Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Cultural Decay

who's talking here?

d:-] 1
Warren Peace 5
AwesomeTattooedDragon 6
JohnLynch 16
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Megg 1
Emperor of Kingwood 1
Ogre13 13
MissPris 3
Butterbean 2
AMDG 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Edward Gibbon who wrote The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire stated...

"The five marks of the Roman decaying culture:

Concern with displaying affluence instead of building wealth;

Obsession with sex and perversions of sex;

Art becomes freakish and sensationalistic instead of creative and original;

Widening disparity between very rich and very poor;

Increased demand to live off the state."




"There are striking similarities between America's current situation and the factors that brought down Rome, including declining moral values and political civility at home, an over-confident and over-extended military in foreign lands and fiscal irresponsibility by the central government".

- David Walker - head of the GAO from 1998 until 2008 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Hi John, how was the hoosgow? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I have decided that freedom is our greatest gift and greatest curse. And we know this from history which tells us all great civilizations seem to self destruct.

They do have an interesting journey however, and that can be a good thing. If you are wise. 

Megg --- 12 years ago -

Every great empire falls. Nothing lasts forever.

I hope that after this empire falls, a new more ethical and Eco-friendly society emerges. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Every great empire falls. Nothing lasts forever.

wow...defeatist attitude...it doesn't have to happen...if people would LEARN from history

the roman empire was around for about 5 centuries...the USA should have been able to make it longer than that... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

wow...defeatist attitude...

Not defeatist if it's true.

History shows that even the greatest empires, Rome being but one example, ebb and flow.

Also, I think both Gibbon and Walker's analysis is simplistic and comparisons to the United States to Rome ignore the fact that they were two utter different types of societies, and even utterly different types of Republics. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

ignore the fact that they were two utter different types of societies, and even utterly different types of Republics.?

they're following the SAME pattern of cultural decay... 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

I have decided that freedom is our greatest gift and greatest curse.

I hear "Freedom" a lot. What exactly are we free from?

Any system that allows people to live off the government or allows elected officials to accept contributions is destined to fail. We have both so it's only a matter of time. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

they're following the SAME pattern of cultural decay...

As I said, simplistic logic. Something a high schooler would comprehend but doesn't have any real meaning in the end. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Why not go with Vaclav Smil? Professor Emeritus at the University of Manitoba, and named one of the top 100 thinkers in the world in 2010?

His book, Why America Is Not a New Rome actually goes beyond superficial comparisons and provides REAL social science analysis of the topic.

Who was Edward Gibbon? He was an 18th Century English historian and Member of Parliament. I can tell you ONE thing about 18th C. English Historians... In spite of Gibbon often being cited as the prototype to the modern historian, and he used extensive primary sources in the writing of his books which wsa very unusual at the time. Their primary goal was not really to write about history in an unbiased way. Their goal was to write abut history in a way that glorified the English Empire.

What Gibbon NEVER wrote about was a comparison between Rome and the United States, which wasn't even it's own country when the book was first published in 1776!

The other guy? David Walker... as far as I can tell he's just an economist and politician. I'm not sure how he's qualified to even begin to make a real sociological comparison between the U.S. and Rome.

Unless of course, you're talking about astronaut, Capt. David M. Walker, USN. And he's even less qualified to do the job. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

BTW... JL, when I'm saying the logic is simplistic... I mean it's about as simplistic as this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrzMhU_4m-g 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

As I said, simplistic logic.

and simplistic logic is usually the truth...

"Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools"

What Gibbon NEVER wrote about was a comparison between Rome and the United States, which wasn't even it's own country when the book was first published in 1776!

he didn't need to write a comparison...we're living it... 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

JL, are you calling for the redistribution of wealth? You cite widening disparity between the rich and poor as being a main tenet of the fall of empire. I'm wondering what your solution to close that gap would entail. Also, are you saying that Keeping Up With The Kardashians, Duck Dynasty and Toddlers & Tiaras are freakishly sensationalized art that is leading to our downfall? What would you propose we do to get back to creative and original art? 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Rome and the U.S. may have plenty of similarities, but their differences are far more numerous. They are two different nations that were created under different circumstances, under different ideals, in different eras, with different demographics, different natural resources, different neighbors, different politics, different economies, different religious makeup, all of which makes for a different culture, and a myriad of other things that absolutely make comparing the two far less noteworthy than it appears on the surface. The way these two nations evolved isn't even remotely similar. Efforts to suggest that it's a worthwhile comparison come across to me more like an effort to manipulate others into overvaluing something that someone believes you should value more.

When someone refers to a culture as something that decays rather than something that evolves, you know you're dealing with simple thinkers with a prominent bias.

But it is true that the comparison sells books and makes for interesting conversation. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Yet, the truth IS that people have never changed. Rome and the US are different but they have one common denominator that is key, human beings. While vastly different and unique by personality, most people put in certain conditions such as certain societal environments, will almost always do the same or similar things....like greed for example. There was no corporate structure for business in Rome like what we obviously have here and now, yet I will bet you they had business greed just like we do today. And I bet that greed contributed to the decay in society.


People have always been the same. As long as they are free to make decisions that effect more than just themselves, you will have decay. It doesn't matter what their living conditions are or how they evolved, personal freedom creates trends in society that impact the whole, that might not even be a negative thing obviously, but think social media and the internet . They have changed our lives FOREVER. It's really about the cyclical nature of humanity, beginnings and endings. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Wow, W&P & SSG! That's good stuff. Sounds accurate to me. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

but their differences are far more numerous. They are two different nations that were created under different circumstances, under different ideals, in different eras, with different demographics, different natural resources, different neighbors, different politics, different economies, different religious makeup, all of which makes for a different culture, and a myriad of other things that absolutely make comparing the two far less noteworthy than it appears on the surface.

there you go off in left field somewhere...none of that changes the fact that Rome declined for the reasons given...and the USA is in decline for those same reasons

When someone refers to a culture as something that decays rather than something that evolves, you know you're dealing with simple thinkers with a prominent bias.

when people make the ASSUMPTION that evolve means to "get better" you know you are dealing with simplistic thinking...evolve just means "incremental change over time"...decay is change...and decay is the proper descriptive for what has and is occurring in this country 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

and simplistic logic is usually the truth...

Only for simplistic people.

Yet, the truth IS that people have never changed.

I don't disagree that there are some basic behaviors of people that generally remain the same. But the truth is that Romans do NOT think or act like Modern Americans or Modern ANYONE for that matter. There was a completely different set of cultural and social values. Family structure was not the same. Government structure was distinctly different.

Again, it's a superficial comparison.

I don't think this nation is actually experiencing a "decline" so much as experiencing a leveling of the playing field and a loss of spirit.

After WWII we had a great enemy which made it so that we could polarize the world into basically two camps. US and the Reds. (There were other, smaller camps, but they were mostly irrelevant). Then, the USSR collapses, leaving a power vacuum that no one really stepped into. But OUR thinking didn't change... you see it even today when certain politicians talk about Russia, you can tell they are stuck in a Cold War mentality.

But over time, China came along and their dignitas and gravitas increased dramatically, Germany has been on the rise as well (more so than the EU in general), and even Russia is coming back from the brink.

And yet, we still have Cold War thinkers running the show. So..decline? No, I don't think so... this nation is better off now than it's been at any time in its past. Some stagnation of policy? yeah, there's a lot of that because people in charge still think we are at war with the USSR.

The other question I think on is this. Has American exceptionalism gone by the wayside? Except in the rhetoric of certain politicians and pundits, yes, I think it has. It's been given over to bean counting.

If the space race happened today, we'd lose it. Not because we're not the most technologically advanced nation, but because we've become a nation run by bean counters. and the exploration of space does not result in immediate profits.

Heck, think about all the EXCEPTIONAL things this nation has done that didn't show a profit in the short-term... Louis and Clark expedition, Adm. Perry going to Japan, breaking the sound barrier...etc...etc...etc....

So much would never have been done simply because it didn't quickly put you in the black on some spreadsheet. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

When someone refers to a culture as something that decays rather than something that evolves, you know you're dealing with simple thinkers with a prominent bias.

I agree with this statement. A culture that doesn't change and grow is doomed to die. Very often change and growth is defined as decay by those who fear change and growth.

Even the Amish, the classic American Luddites, know this. They've had to change many of their policies over the years just to survive... I.e. the use of modern machinery. because there's not enough work for their kids within the community,and they need outside sources of ready cash, they send their young men off to work outside the community. They found that they couldn't do that with restrictions on the use of modern technology. They still can't own it, but as long as it's owned by someone else, an Amish person CAN USE said machinery. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Only for simplistic people.

nope...for everybody

A culture that doesn't change and grow is doomed to die. Very often change and growth is defined as decay by those who fear change and growth.

NONSENSE...a culture that makes the WRONG changes is doomed to die...

cultural decay is decline... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I'm trying to imagine why anyone would argue with Ogre about historical events- and then I considered the source... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Only for simplistic people.

nope...for everybody


OH good grief... Lynch, get a new Schtick.

Coming back with "NUH HUH" is something my mentally retarded sister does.

The analysis of Gibbon and Walker is fatally flawed. Plain and simple and it doesn't matter how many facts one presents to you proving this, you'll simply do your little jr. high debate tactic of "I'm rubber, you're glue."

All you do when you do that is show your lack of education, your ignorance, and the fact that because you WANT something to be true, you'll ignore all evidence to the contrary.

It makes you look STUPID.

a culture that makes the WRONG changes is doomed to die...

I'm sorry, I presumed that that went without saying.

For instance... we like to think that the White Man destroyed the buffalo herds, and they certainly had a hand in it. but the native Americans at the time also had a part to play. For one, the Great Plains tribes opened the hunting grounds up to the White Man for profit. That's one mistake of a culture changing in a bad way. Another was, that they made so much money off buffalo hides that they started hunting pregnant females (because their hides were larger). Well, when you kill off the gravid females, guess what happens? Birth rates DROP. By the late 19th C. by 80%. The herds simply could not sustain the damage.

THUS, and example of cultural change, based on GREED that eventually wound up with the tribes starving to death because their buffalo based economy collapsed. In the 19th C. the Comanches went from a population 30,000 +/- to less than 5,000 because they could not support themselves.

ARE WE DOING THE SAME IN SOME WAY HERE? I dunno, I think the jury is still out. We have some financial issues, but even our debt is not as dramatic as it was after the Civil War. And we came back from that.

But there is a large contingent of modern Luddites out there that fear change and like to call change decay. And John, you're one of them. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

most would bow out gracefully, at this point- most people- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I'm trying to imagine why anyone would argue with Ogre about historical events- and then I considered the source...

probably because he is wrong most of the time...

The analysis of Gibbon and Walker is fatally flawed.

Gibbon's assessment agrees with other historians that i have read...

you resorting to saying someone is...doing "your little jr. high debate tactic of "I'm rubber, you're glue." makes you look stupid

But there is a large contingent of modern Luddites out there that fear change and like to call change decay. And John, you're one of them

i'm not afraid of change...it is the "moral decline" type of change...which is definitely decay...that bothers me...

and your "analyses" of the destruction of the buffalo is NONSENSE and simplistic...it was the white man...who established the commodities markets for buffalo meat, tongues and skins...and who established railroads...which were the two largest impacts upon the herds...although disease, fires, climate and competition from horses played a part 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

most would bow out gracefully, at this point- most people-

most people wouldn't comment on things they know nothing about...most people 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

so Ogre knows nothing, compared to you? 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

John, empires collapse and transform because of economic policy or military defeat, not buttsex and art. If we want this nation to last we need to worry less about buttsex and focus more on preserving our economic freedoms and national defense.

It is not astonishing in the least that the Roman Empire became less powerful and less influential. When you look at the eventual economic policies of the empire is when it becomes astonishing that it even lasted as long as it did. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

cultural decay is decline...

As usual, nuance goes over your head. It's the nature of being a committed literalist to written words.

A basic level of social awareness is all that is required to understand that using the word "decay" to describe a cultural transformation signals the use of a dramatic word choice for the purpose of injecting a personal bias. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

*standing ovation* 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

double post- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I think every society had the same proclivities- the difference now is with the internet, we're more aware of everything going on- even the war with Viet Nam was the first one covered by media- therefore, the response from people was negative toward the soldiers- the Korean war was the same, but no one really knew every little thing about it- 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

John, empires collapse and transform because of economic policy or military defeat, not buttsex and art.

it all works together to destroy a culture warren...don't be so naïve

As usual, nuance goes over your head.

as usual...you must not understand nuance...subtle differences aren't the problem...

A basic level of social awareness is all that is required to understand that using the word "decay" to describe a cultural transformation signals the use of a dramatic word choice for the purpose of injecting a personal bias.

actually your statement is all that is required to understand that you don't believe in absolute truth and righteousness from which morals are derived...

your personal bias is shown to be...let a word have any meaning "i" choose for it... 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Working from memory - so don't blast me, but also though there was a train of thought that blamed the rise of Chrtianity in Rome. A softening in defense not there under the pagan empire. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

it was the white man...who established the commodities markets for buffalo meat, tongues and skins...

BZZZZ... would you care to play again. It was the Comanche and the Souix in particular that established and supplied the market with the vast majority of hides. The AVERAGE White man would not eat the meat. The natives did though, right up until the Buffalo were gone and they were trapped on the reservation relying on the white man for food.

The Railroads, particularly the transcontinental railroads had minimal effect on the actual herds. It was the combo of the loss of control by the natives due to their desire for money (which was fine when the region was controlled by Mexico and Spain - for the most part the Mexican and Spanish governors didn't want conflict with the natives.) And their overhunting of pregnant cows for the more valuable larger skins. Want a source? Comanche Empire by Pekka H?l?en. Dr. H is THE recognized expert in history of Native Americans and the North American Borderlands.

The white man? The Railroads? MINIMAL effect in the face of the fact that the Comanche ALONE took up to 80 Buffalo a year per person per year (Sometimes simply driving entire herds off cliffs to kill them). At the peak, that's 2.4 MILLION buffalo, 60% pregnant cows. Throw in about ten other plains tribes doing the same and a five year drought which decimated the herds too, and there ya go.

As to me being wrong... Unlike YOU I can provide current resources for the vast majority of what I post. You just posted something from an ancient historian whose primary goal was the glorification of the British Empire and an economist who has no qualifications to make sociological analysis. I'm MORE qualified than Walker to make social analysis. Dr. H?l?en MOST certainly is.

As to the rest. JL

Gibbon's assessment agrees with other historians that i have read...

Which historians would those be? Or do you need time to go onto Amazon or Wiki to look a few up?

you resorting to saying someone is...doing "your little jr. high debate tactic of "I'm rubber, you're glue." makes you look stupid

There it is, your Jr. High debate team tactic. Doesn't work in the real world of either debate, history nor scholarship. Ever.

It's pathetic. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Oh, bloody he11.

H?l?en = Hamalainen ---- the A's have Umlauts over them and the copy and paste feature on this site is screwed up.

Dr. PEKKA HAMALAINEN, UCSB AND Oxford University.
Prof. of North American Borderlands and Native American History at UCSB and a Rhodes Professor at the University of Oxford!

But of course, John Lynch is smarter than he is....

He taught at Texas A&M University from 2002 to 2004. His work has appeared in the American Historical Review, Journal of American History,William and Mary Quarterly,and the Western Historical Quarterly.

HIS MENTOR, (whose name I don't recall, and I don't have the book handy right now) was the man who coined the phrase "Borderland" and established an entirely new field of historical/sociological study. Dr. H. is considered the foremost living expert on the topic today.

I'll take the scholarship of someone who has won the Bancroft Prize (I.e. the most prestigious prize a Historian of the Americas can get) over your History Channel Education any day of the week Lynch. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Unlike YOU I can provide current resources for the vast majority of what I post.

you just supply people that agree with your opinion...and most of the time your opinion is incorrect

when i did research for a history project...i had a friend whose great grandfather was a "buffalo hunter" who routinely shot over 100 buffalo a day...he was paid 44 cents per hide...

to say that the Indians purposely killed one of the sources of their livelihood is just ludicrous...

your jr. high debate team tactic doesn't work in the real world of history nor scholarship...it's pathetic... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

i had a friend whose great grandfather was a "buffalo hunter" who routinely shot over 100 buffalo a day...he was paid 44 cents per hide...

LOL... ah, yes, that's called hearsay. The very professional; "I had a friend" research technique. The telling of history from one family member to another is invariably flawed. Most of the time simply false. If everything everyone's family said was true, then we'd all be descendants of Indian Kings, and wealthy robber barons.

I'm SUPPOSED to be 1/8th Cherokee according to family history. According to REAL research done by myself and my wife, AND DNA testing, I'm more like 1/256th. My Aunt, who did research on the OTHER side of my family still insists that we're all German Jews...and yet, my DNA results show NO Jewish Markers and the line that she claims is Jewish cannot be traced past the great storm in Galveston in 1900. But she's still insistent in spite of REAL evidence to the contrary.

Just like you, JL. You think you're smarter with your half-Arsed education than a man who is effectively the FOUNDER of the line of research I quote.

You would argue with Einstein over relativiity thinking you're smarter than he is.

You're not. In fact the more I hear from you the more I think you're more like my mentally retarded sister than anyone else I know.

Join the rest of the world in reality. You are NOT Gods' special snowflake of knowledge.

YOU ARE WRONG. Period.

Oh, and your jr. high debate team tactic doesn't work in the real world of history nor scholarship...it's pathetic...

DO YOU JUST NOT GET IT??? This is exactly what I'm talking about when I say all you got is the "I'm rubber, you're glue" debate technique. Sad. Pathetic. LAME.

Go away Lynch. You're part of the problem. Someone who thinks they know everything when in fact they know nothing the don't learn off TV. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

LOL... ah, yes, that's called hearsay

actually ogre...no it isn't...hearsay is a legal term used in the courtroom

fyi...i READ letters that the man wrote

You think you're smarter with your half-Arsed education than a man who is effectively the FOUNDER of the line of research I quote.

the FOUNDER of incorrect knowledge is still incorrect

You are NOT Gods' special snowflake of knowledge.

don't need to be...not when i have you putting out all that nonsense

fyi...a person can be Jewish by religious conversion...so you are WRONG once again...you should go apologize to your aunt 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

Point goes to JL 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

it all works together to destroy a culture warren...don't be so naive

Naive? John have you even read what you're suggesting?

If you actually believe that provocative art and where someone chooses to ejaculate has anything to do with a nation's long term viability, then please proceed with supporting this premise. Maybe the State Dept could use a lesson from you in the untapped potential of the ejaculative arts for future foreign policy operations?

Your emphasis on this (in your selections culled from Gibbons' thesis) is hardcore stupid, bordering on childlike naivity.

Some of the most successful businesses (Microsoft, Apple, Google, IBM, Nike, Levi Strauss, Starbucks, Boeing, and countless others) embrace, promote, and cater to this lifestyle and are wildly successful because it is economically productive to do so.

Homosexuality has been around forever. It exists in successful and unsuccessful nations. Early French and Spanish explorers noted that American Indians (untainted by Greco Roman influence) were observed engaging in homosexual behavior. It was part of Greek and Roman culture during the entire timeline of the empire's existence. Though Gibbon personally believed homosexuality to be a cause of the empire's decline (without a lick of evidence), he willingly embraced a self refuting argument by stating, "of the first fifteen emperors Claudius was the only one whose taste in love was entirely correct." In other words, the founding fathers of the Roman Empire were just as fond of homosexual acts as when the empire peaked. Maybe we have some historians that can take it from here, but I have never read that Gibbons made a persuasive case that homosexuality was increasing as the empire began its decline. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground