Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Five Myths about Jesus: Challenging everything you think you know

who's talking here?

wayward1 1
SoupIsGoodFood 7
Perfection 1
Just Ray 1
voice of reason 9
jtcitrus 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 6
JohnLynch 6
RedMulch 1
a672999uu 2
I AM Innocent 3
Emperor of Kingwood 2
Gigolo Bloodline 5
a889324uu 2
JimBecka 3
Dawson 1
jacobson 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

Five MythsChallenging everything you think you know
By Reza Aslan, Published: September 26

Reza Aslan is the author, most recently, of “Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth.”


Perhaps no historical figure is more deeply mired in legend and myth than Jesus of Nazareth. Outside of the Gospels — which are not so much factual accounts of Jesus but arguments about His religious significance — there is almost no trace of this simple Galilean peasant who inspired the world’s largest religion. But there’s enough biblical scholarship about the historical Jesus to raise questions about some of the myths that have formed around Him over the past 2,000 years.


1. Jesus was born in Bethlehem.

The first Christians seem to have had little interest in Jesus’s early years. Stories about His birth and childhood are conspicuously absent in the earliest written documents about Him: the letters of Paul (written between A.D. 50 and 60) and the Gospel of Mark (written after A.D. 70). But as interest in the person of Jesus increased, the nascent Christian community tried to fill in the gaps of His youth to align His life and mission with the myriad, and often conflicting, prophecies about the messiah in the Hebrew scriptures.

One of those prophecies requires the messiah, as a descendant of King David, to be born in David’s city: Bethlehem. But Jesus was so identified with Nazareth, the city where most scholars believe He was born, that He was known throughout his life as “the Nazarene.” The early Christians needed a creative solution to get Jesus’s parents to Bethlehem so He could be born in the same city as David.

For the evangelist Luke, the answer lay in a census called by Rome in A.D. 6, which he claims required every subject to travel to his ancestral home to be counted. Since Jesus’s father, Joseph, was from Bethlehem, he and his fiancee, Mary, left Nazareth for the city of David, where Jesus was born. And thus the prophecy was fulfilled.

Yet this Roman census encompassed only Judea, Samaria and Idumea — not Galilee, where Jesus’s family lived. What’s more, since the purpose of a census was taxation, Roman law assessed an individual’s property in the place of his residence, not his birthplace.

Simply put, Luke places Jesus’s birth in Bethlehem not because it took place there but because that story fulfills the words of the prophet Micah: “But you Bethlehem . . . from you shall come for me a ruler in Israel.”


2. Jesus was an only child.

Despite the Catholic doctrine of His mother Mary’s perpetual virginity, we can be certain that the historical Jesus came from a large family with at least four brothers who are named in the Gospels — James, Joseph, Simon and Judas — and an unknown number of sisters. That Jesus had brothers and sisters is attested to repeatedly by the Gospelsand the letters of Paul. Even the 1st-century Jewish historian Josephus refers to Jesus’s brother James, who would become the most important leader of the early Christian church after Jesus’s death.

Some Catholic theologians have argued that the Greek word the Gospels use to describe Jesus’s brothers — “adelphos” — could also mean “cousins” or “step-brothers,” and that these could be Joseph’s children from a previous marriage. While that may be true, nowhere in the New Testament is “adelphos” used to mean anything other than “brother.” So there is no rational argument for viewing Jesus as an only child.


3. Jesus had 12 disciples.

This myth is based on a misunderstanding of the three categories of Jesus’s followers. The first was made up of those who came to hear Him speak or to be healed by Him whenever He entered a village or town. The Gospels refer to this group as “crowds.”

The second category was composed of those who followed Jesus from town to town, village to village. These were called disciples, and according to the Gospel of Luke, there were 70 or 72 of them, depending on which version of the text you believe.

The third category of Jesus’s followers was known as the apostles. These 12 men were no mere disciples, for they did not just follow Jesus from one place to another. Rather, they were given permission to go off on their own and preach His message independently and without supervision. They were, in other words, the chief missionaries of the Jesus movement.

4. Jesus had a trial before Pontius Pilate.

The Gospels portray Pontius Pilate as an honest but weak-willed governor who was strong-armed by the Jewish authorities into sending a man he knew was innocent to the cross. The Pilate of history, however, was renowned for sending his troops onto the streets of Jerusalem to slaughter Jews whenever they disagreed with even the slightest of his decisions. In his 10 years as governor of Jerusalem, Pilate eagerly, and without trial, sent thousands to the cross, and the Jews lodged a complaint against him with the Roman emperor. Jews generally did not receive Roman trials, let alone Jews accused of rebellion. So the notion that Pilate would spend a moment of his time pondering the fate of yet another Jewish rabble-rouser, let alone grant him a personal audience, beggars the imagination.

It is, of course, conceivable that Jesus would have received an audience with the Roman governor if the magnitude of His crime warranted special attention. But any “trial” Jesus got would have been brief and perfunctory, its sole purpose to officially record the charges for which He was being executed.


5. Jesus was buried in a tomb.

The Gospels say that after the crucifixion, Jesus’s body was brought down from the cross and placed in a tomb. If that were true, it would have been because of an extremely unusual, perhaps unprecedented, act of benevolence on the part of the Romans.

Crucifixion was not just a form of capital punishment for Rome. In fact, some criminals were first executed and then nailed to a cross. The primary purpose of crucifixion was to deter rebellion; that’s why it was always carried out in public. It was also why the criminal was always left hanging long after he died; the crucified were almost never buried. Because the point of crucifixion was to humiliate the victim and frighten witnesses, the corpse would be left to be eaten by dogs and picked clean by birds of prey. The bones would then be thrown onto a trash heap, which is how Golgotha, the place of Jesus’s crucifixion, earned its name: the place of skulls.

It is possible that, unlike practically every other criminal crucified by Rome, Jesus was brought down from the cross and placed in an extravagant rock-hewn tomb fit for the wealthiest men in Judea. But it is not very likely. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

LOL. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Must be sad having so much venom in ones soul 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

And the point is?...... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

.......... on the top of someones head. 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

Must be sad having so much venom in ones soul


i know. soup is full of venom. that's why I block soup's comments/vomit these days.



And the point is?......

education, bob, education. or are you so close-minded that you shut all learning down? 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

lol...notice how vor uses articles written by followers of Islam to make points concerning Christianity...big fail 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

or are you so close-minded that you shut all learning down? 

Part of learning is the ability to discern fact from hypothesis. Its clear you havent reached that point. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

i know. soup is full of venom. that's why I block soup's comments/vomit these days.

LOL......... she was talking about you, VoR.

The only reason VoR blocks me is because she can't handle me. She's afraid of me. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

I'm sure there's some truth to all that, but those things are just technicalities- none of it changes the end result- 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

LOL. A faith built on a story sold to the masses for money and power.

Soak it up... 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

any falsehood changes the end result... 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

any falsehood changes the end result...

With all the falsehoods that end result must be spinning like a UT cornerback. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

absurd- what Pilate said to the Jews or didn't say to them He was still crucified- and for the same reasons- 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

lol...notice how vor uses articles written by followers of Islam to make points concerning Christianity...big fail



the only failure around here is you. you have determined that from a name? no news here as you are the most close minded on this board.

he's written a book, Reza Aslan is the author, most recently, of “Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth.”
which is way more than you can say. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

He was still crucified- and for the same reasons-

He was a political nuisance. He and thousands others, no difference. 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

Part of learning is the ability to discern fact from hypothesis. Its clear you havent reached that point.


it's all hypothesis in regards to hey-zeus which is why they call it FAITH. duh. 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

He was a political nuisance. He and thousands others, no difference.


ding ding ding
we have a winner. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

too much fun 

a889324uu --- 13 years ago -

It's amazing how ignorant people are of Roman history. 

a889324uu --- 13 years ago -

Soup has me hosed because he can't handle me.

He's a cowering man-child. Hey!!! This is a fun game! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

0undefined 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Soup has me hosed because he can't handle me.

LOL............. I don't even know who you are.

Handle you? I can own you. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Just checked. I don't have you hosed.

See. I own you already. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

it's all hypothesis

nope...it isn't...much of the Bible is historically verifiable...so it's not ALL faith 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

so it's not ALL faith

BAHAHAHA 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

a889324uu --- 24 min ago - quote - hide comments
Soup has me hosed because he can't handle me.

He's a cowering man-child. Hey!!! This is a fun game!


hidden at your request (Wrath of Soup) - show comment - remove block


hidden at your request (Wrath of Soup) - show comment - remove block


hidden at your request (Wrath of Soup) - show comment - remove block






bahahahaha! you obviously are pushing his buttons big time if your spanking generated three posts from soupy sales. 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

much of the Bible is historically verifiable



yeppers only in small minds. 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

Not really too much new there, after some thought on this topic. I, to some degree, seperate Jesus of Nazareth, from Jesus the Christ.

This is not what I believe, but even if the man, was just the basis for the idea that became the God. And that God did all the good I beleive He has done, and will do - I am ok with that. 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

For those interested, with some time to kill - here is a pretty balanced counter argument:

Here are 14 things to know about “Zelot”

1) What is Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth?

It is a book authored by Reza Aslan and published by Random House in July of 2013.

With the power of the Random House marketing machine behind it, the book quickly shot to the top of Amazon’s bestseller list.

The book is billed as a biography of Jesus of Nazareth.

In keeping with Aslan’s creative writing background (see below), much of it is written in a casual, narrative style that does not stop to cite sources, mount arguments, or consider alternative viewpoints.

It reads rather a lot like historical fiction, with Aslan inviting us to imagine the colors of the curtain of the Jerusalem temple, how scene at the temple would have sounded, and even how it would have smelled (rather putrid, according to Aslan).

2) Who is Reza Aslan?

Aslan is an associate professor of creative writing at the University of California Riverside. He lives in Hollywood.

He was born in Tehran, Iran but raised in the San Francisco Bay Area.

His family background is Muslim, though not devout.

He himself experienced a conversion to Christianity in his teens but later lost his faith.

He has a doctorate in the sociology of religions from the University of California Santa Barbara.

3) Is Aslan trying to hide his Muslim background?

He has been accused of doing so in television interviews, but this seems unfounded.

He certainly does not hide it in the book. In fact, there is an “Author’s Note” at the beginning of Zealot that explains his religious background very forthrightly.

Aslan’s Muslim background is not very relevant to the views he proposes in Zealot, and given the dynamics of TV interviews, it wouldn’t make sense for Aslan to discuss this unless he were specifically asked about it.



4) Is Aslan giving us a Muslim re-reading of Jesus?

Aslan has similarly been accused of doing so, but this is also unfounded.

Muslims typically hold that Jesus was born of a virgin, that he was the Messiah, and that he was not crucified.

Aslan appears to reject all three of these positions.

• Early in the book he casts doubt on Mary’s virginity.

• He does not appear to regard Jesus as fulfilling the role of a divinely-authorized Messiah.

• And he believes that Jesus was crucified.

In fact, early in the book he states that Jesus’ crucifixion is one of only two “hard historical facts” about Jesus that can be relied upon (see below).

Rather than providing a Muslim re-reading of Jesus, Aslan offers a standard liberal-skeptical re-reading of Jesus.

5) What does he think we know about Jesus?

His bottom line summary is as follows:

In the end, there are only two hard historical facts about Jesus of Nazareth upon which we can confidently rely: the first is that Jesus was a Jew who led a popular Jewish movement in Palestine at the beginning of the first century C.E.; the second is that Rome crucified him for doing so.


If Aslan were to stop with what he considers the only hard historical facts on which we may confidently rely, it would make for a rather short biography.

So he goes beyond these bare bones to offer an imaginative reconstruction of the life and times of Jesus based on his own thoughts about what most probably happened.


6) Is that the way biographies are normally written?


No. Biographies typically go beyond trying to offer imaginative reconstructions of a person’s life.

If you really think that you only know two things about a person then you can’t write a biography of more than a few sentences.

Providing a book-length exercise of imagination, however much detail from historical sources you include, puts you in the realm of historical fiction rather than biography.

One is tempted to say that Aslan’s Zealot is only a “biography” of Jesus of Nazareth the way that Robert Graves’s I, Claudius and Claudius the God are “biographies” of the Roman Emperor Claudius.

That is to say, all three are works of historical fiction written as if they were biographies.

The difference is that Graves has more literary style than Aslan and is more up-front about the fictional nature of what he is doing.

7) How does Aslan imaginatively reconstruct the figure of Jesus?

Drawing on the facts that Jesus led a popular movement in Palestine and that the Romans crucified him, Aslan adds a third supposed fact:

Crucifixion was a punishment that Rome reserved almost exclusively for the crime of sedition.

He then infers that Jesus must have been guilty of sedition and re-casts him in the role of one of the many political revolutionaries of the day who tried to throw off Roman rule, only to get squashed.

This is where the book gets its title—Zealot. The claim is that Jesus was just one of the many zealot-like revolutionaries of the time.

Aslan then cherry-picks the evidence of the gospels, accepting whatever agrees with his thesis and discarding everything that doesn’t.

8) How does he explain the fact that the gospels do not depict Jesus as a political revolutionary?

According to Aslan, the gospels were written long after the fact and are unreliable on these points.

However, they are apparently reliable whenever they say something that he can use to support his thesis.

According to Aslan, all of the Gospels were written after the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70. (He dates Matthew and Luke to between A.D. 90 and 100 and John to between A.D. 100 and 120!)

At these late dates, Aslan informs us, Christians wanted to de-couple their religion from the failed political messianism that resulted in the destruction of Jerusalem, and so the gospels falsify their depiction of Jesus and make him a non-revolutionary.

9) How widely received is this view in the scholarly community?

It’s certainly been proposed before, but it is far from the only view out there.

In fact, among the skeptical scholars who try to discern the truth about “the historical Jesus” (as opposed to “the Christ of faith”), the Jesus-as-failed-political-revolutionary view is not the dominant one.

There are rival conceptions in the present or “third” Quest for the Historical Jesus. Wikipedia (accurately) notes:

The mainstream profiles in the third quest may be grouped together based on their primary theme as apocalyptic prophet, charismatic healer, Cynic philosopher, Jewish Messiah and prophet of social change. But there is little scholarly agreement on a single portrait, or the methods needed to construct it.

So Aslan’s view is neither original nor dominant, even among those who doubt the portrait of Jesus given in the gospels.

10) How might one respond to Aslan’s claims?

One line of response is to note the subjectivity which he himself attributes to it. He states:

Writing a biography of Jesus of Nazareth is not like writing a biography of Napoleon Bonaparte.

The task is somewhat akin to putting together a massive puzzle with only a few of the pieces in hand; one has no choice but to fill in the rest of the puzzle based on the best, most educated guess of what the completed image should look like.

The great Christian theologian Rudolf Bultmann liked to say that the quest for the historical Jesus is ultimately an internal quest.

Scholars tend to see the Jesus they want to see.

Having told us that there are only two things about Jesus we can be really confident of, Aslan then promises only a portrait of Jesus based on “fill[ing] in the rest of the puzzle based on the best, most educated guess of what the complete image should look like.”

This does not give us reason to take his portrait of Jesus particularly seriously.

And his periodic mishandling of the evidence gives us further reason for caution.

11) Does Aslan make obvious mistakes in his book?

Yes. For example, at one point he writes:

Paul may have considered himself an apostle, but it seems that few if any of the other movement leaders agreed. Not even Luke, Paul’s sycophant, whose writings betray a deliberate, if ahistorical, attempt to elevate his mentor’s status in the founding of the church, refers to Paul as an apostle. As far as Luke is concerned, there are only twelve apostles, one for each tribe of Israel, just as Jesus had intended.


Even setting aside Aslan’s unwarranted and prejudicially-phrased statement on Luke . . . Um. Dude? Acts 14:14?

But when the apostles Barnabas and Paul heard of it, they tore their garments and rushed out among the multitude.

This is beyond a mistake in interpretation, to which every scholar is entitled. It is a mistake of basic fact, which an actual scholar of this material would not make.

Aslan’s emphatic claim that Luke does not refer to Paul as an apostle betrays a fundamental lack of mastery of the material he is commenting on. He has, apparently, never even done a simple word study on the office of apostle, but he is making emphatic claims about it.

12) How accurate are the dates Aslan gives the gospels?

To support his cherry-picking, Aslan assigns very late dates to the gospels. In fact, he assigns dates that tend to be a decade later than most liberal scholars assign them.

Of special importance is that they be written after the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70, since this was (for the time being) a crushing blow to Jewish political messianism and would, on his theory, provide Christians with a reason to re-cast Jesus as a non-revolutionary.

But the evidence is that the gospels were written much earlier. In fact, the best evidence is that they were all penned before A.D. 70, since they record Jesus’ prediction that the temple would be destroyed but they do not record its fulfillment.

The evangelists would have loved to say, “And it all happened, just the way Jesus predicted.” It would be a mark of credibility. But they don’t say that. The most plausible explanation is that the fulfillment of his prediction had not yet happened.

Further, since the book of Acts cuts off suddenly in A.D. 60, and since the Gospel of Luke was written before Acts, we have reason to think that Luke dates to no later than A.D. 59 (just 26 years after the crucifixion), and perhaps even earlier.

13) What about his claim that the Romans reserved crucifixion for sedition?


It is not true that crucifixion was “reserved almost exclusively for the crime of sedition”—particularly if by “sedition” you mean political rebellion:

The Romans used crucifixion to bring mutinous troops under control, to break the will of conquered peoples, and to wear down rebellious cities under siege.

Dangerous and violent robbers could be crucified—often near or at the scene of their crimes. Quintilian (ca. 35–95 a.d.) approved of crucifixion as a penalty for such criminals, and thought that this form of execution had a better deterrent effect when the crosses were set up along the busiest roads. . . .

The Romans used crucifixion above all as the servile supplicium (“the slaves’ punishment”), a terrible form of execution typically inflicted on slaves [Yale Anchor Bible Dictionary, s.v. “Crucifixion”].

14) What is the most fundamental problem with the book?

The most fundamental problem is that Aslan’s central thesis can only be supported by cherry-picking the data—that is, accepting some of it and rejecting everything that doesn’t fit.

This is an unreliable and unscholarly method, because if you can jettison anything that doesn’t fit your theory then you can prove anything you want to.

With all the problems that beset Aslan’s imaginative reconstruction of Jesus, there is simply no reason to take Zealot as anything like a reliable account of his life.

Certainly not compared to those offered in the gospels. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

hidden at your request (Wrath of Soup) - show comment - remove block

You're afraid of me. I understand. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

you're amazing to be able to see possible truths that you don't believe in- you're that open minded- kudos!! 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

#2 isn't much of a stretch. 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

For those interested, with some time to kill - here is a pretty balanced counter argument:


thanks for proving jdlynch is full of crap once again. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

what are you talking about vor?...what she posted backed up what i said... 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

noone on either side ever backs you up jdlynch 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

I respect Reza's personal opinion.

I hope he feels the same about mine.

Here it is...

Jesus! He's more than just a man. He is the LORD God Almighty, the Everlasting Father. The Alpha and the Omega.

He created EVERYTHING there is and is the glue holding it all together. He will save to the uttermost all who will allow him to do so.

He is all wise, all knowing, all loving and holds all the power of the universe in his hands. EVERY knee will bow to him for he has a name above ALL NAMES and has ALL POWER in both heaven and on earth.

He created Mohammed and cast ALLAH(Satan) out of heaven for the iniquity found in him.

Jesus is Everybody's Everything!

Jesus is coming soon to execute vengeance and judgment upon ALL who DO NOT KNOW GOD nor OBEY his gospel.

He is the Lily of the valley and the rose of Sharon.

Jesus invites all men everywhere to taste and see that the Lord is good, he is the WAY, the TRUTH, and the LIFE.

Jesus gives ABUNDANT LIFE.

I invite one and all to call upon him while you may.

He is the heart mender and the master of the wind who can calm all storms of life.

in short...

Jesus is so indescribably good and great and unfathomably sweet no one explanation will do.

and most importantly...

Jesus loves you dearly, more dearly than the written or spoken word can tell. Why don't you choose you this day to serve him.

For have no doubt,
IN THE END

You will either serve the real and true Jesus.

or!!!

You will be found serving ANOTHER JESUS of another Gospel.

There are NO ALTERNATIVES! 

Dawson --- 13 years ago -

Is attacking each other all you people do? 

jacobson --- 13 years ago -

Yea. Why can't you guys debate the ideas that you disagree with and stop with the name calling? This isn't supposed to be an elementary school playground. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

jacobson,you and dawson popped up in Kingwood 3 days ago- must be a coincidence, right? THREE days?? hmmm... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground