Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

This Is Why The Internet Will Make You Nuts

who's talking here?

Porter Wagoner 1
Polly Ester 3
Work in Progress 1
idontplaynice 1
Dorothy Parker 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 11
Nurse Ratched 1
Semper 4
Emperor of Kingwood 4
Sweet Cherub 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

So, I was reading on Reddit and someone posed this relationship question:

"We have been dating for about half a year now and I just can't seem to get over her past. One of the biggest things I can't get over is the fact that she used to have a friends-with-benefits sort of deal. She justified it as a rough patch in her life and that she would never do it again and that she's changed because she only did it because she wanted to feel loved by someone. The problem is, it was only about half a year ago when she ended this and I am having a hard time getting over it. We are each other's first and real boyfriend and girlfriend. I feel awful that I can't seem to get over her past and I have brought this up with her multiple times and she is comforting and says that she will do anything to earn my trust. I guess I just want some advice as to what I should do about my situation? I don't know what is wrong with me because we both agreed that we care for each other greatly and we are very emotional attached to each other. What are some ways I can learn to get over this paranoia that one day she will cheat on me?
tl;dr: girlfriend has had a past I cannot stand, paranoid that she will cheat on me eventually, we are both very emotionally invested in each other, what do I do?


5 commentsshare
all 5 comments
sorted by: best
[–]delibertine 2 points 4 hours ago
we care for each other greatly and we are very emotional attached to each other.
Every little thing from her past has made her who she is now, good and bad. Trust her, as she's already told you she's willing to do anything to earn it, but also trust yourself that you'll be the kind of boyfriend for her that won't give her a reason to cheat on you and trust the relationship itself, that together the both of you are strong enough and care enough about each other not to stray and understand that you and your relationship with her now will play a part in who she becomes in the future and the same goes for you. It's a new start for her and she's probably really hoping you allow her the chance to prove to you and herself that she's grown from her experiences.

[–]mthang 2 points 3 hours ago
Why would you be paranoid she would cheat on you when she has never demonstrated that she has that tendency?

[–]Brightt 1 point 2 hours ago
There is nothing wrong or weird about FWB, in fact, it's amazing, as long as both of you can deal with it like adults and neither develops feelings.
As for the cheating, why would she cheat on you? Because at some point in time she screwed another guy without emotional attachment? Why would that be any different from having had a boyfriend in the past?
As long as she doesn't display any tendencies that she might cheat, don't bother. You're immensely overreacting.


[–]selfcerulean [score hidden] 3 minutes ago
What's wrong with you, and what part are you actually mad about? Are you a virgin?
permalink
[–]AMerrickanGirl 1 point 2 hours ago
Before I met my first husband I had a decent amount of sex with no strings attached with multiple partners. Did that make me a cheater? Heck no. I've never cheated on anyone, ever, and I'm more than twice your age, OP.
One thing has nothing to do with another.
If you're afraid she will cheat based on zero justification, that says a lot more about you than it does about her. Maybe see a therapist?"





So, now, the person who isn't comfortable with casual sex hook ups, one nighters and sport screwing is the one who needs a therapist????? These people need to read the science behind sex and the brain, the fallout emotionally from this behavior and DISEASES.

The person not comfortable with someone sharing the most intimate part of themselves with people they have no emotional connection with is the strange one, K.

Lmao.



As far as the actual posed question? It's something they should be able to work thru if they can establish trust. But I don't blame him a bit for being uncomfortable with someone who thinks sex is just another bodily function, when it's not. 

Porter Wagoner (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I would love a friend with benefits - I need a better health plan. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

"According to an ABC News article on sex, researchers conducted a study at the University of Montana asking college students about their hookup experiences. The study defined “hooking up” as “a sexual encounter between two people who are not in a dating or serious relationship and do not expect anything further.”

The results weren’t surprising: 54 percent of the participants reported having casual sex throughout the school year.

While looking over the statistics, I couldn’t help but wonder: Can sex really be casual?

For me, casual is sitting around in my pajamas and watching Seinfeld. Casual is going to Chipotle for lunch with friends. Casual is, well, casual.

But sex?

I once attended a seminar taught by Marcie Calandra, an exceptionally brilliant woman with exceptionally brilliant things to say. She worked as an advanced practice nurse in woman’s health for 30 years. Now, she’s a director in nursing at Adventist Hinsdale Hospital. Needless to say, Marcie has credentials.

The topic of the seminar was sex, science and spirituality.

Marcie began with the brain and some very big numbers: 100 billion neurons and 300 billion synaptic opportunities in the neurons. That’s how powerful our brains are. These neurons are what create our memories. Every experience we have, our neurons are firing, firing, firing, and then, BAM — a memory is formed.

Sexual experiences are no different than any other neural experiences. When you have sex, you’re activating neurons that have never been activated before. The reason for this in a traditional hookup is simple: Either you’ve never had sex before, or you’ve never been with that person before.

Once the neurons have been activated, you can’t reverse the process and put them back in a non-activated state. Different experiences activate new neurons. And, in the case of sexual experiences, different people.

“Here’s the take-away,” Marcie said at this point. “The main idea: In the human sexual response, these neurons bind you forever to that human being. You can never erase that unless you have a stroke, Alzheimer’s, or a traumatic brain injury.”

And as if that concept wasn’t thought-provoking enough, Marcie hit us with another. This time, it involved spirituality.

Eyes wide, she told us about a study that was conducted on a group of nuns who claimed to see God during intense prayer and meditation. Researchers found that the part in a nun’s brain that lit up during these moments was the same part that lights up in a person’s brain during sexual climax.

Again, Marcie’s take-away: “The same place where you have your most intense experience of spirituality is the same place in the brain that is excited in the most intense moment of your sexual climax,” she said. “So having a sexual experience with someone is a pretty powerful thing.”

Apparently, I wasn’t the only one stunned by this new knowledge. The girls around the room were silent, grappling with these mind-blowing ideas.

In a world where casual sex has become the norm, Marcie showed us that there is so much more to it. But this information is not well-known, let alone talked about.

Let’s say a guy meets a girl at KAM’S. They each have a few drinks, and then decide to go back to his apartment. What are the chances that they will discuss the brain’s neuronal activity during the human sexual response?

I’d say the chances are slim to nil.

The truth is that casual sex, according to the brain, is not possible. In fact, if sex is directly tied to science and spirituality, it is anything but casual.

For us college students, it’s something to think about: Does billions of neurons rapidly firing in your brain sound casual to you?" 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

I'm saving that article you posted there SciFi. That is wonderful!

One day, my boys will need to understand that sex is not at ALL casual.

Love it. Thank you! 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I don't have a problem with two consenting adults having casual sex...that's their business.

And I certainly don't see it as a character flaw or that they'll be prone to being a cheater.

Sex can be just sex... 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Herein, I think lies the difference. Theres having sex and making love, two distinctly different things. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

My issue isn't really about the behavior itself tho I'm opposed to it. It's about how the guy who had issues with hook ups is vilified bc he doesn't like it. Like somehow he has no right to question that now that he's in a relationship with someone he cares about. I think he has every right to wonder if past behavior might be an indicator of future behavior? If this woman handles a "rough patch" in her life with sex hook ups, I think questioning that is more than fair from his perspective.

Also according to brain testing, sex is bonding whether one agrees or not. You are in essence fighting the physical biology of it by saying you aren't attaching, it's just sex. Not that one can't talk themselves into believing that. But there are lots of issues with FWB becoming a complicated mess too bc people DO end up attaching. To deny that is a possibility isn't being realistic.

Just as wondering if someone you are in love with now who had casual hook ups before, won't handle rough patches again in the same way. Who the hell wouldn't wonder about that?? 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

that guy sounds immature to me. she was honest about a past relationship. she wasn't sleeping with 100s of guys. she had sex with someone she liked and was close to but not in love with.

FWB isn't something new. people have always sex for many different reasons and with different degrees of attachment. I don't see the connection between her past relationship and her potential for cheating. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Bob in Texas --- 7 min ago - quote - hide comments
Herein, I think lies the difference. Theres having sex and making love, two distinctly different things.



True. But the brain sees sex as bonding. Even if you don't want it to be so. You are engaging in an intimate act, meant for intimacy IMO. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

But the brain sees sex as bonding.

Im not so sure about that, especially with some men Ive met. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

FWB isn't something new. people have always sex for many different reasons and with different degrees of attachment. I don't see the connection between her past relationship and her potential for cheating.


And I agree it might not mean she will cheat. But again if casual sex is ok with her but causes him doubts, isn't that a fair issue for him to consider? Their values re different. And while people can make anything work if they want to, him being honest and wondering this is completely NORMAL, not therapy material. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Just as wondering if someone you are in love with now who had casual hook ups before, won't handle rough patches again in the same way. Who the hell wouldn't wonder about that?? 


I wouldn't wonder about that. Friends with benefits isn't cheating. It's hooking up with someone who is on the same page you are.

I think to worry about that is strange, but that's just my opinion. If it really bothers someone, it sounds like they need to find a new significant other. Someone who thinks more like they do.

Problem solved. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

But again if casual sex is ok with her but causes him doubts, isn't that a fair issue for him to consider?

You are absolutley correct. Its about values which extrapolates into many other areas of life. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

That makes Sense ,DP, but he's already in love so he has questions. 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

But again if casual sex is ok with her but causes him doubts, isn't that a fair issue for him to consider? Their values re different. And while people can make anything work if they want to, him being honest and wondering this is completely NORMAL, not therapy material.

I agree that values are different and maybe theirs are too different. If he is that into her though and is questioning if she is going to cheat on him due to having a past relationships, he has hangups, at least where she is concerned. If he wants the relationship to move forward maybe he does need to talk to an outside person to see if this is something he can get past or not.

he is worried that she is going to cheat, I think it is just as likely that he would become the untrusting and the possessive, jealous type and throw her past up in her face if they hit a "rough patch". It goes both ways.

I think he is making a big deal about a relationship that she was totally honest about. but if it is that big of deal to him he might need counseling to get past it or it will be a big issue in their future together. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Hissy Fit --- 2 min ago - quote - hide comments
But again if casual sex is ok with her but causes him doubts, isn't that a fair issue for him to consider? Their values re different. And while people can make anything work if they want to, him being honest and wondering this is completely NORMAL, not therapy material.

I agree that values are different and maybe theirs are too different. If he is that into her though and is questioning if she is going to cheat on him due to having a past relationships, he has hangups, at least where she is concerned. If he wants the relationship to move forward maybe he does need to talk to an outside person to see if this is something he can get past or not.

he is worried that she is going to cheat, I think it is just as likely that he would become the untrusting and the possessive, jealous type and throw her past up in her face if they hit a "rough patch". It goes both ways.

I think he is making a big deal about a relationship that she was totally honest about. but if it is that big of deal to him he might need counseling to get past it or it will be a big issue in their future together.





He's serious about her and that makes one feel very vulnerable. You don't think that's normal?


Also she said she handles stressors or a "rough patch" with sex. I think that's totally reasonable to question as well.


Everyone has past relationships, but that's the difference, it wasn't a real relationship with sex and emotions. THAT is the issue for him. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Ditto Hissy's post.

You can't really love someone and sit there questioning them all of the time. If they're honest with you and have shown you no reason to doubt their loyalty and dedication to the relationship and you're still holding their past against them, the problem lies with you, not them.

I shouldn't have to prove myself, give constant reassurance and placate someone in a new relationship because they have an issue with my past. I don't deal well with irrational insecurity.

Either you accept me or you don't. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

He probably sees her attitude about sex as cavalier and that doesn't jive with his perspective. He knows the truth. Now he either needs to move on or decide whether he can get past it.

People need to be honest in their relationships and what they consider dealbreakers. If they aren't willing to compromise or get past the "past" then find someone else.

As a single woman, never married, no kids; I wasn't willing to compromise on ethnicity, religion, previous marital status, child status and so I didn't bother with anyone that didn't fit those particular requisites. It's not like someone was going to change who I was and I wasn't going to change anyone either so why waste time, energy or emotion? 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

As a single woman, never married, no kids; I wasn't willing to compromise on ethnicity, religion, previous marital status, child status and so I didn't bother with anyone that didn't fit those particular requisites. It's not like someone was going to change who I was and I wasn't going to change anyone either so why waste time, energy or emotion?


I think that is fine and if those were dealbreakers for you then I understand not compromising. but sometimes you meet someone when you weren't looking and the chemistry hits and you weren't planning on having those feelings. That is when you have to analyze if the relationship is one that has a future or not, and if it doesn't move on before you get too deep.

If his value system or emotional stage in life or relationship experience or whatever it is that is giving him these concerns makes her past relationship something he is hung up on he needs to either get it worked out (maybe with a therapist, nothing wrong with that) or move on.

I also don't think that just because during a particular stage in her life she turned to a friend for a sexual relationship means that is how she would handle every stress or rough place. I think we have all handled things in our past in ways we wouldn't handle them in the future. It doesn't sound like this was a routine thing with her, it was a one time relationship.

it is a bigger issue if she thinks there was nothing wrong with that and he does. That says more about how they view things and is more likely to mean they will view other important things vastly different too. doesn't make either one right or wrong, except it might mean they are not right or wrong for each other. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

, except it might mean they are not right or wrong for each other.

Bingo. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

From a mans perspective, a womans past relationships are not an issue. Underscore the word relationship which connotes a love bond.

Her past hook ups (casual sex) might be an issue if shes been like the village bicycle. Its a values thing.

A healthy relationship does not revolve around distrust. 

idontplaynice --- 12 years ago -

I am against casual sex. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I don't think this is something two reasonable people can't resolve. I was just thrown by the way the comments went. She had a F buddy and that was understandable. He was weird for having some questions about that behavior. It's almost as though we like to say they both have the right to their feelings but when she sleeps around we can understand that but not why someone would have questions. I think it's very possible he wonders if she can have intimacy issues if she can sleep with her friends.

I also truly wonder what he's suppose to do with it now? Is he going to be expected to have a few beers with this guy? Is he expected to hang out with him?

Would he be reasonable to wonder about those things? That's how past " experiences" can be complicated to present things. In the event of an ex you had a failed relationship with, most stay far, far away and you don't have to even see them. Lol 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

I recall being at a party where my husband's ex girlfriend was with her then husband. Her foster mom whom I was friends with invited me to her grandkid's party and advised me that the ex would be there in case I wanted to skip it. (Yeah, right).

We went and I died laughing when the foster mom introduced us like the ex and my husband had never known each other. The ex and her husband split within 15 minutes. My husband was saying that the husband wasn't very friendly. I almost bopped him upside the head. "Really...he's supposed to sit down and have a discussion with the man he knows his wife was intimate with?" 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

The same place where you have your most intense experience of spirituality is the same place in the brain that is excited in the most intense moment of your sexual climax,” she said. “So having a sexual experience with someone is a pretty powerful thing.”


Wow, thanks for sharing this. I found it really interesting. Just one more thing that shows that God intended sex to be with the person you were supposed to spend the rest of your life with, not some random person you met at a nightclub and never saw again. Too bad things like this aren't more well known. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I recall being at a party where my husband's ex girlfriend was with her then husband. Her foster mom whom I was friends with invited me to her grandkid's party and advised me that the ex would be there in case I wanted to skip it. (Yeah, right).

We went and I died laughing when the foster mom introduced us like the ex and my husband had never known each other. The ex and her husband split within 15 minutes. My husband was saying that the husband wasn't very friendly. I almost bopped him upside the head. "Really...he's supposed to sit down and have a discussion with the man he knows his wife was intimate with?"



Lol! That's funny. I am on good terms with my dh's ex. We always got along well. To the point we sat together at a family wedding and had a fantastic time. People came up to us and said, aren't you two suppose to hate each other? Lmao

But I totally understand why it's not that way a great amount of the time. And in the event where someone has a F buddy they are still friends with and now dating and in a real relationship, you can't expect them to want to be around that person. Why? Because of jealousy that is natural as well as hate, lol 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

I don't think this is something two reasonable people can't resolve


If their morals don't line up on this subject, then it could absolutely be something they can't resolve. If it bothers him that much now, that is a warning flag to me. Too many times people ignore those warning signs and get married anyway...then end up divorced down the road. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

Too many times people ignore those warning signs and get married anyway...then end up divorced down the road.

Very true. Good intentions are not enough sometimes. There are couples where one doesn't want to have a child ever and the other one does and thinks that they will change their partner's mind on the subject. That's a crapshoot. Going around thinking that you can overcome something just because you don't want to be alone or because you are afraid you will never find another love or because you feel you will change someone is not reason to stay the course. To thine own self be true. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I don't think this is something two reasonable people can't resolve


If their morals don't line up on this subject, then it could absolutely be something they can't resolve. If it bothers him that much now, that is a warning flag to me. Too many times people ignore those warning signs and get married anyway...then end up divorced down the road.




It just depends on a lot of things, mainly whether or not they both want monogamy now. If she wants F buddies and he doesn't, it's toast.

But if they both want commitment and she is sure she does, then they start out where every other couple does. Trust is essential but it has to have clear boundaries they both agree on.

Most relationships tank anyway. If there is really love and they are good companions, then you walk forward with no guarantees, just like everyone else. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

To thine own self be true


Exactly...don't settle, not when it comes to marriage. Til death do us part can be a very long time....lol 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

To thine own self be true


Exactly...don't settle, not when it comes to marriage. Til death do us part can be a very long time....lol




Divorce is sky high and remarriage has even worse stats, so most folks don't ever walk down the "til death do us part" highway. Lol 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

so most folks don't ever walk down the "til death do us part" highway. Lol


....but some of us do.... 

Nurse Ratched --- 12 years ago -

I've been involved in very healthy and mutually beneficial FWB situations in the past that I do not regret in the slightest. They're great for times when you're not in a place where a relationship makes sense, either due to recovering from a previous one, being too busy for dating, or whatever it may be. So long as both parties are completely honest both with themselves and each other about what they want, I don't see the problem.

As far as the original post goes, I hope the girlfriend doesn't fall into the trap of letting her boyfriend make her feel ashamed or "less than" because he can't deal with the fact she slept with someone before him. And, yes, if he continues to obsess over it to the point he can't function in the relationship, he needs therapy. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

If you go into an adult relationship assuming the person has no past, you're setting yourself up for failure.

After re-reading the OP, the guy has only been in this relationship for 6 months...why is he acting like they're married and she betrayed him?

I would dump the guy for constantly asking me for reassurance and justification for a past that didn't involve him.

Needy, insecure men are a huge turn off. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground