Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you feel a flat tax is a fair tax,

who's talking here?

planemom 2
Justwatching72 2
Sandyr9111 1
lizandmike 3
AuthorMan 4
david 2
justforfun 2
~sassy~ 8
Nightstorm 1
zapper007 2
voice of reason 3
jtcitrus 4
evolved 4
allday 1
B12Fan 1
Grumpy 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
In AbsentiaW 1
PiratePersona 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you feel a flat tax is a fair tax,

Flat tax for everyone personal, small business, corporations everyone pays the same %.

Yes Vote
 
 64.0% (32)
no Vote
 
 36.0% (18)
david --- 16 years ago -

Flat tax for everyone personal, small business, corporations everyone pays the same %. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It's the ONLY fair tax.........but it will NEVER happen 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

what about all the taxes other than income that aren't a flat percentage of income? are they fair? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

It'll never happen. How many government employees would lose their jobs? Not to mention accountants and tax lawyers. Too many people have a vested interest in keeping our tax code arduous and complicated. 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

Only if it is a consumption tax. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

Only if it is a consumption tax.



there you have it. 

david --- 16 years ago -

Vor all income capital gains,etc....

Grumpy I agree I would love a vat tax and do away with the income tax all together 

allday --- 16 years ago -

What rate gets the same revenue? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Grumpy I agree I would love a vat tax and do away with the income tax all together



Hell, BO wants to KEEP the current tax code AND add a vat........what a crock! 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

The VAT tax seems to work overseas, doesn't it 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

The VAT tax seems to work overseas, doesn't it

i like the idea, but our government is so freakin' big it would NEVER fly over here.

The Gvmn't would then have to live within their means and we all know that ain't happenin'. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

The VAT tax seems to work overseas, doesn't it

i like the idea, but our government is so freakin' big it would NEVER fly over here.

The Gvmn't would then have to live within their means and we all know that ain't happenin'. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

I voted no.
I don't think it would be fair for someone earning $1million to pay the same percent as someone earning $20,000 per year.
By the same token, I think it has gone too far when 5% pay 49% of the tax. And they want to tax the 'wealthy' more on top of that. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

Vor all income capital gains,etc....


well then that is absolutely a NO vote. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

I voted no.
I don't think it would be fair for someone earning $1million to pay the same percent as someone earning $20,000 per year.
By the same token, I think it has gone too far when 5% pay 49% of the tax. And they want to tax the 'wealthy' more on top of that.




Amen 

PiratePersona --- 16 years ago -

"I don't think it would be fair for someone earning $1million to pay the same percent as someone earning $20,000 per year. "

So you think robin hood wasn't a criminal.

A flat tax has the millionaire paying 100,000 in taxes while the lazyboy only has to pay 2,000. See, the millionaire still pays MORE $$ than the lazyboy.
By your reasoning, the 20k earner should not have to pay any tax. And the 1mil earner should have to pay 980,000 in taxes. No one should be allowed to bring home any more of their earned income than ANYone else! That would be the ultimate progressive tax. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

A flat tax has the millionaire paying 100,000 in taxes while the lazyboy only has to pay 2,000. See, the millionaire still pays MORE $$ than the lazyboy.

And the millionaire brings home 900,000, while the other (I refuse to call him lazy) brings home 18,000. BTW, there is no way for the other to pay more than 2% of what the millionaire makes. That is his total income.

By your reasoning, the 20k earner should not have to pay any tax. And the 1mil earner should have to pay 980,000 in taxes.

No, that is an erroneous assumption on your part. If you want to blurt your assumptions, do so.
Plus, why do you change screen names so much? One identity not enough for you? 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

nd the millionaire brings home 900,000, while the other (I refuse ato call him lazy) brings home 18,000.


So should everyone make the same annual income? Those making upwards of 200k/year are working hard for it. They have, in most cases, spent years in school to obtain the skills to perform their job and often spent years "climbing the corporate ladder" to have the positions that pay those kinds of salaries.
Please explain to me why it's ok for the government to take a substantially larger percent of that income than the guy who didn't apply himself in school, make the sacrifices to attend college, spend years beng adedicated employee. I understand not taxing everyone the same amount, but why not the same percent? Shouldn't hard work and dedication pay off?
I don't understand the idea od penalizing the top earners in our society. There seems to be a real villainization of those who earn +200k or so. What happened to the American spirit of hard work? 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

nd the millionaire brings home 900,000, while the other (I refuse ato call him lazy) brings home 18,000.


So should everyone make the same annual income? Those making upwards of 200k/year are working hard for it. They have, in most cases, spent years in school to obtain the skills to perform their job and often spent years "climbing the corporate ladder" to have the positions that pay those kinds of salaries.
Please explain to me why it's ok for the government to take a substantially larger percent of that income than the guy who didn't apply himself in school, make the sacrifices to attend college, spend years beng adedicated employee. I understand not taxing everyone the same amount, but why not the same percent? Shouldn't hard work and dedication pay off?
I don't understand the idea od penalizing the top earners in our society. There seems to be a real villainization of those who earn +200k or so. What happened to the American spirit of hard work? 

PiratePersona --- 16 years ago -

"By your reasoning, the 20k earner should not have to pay any tax. And the 1mil earner should have to pay 980,000 in taxes."

No, that is an erroneous assumption on your part.


It's NOT erroneous... it is the far end of a progressive tax.
If that is wrong/not fair/whatever ... then what makes the near end of the progressive scale ok??? ... why should ANYone make more money than some other person????

Why not just have the IRS collect 100% from EVERYONE... let the government use what they want, then divide the rest evenly between all people within our borders? How can that not be fair by your standards??? 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

. why should ANYone make more money than some other person????

Are you serious??? Should a brain surgeon and the kid working the drive thru window be paid the same amount?

I can't believe you actually think that. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Federal Sales Tax would be my vote. Everyone pay tax based on what they buy period. You would still have property tax but it should be reasonable not the crap we have now. In other states you can buy a million dollar home and pay 3000 a year in property tax or less. Not here.

Oh and flat tax would be the next best thing. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -


Are you serious??? Should a brain surgeon and the kid working the drive thru window be paid the same amount?



I can't believe anyone thinks like that. 

PiratePersona --- 16 years ago -


I can't believe you actually think that.


I'd like to think that if you read the entire thread, you'd understand that I was being facetious.
It is, however, the TYPE of thinking that makes people think a progressive tax system is "fair". 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

How can that not be fair by your standards???

It is, however, the TYPE of thinking that makes people think a progressive tax system is "fair".

You have no clue what my standards are.
Plus, you might want to read all of my first entry:

By the same token, I think it has gone too far when 5% pay 49% of the tax. And they want to tax the 'wealthy' more on top of that.  

PiratePersona --- 16 years ago -

In other states you can buy a million dollar home and pay 3000 a year in property tax or less. Not here.

In those states, you also pay a state income tax... something we DON'T pay HERE.

But yes... we pay Federal Income taxes, SocSec taxes, Medicare/Medicaid taxes, gasoline tax, special taxes attached to each of your utilities, fees paid to government agencies for various things you want/need to do... Do most people even realize that nearly 50% of their income (sometimes more) ends up in the government coffers eventually?? 

PiratePersona --- 16 years ago -

By the same token, I think it has gone too far when 5% pay 49% of the tax. And they want to tax the 'wealthy' more on top of that.

Then you need to support a flat tax.
(Or a federal sales/use tax withOUT an income tax.)

Your "gone too far" problem is the end result of having a progressive tax structure. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Let's simplify my thoughts for you.
Flat tax is unfair to low wage earners.
Current progressive tax has gone too far.
So, we need to meet in the middle. 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

I think a FAT tax would be fairer.

People could pay based on the %-age over their goal weight...lol

There would be a great many broke people in the world, including me... 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I vote abolish income tax and go to straight across the board sales tax. That would take out the equation of those making cash and not paying income tax and i bet there is more of those than you think. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

I would prefer the Fair tax over the Flat tax.

Fair Tax Vs. Flat Tax 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

I like it when people argue about the relative fairness of tax systems without clarifying their different criteria for "fair". It's so productive.

I'll see if I can find the thread where I wrote about this at length... 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

Sorry jcitrus, this is KU, nothing is ever productive on here when it come to discussions about religion, or politics or how the country is being ran.

Figured you would know that by now. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Let's simplify my thoughts for you.
Flat tax is unfair to low wage earners.
Current progressive tax has gone too far.
So, we need to meet in the middle.



That about sums it up A-man but you know the government will NEVER change the current system. To do so might mean cutbacks for them and they would never allow that to happen.

Congress might have to give up their lavish perks and over the top retirement plans and insane petty cash allotments.

Wonder how many of 'em still accept lavish trips and gifts from lobbyists that were supposedly outlawed some years ago. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Authorman. We have to have a progressive system, I believe. Not many multi millionaires scream and cry about taxes. It's the middle class who carry a burden that's unfair.

I'm never going to say "poor people" are getting over on me by not paying. That's asinine and insulting to less fortunate. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

Figured you would know that by now
I know JW. I know.... but someone usually someone else points it out.




Sorry this is so long... google dug it up out of the "Pendleton Underground" lol.


jtcitrus --- 135 days ago - quote

I'm busy today [b/c I checked in on KU too much yesterday ;)]. So I'll answer in bits and pieces as we go along. Once I'm done with my serial pedantic monologue, I'll come back (wife permitting) and respond to comments and to the ridiculous assertions of the fair/flat tax people (not that those are necessarily bad ideas) [how's that for academic non-commitment] [cue classical music]

Why a Progressive income tax can be considered fair: It has to do with what is known as "Diminishing Marginal Utility". In this case the "Diminishing Marginal Utility of Money" DMUM, means that as your income rises, the last dollar earned adds less and less benefit to the earner. Conversely the utility gain from the first several dollars earned is quite significant... this ties into why people are "risk-averse"; it hurts more to loose $100 than it feels good to win/earn $100. here is a graph with an appropriate curve.


0

imagine that a person making 100k (at the far right hand side) and a person earning 20k (towards the left). A 20 % drop in wealth/income represents a much smaller detriment to utility for the person earning 100k than it does for the person earning 20k. the only way the relative "pain" of taxation under a flat tax would be equal, would be if there were no diminishing marginal utility (a flat straight line where everyone has the same utility of money regardless of wealth or income level). Experimental economists and behavioral psychologists and even game shows have supported in empirical tests that DMUM is a real phenomenon. Therefore, a flat/fair tax cannot in any way universally be considered the "fairest".

to claim that the "pain" would be equal assumes something about the aggregate shape of that curve that we don't know.

...so, Whatever income tax scheme you go with (progressive, regressive, proportional (flat)), in order to claim that one of them is more fair than the other assumes that
1) You know what the aggregate Marginal Utility Curve looks like,
2) that such a thing exists. One of the things that gets Macro-economists in trouble is the assumption that preferences can be aggregated. This is probably not true and is highly technical to demonstrate.

The end result is that in both practice and even in theory, it is probably nonsensical to talk about a "fair" tax system for everyone at all. - it is likely that the best we can hope fore is a system that is "good-enough". AKA, "that which achieves the goal of adequately funding the provision of public goods without sufficiently screwing over a significant portion of the electorate."

That's what I think about the "Fairness" portion of the question... but there's still the question of efficiency, and (since it was the original point of the thread) the kinds of policies I'd like to see.


You'll notice in the above that "sufficient" and "significant" are slippery words, and that I didn't say which public goods

Some tax policy changes that I'd like to see (and for the most part seem possible):

1) Scrap Cap-N-Trade, and impose a small carbon tax on combustible fuel - in exchange, demand a [ahem] "revenue neutral" decrease in payroll taxes.

2) Get rid of the cap on S.S. taxable income, every one pays it on every dollar (not just the first 100k or whatever it is now) - in exchange, cut the rate by about half
3) Tax dividend payments as regular income - in exchange, cut corporate income taxes by 50-100%

other things I'd like to see: move the S.S. retirement age back one year every 2 or 3 years until it is equal to a lagged average life expectancy of all workers (set to adjust automatically every decade) BUT leave the "retirement age" rules for tax advantaged accounts largely unchanged. I have other ideas, and the devil is of course in the details.
 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

jcitrus, you're talking to the wrong crowd.

If you try to expalin to them that the 4th cheeseburger will not derive them as much marginal utility they will cry that it's not so. LOL 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

If you try to expalin to them that the 4th cheeseburger will not derive them as much marginal utility they will cry that it's not so. LOL

doesn't that depend on the cheeseburger? after all, if the decrease is imperceptible it wont affect utility...

:) 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

OK OK...but assuming you can only eat so many before you get sick and the first one to a cheeseburger fanatic holds extremely high util value then I'd say the incremental satisfaction would drop on the 4th even for the most delicious of cheeseburgers -:) 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

We have to have a progressive system, I believe. Not many multi millionaires scream and cry about taxes.


Wanna bet? Oh never mind, guess it would be kinda hard to know this when you live with your head in the sand.

If you don't think those in the top 5% have a problem carrying the load for the other 95% you have serious issues. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground