yes.. i have to for my job and i think everyone should 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

I voted NO because such testing is NOT free and who will pay for it? I think the problem is way overblown, and if it is a problem, then I would vote yes IF the legislators and Congress reps were given the same tests.

Our current Rep. Brady was arrested for DUI and had NO problem getting re-elected. Hell I bet he could be tested for drugs and if he tested positive he would STILL be elected. So this concern over drug use is a bit hypocritical

This is like the Tea Party being concerned about term limits, and forcing mayors in Houston to limits, but refusing to set limits on our Guv. for Life Perry. Term limits and drug tests are great for everbody else, but not their buddies. Get REAL! 

Three Greens and a Red --- 14 years ago -

I voted NO also. Most on here seem to be of a conservative bent, and conservatives are always yelling about smaller government. Passing laws to drug test everyone equates with bigger government.

Also, I don't think everyone in the workplace needs to be drug tested. I consider that unConstitutional search. This all got started during the Reagan administration, and if you think back on it there was a big national debate over whether it was Constitutional or not and the government THEN said they'd ONLY use drug testing on people in "safety sensitive" transportation jobs. You can see where it lead us. It's a slippery slope, and evidently nobody has a problem with that. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

i for one am not liberal or conservative or any other politcal party ( i hate politics with a passion) so for me a yes is about the fact is i dont someone working with me who is under the influence of anything.. i wouldnt want anyone working with bf under the influence he works with heavy machinery, cutting tools and had worked in chemical plants.. i think drug tests should stand as you have no reason to be under the influence and working.. i am sorry.. i caught grief for being on perscription meds at work after my surgery.. i wasnt in trouble but just the looks and talk was enough for me to stop taking them while at work and i sit at a desk.. 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 14 years ago -

My guess is the 2% are on unemployment. Just saying! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Passing laws to drug test everyone equates with bigger government.


Generally I would agree with you however this poll is about those who are receiving a government check, unemployment, which requires you be actively seeking employment as a condition for getting the check.

One cannot be actively seeking employment if they are choosing to do actions that would make them unemployable. Therefore they should not be eligible for a government check.

Since the individuals who are accepting the government payment know the rules, they should be held accountable for them. 

Ms Purseonality --- 14 years ago -

I say no, the individual had to of worked at some point to even qualify for unemployment. Not ever person on unemployment is on drugs! Good grief people! 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

I've never received unemployment but my question is...doesn't unemployement have a cap time wise? I'm just thinking out loud whether it would be cost effective if it's only for x-amount of time. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

How much money are we talking to routinely test people for drugs before giving unemployment?

And how easy would it be for them to "cheat" the test?

I'm all for it, if it is practical. . . 

I roll around kingwood --- 14 years ago -

Drug screening for unemployment yes. But not for jobs. Doesn't matter what your doing at home as long as you get stuff done at work. But unemployment is a different story. If you have higher priorities than searching for a job while unemployed, then chances are youll have higher priorities than going to work 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

But not for jobs. Doesn't matter what your doing at home as long as you get stuff done at work

What about the airline pilots that have been caught drinking on the job, or the teacher that is with children all day, etc.? Those are actions that affect other people. 

Ms Purseonality --- 14 years ago -

 

Unpopular Poet --- 14 years ago -

Yes.
But I think a CLEAN drug-screen should be a requirement to even receive any sort of government benefit.
My answer has nothing to do with their ability to "get a job", since there are plenty of job opportunities that do NOT require a drug-test. 

I roll around kingwood --- 14 years ago -

Alcohol maybe. I guess certain jobs such as airline pilot and teacher. Can't really think of anymore though. I know a bunch of people who work big jobs yet they enjoy a little smOke once in a while. Lol but there is a difference about doing things at home like I just said and doing things while ON the job. Not hurting anyone at home are they? 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Sounds like a big spending proposal to me. Wierd who comes up with all these ideas for spending.

I guess it's as I say not as I do. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

if the money is already being spent by giving it to those who are not actively seeking employment - based on the fact that they are incapable of passing a drug screening, this would not cost any more money. We would shift the funds away from giving it them and that would pay for the tests.

Seems easy, then savings could be put back in to the program to assist those following the rules.

Reward good behavior, punish bad. Isn't that how you raise a child to be responsible? 

crazypinetrees --- 14 years ago -

ONLY use drug testing on people in "safety sensitive" transportation jobs.

Sorry but they better keep testing in all jobs. NOT just transportation jobs. I dont need some stoned jackwagon on an oil rig killing my husband. 

PokerFace --- 14 years ago -

That unemployment money doesn't last that long depending on what state you are in. Your employer pays into the program via taxes, so it's not just "government money.". Not everyone is able to receive benefits either, so no, I don't think we need drug test people on unemployment.

Welfare is another story... 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Not ever person on unemployment is on drugs!

That may be true, however, some may now be on drugs, due to unemployment! Depression will cause folks to need drugs to function and I'm thinking if a person worked at a job for many years and was laid off, they may become depressed.
So, with that being said, a doctor's prescription can verify that. But how long do you give a person to "get over it"! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Gigix4 one of the fastest growing diagnoses for disability claims now is depression from being out of work.

Have to love a system that pays someone to stay out of work by saying they are sad they are out of work. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Have to love a system that pays someone to stay out of work by saying they are sad they are out of work.

Yeppers! 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Not just no, but hell no. These people have done nothing wrong. They don't deserve that type of scrutiny. If they have been laid off, they obviously had held a job so there is no reasonable suspicion of drug use.


How do people that are against "gov't intrusion" than think it's o.k. to drug test for absolutely no reason? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Reward good behavior, punish bad. Isn't that how you raise a child to be responsible?


And what the hell makes you think you have the right to "parent" someone because they were laid off. They don't need parenting they've been laid off and now are recieving unemployment benefits that they earned by being in the workforce.(for likely most of their lives) 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

I voted NO because such testing is NOT free and who will pay for it?

A liberal worried about someone else paying for something. Classic.

Get the taxpayer to pay for it. It works with all the other liberal supported taxpayer programs. 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

Poll results: The conservatives are overwhelmingly in favor (92.7 vs 7.3) of spending money for programs they deem appropriate.

There will be no more claims that they favor smaller government, lower taxes, and a balanced budget, since those things obviously take a back seat to their political agenda. 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

I vote yes and as far as drug screen cost. OMG you can buy a test at walgreens for less than 20$ I am sure the government can get the for almost FREE! better than paying for some drug addict on foodstamps or unemployment using the money for drugs. I see people all the time sharing their lonestar card and giving money to people with them so they can go buy drugs. And dont tell me its not true.. I know for a fact it is!

Also I agree if you have to be drug free to hold a job then you must be drug free to get the governments money, which in all reality is OUR money! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Since the requirement is actively seeking employment and a requirement of employment is passing a drug screen this makes sense.

If you don't want to seek employment that's your choice, no one is forcing you to seek employment. But if you aren't seeking, you don't get paid.

Why should we pay for lying? 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 14 years ago -

Yes 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I think alcohol is a bigger issue in my opinion and its freaking legal. So many lazy drunks that can't get their butts out of bed and get to work. How would you test for legal substances if they are not intoxicated but are just a drunk?

The alcoholic passes the system because its legal but is just as dysfunctional.

What about people who take legally prescribed drugs for any number of mental or physcial issues?

Do they get benefits? How does the employment office know if they are supposed to be taking those medications? Do they need to submit their medical history with a note from their doctor?

Where do we draw the line on what drugs are allowed? Abuse it abuse. 

PokerFace --- 14 years ago -

Why should we pay for lying? 

One of the befits of being an employed individual is that your employer pays into this program for you to help cover expenses while you look for another job. "you" are not paying anything.

I have had several jobs in my working life, and had never been drug tested. A responsible working individual uses that money to live off of until they find employment. It's not an endless stream of money, either.

Stop acting like you are being taken advantage of by people on unemployment. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

i dont get it. why drug test? how about alcohol, which is way more pervasive? i think that people associate drugs and unemployment based on perceptions and biases and not the reality that unemployed is unemployed. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

How do people that are against "gov't intrusion" than think it's o.k. to drug test for absolutely no reason?

Oh, this is different. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Actually you all bring up a great point.

If the government was not involved in paying for the unemployed we would not have this discussion therefore the base reason isn't the screening, it is the government intrusion in to business and lives of individuals.

Therefore, stop paying for the unemployed and let them save for times not working, let businesses use the money the would otherwise pay the government to either hire more people, pay people more or reinvesent in their business or take the profit - their choice. That way each person is responsible for their own destinies.

Great point all. You are RIGHT. We need to end unemployment payments!!!!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground