Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is Calling Someone Fat Bullying?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
planemom 2
ExLady In Blue 2
captureit11 1
Perfection 3
AngieKaye 1
zapper007 1
voice of reason 2
jtcitrus 2
JohnLynch 3
sweetscreaminmonkey 3
Work in Progress 10
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3
itstxdaddy 7
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
justforfun1 2
TheFallen 1
FluffyPenguin 3
anjjjk 1
tredanis 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Saw this on The today Show, wondering what you guys thought..?



"When Wisconsin news anchor Jennifer Livingston received a message from a viewer criticizing her weight, she decided to speak out about it on air, calling the viewer a bully. NBC's Mara Schiavocampo reports and Livingston explains why she needed to address this letter publicly.

By JoNel Aleccia, NBC News

"What has happened has been really inspiring, but overwhelming at the same time," Wisconsin television anchor Jennifer Livingston told TODAY's Savannah Guthrie Wednesday.

The 37-year-old anchor/reporter at WKBT-TV in La Crosse, Wis., became the center of attention Tuesday after she went on air to respond to what she called "a personal attack," a harshly critical email from a viewer who suggested she was too fat to be on TV. Her bold retort has become national news, spurring a heartwarming response from the public and a new discussion about the boundaries of bullying.

"I have never gone in the public and said I was a shining example of what your health should be," Livingston told TODAY Wednesday. "And I have never said girls should aspire to have a body like mine."

She continued, "When you attack somebody on a level that is personal, it’s not fair."

In the original email, the viewer wrote: “Obesity is one of the worst choices a person can make and one of the most dangerous habits to maintain. I leave you this note hoping that you’ll reconsider your responsibility as a local public personality to present and promote a healthy lifestyle.”

Many media types may have shrugged off the criticism as part of the job. Anyone who’s in the public eye is used to hate mail, name-calling -- and worse. But then Livingston’s husband, fellow WKBT anchor Mike Thompson, posted the email on the station’s Facebook page.

Hundreds of people left comments; more than 2,200 “liked” the posts.

And so Livingston decided to fight back.

In an on-air segment that ran more than 4 minutes, she acknowledged that she is overweight – “You can call me fat, and yes, even obese on a doctor’s chart,” she said -- but then she lashed out at the viewer for contributing to a culture of bad-mouthing and bullying.

“If you are at home and you are talking about the fat newslady, guess what, your children are probably going to go to school and call someone fat,” she said.

She urged children and others who have been victims of cruel criticism to take heart.

“Do not let yourself be defined by bullies,” she said.

On TODAY Wednesday, Livingston, the mother of three girls, said it wasn't the fat-shaming that upset her, but the accusation of being a bad role model.

"I can deal with being called fat ... with being called obese," she told TODAY's Guthrie. "It was calling me a bad role model that rubbed me the wrong way, and not only a bad role model for our community, but for young girls, in particular."

The man who wrote the email, Kenneth Krause, told the Associated Press that his emails had nothing to do with bullying. Livingston and Krause exchanged a few emails, but Livingston said he wouldn't back down from his opinion that she was a bad role model.

On Tuesday Krause stood by his initial email and issued a statement: "I hope she will finally take advantage of a rare and golden opportunity to influence the health and psychological well-being of coulee region children by transforming herself for all of her viewers to see over the next year, and, to that end, I would be absolutely pleased to offer jennifer any advice or support she would be willing to accept." 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

Its totally wrong yes. I taught my boys to laugh back with people that make fun of them, made life easier on them in school. Dont get your feelings hurt, then they win!! laugh back at them and they are confused and go to someone else that is weak!

Our family has a weird last name and we get joked at alot, doesn't bother either of us, not to mention my boys were and are "big boys" 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

according to chunkster's logic, if they are fat then it isn't bullying it is the truth. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

according to chunkster's logic

you sure do love you some chunky don't you? 

captureit11 --- 14 years ago -

ABSOLUTELY YES 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -

You wouldn't want your son or daughter calling another kid in their class fat would you? Why is it acceptable for adults doing it? Does her being overweight really ruin this person's life that much? Is it hurting them because of HER choice to be overweight? Does it really mess up her ability to give the news? Doubtful! 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

i don't know if it's "bullying" so to speak, but it's wrong.

it could be bullying depending on how it's used. like when one of you post a pic of an overweight person and put perfection's name on the pic, then you all sit back and laugh about it....yep, bullying. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

the problem with this particular sitautaion is that she is on TV, and therefore subject to ratings and such.

if people stop watching because she is overweight, the station has to make a change. 

anjjjk --- 14 years ago -

This is wrong. I believe fat is defined differently to each individual. If you don't feel that you are fat then so be it. I'm sorry but to me too skinny is uglier than too "fat". I love what this woman did!
As for my son, he is a little bigger but in his school he says he is "normal". So when one kid called him fat last year he told them "look around i'm the normal one sorry that doesn't make you feel good about yourself". I love that kid! 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -


if people stop watching because she is overweight, the station has to make a change.



That's like saying if people stop watching because the news castors are 'ethnic' they should make a change.

I don't agree with either. If it's not affecting her ability to deliver the news it should not be a problem. There are 'fat' news castors all around. It just seems because this one is a woman that she should be subjected to scrutiny. I do understand that our society has a really messed up view on what 'beauty' is, but this goes too far. It doesn't hurt you(general) that she's 'fat' , it hurts her. Positive reinforcement is better than bashing. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

Like any word it depends on the context. Spoken in a certain way the words skinny and pretty can be used to bully. This viewers email must have struck a nerve for her to speak out. It's probably not the first one she has received regarding her weight. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I love how she handled it.

She knows she is overweight, it's not like it is news to her.

The emailer tried to use words to hurt her - that is the bullying component.

Bullying is intent - it is why something is said not just if it is factually correct. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

Reporters will be hired and fired based on their looks. Anybody who is in television knows that whether they are on the news or on a soap opera. TV shows, including the news, make their money based on advertising. Advertising prices are based on viewership. Anything that causes viewership to decrease will be changed. Why do you think Leno got his spot back on the Tonight Show? 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

you sure do love you some chunky don't you?


ICEABLE OFFENSE! you called her by something other than her current moniker!

Mods, can we get a ruling please.


/sarcasm 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

0 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -

Perfection --- 3 min ago - quote - hide comments
0 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

What if this person emailed her and told her that her nose was too big? Her teeth were crooked? Her eyes were set too close together or whatever?!?! There would be no debate over it, it would be rude and bullying. To think that people beleive it is ok to blast people about how they look, no matter the facts is just a reflection on how uncaring our society has become. People have always talked, sometimes bad, about people behind their backs but it is recent that it has become the norm and considered by some to be ok for people to publicly attack others because of their looks. Very sad. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I think it was rude. I don't consider it bullying. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

to be considered bullying...the comment would have to be repeatedly directed towards that individual by the perpetrator 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

I think it was rude. I don't consider it bullying.

I concur. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

As someone who constantly struggles with weight, I have to agree with Y3. It's rude, but it's not bullying to point out the obvious.

It's rude, because it's not like she doesn't KNOW, and it's not some viewers place to tell her to live a healthy lifestyle, as if she'd never thought of it before, especially since it had absolutely nothing to do with her segment or talking points. If she were a nutritionist touting some miracle diet. . .well, then yeah, that would be pertinent to her information.

But bullying is an attempt to harm or control the person. And that letter didn't do that. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

I look at this differently. The viewer sent a private email to the anchor woman. The anchor woman decided to go public because she had the audience to use. How and why did a private email become so well known? Who is really the bully? 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

That's like saying if people stop watching because the news castors are 'ethnic' they should make a change.

it's not about if they should...it's ALL about ratings. if their ratings are low for an extended period of time, it doesn't matter why...they have to make a change or lose MONEY! 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

ICEABLE OFFENSE! you called her by something other than her current moniker!

i was talking about the candy bar...what are you talking about? 

zapper007 --- 14 years ago -

Yes...

Weight - and sexual and religious preferences are personal.

Not out there for discussion or name calling...jmho 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Weight - and sexual and religious preferences are personal.

Yes they are, but on a message board, we hash out these things. We don't have to make it personal, often, we are talking in the abstract. It's fun.

Every once in a while, we all get a little honked and make a personal jab, but that's the nature of politics and religion debates.

But there are several on here that are capable of having really heated discussions about the issues without personally calling out another poster. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

We talk about weight on here too. It's not personal, unless you personally call me "fat." For the record, it doesn't really bother me. I am fat, but I'm working to change that. It's an ongoing struggle, but one that needs to be done. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

justforfun1 --- 9 min ago - quote - hide comments

I look at this differently. The viewer sent a private email to the anchor woman. The anchor woman decided to go public because she had the audience to use. How and why did a private email become so well known? Who is really the bully?


I disagree. She did not name the author of that e-mail, she merely gave him a rebuttal on TV.

She is a NEWS ANCHOR, not a swimsuit model. As such, the idiot moron that wrote the letter would have had a leg to stand on had he actually taken issue with her NEWS REPORTING capabilities. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

I look at this differently. The viewer sent a private email to the anchor woman. The anchor woman decided to go public because she had the audience to use. How and why did a private email become so well known? Who is really the bully?




I stand by my comment. No one but this woman and the viewer knew about this email so again I ask, who is the bully? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

The problem with food issues, is that unlike every other type of "issue", everybody can see it! It can't be hidden.

So perfect strangers from across the room can look at you and see that food is something that you struggle with.

In some ways, that is a blessing, because it HAS to be handled and dealt with.

But it makes people feel like they have the right to write strangers and address their personal issues. This wasn't a public messageboard. They wrote a private e-mail to her pointing out her personal flaws. 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

i was talking about the candy bar...what are you talking about?

Why yes; the Chunky bar, of course.

0

^^^^^^ This Chunky loves Chunky bars.

***Self-deleted*** 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I look at this differently. The viewer sent a private email to the anchor woman. The anchor woman decided to go public because she had the audience to use. How and why did a private email become so well known? Who is really the bully?


Good point. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

JohnLynch --- 54 min ago - quote - hide comments
to be considered bullying...the comment would have to be repeatedly directed towards that individual by the perpetrator




jonL, sounds like your typical m.o. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

I believe fat is defined differently to each individual.

yes, but obesity isn't.

However considerate we need to be of the feelings of people with this problem, it's not a problem that can be ignored, and it's not one that should be "normalized". Obesity's association with multiple chronic diseases (mostly as a barometer, but also causally) and the fact that it is afflicting younger and younger people every year make it an issue that must be granted time on center-stage.

I'm not saying that an obese local news woman should be considered in the same category as law-breaking professional athletes, but the e-mailer's point, however tactless the entirety of the private email may be, is valid.



Is Calling Someone Fat Bullying?
If done to cause pain or embarrassment, then yes.
If done out of genuine friendly concern, then no.

it depends on the situation.

sadly, it usually takes a personal or familial medical emergency before people feel comfortable having those conversations. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

let's also keep in mind that PLENTY of "skinny" women have serious issues with their body image as well.

again...if it's said to them as a means to hurt them, yea it's bullying to an extent. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

But there is some decorum on how it is handled. Can we have public discussions on the risks of obesity? Absolutely! And we should.

But to privately e-mail someone pointing out that they are fat, especially when you don't know them, it's just rude. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

She did not specify in her rebuttal, but there COULD be a MEDICAL reason why she is overweight. She could be on steroids, or had an organ transplant, metabolic issue, or any number of other things that she does not necessarily want to share with the general public. True she is the one that decided to publicly address the issue, but is doesn't mean there can't be a very private medical issue that is causing her obesity (and for anyone else that appears to be "fat" by "your" standards or the medical industry's standards). 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I think calling it bullying is ridiculous. Humble ISD has a fairly strict bullying policy. I think this policy will become more strict over time. Do you think a 3rd grader should be subjected to the bullying policy for calling a student fat? I think the kid should get in trouble but I think not to the level of someone who is truly bullying.

I think we need to be careful where we let these things go.

I not that stares at a girl he thinks is pretty is now stalking?

It's getting ridiculous. 

TheFallen --- 14 years ago -

I think people's opinions on this issue will vary based on the level of responsibility each person believes an obese person has for their weight.

Imagine if the same email changed every instance of the word "obesity" to the word "smoking." Wouldn't we all agree that he was right:

In the original email, the viewer wrote: “Smoking is one of the worst choices a person can make and one of the most dangerous habits to maintain. I leave you this note hoping that you’ll reconsider your responsibility as a local public personality to present and promote a healthy lifestyle.”

Isn't that because people believe smoking is a choice and people who smoke chose to do so. Some feel the same way about being overweight. Some don't. That does not mean that being obese is healthy... which is the point he appeared to be making.

He did not say, "I want you off my tv because your size makes you tough to look at." He essentially said, "you are viewed as a role model, yet you are not taking care of yourself." I guess the difference between smoking and weight is that weight is a more delicate issue because appearance is a more delicate issue. He wasn't discussing her asthetic value though; he discussed her health.

While he was not that tactful, I think people have assumed they know his motivations and that those motivations were to be mean and hurtful. I don't believe that. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

doesn't mean there can't be a very private medical issue that is causing her obesity

absolutely. But much like the genetics reasoning, it's a minority of the population. Sadly. it may be that factors that cause those medical conditions also have direct causal relationships with obesity, which makes the science more difficult.

I think we need to be careful where we let these things go.

I agree. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground