Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Sunstein: Greatest win for gay marriage is just two words

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
Red Heifer 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
Gigix4 6
Davi 1
Wolfram 1
Emperor of Kingwood 3
butch baby 1
a889324uu 1
Butterbean 11
mutton 1
jacobson 21
AMDG 5
Oregonian 4
Ed Earl 3
FNHO 1
Candy 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

Sunstein: Greatest win for gay marriage is just two words

By Cass R. Sunstein
| Bloomberg View

Last Updated Sep 06 2014 05:13 pm

The movement for marriage equality
Thursday received its greatest legal victory. Judge Richard Posner, of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, wrote a powerful opinion ordering Indiana and Wisconsin to recognize same-sex marriages. In the process, he eviscerated the states? efforts to defend their discriminatory laws.

The author matters in this case. Posner was appointed by Ronald Reagan, and he isn?t known for favoring an active judicial role or for thinking that courts should promote social change. He is also widely admired, and probably counts as the most influential lower court judge of the past 50 years. When he speaks, people listen.

To understand his opinion, it is important to distinguish among three quite different objections to laws forbidding same-sex marriage.

The first is that they interfere with the right to marry. On this view, under the Constitution?s due process clause, that right is fundamental, so states can?t interfere with it without a "compelling justification" (for example, to prevent marriages between parents and children).

The second is that because gays and lesbians have been subject to pervasive prejudice and hostility, and because sexual orientation is immutable, any form of discrimination against them is "suspect" under the equal protection clause ? which means, again, that it can?t be allowed without a compelling justification.

The third, and simplest, argument is that laws against same-sex marriage lack any reasonable basis, so they violate the equal protection clause for being "irrational."

Judge Posner embraced the second argument, but in the end, his opinion rested on the third.

Indiana offered just one rationale for limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples: essentially, that marriage is meant to enhance the welfare of children by reducing the risk that, in cases of "accidental births," men will avoid taking responsibility for them. Marriage, Indiana argued, channels "unintentionally procreative sex" into a legal relationship, in which the biological father is required to assume responsibility. Because same-sex relationships can?t produce accidental births, there is no reason for marriage.

Posner had a field day with that argument. "Heterosexuals get drunk and pregnant, producing unwanted children; their reward is to be allowed to marry. Homosexual couples do not produce unwanted children; their reward is to be denied the right to marry. Go figure."

Indiana?s argument was undermined by the fact that the state allows infertile couples to marry. Indeed, it allows first cousins to marry if they are over 65-years-old, apparently because by that age, women are infertile. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

The movement for marriage equality

It has nothing to do with marriage equality. Two people of the same sex do not fit the definition of marriage, plain and simple.

Just another liberal atheist making his move to help destroy our country. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Another 2 words: who cares? 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

Just a symptom of a decaying culture.

If we manage to preserve our freedom, this too shall pass. 

Davi --- 12 years ago -

First, I am a Christian and do not believe in same sex marriage. The Bible does not in any way support it.

However, the question same sex marriage while among Christians is a moral issue, the issue when brought to a court is a legal issue. Therefore, the morality of the issue is irrelevant. A court cannot support morality without a law prohibiting the act, i.e. Stealing, it is a moral issue in the Bible, and it is a legal issue among men. (Generic reference).

There is no Constitutional basis to reject same sex marriage. All of our laws have to be Constitutional to be upheld and enforced by our courts. Our founding fathers, either by lack of vision, or perhaps even intentionally failed to address the issue in the Constitution. Our law makers 50 years ago probably could have passed a law at that time that would not have been challenged for many years in the future. But they did not.

As a Christian, I do not and will not condone same sex marriage. I will pray that those that seek that lifestyle will see the sin, and repent. But, if they don't it is not my place to judge. God has exclusive ownership of the judging part. It is not mine to say that someone will go to hell for being gay, just as it is not my place to tell the adulterer, or the person that uses God's name in vain that they will go to hell.

I have a very dear family member involved in a gay relationship. I have told her she is my niece first and foremost, her sexual preference is between her, her partner and God. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Therefore, the morality of the issue is irrelevant

No, you are incorrect. We obtained our morals from God. Any Christian should know that fact.

There is no Constitutional basis to reject same sex marriage.

Yes, there is. States are given the right to decide that issue, not the courts. The courts are going against the Constitution and the will of the people.

It is always sad when someone who professes to be a Christian tries to meld worldly views into God's teachings. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

I have a very dear family member involved in a gay relationship. I have told her she is my niece first and foremost, her sexual preference is between her, her partner and God.

Sounds like sanity to me. And they have equal rights of civil ceremony for marriage. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

And they have equal rights of civil ceremony for marriage.

If it's only a civil ceremony, then it really isn't a marriage. 

Ed Earl --- 12 years ago -

Your rights stop when they start infringing on my rights. Churches and pastors are now being sued because they refuse to perform a marriage ceremony for gay couples. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Davi - well said,

Jacobson don't want to miss the chance to say

only a civil ceremony, then it really isn't a marriage.

Agree 

a889324uu --- 12 years ago -

And YOUR rights stop when they infringe on others.

Funny how that works.

Perhaps if your marriage was good, you wouldn't be so grossly concerned about others.

Equality for ALL. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Agree?

Then it shouldn't be called a marriage. Agree?

And YOUR rights stop when they infringe on others.

That is an absolutely false statement.

Perhaps if your marriage was good, you wouldn't be so grossly concerned about others.

LOL, are you God? You know nothing about his marriage, so why would you assume you do? Is it because yours isn't all it's supposed to be?

Equality for ALL.

There is already equality for ALL. Any adult can get married under the real definition of marriage. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Then it shouldn't be called a marriage. Agree?

Agree - you can call it what you like, it is not marriage.

I don't mind a civil contract that gives same sex couples the same civil rights as traditional marriages , however whatever you want to call it, it is not a marriage. 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

whatever you want to call it, it is not a marriage.

Civil union? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

sounds good to me- 

Ed Earl --- 12 years ago -

Do you believe churches should be forced to perform a civil union? 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

Do you believe churches should be forced to perform a civil union?

Personally ... no! Churches are for religious services, civil unions should be performed in a "civil" location. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Churches are for religious services

Churches were not meant to be for religious services. They were meant to be a gathering of believers. 

Ed Earl --- 12 years ago -

Churches and pastors are being sued because they refuse to perform a civil union for gay couples. This is wrong. 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

This is wrong.

Yes it is! If the government wants to keep religion out of government business then the government should stay out of church business.

And J, nobody pays attention to you anyway so why do you keep "yoking" yourself with us heathens?

If churches are meant to be a gathering of believers, it also should be a place for a gathering for those who believe in a blessed marriage.

You just have to argue, don't ya? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

And J, nobody pays attention to you anyway so why do you keep "yoking" yourself with us heathens?

LOL, the truth is that more people pay attention to what I say than pay attention to what you say.

it also should be a place for a gathering for those who believe in a blessed marriage.

I have no argument with that. It's too bad that you don't realize that a blessed marriage has nothing to do with a religious service.

You just have to argue, don't ya? 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

I don't know all the legalese; I am certainly not a lawyer. I do, however believe that a legal marriage is a civil union whose power to perform has been extended to clergy, by authority of license to do so by the state.

Every "church" ceremony that I've attended has, somewhere in the text, "by the authority granted to me by the state of _________."

However persons view this is not my business. A legal marriage, that affords all the legal rights of marriage, is a civil ceremony. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

A truly legal marriage is one ordained by God. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Sorry Jake. It's either legal or illegal, in the eyes of man.

God can figure out what's acceptable. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

It's either legal or illegal, in the eyes of man.

Sorry Bean, but God has the final say. Man's eyes are easily deceived.

God has already told us what is acceptable. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Your rights stop when they start infringing on my rights.

If that were really true, there would be no affirmitive action. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

God has already told us what is acceptable.

Not everything, Jake. I have to chat with Him daily. Otherwise I won't know His current thinking. 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

God has already told us what is acceptable.

So, let God take care of it and the rest is nunya'! 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

If that were really true, there would be no affirmitive action.

I think that is a true statement. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Not everything, Jake.

Yes, He has Bean. And you have no idea what his current thinking is. If you did, you wouldn't say some of the things you do.

So, let God take care of it and the rest is nunya'!

DUH, He told us so that we could take care of it ourselves. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

And you have no idea what his current thinking is.

Talked with Him just this morning, Jake. I said, "Thank You."
He said, "You're welcome." 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Talked with Him just this morning, Jake.

LOL. Only in your dreams. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Yes, Jake. In my dreams and daily life. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Bean, "in your dreams" refers to fantasy.

God's Word tells us how to recognize false teachings - those that are contrary to His Word. Your words are indicative of false teachings. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

Bean, "in your dreams" refers to fantasy.

Nope, Jake. Dreams are part of what I am and will become. He helps me to envision all that I can be and then helps me get there - daily. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Like I said - fantasy. 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

- fantasy.

May be for you, Jake. He's alive and well for me - daily. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

He's alive and well for me - daily

Yes, He is for everyone. But like most, you don't follow His word. 

Candy --- 12 years ago -

As a Christian, I do not and will not condone same sex marriage. I will pray that those that seek that lifestyle will see the sin, and repent. But, if they don't it is not my place to judge. God has exclusive ownership of the judging part. It is not mine to say that someone will go to hell for being gay, just as it is not my place to tell the adulterer, or the person


"Davi," wonderfully put. Exceptionally worded!

And J, nobody pays attention to you anyway so why do you keep "yoking" yourself with us heathens?

LOL, the truth is that more people pay attention to what I say than pay attention to what you say.


LOL. That is a complete joke. And I thought you didn't have a sense of humor at all.

"Gigix4," love what you said. Made my day!

It is obvious that "Jacobson" believes he is the judge, jury and executioner. He must believe that he speaks for Christ Himself. Waco is calling "Jacobson " you better pick up the phone. What color is that Kool Aid you've been drinking? 

Butterbean --- 12 years ago -

But like most, you don't follow His word.

You don't know that, Jake. False witness?

Must be close to din-din time in the home, Jake. Push the button and ask what you're having. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground