Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Dumbed Down in the Name of Inclusion

who's talking here?

GCan 1
randyjet 1
planemom 2
Sandyr9111 2
HUMBLE PIE 1
ukchristine 2
AuthorMan 1
Mabbers 1
onlygirl 2
txdaddy 5
SuperFantastic 1
Diamom 3
Perfection 6
Scottie's Hottie 1
~Songbird~ 1
justcat 2
Paige Paige 1
keepinitreal09 2
Laurabeth 1
Allimama 3
oneyedman 2
Ogre1 4
jtcitrus 1
ladyjane 2
evolved 2
mommie21g1b 1
MxMike. 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

One thing I've noticed for sure... Inclusion is stupid. Putting ESL, Special Needs, Regular Students and AP all in one room only ensures that NOBODY learns anything worth a d@mn-d. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

But they are all treated equally and without making anyone feel bad about being slower. Isn't that a great kumbya feeling? Why would you want to teach kids to excel? Isn't that making those who excel differently feel bad? We don't want that. Dang, can't give liberals anything they want, it's never good enough LOL 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

You can't blame "liberals" for this chunky, it's been a universal constant since I was in school (when dinosaurs roamed the earth). In fact, you may be the first person I've heard call the TEA liberal. Which would be amazing considering that Texas hasn't had a "liberal" government since Anne Richards left office in '95. Sam Clemens said it best, "God created the idiot for practice, then he created the school board." 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

Have to disagree. Very liberal policies. Same that got rid of prayer in school, tied staff's hands in terms of disciplining kids, and "leveled the playing field", i.e. dumbed it down, for everybody. What drives the madness is all the lawsuits - people don't get what they want and they hire an attorney to try to sue the pants off the school for their hurt feeeeeelings. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

IMO, retarded people do not even belong in school...at least not past elementary school. It is a complete waste of time, money and space for other kids. Plus parents use school as day care for their handicapped kids so they don't have to deal with them all day. I mean...come on...why? Why do they sit in high school for 10 years? What do they need to learn that could possibly contribute to society at all? (No offense to people with special needs kids, it's just true.) 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

This was a source of a lot of my frustration Ogre. The inclusion concept seemed to place a lot of kids in my room who simply were not capable of doing the work. I was supposed to individualize the lesson plans for 150 different students, while keeping the distractions of the students to a minimum. A normal, healthy middle school student is wild enough, but when you add in the emotionally disturbed, the mentally challenged, and the ultra gifted amongst the raging hormones, all hell can break loose. I wish you luck. It does get easier. You'll find your teaching "style" that works with the kids and you'll have a lot more successful days than non successful ones. Be sure to take a multivitamin, because you will be more tired than you have been in your LIFE when you first start teaching. Your first year will the toughest, and you will learn more than the students. It's sink or swim, but I know with your sense of humor and insight, you'll be fine. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

The national TEA is a liberal group. Mainstreaming is a federal plan. Even at the cost of a majority of the students the needs of special kids must be met. I agree in many cases it does not work. The separte classrooms will not be returning any time soon. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

That's very true, schools are notorious places for liberalism. Just wait till you get the stuff from the HFT! I just laughed when I read all of the propaganda. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Perhaps Ogre1 is so left leaning that it seems they are conservative to him. Schools do not teach children to compete, they teach them to get along and play only to the middle of the pack. Such a shame. I remember as a kid when I would accomplish something how great it felt and I wanted to do it more and more. We have taken that away from our children, we have allowed it to be taken away. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

MxMike. --- 3 min ago - quote - flag comment IMO, retarded people do not even belong in school...at least not past elementary school. It is a complete waste of time, money and space for other kids. Plus parents use school as day care for their handicapped kids so they don't have to deal with them all day. I mean...come on...why? Why do they sit in high school for 10 years? What do they need to learn that could possibly contribute to society at all? (No offense to people with special needs kids, it's just true.) WTF is wrong with you?????? 

~Songbird~ --- 16 years ago -

MxMike, my son has asperger's and is special needs. He is doing better than most of the normal ed kids in his classroom. Did you know Bill Gates and Stephen Spielburg have some form of autism? Did you know that the way our entire cattle and beef industry does most of their processing from a program that was put together by an autistic woman? IMO, retarded people do not even belong in school...at least not past elementary school. They are capable of learning to read, write, do math, etc etc etc. They are capable of doing MANY skills. If they weren't able to go to school, they wouldn't be able to learn at all. Plus parents use school as day care for their handicapped kids so they don't have to deal with them all day. This is the most frustrating comment I've seen in a long time. You have absolutely NO idea what one of these parents have to go through on a day to day basis. Most of the time, both parents have to work to afford to take care of their family. They have to pay for extra medical bills, go to extra meetings to make sure the child's education is maximized so that they can grow up to do more than just sit on the couch their entire life. Amongst many MANY other things. I don't drop my son off at school as a daycare so I don't have to deal with him. I send him to get an education. What an offensive statement. I mean...come on...why? Why do they sit in high school for 10 years? What do they need to learn that could possibly contribute to society at all? I have a friend I went to school with who has downs syndrome. This man (to your definition) was a waste of space, time and money in school. He has a drivers license, a job, and he helps out at the school. He pays taxes and contributes to his household. He has a girlfriend. None of which would be possible without all that time he spent wasting space and money in school. I do agree with you Ogre. They should not all be lumped in together with all their different situations. My son's school has figured this out. They have separate rooms for each disposition. However, their school has one of the best special needs programs in the state. 

onlygirl --- 16 years ago -

Ditto Laurabeth and Songbird. I'm sick to my stomach reading that IGNORANT comment! MxMike - I hope that you don't have a child with special needs one day! 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

WTF is wrong with you?????? Don't be too hard on him. He is borderline special needs too. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

a child with special needs one day! While I am in NO way agreeing with MxMike here, you said it best yourself onlygirl. The child has special needs, that denotes that they should not be in a mainstreamed class and this is what Ogre1's post is about. Including children of all levels in one classroom does not lead to challenging those who need to be challenged, it only leads to helping those who need a little more time to catch up. While this is good for those who need the special attention, it is not good for those who need to learn more and are capable of it. You said it yourself, a child with special needs............ 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

Umm, doesn't it depend on what the special needs are? You can't work or live anywhere where everybody's just the same. Isn't it the degree of variability that presents a problem? 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

it's been a universal constant since I was in school (when dinosaurs roamed the earth). seriously? where did you go to school? i gather we are about the same age, and i never saw the inclusion or "everybody wins" attitude or concept in my school. 

keepinitreal09 --- 16 years ago -

I have to say that I do agree with most of the opinions on underground...One thing has not been mentioned though, and that is parents who foster their childrens learned helplessness......When a child tells you that he can not do something because he is ADHD, it kind of makes you want to throw up.... 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

special needs I detest this kind of verbage... They have different needs, what makes their need "special"? 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

mxmike...just wow. you have the mind of a two year old, yet you own weapons. sheesh. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

special needs I detest this kind of verbage... They have different needs, what makes their need "special"? they require a specialize educator to assist them. a 'normal' teacher is not trained to help these kids like they need it. so..."special needs". 

onlygirl --- 16 years ago -

What I said has nothing to do with whether I agree or disagree with Orge's original post. It has to do with MxMike's ignorant statement. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Mike you owe a lot of people an apology. Steve, while we may find his bluntness a bit uncomfortable, MxMike has a right to his opinion. Part of what our problem is is that we are afraid of these uncomfortable situations and conversations because we don't want to hurt "feelings". In order to have an adult conversation we need to be able to discuss these items and not take them personally but look at things factually. You said yourself that kids were divided in to various learning groups when you were growing up and that was a good thing. Now kids are lumped together and most of the smarter kids are bored or used as tutors for others or just spend time checking out the internet during the day. MxMike's comment was cringe worthy, without doubt, and I am sure that some took it very personally as evidenced by the posts. But he should be allowed to voice his opinion just as we all are. The discussion is about general educations rules that force children all together, it was not about one specific child. That's where the feelings came in, those who were hurt took it to be their child and not the situation as a whole. Tough to do. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

MxMike's comment was cringe worthy, without doubt, and I am sure that some took it very personally as evidenced by the posts. But he should be allowed to voice his opinion just as we all are. just as steve should be allowed to voice his opinion that mike owes a lot of people an apology. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

they require a specialize educator to assist them. a 'normal' teacher is not trained to help these kids like they need it. so..."special needs". BS.... "Special" is used to massage the feelings of parents, teachers and others who work with these kids. Just like they are no longer "retarded" but or "Handicapped", but "Handicapable" instead. Changing the verbage does nothing to change the thing. It is a crutch for the weak of mind. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

just as steve should be allowed to voice his opinion that mike owes a lot of people an apology. Absolutely. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

BS.... "Special" is used to massage the feelings of parents, teachers and others who work with these kids. Just like they are no longer "retarded" but or "Handicapped", but "Handicapable" instead. Changing the verbage does nothing to change the thing. It is a crutch for the weak of mind. are you really angry with the way these kids are referred to? i mean, seriously? pretty sure they have anough to deal with without some a-hole saying their parents are weak because they call them special needs instead of your preference. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

MxMike's comment was cringe worthy, without doubt, and I am sure that some took it very personally as evidenced by the posts. But he should be allowed to voice his opinion just as we all are. To defend something that belittles the hardships that special needs parents and children go through is pathetic. I think the mission is inclusion and education, only some could call it liberal. I'll call it humane and proper. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

It is a complete waste of time, money and space for other kids. Okay fine, I'll address this instead of freaking out. Not necessarily Mike. It may, in fact, seem so from an objective, all-inclusive stereotypical look from 'above' the system. LOL. Although I do not have a special needs child, I can tell you personal and daily interaction is crucial and can be beneficial for all students. Even though ds is in honors and does in fact have, and has had, special needs classmates, he has spent valuable learning time with them teaching and yes...learning as well. Have we thought, "If only we had the money we could seriously help him academically...he'd go so far." Blah, blah, blah. While that may be true academically, it certainly doesn't cover all the other variables of a well-rounded and GROUNDED individual. One must give AND take. I'm fairly certain the good here outweighs the bad, or if anything, it's pretty damn close. In order to trump the attitude of the 'must haves,' there's a degree of service and servitude mentality that should enter any equation. 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

IMO, retarded people do not even belong in school...at least not past elementary school Are you for real????!!!!! I have a friend who is "mentally retarded", I have known him since elementary school. He graduated, has held a full time job, does better at that job then his "normal" coworkers and even has time to do VOLUNTEER work. How many of us work full time and do many hours a month of volunteer work????? I say educate the "retarded" people because they have a good chance of becoming a good citizen and jail the jr high thugs because that is all they will ever become. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

Inclusion is not just for those who have mental or physical challenges - it is for all children. It teaches human compassion at an early age. So many children have such ignorant parents to teach their own kids that these people are a waste of time. EVERY child is created in the image of the creator. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I have a sister who is mentally retarded. She has SPECIAL needs. Needs that are not the same as an "ordinary" child. She also happens to be the first of my sibling group to actually graduate from high school (My other sister, brother and myself all have GED's). MxMike, you are wrong. Plain and simple. The mentally challenged, retarded, emotionally disabled, or whatever code-word you care to use to describe these children, need to shepherded through to a decent education that allows them to be productive at whatever level they can achieve. That's just simple equity. I have no problem with EQUITY. My problem is with the lumping together of all students because it's "Fair". Special needs, Special Education, different; we've placed connotations on these words that simply should not be there. THIS is the root of the problem. NOT the TEA, whether state or federal, but Parents. I don't know the stats, but every teacher I spoken with has said that PARENTS do not want their children labeled "Special" or Retarded, or "Different" and demand that their child be "mainstreamed". The agencies are simply responding to that demand. This is a detriment to both the special needs child and the regular student. As far as the TEA being liberal... how could that even be possible since the director of the agency is appointed by the Governor and the Governor of Texas is a conservative. Doesn't even make sense. And the Federal DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (Not Fed. TEA) is a bloody cabinet posting and for the past eight years has been under a very Conservative administration. Current Federal guidelines are mostly this little thing called NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND which was Bush's brainchild. Mainstreaming is NOT a liberal or conservative issue. BOTH parties support it as evidence by the state of schools today. NOW, I think the federal govt needs to get the he11 out of education entirely. But would never bet on them doing so. This is the business of the states and no one else's. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I remember as a kid when I would accomplish something how great it felt and I wanted to do it more and more. We have taken that away from our children, we have allowed it to be taken away. The schools my kids go to reward achievement. I don't have a clue to what you are referring. If you don't think it's beneficial for "normal" kids to assist and be a part of the education, lives of "special needs" children then that's sad. Academics are as cut throat an endeavor as they ever were, perhaps more with the jockeying for academic scholarships, etc. Sports is even more competitive than before. You are engaging in AM radio ideology before pure knowledge. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

So much depends upon the attitude of the parents and kids as well. I've taught kids with a lot of different disabilities, and often, because of their parents' strength, expectations, and love, they were some of my top performers. I will take a kid with aspberger's who wants to learn anyday over a "normal" child who just doesn't. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Id LOVE for my daughter not to be mainstreamed. Honey she can prove different all by herself! And yep she is special....very special to me with all her quirks and differences. And if you think it teaches these kids compassion, you are blind and deluded because it doesnt. It gives them another kid to bully and harass because they are different. Most kids dont even know what compassion is nowdays. And MXMIKE I overlook alot that you say because ur just different and that is ok. My daughters differences have taught me alot on how to deal better with others differences, BUT i think that was the most rude thing Ive ever heard come out of your mouth and I WISH you a very special child if you can ever find the right woman to breed with so you understand this life isnt a cake walk. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

i tought freshmen & sophmores Econ 1304 @ uh for 3 semesters... its sad that the firs 2 years of COLLEGE are spent teaching EVERYTHING they should have learned in high school 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

I have to disagree about the compassion Sandy - maybe it is the group of kids. My niece is in K & LOVES the afternoons when the inclusion kids come in. She quotes 'just because we look or act different doesn't me we are' How else would you end up with kids wanting their special needs basketball trainer to play in the fall game? Or the girl with special needs being named homecoming queen? Both true stories. I have a nephew with Down's. Inclusion should be based on the disability and what is best for all the kids. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Hold on... I'm not saying SEGREGATE special needs children out of the school population. cripes, where's the idea that the only people kids deal with are the other kids in their blocks??? I don't get that. There are plenty of opportunities for interaction. And teaching compassion is NOT a school teacher's job. It's nice if one does so. But that is YOUR JOB as a parent.... OH, and someone made a comment about prayer in school. PRAYER has not been removed from school. Any student may pray if they so desire, they can even form clubs in which they can pray together. What has been removed from school is PROSCRIBED prayer. And if you actually believe forcing a child to pray to YOUR god, no matter what their faith, is a good thing, then you are a complete scumbag and should move to some place with the level of religious tolerance you can understand...say Iran. 

SuperFantastic --- 16 years ago -

MXMIKE congratulations on looking like a total FUC$TARD 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

Compassion can not happen until there are situations to do so. I teach my kids every chance I get. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Compassion can not happen until there are situations to do so. I teach my kids every chance I get. And as parents we all should but many dont bother. And I dont believe they should be totally segregated BUT i wish it was like when I was in school where the kids that need a lil extra help to keep up were in other classes and not crammed into a class with 25+ other kids and struggle to keep up. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground