Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

STAR Test

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
coach'sgirl 2
movedagain 1
toot 1
VEKI4 1
Polly Ester 1
SleightOfHand 1
iluvthebeach 1
Lillabeth 2
Jpgirl 3
Gigix4 2
kari.kolo 7
JustAskin' 3
skeeter 1
FabFive 8
Semper 6
Emperor of Kingwood 1
Hippiedippiechik 2
Juliet Binoche 6
lmillie 1
oh no 1
Emmy 1
Tootiefrog 2
publicserviceA 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Juliet Binoche --- 13 years ago -

Kids go to school to learn. Some may need help with certain concepts, but if there are skills that are lacking, and a student barely passes, why is it the parent who should be tutoring at home? Did I miss something? I have a full-time job and household. How can they say supports and placement are working? I feel like I am in the Twilight Zone. I would never pass the buck to a parent. What are your thoughts? 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

Learning doesn't stop once your child leaves school. One of my many hats that I wear is being a teacher to our kids. It's important for our kids to know that mommy and daddy are here for them in all aspects of their lives. Even tutoring. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

If your child needs help you should help them. It is your child. Don't they offer free tutoring at the school? If not or maybe even, on top of that, you could send them to Sylvan or some other place similar. You had the child, he is your responsibility so if you don't want to tutor him yourself, you will most likely have to pay someone to do it for you. Teachers do what they can during the day but in the end, they have around 25-30 kids to try to teach and the ones that don't get it are bound to be left behind. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

The star test is ridiculous. It is not objective of actual learning.


Our oldest is very GT and the schools never met her needs either. If your child falls outside the normal curve in any way, you're screwed. Pardon my French. 

coach'sgirl --- 13 years ago -

I have a full time job and a household as well...but I am also back in middle school. We do homework and study for hours. They get what they can at school, but my job as a mom is to go over it and reinforce it once we are home. I don't expect a teacher with 20+ other students to be able to work with every student one on one until they get it.

So yes, it is the parents job to tutor (or I call it "work with") their own children. 

Juliet Binoche --- 13 years ago -

I was a 4-8 Generalist for two years. LOL and Sylvan is ridiculous. KUMON is the best program there is. I worked there. LOL I don't have a problem with tutoring my child. I have a problem with him not learning at school. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

Yeah, we are moving out of humble Isd. The education is sub par now. 

VEKI4 --- 13 years ago -

I don't have a problem with tutoring my child.

Your original post sounds like you do:

why is it the parent who should be tutoring at home? 

coach'sgirl --- 13 years ago -

If he isn't learning at school, you need to find out why. Can he not focus? Does he not understand what is being taught? Has he always struggled? Possible LD? 

iluvthebeach --- 13 years ago -

Teachers do the best they can with students who are struggling. They tutor, monitor constantly for understanding, and even meet one-on-one when time permits. But they are responsible for 20-30 students' learning, not just your child. If you are asked to help with homework or listen to your child read at home, please do. Your support shows your child you value their education and reinforces their learning. It is so apparent in the classroom which children receive encouragement and support at home and those who does not. Some parents never check their child's binder and have no idea what learning is taking place in classroom. Some parents don't even know their child's homeroom teacher's name. Truly, you reap what you sow. You choose to be a partner in their education or leave it all up to the school. But think about the ratio of student to adult when you rely on the school to do all the teaching for your child. The child is the one who suffers when he is struggling. They begin to realize they aren't keeping up. They act out, they cry in frustration, they feel stupid. As a parent, if you can prevent any of these negative feelings by helping out at home, why wouldn't you? IMO, you are sacrificing your child's needs and self esteem when you choose to expect the school to do it all. You have a responsibility to step up and do whatever it takes to ensure your child grows up to be the best he/she is capable of. The buck stops with YOU! 

skeeter --- 13 years ago -

 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -


I was a 4-8 Generalist for two years. LOL and Sylvan is ridiculous. KUMON is the best program there is. I worked there. LOL I don't have a problem with tutoring my child. I have a problem with him not learning at school. 


So you worked at KUMON and yet your child failed the STAR test and now it seems as if you're complaining about tutoring YOUR child at home now?

As a parent, I know when any of our children are struggling with a subject. And we help them. I love helping them. I enjoy that one on one time with them. I especially love it when I explain it in a way they can finally understand.

Yes, our schools need a lot of work. Yes, I think they spend way too much time preparing for these darn tests, but they're required to pass it. 

Juliet Binoche --- 13 years ago -

What is the point of inclusion, pushin support, and tutoring for reading but passing math by one point? They were happy about it. I looked at them and said that's not good enough and was laughed at but if you can't teach my child with inclusion and pushin support then you need to figure out how to do it. I should not have to do your job. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

My neighbor and I have sons in the same class. She has had complaints all year about the teacher and how much her kid hates school. Most recently she was in a tizzy because she learned her kid had not turned in 7 assignments. A late assignment is an automatic 30 point deduction.Presuming a kid get a perfect score...he would still only receive a 70. If they miss a few questions then it is easily a D or F. While yes the teacher might have made a phone call to check why my son's classmate hadn't turned in assignments, my neighbor would have known if she had checked online. The school documents all grades,assignments completed or pending,absences ,etc. I check my children's grades daily and even have email reminders if they fall below a 90. While teachers have a responsibility to all their students...I have the bigger responsibility to my child. It is my job to work in concert with their teachers to make sure their needs are being met.

My son advised me yesterday that his friend will now have to repeat the 5th grade instead of making the transition to 6th. Coincidentally... his younger brother was held back this year and has experienced a lot of bullying from kids calling him stupid,etc.

These two boys just won their baseball tournaments and my neighbor was over the moon. I have observed the passion with which this family handles the baseball season. Getting extra coaching...going to batting cages..a attending practices and playing games that easily go into 11pm on a school night. I have nothing against sports but when it seems to take priority over basic education, that is a problem. 

Hippiedippiechik --- 13 years ago -

What is the point of inclusion, pushin support, and tutoring for reading but passing math by one point? They were happy about it. I looked at them and said that's not good enough and was laughed at but if you can't teach my child with inclusion and pushin support then you need to figure out how to do it. I should not have to do your job.


Did I miss something?!?!? HE PASSED!! You should be happy with that-there are a ton of kids out there who didn't pass.

As a parent of a child in inclusion, I am happy with the B's and C's as long as I know my child tried her best. Being in PPCD would not help your child get the support needed to pass that test. My child was in there for 1 1/2 years and learned nothing. With inclusion, she is at the top of her class in reading but still struggles with Math(she has dysgraphia). The school she is at now is great but I am the one responsible when she walks through my house to see that homework is done and she is learning. Sometimes, it would take an hour to do simple math problems but we sat there until it was done. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

I should not have to do your job.

No JB you shouldn't have to do their job. You should have to do YOUR job though. If that means, you have to sit next to them while they do their work, that's what you do. I understand you work and have a household to manage but who doesn't? The teachers have to manage not one child but no less than 20. They also have households to run and in some cases, their own children to look after as well. 

Tootiefrog --- 13 years ago -

There are studies that prove that children who have parents who actively work with them at home do better academically...especially those who have parents with degrees.

Working with your kiddo after school is not a bad thing. It is a great time to find out how they are doing for yourself and for me, it was when my kids told me a lot about how their day went.

Look for the positive in spending quality time with your child. You don't have much control over how the schools deal with things but you DO have control over how you handle situations. Tutoring your child can be a bonding experience even if you are already plenty bonded. Quality time is a GREAT thing even if you have to look thru school books to do it. :) 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

I was never a big fan of math especially algebra. But since I've been going over tests and assignments with my middle schooler, I've realized that 1) I remember a little bit more than I thought and 2) I actually understand the processes better than I did when I was in the grade he is in now. I'm endeavoring to understand it so I can help my kids. There are videos online that help me "get it" as well. Some days I truly feel like I'm in 7th grade again...at least for this subject! 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

I've kept my mouth shut but here goes. Semper is RIGHT on the mark. Many of you know I have a son who is mentally ill and developmentally disabled but he's fairly functional. He's had issues since birth including behavorial. At one point in Ohio he was in a classroom with other students who had behavorial issues.
I've read your posts and I am very concerned that your son is not getting what he needs from you and your husband ( or father) to help him manage his behavior. Not a slam- just my story on what we did.
1-first off you and your husband HAVE to work together as a team and be on the same page where your son is concerned. My dh and I saw my son's therapist once a week for several years to come up with strategies on how to work on our relationship weaknesses and how to better manage our son.

2- become an ally with the school NOT an enemy. You and the school are working at cross purposes right now and that serves no one. You live in Texas that means the bottom of the barrel for helping anyone wih special needs. My husband and I made the difficult decision that I would not return to the work force so I was available 24/7 for my son- that meant also for the doctors, therapists, teachers, school. It was very very difficult and we struggled financially. I told the school I would attend class and sit right there beside my son if needs be. I worked with him every single night- on homework and life skills strategies to help HIM. I had to go to school when he had a meltdown, I had to deal with administration when he made threats and got suspended. And no I did not try to defend my son ( because he couldn't help it)- instead I insisted on OSS instead of ISS, and my son attended Mom's Bootcamp so he could understand the severe consequences of his behavior. Why??? Because the real world doesn't care if your son can't help it- he'll end up getting in big trouble or worse with the police. Funny- my son attended Moms Bootcamp twice and somehow he never acted out at school again. Home was a different story-we've had police visits many times.
3- Medication is a necassary evil. Do I enjoy giving him Psycho drugs ?? No- but they help. After 18 years we FINALLY found a combination that works for him. He can now manage his behavior because the meds help him. If your child were epileptic - would you deny him meds to help manage the seizures.
4- if you can't come to terms with the school- pull him out and educate him at home.
I'm sorry this is so long and I really do feel for you- this is the worst nightmare a parent can live. I guess I got through it and continue to deal with it because of my no nonsense approach and objective approaches - because really it come down to something Dr Phil said that hit home with me-"Do you want to be right or do you want to be successful in dealing with what's at hand?"
Good luck and many prayers 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

That is an awesome testimony JP. I don't have the challenges with dealing with a child that has difficulty learning. My challenges are on the other end of the spectrum with advanced learners. Everyone thinks it's easy and in comparison to other situations it is. But parents of gifted learners have another set of issues to contend with such as kids who challenge teachers with questions they are not prepared or interested in answering, not being challenged with the schoolwork, being given more busy work but not work that meets their level of understanding, children who become scattered brained and disorganized when bored and alternatively hyperfocused when subjects interest them and a tendency for teachers to suggest that because they are bored and very kinetic that they automatically have ADHD. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

Kids go to school to learn. Some may need help with certain concepts, but if there are skills that are lacking, and a student barely passes, why is it the parent who should be tutoring at home? Did I miss something? I have a full-time job and household. How can they say supports and placement are working? I feel like I am in the Twilight Zone. I would never pass the buck to a parent. What are your thoughts?

Well, he passed. Maybe without the supports they provided he wouldn't have. Does that mean he will pass next time? No, you said he barely passed so obviously he is not as proficient as he needs to be. With the school's support he is managing to stay afloat for now. He needs your support at home too.

When you have a child that requires more attention than the majority of the students you will need to be able to support the teachers and your child.

Do you think all of the high achieving students just got that way by accident? Most of them have parents reinforcing lessons and providing educational opportunities at home. Most kids learn the value of education from their parents.

There are many ways to set aside some time each day to support lessons. A lot of it can even be done in the car, just by discussing and asking questions.

You say what they are doing is not enough. Is what you are doing enough? If you want him to do better then you will need to invest more time. That is just a fact. 

publicserviceA --- 13 years ago -

its the STAAR Test, not STAR 

Tootiefrog --- 13 years ago -

I said this in your previous thread...I think you and the school have worn each other out. It seems that you have reached an impasse...

Can you homeschool? Transfer him to another district?

I would never pass the buck to a parent. What are your thoughts?

You are the ultimate advocate for your son. I have a friend who has a son with a peanut allergy so bad it could be fatal. She fought TOOTH AND NAIL for her son to be accommodated and he was. It was a fight but she handled herself with the ferocity of a mama bear but did it with dignity and grace.

She went to the schools and district with solutions and a solid plan...the schools could not accommodate her on site so they arranged for him to have schooling at home and via skype.

It can be done but YOUR delivery of any messages advocating for your son is key. You said in your last post that you feel like you're yelling an no one is listening...I don't listen to people who yell. 

JustAskin' --- 13 years ago -

Did I miss something? I have a full-time job and household.

I don't mean this to sound cruel, but it seems what your missing is that your child IS your full time job. And if he's not, he should be.

I would never pass the buck to a parent. What are your thoughts? 

If you aren't willing to take any part or responsibility in making sure your child is educated, why should the school? 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Sempre, your post about GT kids couldn't be more accurate. We went through all that in the first grade alone. In a "great" district. We now homeschool. I get criticized for not keeping her in an fighting, but I only have enough time to fight so I prefer to use the time and energy on my child to do something, not to fight people who don't give a crap anyways. They are too busy focusing on the kids passing the test. Our system is very broken and both the teachers and kids lose. Our expectations of teachers (20-30 kids at all different levels) is too high and our expectations of kids is not high enough. 

oh no --- 13 years ago -

My son constantly struggles with some of his school work, even with his accommodation's. I hate the state testing's, but I know that as long as I decide to keep him in public school it's something he has to learn to deal with. As a parent, IT'S your job to see that he gets all the help he needs. 

toot --- 13 years ago -

I am a retired elementary teacher and want to applaud the creators of some of the threads above. You are right. Parents, not parent, when there are two are to work together on the education and life prep of their children. School and teachers can only do so much with the education and socialization of students. Parents, ultimately, can do more. The being you created is your responsiblity and what they become is your future. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

Don't they offer free tutoring at the school? .


lol - nothing is 'free' at the schools

just like teachers who are paid during the summer when they do absolutely nothing, 'free' tutoring is still subsidized by tax-payers

. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

just like teachers who are paid during the summer when they do nothing

Teachers are paid an annual salary - they can get it on a 9 or 12 month basis. 

JustAskin' --- 13 years ago -

just like teachers who are paid during the summer when they do nothing, 'free' tutoring is still subsidized by tax-payers



Look, I'm not high on public education as I homeschool, but teachers don't get "paid in the summer for doing nothing". They have a set salary for a contract year of teaching, and then it is divided over 12 months. Just like any salaried position, pay doesn't stop when you are on your job's specified days off. If a teacher goes over and above the set time allotted for them to be off, then they don't get paid.

Would it make you feel better if their paychecks were simply divided among August-June? They would still make the same amount...they just wouldn't get a check in July or a full check in August or June.

There are many things in the public school system to be upset about, but criticizing the fact that teachers receive part of their annual salary during the summer months seems to weaken the argument for more legitimate concerns. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

When I looked at the course material for advanced placement math and science I found it pretty basic and no where near the advanced placement of 35 years ago. The public schools graduate barely functional yet highly politically correct students. 

publicserviceA --- 13 years ago -

It's not the teacher's fault. America and its government has decided to hold back all of their smart students so that the slower students can catch up (no child left behind act). Instead of having the smart get smarter they are held back because little Timmy's mother can't deal with the fact that her baby might not be as smart as the rest. So instead of getting the extra help little Timmy needs, mom complains that the teacher is going too fast or not teaching the material well enough. In extreme cases little Timmy just may even need to be held back. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

Look, I'm not high on public education as I homeschool, but teachers don't get "paid in the summer for doing nothing". They have a set salary for a contract year of teaching, and then it is divided over 12 months. Just like any salaried position, pay doesn't stop when you are on your job's specified days off. If a teacher goes over and above the set time allotted for them to be off, then they don't get paid.

There are many things in the public school system to be upset about, but criticizing the fact that teachers receive part of their annual salary during the summer months seems to weaken the argument for more legitimate concerns.
.


I think that fat and waste in the the public school system is something to be critical about - don't you?

because if it wasn't for the fat and waste, we'd make each dollar stretch further for each student to learn better


here's the deal - teachers, just like salaried people in other professions, invest in their own additional training and certifications, work additional hours only to receive no extra pay, pick up extra money at other jobs during their time off, etc

teachers are just like all other professions in this sense

except of course that teachers - unlike other professions - get SUMMERS OFF. that's uninterrupted time off the jobsite to pursue other personal endeavors, while they're still being paid by tax-payers for not educating students


but back to the previous point: nothing is 'free' including 'free tutoring' - you just think it's free because you're not whipping out your purse and paying for it day-by-day

. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

It's not that they get paid for twelve months. They don't. They get paid for nine months and choose to spread it over 12 months if they choose. That way through the summer their income doesn't cease.

Those of us who Homeschool still pay taxes in, purchase our own curriculum, pay 100% for field trips, and still don't get paid a dime, either nine or twelve months. It's still worth it to me. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

It's not that they get paid for twelve months. They don't. They get paid for nine months and choose to spread it over 12 months if they choose. That way through the summer their income doesn't cease.


lol - are there any other career fields you can think of that enjoy the luxury of getting paid for 12 months of work when they only do 9 months of work?

that's just like an underpaid cashier who justifies stealing from her cash register - somehow thinking it's some sort of 'employee compensation plan' for the work she's yet to actually do!

. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Our expectations of teachers (20-30 kids at all different levels) is too high and our expectations of kids is not high enough.

Agreed.

Unfortunately the conventional school system is set up to best serve the average student. Kids on either side of average may get educated but often it's not enough to meet their unique circumstances. That's why parental involvement is tantamount to successfully getting these kid's what they need or giving it to them yourself.

Fab...New Caney ISD has an excellent program for 7th and 8th grade GT kids. It not only provides for their academic needs but also for their emotional, social as well. It's called SPARK (Students Pursuing Academic Rigor and Knowledge). Being that everything north of Kingwood is usually seen as "less", it's impressive that this school district is realizing that just as the schools need to provide for those who are learning challenged, they need to provide for those who are gifted learners as well. 

JustAskin' --- 13 years ago -

except of course that teachers - unlike other professions - get SUMMERS OFF. that's uninterrupted time off the jobsite to pursue other personal endeavors, while they're still being paid by tax-payers for not educating students

There are very few professions where someone with a doctorate degree and 26+ years of experience makes $58,996 a year and that's the top level of what the profession can make in Humble ISD. HOWEVER, pay is commensurate with a 187 day contract. A more traditional job requires around 240 days, and so if you took the same pay rate, a person would earn $75,716 a year. Still seems awfully low for someone with a PhD and 26+ year of experience.

Again, arguing that teachers get paid too much weakens your argument against real problems with the public school system.

Now administrators' salary is a whole other ball of wax :)

If it were up to me, I would INCREASE the salary of the teachers and make the process of firing poor teachers much easier. I would focus on getting great principals in the schools and eliminate the vast majority of the upper administration positions. I would get back to letting great teachers teach their own lessons in their own ways and producing great students who are meeting their own potential (and not that of the lowest or highest denominator) and whose joy of learning isn't sucked out of them by all the bureaucracy that teachers and students alike have to wade through.

But then, no one is asking me :) 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

I agree about the GT kids too- my nephew was GT and drove everyone crazy ( even parents and aunts ;) so my SIL put him in parochial school - worked with the school and stayed on his butt and he graduates next month with a PhD in quantum physics. Yep he was DX'ed ADD as a kid too.
Totally agree that parents can and need to do more- it's called sacrifice. And I'm not talking the hover parent either- I'm talking hard work, blood and sweat- no excuses- hard love kind of parents. It's not easy and I can't tell you how many time I wanted to bail( hubby too). Now life isn't perfect and my ds will continue to struggle but I am proud that he has maintained several minimum wage jobs and even at 26 continues to mature and try. That's all I can ask. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

There are very few professions where someone with a doctorate degree and 26+ years of experience makes $58,996 a year and that's the top level of what the profession can make in Humble ISD. HOWEVER, pay is commensurate with a 187 day contract. A more traditional job requires around 240 days, and so if you took the same pay rate, a person would earn $75,716 a year. Still seems awfully low for someone with a PhD and 26+ year of experience.

Again, arguing that teachers get paid too much weakens your argument against real problems with the public school system.


when calculating teacher pay, be sure to include health insurance, life insurance, retirement and the entire compensation package - the whole enchilada paid for by tax-payers

it's much more than you state


however, every teacher who whines about how little they see in their paycheck needs to complain instead about:

- how much district administrators are overpaid
- how much the government takes from their paycheck in the form of taxes
- the amount of waste from garbage like STARR testing, iPads, grandiose buildings, requirements by the state and feds that aren't funded, and so on

asking tax-payers to throw more and more money into a failing system is absolutely ludicrous!

. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Kari you have lost your mind. I know a lot of teachers and they don't steal a thing. In fact, many of them pay out of pocket to supplement their classrooms. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground